Shona E. Wilde
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Shona E. Wilde has a total of 90 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- James Daniel Lee
Department of Chemistry, University of York, York, YO10 5DD, UK
14 shared publications - Ruth M. Purvis
National Centre for Atmospheric Science, University of York, York, UK
8 shared publications - Grant Allen
Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9PL, United Kingdom
7 shared publications - Jacob T. Shaw
National Physical Laboratory, Hampton Road, Teddington, Middlesex, TW11 0LW, UK
6 shared publications - James Lawrence France
Earth Sciences Department, Royal Holloway University of London, Egham, Surrey TW20 0EX, UK
6 shared publications - Pamela Dominutti
Université Grenoble Alpes, CNRS, IRD, INP-G, INRAE, IGE (UMR 5001), 38000 Grenoble, France
6 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Methane Emissions and Regulatory Stringency: A Case Study Across Canadian Provinces
Canada enacted its first federal methane regulations for the oil and gas sector in 2020; however, these federal regulations were ultimately implemented as separate provincial regulations that were each negotiated under federal-provincial regulatory equivalency agreements. This has resulted in significant variation in regulatory stringency, enforcement practices, and approaches to methane mitigation. These differences present a unique opportunity to examine the direct impact of different regulations on methane emissions in adjacent regions, with otherwise similar production characteristics and operators.In this work we utilize aerial survey data collected using Bridger Photonics’ Gas Mapping LiDAR to compare methane emissions across jurisdictions operating under different regulatory frameworks. First, we examine emissions in the Lloydminster heavy oil production region that straddles the Alberta–Saskatchewan provincial border. Higher allowable venting limits means Saskatchewan’s regulatory framework is substantially weaker than Alberta’s. This directly correlates with a near doubling of methane emissions intensities among comparable production facilities with similar infrastructure. Moreover, for six producers with multiple assets on both sides of the border, five had higher methane intensities in Saskatchewan. These real-world data highlight the critical importance of regulations in driving mitigation, while simultaneously highlighting the limits of voluntary action.A further case study examines the Peace River region in Alberta, in which a small sub-region was subjected to stricter regulations (Alberta Directive 084), introduced in response to odour complaints, while immediately adjacent regions were not. These regulations effectively prohibit routine venting and, despite not explicitly targeting methane, resulted in substantially lower measured methane emissions among facilities within the Directive 084 zone than among similar facilities outside the zone. Interestingly, these stricter regulations further correlate not only with reductions in occurrence rates of venting tanks but also in a reduction of unlit flares. Overall, these empirical observations demonstrate that producers in both Alberta and Saskatchewan can and do achieve measurably greater methane reductions but are unlikely to do so without a clear regulatory requirement.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessMethane Emissions and Regulatory Stringency: A Case Study Across Canadian Provinces
Canada enacted its first federal methane regulations for the oil and gas sector in 2020; however, these federal regulations were ultimately implemented as separate provincial regulations that were each negotiated under federal-provincial regulatory equivalency agreements. This has resulted in significant variation in regulatory stringency, enforcement practices, and approaches to methane mitigation. These differences present a unique opportunity to examine the direct impact of different regulations on methane emissions in adjacent regions, with otherwise similar production characteristics and operators.In this work we utilize aerial survey data collected using Bridger Photonics’ Gas Mapping LiDAR to compare methane emissions across jurisdictions operating under different regulatory frameworks. First, we examine emissions in the Lloydminster heavy oil production region that straddles the Alberta–Saskatchewan provincial border. Higher allowable venting limits means Saskatchewan’s regulatory framework is substantially weaker than Alberta’s. This directly correlates with a near doubling of methane emissions intensities among comparable production facilities with similar infrastructure. Moreover, for six producers with multiple assets on both sides of the border, five had higher methane intensities in Saskatchewan. These real-world data highlight the critical importance of regulations in driving mitigation, while simultaneously highlighting the limits of voluntary action.A further case study examines the Peace River region in Alberta, in which a small sub-region was subjected to stricter regulations (Alberta Directive 084), introduced in response to odour complaints, while immediately adjacent regions were not. These regulations effectively prohibit routine venting and, despite not explicitly targeting methane, resulted in substantially lower measured methane emissions among facilities within the Directive 084 zone than among similar facilities outside the zone. Interestingly, these stricter regulations further correlate not only with reductions in occurrence rates of venting tanks but also in a reduction of unlit flares. Overall, these empirical observations demonstrate that producers in both Alberta and Saskatchewan can and do achieve measurably greater methane reductions but are unlikely to do so without a clear regulatory requirement.
