Foundations of Human and Animal Sensory Awareness: Descartes and Willis
Open Access
- 1 January 2023
- book chapter
- Published by Firenze University Press
- p. 81-99
Abstract
In arguing against the likelihood of consciousness in non-human animals, Descartes advances a slippery slope argument that if thought were attributed to any one animal, it would have to be attributed to all, which is absurd. This paper examines the foundations of Thomas Willis’ comparative neuroanatomy against the background of Descartes’ slippery slope argument against animal consciousness. Inspired by Gassendi’s ideas about the corporeal soul, Thomas Willis distinguished between neural circuitry responsible for reflex behaviour and that responsible for cognitively or consciously mediated behaviour. This afforded Willis a non-arbitrary basis for distinguishing between animals with thought and consciousness and those without, a methodology which retains currency for neuroscience today.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Are There Levels of Consciousness?Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 2016
- Thomas Willis, a pioneer in translational research in anatomy (on the 350th anniversary ofCerebri anatome)Journal of Anatomy, 2015
- Animal Automatism and Machine IntelligenceRes Philosophica, 2015
- Thomas Willis: The faculties and his two cognitive frameworksBrain and Cognition, 2014
- Jan Swammerdam's frogsNotes and Records, 2012
- A pathology of the animal spirits – the clinical neurology of Thomas Willis (1621–1675) Part I – Background, and disorders of intrinsically normal animal spiritsJournal of Clinical Neuroscience, 2003
- Exorcizing the animal spirits: Jan Swammerdam on nerve functionNature Reviews Neuroscience, 2002
- The old martyr of science: The frog in experimental physiologyJournal of the History of Biology, 1993
- ON THOMAS WILLIS'S CONCEPTS OF NEUROPHYSIOLOGY [Part I]Medical History, 1965
- ON THOMAS WILLIS'S CONCEPTS OF NEUROPHYSIOLOGY: PART IIMedical History, 1965