The meaning and role of the functional-organic distinction: a study of clinicians in psychiatry and neurology services
Preprint
Abstract
Aims: The functional-organic distinction attempts to differentiate disorders with diagnosable biological causes from those without and is a central axis on which diagnoses, medical specialities, and services are organised. Previous studies report poor agreement between clinicians regarding the meanings of the terms and some of the conditions to which they apply, while noting the value-laden implications of relevant diagnoses. Consequently, we aimed to understand how clinicians working in psychiatry and neurology services navigate the functional-organic distinction in their work. Method: Twenty clinicians (10 physicians, 10 psychologists) working in psychiatry and neurology services participated in semi-structured interviews that were analysed applying a constructivist grounded theory approach. Results: The distinction was described as often incongruent with how clinicians conceptualise patients’ problems. Organic factors were considered to be objective, unambiguously identifiable, and clearly causative, whereas functional causes were invisible and to be hypothesised through thinking and conversation. Contextual factors – including cultural assumptions, service demands, patient needs, and colleagues’ views – were key in how the distinction was deployed in practice. The distinction was considered theoretically unsatisfactory, eventually to be superseded, but clinical decision-making required it to be used strategically. This included helping communicate medical problems, navigating services, hiding meaning by making psychological explanations more palatable, tackling stigma, giving hope, and giving access to illness identity. Clinicians cited moral issues at individual and societal levels as integral to the conceptual basis and deployment of the functional-organic distinction and described actively navigating these as part of their work. Conclusions: There is a considerable distance between the status of the functional-organic distinction as a sound theoretical concept generalisable across conditions and its role as a gatekeeping tool within the structures of healthcare. Ambiguity and contradictions were considered as both obstacles and benefits when deployed in practice and strategic considerations were important in deciding which to lean on.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: Medical Humanities, 50 (1), 170.
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Integrating neuroscience in psychiatry: a cultural–ecosocial systemic approachThe Lancet Psychiatry, 2023
- The vicious cycle of functional neurological disorders: a synthesis of healthcare professionals’ views on working with patients with functional neurological disorderDisability and Rehabilitation, 2020
- Human brain connectivity: Clinical applications for clinical neurophysiologyClinical Neurophysiology, 2020
- Taking an engineer's view: Implications of network analysis for computational psychiatryBehavioral and Brain Sciences, 2019
- Urologic symptoms and functional neurologic disorders2016
- The dappled nature of causes of psychiatric illness: replacing the organic–functional/hardware–software dichotomy with empirically based pluralismMolecular Psychiatry, 2012
- Basic Concepts in Neuropsychiatry2009
- Cognitive ontologies for neuropsychiatric phenomics researchCognitive Neuropsychiatry, 2009
- Bracketing interviews: addressing methodological challenges in qualitative interviewing in bereavement and palliative careMortality, 2006
- NOTES ON DISEASES OF THE NERVOUS SYSTEM.The Lancet, 1886