Comparative Evaluation of Fuzzy Logic and Q-Learning for Adaptive Urban Traffic Signal Control
Authors:
- Ioana-Miruna VlasceanuIoana-Miruna Vlasceanu
- Vasilica-Cerasela-Doinita CeapaVasilica-Cerasela-Doinita Ceapa
- Ioan Stefan SacalaIoan Stefan Sacala
- Constantin Florin CaruntuConstantin Florin Caruntu
- Andreea-Ioana UdreaAUAndreea-Ioana Udrea
- Nicolae ConstantinNCNicolae Constantin
- Mircea SegarceanuMSMircea Segarceanu
Open Access
- 9 July 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Electronics
- Vol. 14 (14) , 2759
Abstract
In recent years, the number of vehicles in cities has visibly increased, leading to continuous modifications in general mobility. Pollution levels and congestion cases are reaching higher numbers as well, pointing to a need for better optimization solutions. Several existing control systems still rely on fixed timings for traffic lights, lacking an adaptive approach that can adjust the timers depending on real-time conditions. This study aims to provide a design for such a tool, by implementing two different approaches: Fuzzy Logic Optimization and an Adaptive Traffic Management strategy. The first controller involves Fuzzy Logic based on rule-based that adjust green and red-light timings depending on the number of vehicles at an intersection. The second model provides traffic adjustments based on external equipment such as road sensors and cameras, offering dynamic solutions tailored to current traffic conditions. Both methods are tested in a simulated environment using SUMO (Simulation of Urban Mobility). They were evaluated according to key efficiency indicators, namely average waiting time, lost time per cycle, number of stops per intersection, and overall traffic fluidity. Results demonstrate that Q-learning maintains consistent waiting times between 2.57 and 3.71 s across all traffic densities while achieving Traffic Flow Index values above 85%, significantly outperforming Fuzzy Logic, which shows greater variability and lower efficiency under high-density conditions.Keywords
Funding Information
- project “Romanian Hub for Artificial Intelligence—HRIA”, Smart Growth, Digitization and Financial Instruments Program (334906)
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Artificial Intelligence-Based Adaptive Traffic Signal Control System: A Comprehensive ReviewElectronics, 2024
- Multi-Objective Adaptive Traffic Signal Control Using Fuzzy Control and Q-Learning2024
- Deep Reinforcement Learning for Traffic Light Timing OptimizationProcesses, 2022
- Traffic Signal Optimization Based on Fuzzy Control and Differential Evolution AlgorithmIEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems, 2022
- Improving the Road and Traffic Control Prediction Based on Fuzzy Logic Approach in Multiple IntersectionsMathematics, 2022
- Deep Reinforcement Learning based approach for Traffic Signal ControlTransportation Research Procedia, 2022
- Adaptation Scheduling for Urban Traffic Lights via FNT-Based Prediction of Traffic FlowElectronics, 2022
- Autonomic Road Transport Support Systems2016
- Short-term traffic forecasting: Where we are and where we’re goingTransportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies, 2014
- Application of fuzzy algorithms for control of simple dynamic plantProceedings of the Institution of Electrical Engineers, 1974