- Open Access
- 28 October 2025
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in ACS ES&T Air
- Vol. 2 (11) , 2527-2536
The Efficacy of Methane Leak Detection and Repair (LDAR) Programs in Practice
Periodic leak detection and repair (LDAR) surveys are a key part of most modern oil and gas sector methane regulations, however their effectiveness in real-world practice has been difficult to assess. This study analyzes three years of reported data from regulated LDAR surveys in British Columbia, Canada, which suggest that 3×/year optical gas imaging (OGI)-based LDAR surveys reduce detected emissions by half at fully compliant sites. However, independent source-resolved aerial surveys at an identical subset of sites find 12 times more methane emissions overall, and four times more emissions after conservatively excluding potential combustion-related and intentional vent sources not targeted by OGI LDAR surveys. This demonstrates that regulated OGI-based LDAR surveys only capture a small portion of total emissions in practice, raising concerns about overestimated mitigation impacts and potentially misguided expectations when assessing alternative technologies. Further analysis reveals the two methods find complementary subsets of sources, with aerial detections comprising a range of larger combustion, vent, and fugitive sources and LDAR detections dominated by numerous smaller leaks from connectors and valves. This underscores the importance of integrating complementary measurement approaches to capture the full distribution of emissions and the necessity of independent verification frameworks such as OGMP 2.0.
- 28 October 2025
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in ACS ES&T Air
- Vol. 2 (11) , 2527-2536
Open AccessThe Efficacy of Methane Leak Detection and Repair (LDAR) Programs in Practice
Periodic leak detection and repair (LDAR) surveys are a key part of most modern oil and gas sector methane regulations, however their effectiveness in real-world practice has been difficult to assess. This study analyzes three years of reported data from regulated LDAR surveys in British Columbia, Canada, which suggest that 3×/year optical gas imaging (OGI)-based LDAR surveys reduce detected emissions by half at fully compliant sites. However, independent source-resolved aerial surveys at an identical subset of sites find 12 times more methane emissions overall, and four times more emissions after conservatively excluding potential combustion-related and intentional vent sources not targeted by OGI LDAR surveys. This demonstrates that regulated OGI-based LDAR surveys only capture a small portion of total emissions in practice, raising concerns about overestimated mitigation impacts and potentially misguided expectations when assessing alternative technologies. Further analysis reveals the two methods find complementary subsets of sources, with aerial detections comprising a range of larger combustion, vent, and fugitive sources and LDAR detections dominated by numerous smaller leaks from connectors and valves. This underscores the importance of integrating complementary measurement approaches to capture the full distribution of emissions and the necessity of independent verification frameworks such as OGMP 2.0.
- Open Access
- 3 October 2025
- Published by Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) in Environmental Science: Atmospheres
- Vol. 5 (12) , 1282-1296
SO 2 and NO x emissions from ships in North-East Atlantic waters: in situ measurements and comparison with an emission model
Measurements of apparent fuel sulfur content in ship exhausts (aFSC) and NOx/CO2 ratios were made from an airborne and ground-based platforms in the open Atlantic Ocean and the European sulfur emission control area (SECA) during multiple field campaigns from 2019 to 2023. In the open ocean a nearly 10-fold decrease in the mean aFSC demonstrates the strong impact the International Maritime Organization regulation change in 2020 had on sulfur emissions from ships. In 2019, 8 ships out of 19 showed a measured aFSC higher than the 3.5% limit at the time and in 2021 and 2022, 5 ships out of 78 were observed to be higher than the new 0.5% limit. In the SECA in the English Channel, the average aFSC across both 2019 and 2021 measurements was 0.04 ± 0.01%, well below the more stringent 0.1% limit. In the port of Valencia, Spain, which is not in a SECA, observed aFSC was on average much lower than in the open ocean and close to the EU Sulfur directive of 0.1% fuel sulfur content in port areas if the ship stays more than 2 hours in port. In the Port of Tyne (within the European SECA), the aFSC is virtually identical to those measured in the English Channel, with no ships breaching the 0.1% limit. On average, measured aFSCs agree well with the estimates of the Ship Traffic Emission Assessment Model (STEAM3), although the model does not pick up outliers that breach limits. In the open ocean in 2019 the NOx/CO2 ratio was 0.021 ± 0.002, with ratios observed in port significantly lower (Port of Tyne 0.009 ± 0.001, Port of Valencia 0.011 ± 0.001), with a switch to auxiliary engines in ports a potential reason for this lower emission ratio. This work presents the first aircraft-based measurements of aFSC from ships outside of sulfur control zones since the change in sulfur emission regulations in 2020 and largely justifies the assumption that is often made that ships now emit around 7 times less sulfur than before 2020.
- 3 October 2025
- Published by Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) in Environmental Science: Atmospheres
- Vol. 5 (12) , 1282-1296
Open AccessSO 2 and NO x emissions from ships in North-East Atlantic waters: in situ measurements and comparison with an emission model
Measurements of apparent fuel sulfur content in ship exhausts (aFSC) and NOx/CO2 ratios were made from an airborne and ground-based platforms in the open Atlantic Ocean and the European sulfur emission control area (SECA) during multiple field campaigns from 2019 to 2023. In the open ocean a nearly 10-fold decrease in the mean aFSC demonstrates the strong impact the International Maritime Organization regulation change in 2020 had on sulfur emissions from ships. In 2019, 8 ships out of 19 showed a measured aFSC higher than the 3.5% limit at the time and in 2021 and 2022, 5 ships out of 78 were observed to be higher than the new 0.5% limit. In the SECA in the English Channel, the average aFSC across both 2019 and 2021 measurements was 0.04 ± 0.01%, well below the more stringent 0.1% limit. In the port of Valencia, Spain, which is not in a SECA, observed aFSC was on average much lower than in the open ocean and close to the EU Sulfur directive of 0.1% fuel sulfur content in port areas if the ship stays more than 2 hours in port. In the Port of Tyne (within the European SECA), the aFSC is virtually identical to those measured in the English Channel, with no ships breaching the 0.1% limit. On average, measured aFSCs agree well with the estimates of the Ship Traffic Emission Assessment Model (STEAM3), although the model does not pick up outliers that breach limits. In the open ocean in 2019 the NOx/CO2 ratio was 0.021 ± 0.002, with ratios observed in port significantly lower (Port of Tyne 0.009 ± 0.001, Port of Valencia 0.011 ± 0.001), with a switch to auxiliary engines in ports a potential reason for this lower emission ratio. This work presents the first aircraft-based measurements of aFSC from ships outside of sulfur control zones since the change in sulfur emission regulations in 2020 and largely justifies the assumption that is often made that ships now emit around 7 times less sulfur than before 2020.
- Open Access
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Using Repeated Aerial Methane Measurements to Assess Inventory Protocols and Track Year-over-year Trends in Emissions
Measurement-based inventories combining source-resolved aerial LiDAR measurements with bottom-up emission and activity data have provided unprecedented insight into the origins and magnitudes of oil and gas sector methane emissions and, in Canada, are now being used to inform methane estimates used in official national greenhouse gas inventory reporting. However, the protocols for creating measurement-based inventories are new and continue to be refined as both measurement technology and scientific understanding of the oil and gas sector improve. In this study, we examine independent, measurement-based inventory estimates derived from aerial survey data collected during 2020, 2021, 2023, and 2024 in the Canadian province of Saskatchewan; 2021, 2023, and 2024 in the province of British Columbia; and 2021 and 2023 in the province of Alberta. Data for each province are used to quantify region-specific sample size requirements, providing important insights into how prescribed sample sizes may need to vary depending on the characteristics of the production basin. Year-over-year emission trends are also examined in detail, which reveal varying degrees of success in reducing emissions in regions with distinct regulatory frameworks while highlighting key remaining sources to target for mitigation.
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessUsing Repeated Aerial Methane Measurements to Assess Inventory Protocols and Track Year-over-year Trends in Emissions
Measurement-based inventories combining source-resolved aerial LiDAR measurements with bottom-up emission and activity data have provided unprecedented insight into the origins and magnitudes of oil and gas sector methane emissions and, in Canada, are now being used to inform methane estimates used in official national greenhouse gas inventory reporting. However, the protocols for creating measurement-based inventories are new and continue to be refined as both measurement technology and scientific understanding of the oil and gas sector improve. In this study, we examine independent, measurement-based inventory estimates derived from aerial survey data collected during 2020, 2021, 2023, and 2024 in the Canadian province of Saskatchewan; 2021, 2023, and 2024 in the province of British Columbia; and 2021 and 2023 in the province of Alberta. Data for each province are used to quantify region-specific sample size requirements, providing important insights into how prescribed sample sizes may need to vary depending on the characteristics of the production basin. Year-over-year emission trends are also examined in detail, which reveal varying degrees of success in reducing emissions in regions with distinct regulatory frameworks while highlighting key remaining sources to target for mitigation.
