Optimizing Fluid Resuscitation Strategies: A Network Meta-analysis of Effectiveness and Safety for Hemorrhagic Shock Patients in Emergency Settings
Authors:
- Fan Maitri AldianFAFan Maitri Aldian
- Visuddho VisuddhoVVVisuddho Visuddho
- Michelle Vanessa AnggarkusumaMAMichelle Vanessa Anggarkusuma
- Jesphine Arbi WijayaJWJesphine Arbi Wijaya
- Anthony Camilo LimALAnthony Camilo Lim
- Galen ChandrawiraGCGalen Chandrawira
- Yan Efrata SembiringYSYan Efrata Sembiring
- Bambang Pujo SemediBSBambang Pujo Semedi
- Jeswant DillonJDJeswant Dillon
Open Access
- 27 November 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in Western Journal of Emergency Medicine
- Vol. 26 (6) , 1795-1803
Abstract
Introduction: Hemorrhagic shock is a life-threatening condition and remains a leading cause of death worldwide. Current European guidelines lack recommendations for one fluid type over another in the management of hemorrhagic shock. This study explores the effectiveness and safety of colloids and crystalloids in resuscitation of hemorrhagic shock patients. Methods: We conducted a systematic search in PubMed, Cochrane Cenral Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), Scopus, Web of Science, ProQuest, and Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature (CINAHL) up to January 3, 2024. We performed data analyses using Rstudio v.4.4.1 in Frequentist network meta-analysis with DerSimonian-Laird random-effects model. Subgroup and network meta-regression analyses was also performed in Bayesian methods. We analyzed safety aspects using meta-proportions with generalized linear mixed models models. Results: A total of 3,693 patients from 23 randomized controlled trials were included in this study. Synthetic colloid demonstrated the lowest mortality rate (odds ratio 0.37, 95% CI, 0.15-0.93; P-score = .94) with the lowest fluid input requirement (mean difference -1.02; 95% CI, -1.62 to -0.41; P-score = .75). Subgroup and network meta-regression analysis revealed none of the covariates significantly influenced these two outcomes. Regarding safety aspects, isotonic crystalloid caused the most diverse adverse events, with acute respiratory distress syndrome (prop = 0.067) and overload syndrome (prop = 0.063) being the most common adverse events. Conclusion: This study provides robust evidence favoring the initial use of synthetic colloid in the management of patients with hemorrhagic shock.Keywords
This publication has 64 references indexed in Scilit:
- Advances in fluid resuscitation of hemorrhagic shock.2001
- Use of Pentastarch Solution in the Treatment of Patients with Hemorrhagic Hypovolemia: Randomized Phase II Study in the Emergency RoomWorld Journal of Surgery, 1998
- Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical testBMJ, 1997
- Evaluation of the Effect of Colloid (Haemaccel) on the Bleeding Time in the Trauma PatientJournal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 1996
- Bayesian approaches to random‐effects meta‐analysis: A comparative studyStatistics in Medicine, 1995
- A Multicenter Trial for Resuscitation of Injured Patients With 7.5% Sodium ChlorideArchives of Surgery, 1993
- PREHOSPITAL RESUSCITATION OF HYPOTENSIVE TRAUMA PATIENTS WITH 7.5% NaCl VERSUS 7.5% NaCl WITH ADDED DEXTRAN: A CONTROLLED TRIAL1993
- 7.5% Sodium Chloride/Dextran for Resuscitation of Trauma Patients Undergoing Helicopter TransportArchives of Surgery, 1991
- Prehospital Hypertonic Saline/Dextran Infusion for Post-traumatic Hypotension The U.S.A. Multicenter TrialAnnals of Surgery, 1991
- Treatment of Hemorrhagic Shock with Intraosseous or Intravenous Infusion of Hypertonic Saline Dextran SolutionEuropean Surgical Research, 1991