Teaching Children to Read : The Fragile Link Between Science & Federal Education Policy
Authors:
Open Access
- 8 May 2003
- journal article
- Published by Mary Lou Fulton College for Teaching and Learning Innovation in Education Policy Analysis Archives
- Vol. 11, 15
Abstract
Teaching Children to Read (TCR) has stirred much controversy among reading experts regarding the efficacy of phonics instruction. This report, which was conducted by the National Reading Panel (NRP), has also played an important role in subsequent federal policy regarding reading instruction. Using meta-analysis, the NRP found that systematic phonics instruction was more effective than alternatives in teaching children to read. In the present study, the findings and procedures leading to TCR were examined. We concluded that the methodology and procedures in TCR were not adequate for synthesizing the research literature on phonics instruction. Moreover, we estimated a smaller though still substantial effect (d = .24) for systematic phonics, but we also found an effect for systematic language activities (d = .29) and tutoring (d = .40). Systematic phonics instruction when combined with language activities and individual tutoring may triple the effect of phonics alone. As federal policies are formulated around early literacy curricula and instruction, these findings indicate that phonics, as one aspect of the complex reading process, should not be over-emphasized.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- Babes in the Woods: The Wanderings of the National Reading PanelPhi Delta Kappan, 2002
- More Smoke and Mirrors: A Critique of the National Reading Panel Report on FluencyPhi Delta Kappan, 2001
- Beyond the Smoke and Mirrors: Putting Out the FirePhi Delta Kappan, 2001
- Phonemic Awareness Instruction Helps Children Learn to Read: Evidence From the National Reading Panel's Meta‐AnalysisReading Research Quarterly, 2001
- Beyond the Smoke and MirrorsPhi Delta Kappan, 2001
- Effect Size, Practical Importance, and Social Policy for ChildrenChild Development, 2000
- Concluding reflections: What should reading instructional research be the research of?Issues in Education, 1999
- Phonological recoding skill and beginning readingReading and Writing, 1993
- Can dyslexia be treated? Treatment-specific and generalized treatment effects in dyslexic children's response to remediationBrain and Language, 1989
- Multisensory teaching approach for reading, spelling, and handwriting, Orton-Gillingham based curriculum, in a public school settingAnnals of Dyslexia, 1987