Abstract
By offering both subscription and ad-supported content options, Internet content providers (ICPs) can monetize both sides of the market, generating revenue from subscribers for ad-free content and from advertisers targeting free users through cross-side network effects. This hybrid revenue model targets two user segments: subscribers and free users, which form the foundation for the hybrid pricing scheme. This study investigates the equilibrium pricing strategies of two ICPs competing in the subscription market, examining the impacts of market characteristics, including subscription competition, users' price sensitivity, advertising intensity, and the standalone-value difference between the ICPs' subscription options, on users' content choices and the interaction between subscription and advertising profits. We find that as subscription competition decreases, the ICP offering a greater standalone value can achieve a higher subscription profit by raising its subscription fee, especially when advertising intensity, users' price sensitivity, and the standalone-value difference are relatively small. However, when the standalone-value difference is significant, the ICP with a lower standalone value can generate a higher subscription profit by raising its subscription fee, as subscribers switch from its rival to the lower-priced option. In the context of lower subscription competition (or higher users' price sensitivity), the ICPs can reduce their advertising prices as some subscribers convert to free users, leveraging advertiser-side network effects to attract more advertisers and boost their total profits. In contrast, the ICPs can raise their advertising prices with higher advertising intensity, while the conversion of free users to subscribers reduces their advertiser demands, particularly under relatively strong advertiser-side network effects, leading the ICPs to focus more on the subscription segment to enhance their total profits. Thus, ICPs can strategically target different market segments to drive the growth of their total profits.
Funding Information
  • Major Program of the National Natural Science Foundation of China (72394373)
  • National Natural Science Foundation of China (72231004)

This publication has 46 references indexed in Scilit: