The Efficacy of Methane Leak Detection and Repair (LDAR) Programs in Practice
Open Access
- 28 October 2025
- journal article
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in ACS ES&T Air
- Vol. 2 (11) , 2527-2536
Abstract
Periodic leak detection and repair (LDAR) surveys are a key part of most modern oil and gas sector methane regulations, however their effectiveness in real-world practice has been difficult to assess. This study analyzes three years of reported data from regulated LDAR surveys in British Columbia, Canada, which suggest that 3×/year optical gas imaging (OGI)-based LDAR surveys reduce detected emissions by half at fully compliant sites. However, independent source-resolved aerial surveys at an identical subset of sites find 12 times more methane emissions overall, and four times more emissions after conservatively excluding potential combustion-related and intentional vent sources not targeted by OGI LDAR surveys. This demonstrates that regulated OGI-based LDAR surveys only capture a small portion of total emissions in practice, raising concerns about overestimated mitigation impacts and potentially misguided expectations when assessing alternative technologies. Further analysis reveals the two methods find complementary subsets of sources, with aerial detections comprising a range of larger combustion, vent, and fugitive sources and LDAR detections dominated by numerous smaller leaks from connectors and valves. This underscores the importance of integrating complementary measurement approaches to capture the full distribution of emissions and the necessity of independent verification frameworks such as OGMP 2.0.Keywords
Funding Information
- United Nations Environment Programme (DTIE22- EN4582)
- Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (06632)
- Natural Resources Canada (EIP-22-002)
- British Columbia Ministry of Environment and Climate Change (TP23CASG0011MY)
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Deployment-invariant probability of detection characterization for aerial LiDAR methane detectionRemote Sensing of Environment, 2024
- Robust probabilities of detection and quantification uncertainty for aerial methane detection: Examples for three airborne technologiesRemote Sensing of Environment, 2023
- Leak detection and repair data from California's oil and gas methane regulation show decrease in leaks over two yearsEnvironmental Challenges, 2022
- Where the Methane Is—Insights from Novel Airborne LiDAR Measurements Combined with Ground Survey DataEnvironmental Science & Technology, 2021
- Blinded evaluation of airborne methane source detection using Bridger Photonics LiDARRemote Sensing of Environment, 2021
- Optimized inspection of upstream oil and gas methane emissions using airborne LiDAR surveillanceApplied Energy, 2020
- Detection Limits of Optical Gas Imaging for Natural Gas Leak Detection in Realistic Controlled ConditionsEnvironmental Science & Technology, 2020
- Methane Emissions from Gathering Compressor Stations in the U.S.Environmental Science & Technology, 2020
- Assessment of the Bacharach Hi Flow® Sampler characteristics and potential failure modes when measuring methane emissionsMeasurement, 2019
- Long-term reduction potential of non-CO2 greenhouse gasesEnvironmental Science & Policy, 2007