- Open Access
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
A Demonstrated Reconciliation of Top-Down and Bottom-Up Methane Measurements to Derive Verified Emission Intensities
Oil and gas companies striving to attain the OGMP2.0 “Gold Standard” for methane Measurement, Reporting, and Verification (MRV) are required to find and measure individual methane sources across all their operating assets, and in particular, to verify total emissions using an independent "top-down" measurement. The process of comparing source-level and top-down measurements is termed “reconciliation” and is an essential part of meeting the “Gold Standard”. However, to date, there is no prescriptive OGMP 2.0 protocol on how to reconcile site and source-level measurements, and there are key knowledge gaps regarding calculation methods, required sample sizes, and uncertainty protocols.This study demonstrates a novel framework for reconciling on site source measurements with independent source-resolved aerial survey data to derive corporate methane emissions and intensity data sufficient to meet or exceed the OGMP 2.0 Gold Standard certification requirements. Critically, the protocol allows for direct analysis of measurement uncertainties. In partnership with an oil and gas producer operating in Canada, a source-level inventory is first created based on extensive ground measurements and company-specific emission factors. Independent source-resolved measurements, covering 100% of the company’s operating assets, are then conducted using Bridger Photonics Inc.’s Gas-Mapping LiDAR (GML). Multi-pass aerial data are analyzed using detailed probability of detection models, which consider the conditions of each pass, and integrated with the bottom-up data to account for unmeasured sources. The result is a comprehensive, verified inventory of total methane emissions for the company. As part of this demonstration, the analysis is repeated using up to four independent aerial surveys, providing real-world insights to the importance of temporal variability in emissions and its influence on required sample sizes for accurate reconciliation. The results have important implications for creating MRV protocols that ensure reported emissions adequately represent the variable nature of emissions, particularly when sample sizes are small because measurements are limited to assets from a single operator as is the case under OGMP2.0 reporting.
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessA Demonstrated Reconciliation of Top-Down and Bottom-Up Methane Measurements to Derive Verified Emission Intensities
Oil and gas companies striving to attain the OGMP2.0 “Gold Standard” for methane Measurement, Reporting, and Verification (MRV) are required to find and measure individual methane sources across all their operating assets, and in particular, to verify total emissions using an independent "top-down" measurement. The process of comparing source-level and top-down measurements is termed “reconciliation” and is an essential part of meeting the “Gold Standard”. However, to date, there is no prescriptive OGMP 2.0 protocol on how to reconcile site and source-level measurements, and there are key knowledge gaps regarding calculation methods, required sample sizes, and uncertainty protocols.This study demonstrates a novel framework for reconciling on site source measurements with independent source-resolved aerial survey data to derive corporate methane emissions and intensity data sufficient to meet or exceed the OGMP 2.0 Gold Standard certification requirements. Critically, the protocol allows for direct analysis of measurement uncertainties. In partnership with an oil and gas producer operating in Canada, a source-level inventory is first created based on extensive ground measurements and company-specific emission factors. Independent source-resolved measurements, covering 100% of the company’s operating assets, are then conducted using Bridger Photonics Inc.’s Gas-Mapping LiDAR (GML). Multi-pass aerial data are analyzed using detailed probability of detection models, which consider the conditions of each pass, and integrated with the bottom-up data to account for unmeasured sources. The result is a comprehensive, verified inventory of total methane emissions for the company. As part of this demonstration, the analysis is repeated using up to four independent aerial surveys, providing real-world insights to the importance of temporal variability in emissions and its influence on required sample sizes for accurate reconciliation. The results have important implications for creating MRV protocols that ensure reported emissions adequately represent the variable nature of emissions, particularly when sample sizes are small because measurements are limited to assets from a single operator as is the case under OGMP2.0 reporting.
