Crossover Comparison of the Laryngeal Mask Supreme™ and the i-gel™ in Simulated Difficult Airway Scenario in Anesthetized Patients
Authors:
- 1 July 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Anesthesiology
- Vol. 111 (1) , 55-62
Abstract
Background: The single-use supraglottic airway devices LMA-Supreme (LMA-S; Laryngeal Mask Company, Henley-on-Thames, United Kingdom) and i-gel (Intersurgical Ltd, Wokingham, Berkshire, United Kingdom) have a second tube for gastric tube insertion. Only the LMA-S has an inflatable cuff. They have the same clinical indications and might be useful for difficult airway management. This prospective, crossover, randomized controlled trial was performed in a simulated difficult airway scenario using an extrication collar limiting mouth opening and neck movement. Methods: Sixty patients were included. Both devices were placed in random order in each patient. Primary outcome was overall success rate. Other measurements were time to successful ventilation, airway leak pressure, fiberoptic glottic view, and adverse events. Results: Success rate for the LMA-S was 95% versus 93% for the i-gel (P = 1.000). LMA-S needed shorter insertion time (34 +/- 12 s vs. 42 +/- 23 s, P = 0.024). Tidal volumes and airway leak pressure were similar (LMA-S 26 +/- 8 cm H20; i-gel 27 +/- 9 cm H20; P = 0.441). Fiberoptic view through the i-gel showed less epiglottic downfolding. Overall agreement in insertion outcome was 54 (successes) and 1 (failure) or 55 (92%) of 60 patients. The difference in success rate was 1.7% (95% CI -11.3% to 7.6%). Conclusions: Both airway devices had similar insertion success and clinical performance in the simulated difficult airway situation. The authors found less epiglottic downfolding and better fiberoptic view but longer insertion time with the i-gel. Our study shows that both devices are feasible for emergency airway management in patients with reduced neck movement and limited mouth opening.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Use of the Laryngeal Mask Airway Supreme in pre-hospital difficult airway managementResuscitation, 2008
- LMA-SupremeTM—a new single-use LMATM with gastric access: a report on its clinical efficacyBritish Journal of Anaesthesia, 2008
- Einsatz der i-gel®-Larynxmaske bei schwierigem AtemwegDer Anaesthesist, 2008
- A New Single Use Supraglottic Airway Device with a Noninflatable Cuff and an Esophageal Vent: An Observational Study of the i-GelAnesthesia & Analgesia, 2008
- Effective ventilation during CPR via an LMA‐SupremeAnaesthesia, 2008
- The LMA Supreme TM – a pilot studyAnaesthesia, 2008
- The I-gel supraglottic airway and resuscitation—Some initial thoughtsResuscitation, 2007
- The iGEL supraglottic airway: A potential role for resuscitation?Resuscitation, 2007
- Evaluation of four airway training manikins as patient simulators for the insertion of eight types of supraglottic airway devices*Anaesthesia, 2007
- Initial anatomic investigations of the I‐gel airway: a novel supraglottic airway without inflatable cuff*Anaesthesia, 2005