Gregory Camilli
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Gregory Camilli has a total of 9 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Sadako Vargas
Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey
3 shared publicationsDavid Mayrowetz
Rutgers University
1 shared publicationDouglas A. Penfield
Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey
1 shared publication- Katrina Bulkley
Rutgers University
1 shared publication Lora Monfils
Rutgers University
1 shared publicationMichele Yurecko
National Institute for Early Education Research and Rutgers University
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 30 August 2008
- Published by Mary Lou Fulton College for Teaching and Learning Innovation in Education Policy Analysis Archives
- Vol. 16, 16
A response to Steubing et al., "Effects of systematic phonics instruction are practically significant": The origins of the National Reading Panel.
A recent article by Stuebing, Barth, Cirino, Francis and Fletcher critiqued the findings of Camilli, Vargas, and Yurecko (2003) and Camilli, Wolfe, and Smith (2006). With a methodological argument, they attempted to resolve the conflict between these studies and the original report Teaching Children to Read (National Reading Panel, 2000). In response, it is argued that three issues must be considered in a fair assessment of the NRP report—program labels or bins, alternative bins, and the role of literacy activities in reading instruction. In this light, three hypotheses ventured by Stuebing et al. are analyzed. It is concluded that the argument by Stuebing et al. does not reveal flaws in the original NRP report by Camilli et al. (2003), though some points of agreement are acknowledged.
- 30 August 2008
- Published by Mary Lou Fulton College for Teaching and Learning Innovation in Education Policy Analysis Archives
- Vol. 16, 16
Open AccessA response to Steubing et al., "Effects of systematic phonics instruction are practically significant": The origins of the National Reading Panel.
A recent article by Stuebing, Barth, Cirino, Francis and Fletcher critiqued the findings of Camilli, Vargas, and Yurecko (2003) and Camilli, Wolfe, and Smith (2006). With a methodological argument, they attempted to resolve the conflict between these studies and the original report Teaching Children to Read (National Reading Panel, 2000). In response, it is argued that three issues must be considered in a fair assessment of the NRP report—program labels or bins, alternative bins, and the role of literacy activities in reading instruction. In this light, three hypotheses ventured by Stuebing et al. are analyzed. It is concluded that the argument by Stuebing et al. does not reveal flaws in the original NRP report by Camilli et al. (2003), though some points of agreement are acknowledged.
- Open Access
- 6 February 2006
- Published by Mary Lou Fulton College for Teaching and Learning Innovation in Education Policy Analysis Archives
- Vol. 14, 4
The legend of the large MCAS gains of 2000-2001.
The legend of the large MCAS gains of 2000-2001.
- 6 February 2006
- Published by Mary Lou Fulton College for Teaching and Learning Innovation in Education Policy Analysis Archives
- Vol. 14, 4
Open AccessThe legend of the large MCAS gains of 2000-2001.
The legend of the large MCAS gains of 2000-2001.
- Open Access
- 8 May 2003
- Published by Mary Lou Fulton College for Teaching and Learning Innovation in Education Policy Analysis Archives
- Vol. 11, 15
Teaching Children to Read : The Fragile Link Between Science & Federal Education Policy
Teaching Children to Read (TCR) has stirred much controversy among reading experts regarding the efficacy of phonics instruction. This report, which was conducted by the National Reading Panel (NRP), has also played an important role in subsequent federal policy regarding reading instruction. Using meta-analysis, the NRP found that systematic phonics instruction was more effective than alternatives in teaching children to read. In the present study, the findings and procedures leading to TCR were examined. We concluded that the methodology and procedures in TCR were not adequate for synthesizing the research literature on phonics instruction. Moreover, we estimated a smaller though still substantial effect (d = .24) for systematic phonics, but we also found an effect for systematic language activities (d = .29) and tutoring (d = .40). Systematic phonics instruction when combined with language activities and individual tutoring may triple the effect of phonics alone. As federal policies are formulated around early literacy curricula and instruction, these findings indicate that phonics, as one aspect of the complex reading process, should not be over-emphasized.
- 8 May 2003
- Published by Mary Lou Fulton College for Teaching and Learning Innovation in Education Policy Analysis Archives
- Vol. 11, 15
Open AccessTeaching Children to Read : The Fragile Link Between Science & Federal Education Policy
Teaching Children to Read (TCR) has stirred much controversy among reading experts regarding the efficacy of phonics instruction. This report, which was conducted by the National Reading Panel (NRP), has also played an important role in subsequent federal policy regarding reading instruction. Using meta-analysis, the NRP found that systematic phonics instruction was more effective than alternatives in teaching children to read. In the present study, the findings and procedures leading to TCR were examined. We concluded that the methodology and procedures in TCR were not adequate for synthesizing the research literature on phonics instruction. Moreover, we estimated a smaller though still substantial effect (d = .24) for systematic phonics, but we also found an effect for systematic language activities (d = .29) and tutoring (d = .40). Systematic phonics instruction when combined with language activities and individual tutoring may triple the effect of phonics alone. As federal policies are formulated around early literacy curricula and instruction, these findings indicate that phonics, as one aspect of the complex reading process, should not be over-emphasized.
- Open Access
- 4 March 2001
- Published by Mary Lou Fulton College for Teaching and Learning Innovation in Education Policy Analysis Archives
- Vol. 9, 7
Critique of "An Evaluation of the Florida A-Plus Accountability Program"
In 1999, Florida adopted the "A-Plus" accountability system, which included a provision that allowed students in certain low-performing schools to receive school vouchers. In a recently released report, An Evaluation of the Florida A-Plus Accountability and School Choice Program (Greene, 2001a), the author argued that early evidence from this program strongly implies that the program has led to significant improvement on test scores in schools threatened with vouchers. However, a careful analysis of Greene's findings and the Florida data suggests that these strong effects may be largely due to sample selection, regression to the mean, and problems related to the aggregation of test score results.
- 4 March 2001
- Published by Mary Lou Fulton College for Teaching and Learning Innovation in Education Policy Analysis Archives
- Vol. 9, 7
Open AccessCritique of "An Evaluation of the Florida A-Plus Accountability Program"
In 1999, Florida adopted the "A-Plus" accountability system, which included a provision that allowed students in certain low-performing schools to receive school vouchers. In a recently released report, An Evaluation of the Florida A-Plus Accountability and School Choice Program (Greene, 2001a), the author argued that early evidence from this program strongly implies that the program has led to significant improvement on test scores in schools threatened with vouchers. However, a careful analysis of Greene's findings and the Florida data suggests that these strong effects may be largely due to sample selection, regression to the mean, and problems related to the aggregation of test score results.
- Open Access
- 21 August 2000
- Published by Mary Lou Fulton College for Teaching and Learning Innovation in Education Policy Analysis Archives
- Vol. 8, 42
Texas Gains on NAEP: Points of Light?
The 1992-1996 gain in mathematics scores on NAEP from 4th to 8th grades in Texas is placed in perspective. The "miracle" in Texas looks much like the median elsewhere. Of 35 states and two districts (Guam and D.C.), the 52-point gain of Texas was good enough to earn Texas a rank of 17th or about the 46th percentile. Taking into consideration the wealth of states, Texas stands in the middle of the pack—no worse than most other states in delivering educational services to students.
- 21 August 2000
- Published by Mary Lou Fulton College for Teaching and Learning Innovation in Education Policy Analysis Archives
- Vol. 8, 42
Open AccessTexas Gains on NAEP: Points of Light?
The 1992-1996 gain in mathematics scores on NAEP from 4th to 8th grades in Texas is placed in perspective. The "miracle" in Texas looks much like the median elsewhere. Of 35 states and two districts (Guam and D.C.), the 52-point gain of Texas was good enough to earn Texas a rank of 17th or about the 46th percentile. Taking into consideration the wealth of states, Texas stands in the middle of the pack—no worse than most other states in delivering educational services to students.