- Open Access
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
A Comparison of the Effectiveness of Regulated OGI Leak Detection and Repair (LDAR) Surveys and Aerial Measurements in the Real-World
Periodic comprehensive or screening leak detection and repair (LDAR) surveys are a central part of many current regulations, which are intended to reduce unintentional methane emissions caused by leaking infrastructure. In principle, by swiftly identifying and repairing leaks, emissions of methane, a potent greenhouse gas, are reduced. The primary tools used for comprehensive LDAR surveys are Optical Gas Imaging (OGI) cameras. While OGI can be effective for detecting and visualizing methane leaks, its extension to quantitative measurement (QOGI) is notoriously imprecise. Moreover, studies have shown considerable variation in the performance of OGI in practice, where successful use is heavily dependent on the skill of the operator. Manual OGI surveys are also time consuming and labour intensive. Implementing and maintaining an effective LDAR program that involves multiple OGI surveys per facility can be costly, potentially disrupting routine operations while requiring the deployment of trained personnel to each site. Although operators are obligated to address and verify the repair of identified leaks, there is also still potential that significant leaks may be allowed to persist if they are not initially detected. Consequently, despite the substantial costs involved, the full potential of methane reduction benefits may not be realized. By contrast, aerial surveys have the potential to overcome many of the negatives associated with OGI surveys. In particular, aerial surveys can permit large numbers of sites to be surveyed per day at significantly lower cost per site, reducing overall compliance costs, labour requirements, and improving safety through reduced risks. However, there remains no objective way to assess the relative performance of aerial surveys in complementing or replacing LDAR surveys under different scenarios. In the context of emerging regulations, this is an especially important topic.This work seeks to directly compare the effectiveness of conventional OGI surveys and aerial measurement under real-world conditions. At an identical set of approximately 500 operating oil and gas sites in British Columbia, Canada, we compare and contrast detected and quantified sources in regulated LDAR surveys with parallel aerial surveys completed using Bridger Photonics’ Gas Mapping LiDAR (GML) technology. The publicly reported LDAR reports are parsed to analyze patterns in detected emissions on 1 and 3 times per year deployments which are contrasted with aerial measurements at the same set of sites. This direct contrast under real world conditions gives one of the first large scale tests of LDAR and aerial performance in practice, helping to provide quantitative guidance for the design of potential alternative LDAR programs under emerging regulatory scenarios.
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessA Comparison of the Effectiveness of Regulated OGI Leak Detection and Repair (LDAR) Surveys and Aerial Measurements in the Real-World
Periodic comprehensive or screening leak detection and repair (LDAR) surveys are a central part of many current regulations, which are intended to reduce unintentional methane emissions caused by leaking infrastructure. In principle, by swiftly identifying and repairing leaks, emissions of methane, a potent greenhouse gas, are reduced. The primary tools used for comprehensive LDAR surveys are Optical Gas Imaging (OGI) cameras. While OGI can be effective for detecting and visualizing methane leaks, its extension to quantitative measurement (QOGI) is notoriously imprecise. Moreover, studies have shown considerable variation in the performance of OGI in practice, where successful use is heavily dependent on the skill of the operator. Manual OGI surveys are also time consuming and labour intensive. Implementing and maintaining an effective LDAR program that involves multiple OGI surveys per facility can be costly, potentially disrupting routine operations while requiring the deployment of trained personnel to each site. Although operators are obligated to address and verify the repair of identified leaks, there is also still potential that significant leaks may be allowed to persist if they are not initially detected. Consequently, despite the substantial costs involved, the full potential of methane reduction benefits may not be realized. By contrast, aerial surveys have the potential to overcome many of the negatives associated with OGI surveys. In particular, aerial surveys can permit large numbers of sites to be surveyed per day at significantly lower cost per site, reducing overall compliance costs, labour requirements, and improving safety through reduced risks. However, there remains no objective way to assess the relative performance of aerial surveys in complementing or replacing LDAR surveys under different scenarios. In the context of emerging regulations, this is an especially important topic.This work seeks to directly compare the effectiveness of conventional OGI surveys and aerial measurement under real-world conditions. At an identical set of approximately 500 operating oil and gas sites in British Columbia, Canada, we compare and contrast detected and quantified sources in regulated LDAR surveys with parallel aerial surveys completed using Bridger Photonics’ Gas Mapping LiDAR (GML) technology. The publicly reported LDAR reports are parsed to analyze patterns in detected emissions on 1 and 3 times per year deployments which are contrasted with aerial measurements at the same set of sites. This direct contrast under real world conditions gives one of the first large scale tests of LDAR and aerial performance in practice, helping to provide quantitative guidance for the design of potential alternative LDAR programs under emerging regulatory scenarios.
