Biological Antecedents Essentialism
Open Access
- 2 August 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Erkenntnis
- Vol. 90 (7) , 2971-2994
Abstract
An essentialist claim often made about organisms is that they could not have originated in different gametes. The thesis of gametic essentialism (GE) is usually understood either as a particular case of material origin essentialism, or as genetic essentialism. This paper argues that it should instead be understood in terms of the numerical identity of the gametes. Since gametes are living cells, their identity conditions should be the same as those of other living beings, and therefore involve neither specific material composition, nor specific genes, but continuity of the same life. Understood in this way, GE is a particular case of biological antecedents essentialism (BAE), a kind of origin essentialism that is better justified in the light of the metaphysical nature of organisms as objects that inherit life from previously existing living organisms. BAE overcomes many objections facing other origin essentialist accounts, and it recognises the importance of the gametes in transmitting not just genes, but actively functioning physical structures necessary for life. If we wish to maintain an origin essentialism principle for organisms, we should prefer BAE.Keywords
Funding Information
- British Society for the Philosophy of Science (British Society for the Philosophy of Science)
- The Royal Institute of Philosophy (The Royal Institute of Philosophy)
- Aristotelian Society (Aristotelian Society)
This publication has 54 references indexed in Scilit:
- Cats are not necessarily animalsErkenntnis, 2022
- Energy metabolism in mammalian sperm motilityWIREs Mechanisms of Disease, 2022
- Anti-essentialism, modal relativity, and alternative material-origin counterfactualsSynthese, 2021
- Horizontal Gene Transfer in Bacteria, an Overview of the Mechanisms Involved2019
- Biological process, essential origin, and identityPhilosophical Studies, 2015
- Harm to Future Persons: Non-Identity Problems and Counterpart SolutionsEthical Theory and Moral Practice, 2011
- Peacocke’s Principle-Based Account of Modality: “Flexibility of Origins” Plus S4Erkenntnis, 2006
- Forbes on Origins and Identities2002
- Origins and Identities2002
- Origin and identityPhilosophical Studies, 1980