- Open Access
- 26 July 2000
- Published by Mary Lou Fulton College for Teaching and Learning Innovation in Education Policy Analysis Archives
- Vol. 8, 35
State Standards & Opportunity to Learn in New Jersey
A survey of 245 New Jersey teachers provides a baseline for examining how the introduction of state standards and assessments affects the teaching of math and science in the 4th grade. These policies are promoting teaching of additional topics in both areas. The changes in the delivery of professional development have not yet been sufficient to lead to substantial changes in instructional practice. While inequities in access to material that characterized the state in the early 1990s have diminished, we find a pattern of inquiry-oriented science teaching more prevalent in wealthy districts and teaching to the test more prevalent in poorer ones. We also note some areas where middle-income districts appear disadvantaged.
- 26 July 2000
- Published by Mary Lou Fulton College for Teaching and Learning Innovation in Education Policy Analysis Archives
- Vol. 8, 35
Open AccessState Standards & Opportunity to Learn in New Jersey
A survey of 245 New Jersey teachers provides a baseline for examining how the introduction of state standards and assessments affects the teaching of math and science in the 4th grade. These policies are promoting teaching of additional topics in both areas. The changes in the delivery of professional development have not yet been sufficient to lead to substantial changes in instructional practice. While inequities in access to material that characterized the state in the early 1990s have diminished, we find a pattern of inquiry-oriented science teaching more prevalent in wealthy districts and teaching to the test more prevalent in poorer ones. We also note some areas where middle-income districts appear disadvantaged.
- 1 March 1999
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Educational Measurement
- Vol. 36 (1) , 73-78
Measurement Error, Multidimensionality, and Scale Shrinkage: A Reply to Yen and Burket
- 1 March 1999
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Educational Measurement
- Vol. 36 (1) , 73-78
Measurement Error, Multidimensionality, and Scale Shrinkage: A Reply to Yen and Burket
- 1 June 1997
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Educational Measurement
- Vol. 34 (2) , 123-139
Variance Estimation for Differential Test Functioning Based on Mantel‐Haenszel Statistics
This article concerns the simultaneous assessment of DIF for a collection of test items. Rather than an average or sum in which positive and negative DIF may cancel, we propose an index that measures the variance of DIF on a test as an indicator of the degree to which different items show DIF in different directions. It is computed from standard Mantel‐Haenszel statistics (the logodds ratio and its variance error) and may be conceptually classified as a variance component or variance effect size. Evaluated by simulation under three item response models (IPL, 2PL, and 3PL), the index is shown to be an accurate estimate of the DTF generating parameter in the case of the 1PL and 2PL models with groups of equal ability. For groups of unequal ability, the index is accurate under the I PL but not the 2PL condition; however, a weighted version of the index provides improved estimates. For the 3PL condition, the DTF generating parameter is underestimated. This latter result is due in part to a mismatch in the scales of the log‐odds ratio and IRT difficulty.
- 1 June 1997
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Educational Measurement
- Vol. 34 (2) , 123-139
Variance Estimation for Differential Test Functioning Based on Mantel‐Haenszel Statistics
This article concerns the simultaneous assessment of DIF for a collection of test items. Rather than an average or sum in which positive and negative DIF may cancel, we propose an index that measures the variance of DIF on a test as an indicator of the degree to which different items show DIF in different directions. It is computed from standard Mantel‐Haenszel statistics (the logodds ratio and its variance error) and may be conceptually classified as a variance component or variance effect size. Evaluated by simulation under three item response models (IPL, 2PL, and 3PL), the index is shown to be an accurate estimate of the DTF generating parameter in the case of the 1PL and 2PL models with groups of equal ability. For groups of unequal ability, the index is accurate under the I PL but not the 2PL condition; however, a weighted version of the index provides improved estimates. For the 3PL condition, the DTF generating parameter is underestimated. This latter result is due in part to a mismatch in the scales of the log‐odds ratio and IRT difficulty.