- Open Access
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
SO2 and NOx emissions from European shipping: a measurement study
The shipping industry is a significant source of both SO2 and NOx, two air pollutants which have neg-active implications for climate and air quality. SO2 is heavily regulated such that January 2020 marked a global reduction of the maximum permitted sulfur fuel content (SFC) in shipping fuel from 3.5% to 0.5% by mass. There are also various limits on NOx in coastal and inland waterways with more widespread NOx emissions limits likely to be implemented in the future. The anticipated effect of the new regulations is an improvement of coastal air quality, but there is a potential drawback in terms of reducing the climate cooling effect of SO2 caused by a change in cloud properties. However, the difficulty in measuring emissions from ships means that the overall impact and level of compliance with new and future regulations is unclear. Therefore, monitoring strategies capable of providing regular and long-term measurements of air pollutant emissions from the shipping industry are essential for fundamental research and compliance monitoring. Here we present top-down methodologies for calculating the SFC, along with emission ratios of ∆NOx/∆CO2 from individual ships. First, we demonstrate the application of an airborne platform to perform targeted measurements of ship plumes in the English Channel and Atlantic shipping lanes, allowing the comparison of emissions inside and out of sulfur emission control areas (SECAs). Second, we implement a stationary, point-sampling approach to measure ships arriving and departing two European ports.Our results show there has been a significant reduction in the SFC of ships in the open ocean shipping lanes due to the new emission regulations, with most ships now well below the 0.5% limit imposed in 2020. Our measurements also show good agreement with a comprehensive ship specific emissions inventory (the Ship Traffic Emission Assessment Model – STEAM). This confirms the validity of models that use the new sulfur limit for radiative forcing calculations. In terms of NOx, the measured ∆NOx/∆CO2 ratios were generally greater than those from diesel vehicles operating within a typical European fleet, suggesting ships could be a significant source of NOx to cities, especially where ports are close to populated areas. It is envisaged that the presented methodologies could be implemented to facilitate widespread monitoring of ship emissions, which could provide the basis for policy formulation and validation.
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessSO2 and NOx emissions from European shipping: a measurement study
The shipping industry is a significant source of both SO2 and NOx, two air pollutants which have neg-active implications for climate and air quality. SO2 is heavily regulated such that January 2020 marked a global reduction of the maximum permitted sulfur fuel content (SFC) in shipping fuel from 3.5% to 0.5% by mass. There are also various limits on NOx in coastal and inland waterways with more widespread NOx emissions limits likely to be implemented in the future. The anticipated effect of the new regulations is an improvement of coastal air quality, but there is a potential drawback in terms of reducing the climate cooling effect of SO2 caused by a change in cloud properties. However, the difficulty in measuring emissions from ships means that the overall impact and level of compliance with new and future regulations is unclear. Therefore, monitoring strategies capable of providing regular and long-term measurements of air pollutant emissions from the shipping industry are essential for fundamental research and compliance monitoring. Here we present top-down methodologies for calculating the SFC, along with emission ratios of ∆NOx/∆CO2 from individual ships. First, we demonstrate the application of an airborne platform to perform targeted measurements of ship plumes in the English Channel and Atlantic shipping lanes, allowing the comparison of emissions inside and out of sulfur emission control areas (SECAs). Second, we implement a stationary, point-sampling approach to measure ships arriving and departing two European ports.Our results show there has been a significant reduction in the SFC of ships in the open ocean shipping lanes due to the new emission regulations, with most ships now well below the 0.5% limit imposed in 2020. Our measurements also show good agreement with a comprehensive ship specific emissions inventory (the Ship Traffic Emission Assessment Model – STEAM). This confirms the validity of models that use the new sulfur limit for radiative forcing calculations. In terms of NOx, the measured ∆NOx/∆CO2 ratios were generally greater than those from diesel vehicles operating within a typical European fleet, suggesting ships could be a significant source of NOx to cities, especially where ports are close to populated areas. It is envisaged that the presented methodologies could be implemented to facilitate widespread monitoring of ship emissions, which could provide the basis for policy formulation and validation.
