“Congruence” and “Responsiveness” in the study of representation
Open Access
- 5 March 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Public Choice
- Vol. 208 (3-4) , 1-14
Abstract
This paper compares two common methods used to measure representation in empirical research: “congruence,” whether a roll-call vote is aligned with constituent opinion; and “responsiveness,” the correlation between roll-call votes and constituent opinion. While sometimes viewed as different ways of capturing the same underlying concept of “representation,” theoretically the measures are not connected. This paper assesses to what extent responsiveness and congruence capture the same thing empirically. Using 4,192 roll-call votes on 33 state laws that were subsequently challenged in referendums, I calculate both congruence and responsiveness for the same set of votes. The main finding is that responsiveness is an unreliable predictor of congruence, and therefore cannot be taken as a proxy for congruence.Keywords
Funding Information
- University of Southern California
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Policy Preferences and Policy Change: Dynamic Responsiveness in the American States, 1936–2014American Political Science Review, 2017
- When Do the Rich Win?Political Science Quarterly, 2017
- Reform and Representation: A New Method Applied to Recent Electoral ChangesPolitical Science Research and Methods, 2016
- Representation in Municipal GovernmentAmerican Political Science Review, 2014
- Does gender matter for political leadership? The case of U.S. mayorsJournal of Public Economics, 2014
- Quantifying parliamentary representation of constituents’ preferences with quasi-experimental dataJournal of Comparative Economics, 2013
- Public choice principles of redistrictingPublic Choice, 2006
- Incumbent performance and electoral controlPublic Choice, 1986
- The elusive median voterJournal of Public Economics, 1979
- The control of politicians: An economic modelPublic Choice, 1973