- Open Access
- 9 February 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Atmospheric Environment: X
- Vol. 21
Mobile monitoring reveals congestion penalty for vehicle emissions in London
- 9 February 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Atmospheric Environment: X
- Vol. 21
Open AccessMobile monitoring reveals congestion penalty for vehicle emissions in London
- Open Access
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Using Mobile Monitoring to Understand Vehicle Emissions in Urban Areas
Tailpipe emissions from road transport have fallen dramatically over the last 30 years due to the combinedeffect of increasingly stringent regulations and technological improvements. However, the air pollutionburden due to road vehicle emissions remains the dominant source of many air pollutants in urbanareas. Policies such as Low Emission Zones (LEZs) have become increasingly popular as a method of reducingon-road emissions by restricting access to the oldest and most polluting vehicles. Most modern vehiclesare fitted with sophisticated exhaust aftertreatment systems, which should lead to significantly reducedemissions of pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx = NO + NO2). However, the performance of suchsystems is non-uniform across all driving conditions. Urban driving conditions are among the most challenging,where vehicle speeds are often low and congestion results in a considerable amount of stop-startdriving with repeated accelerations and decelerations. Under such conditions some aftertreatment systemscannot reach the high temperatures required to operate efficiently, which may limit the effectiveness ofpolicies that target vehicle type alone. Therefore, to develop effective air quality management strategies itis necessary to understand the relative importance of factors that influence vehicle emissions, such as fleetcomposition, traffic state, driver behaviour and ambient temperature.In this work we present results from a mobile monitoring campaign in London, UK. Measurements weremade in two unique locations (central and outer London) in order to provide a quantitative understandingof the main drivers for concentrations in terms of traffic conditions. We show that there is a significant lowspeed penalty for NOx concentrations in central London, where there is a high proportion of diesel vehicles,which are predominately taxis and buses. This effect arises due to the near constant congestion andslow average moving speed of only 12 km h-1, resulting in the non-optimal performance of aftertreatmenttechnologies fitted to diesel vehicles. Moreover, despite the heavy restrictions imposed by the Ultra LowEmissions Zone, which requires all diesel vehicles in the zone to be Euro 6/VI (light/heavy vehicles) compliant,we find that the mean emissions intensity (ΔNOx/ΔCO2) in central London was 0.0039 ppb ppb-1, afactor of 2 higher than outer London (0.0021 ppb ppb-1). For context we compared the measured emissionsintensity to an “urban average" value (0.0018 ppb ppb-1) derived from 135,000 remote sensing measurementsmade directly at the tailpipe. Whilst good agreement was found for outer London, central Londonwas twice as high, suggesting there is a highly unfavourable mix of technology and conditions, which mayhinder the improvements due to current policies. This work aims to quantify the unique effect of congestionon different vehicle types and to provide policy makers with the information needed to better understandthe benefits of congestion control, given that restrictions on technology alone may not always be enough toreduce emissions.
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessUsing Mobile Monitoring to Understand Vehicle Emissions in Urban Areas
Tailpipe emissions from road transport have fallen dramatically over the last 30 years due to the combinedeffect of increasingly stringent regulations and technological improvements. However, the air pollutionburden due to road vehicle emissions remains the dominant source of many air pollutants in urbanareas. Policies such as Low Emission Zones (LEZs) have become increasingly popular as a method of reducingon-road emissions by restricting access to the oldest and most polluting vehicles. Most modern vehiclesare fitted with sophisticated exhaust aftertreatment systems, which should lead to significantly reducedemissions of pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx = NO + NO2). However, the performance of suchsystems is non-uniform across all driving conditions. Urban driving conditions are among the most challenging,where vehicle speeds are often low and congestion results in a considerable amount of stop-startdriving with repeated accelerations and decelerations. Under such conditions some aftertreatment systemscannot reach the high temperatures required to operate efficiently, which may limit the effectiveness ofpolicies that target vehicle type alone. Therefore, to develop effective air quality management strategies itis necessary to understand the relative importance of factors that influence vehicle emissions, such as fleetcomposition, traffic state, driver behaviour and ambient temperature.In this work we present results from a mobile monitoring campaign in London, UK. Measurements weremade in two unique locations (central and outer London) in order to provide a quantitative understandingof the main drivers for concentrations in terms of traffic conditions. We show that there is a significant lowspeed penalty for NOx concentrations in central London, where there is a high proportion of diesel vehicles,which are predominately taxis and buses. This effect arises due to the near constant congestion andslow average moving speed of only 12 km h-1, resulting in the non-optimal performance of aftertreatmenttechnologies fitted to diesel vehicles. Moreover, despite the heavy restrictions imposed by the Ultra LowEmissions Zone, which requires all diesel vehicles in the zone to be Euro 6/VI (light/heavy vehicles) compliant,we find that the mean emissions intensity (ΔNOx/ΔCO2) in central London was 0.0039 ppb ppb-1, afactor of 2 higher than outer London (0.0021 ppb ppb-1). For context we compared the measured emissionsintensity to an “urban average" value (0.0018 ppb ppb-1) derived from 135,000 remote sensing measurementsmade directly at the tailpipe. Whilst good agreement was found for outer London, central Londonwas twice as high, suggesting there is a highly unfavourable mix of technology and conditions, which mayhinder the improvements due to current policies. This work aims to quantify the unique effect of congestionon different vehicle types and to provide policy makers with the information needed to better understandthe benefits of congestion control, given that restrictions on technology alone may not always be enough toreduce emissions.
- Open Access
- 26 January 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics
- Vol. 23 (2) , 1491-1509
Flaring efficiencies and NOx emission ratios measured for offshore oil and gas facilities in the North Sea
Gas flaring is a substantial global source of carbon emissions to atmosphere and is targeted as a route to mitigating the oil and gas sector carbon footprint due to the waste of resources involved. However, quantifying carbon emissions from flaring is resource-intensive, and no studies have yet assessed flaring emissions for offshore regions. In this work, we present carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), ethane (C2H6), and NOx (nitrogen oxide) data from 58 emission plumes identified as gas flaring, measured during aircraft campaigns over the North Sea (UK and Norway) in 2018 and 2019. Median combustion efficiency, the efficiency with which carbon in the flared gas is converted to CO2 in the emission plume, was 98.4 % when accounting for C2H6 or 98.7 % when only accounting for CH4. Higher combustion efficiencies were measured in the Norwegian sector of the North Sea compared with the UK sector. Destruction removal efficiencies (DREs), the efficiency with which an individual species is combusted, were 98.5 % for CH4 and 97.9 % for C2H6. Median NOx emission ratios were measured to be 0.003 ppm ppm−1 CO2 and 0.26 ppm ppm−1 CH4, and the median C2H6:CH4 ratio was measured to be 0.11 ppm ppm−1. The highest NOx emission ratios were observed from floating production storage and offloading (FPSO) vessels, although this could potentially be due to the presence of alternative NOx sources on board, such as diesel generators. The measurements in this work were used to estimate total emissions from the North Sea from gas flaring of 1.4 Tg yr−1 CO2, 6.3 Gg yr−1 CH4, 1.7 Gg yr−1 C2H6 and 3.9 Gg yr−1 NOx.
- 26 January 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics
- Vol. 23 (2) , 1491-1509
Open AccessFlaring efficiencies and NOx emission ratios measured for offshore oil and gas facilities in the North Sea
Gas flaring is a substantial global source of carbon emissions to atmosphere and is targeted as a route to mitigating the oil and gas sector carbon footprint due to the waste of resources involved. However, quantifying carbon emissions from flaring is resource-intensive, and no studies have yet assessed flaring emissions for offshore regions. In this work, we present carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), ethane (C2H6), and NOx (nitrogen oxide) data from 58 emission plumes identified as gas flaring, measured during aircraft campaigns over the North Sea (UK and Norway) in 2018 and 2019. Median combustion efficiency, the efficiency with which carbon in the flared gas is converted to CO2 in the emission plume, was 98.4 % when accounting for C2H6 or 98.7 % when only accounting for CH4. Higher combustion efficiencies were measured in the Norwegian sector of the North Sea compared with the UK sector. Destruction removal efficiencies (DREs), the efficiency with which an individual species is combusted, were 98.5 % for CH4 and 97.9 % for C2H6. Median NOx emission ratios were measured to be 0.003 ppm ppm−1 CO2 and 0.26 ppm ppm−1 CH4, and the median C2H6:CH4 ratio was measured to be 0.11 ppm ppm−1. The highest NOx emission ratios were observed from floating production storage and offloading (FPSO) vessels, although this could potentially be due to the presence of alternative NOx sources on board, such as diesel generators. The measurements in this work were used to estimate total emissions from the North Sea from gas flaring of 1.4 Tg yr−1 CO2, 6.3 Gg yr−1 CH4, 1.7 Gg yr−1 C2H6 and 3.9 Gg yr−1 NOx.