Ambiguous symbolisms: recognising customary marriage and same-sex marriage in South Africa
Author:
- 11 November 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in International Journal of Law in Context
- Vol. 7 (4) , 447-466
Abstract
In this article I draw on the South African legal context to critique the argument that same-sex marriage would provide ‘equal recognition’ for same-sex relationships. I highlight the ways in which, despite strong equality provisions in the South African Constitution and an apparent commitment to substantive rather than merely formal equality, both customary marriage and same-sex marriage continue to be subordinate to heterosexual civil marriage. I then broaden my analysis to consider the extent to which this would also be the case in other jurisdictions, particularly the UK. Drawing on the Butler/Fraser debate on recognition and redistribution, I argue that there is a connection between misrecognition and material disadvantage that goes unacknowledged in ‘symbolic recognition’ claims for same-sex marriage. The critiques of ‘marriage equality’ should sound a warning not only to same-sex marriage advocates but also more generally to those who would seek ‘equal recognition’ through law reform.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Not The Marrying Kind2012
- Faith in the Future: Sexuality, Religion and the Public SphereOxford Journal of Legal Studies, 2009
- The South African Civil Union Act 2006: Progressive Legislation With Regressive Implications?International Journal of Law, Policy and The Family, 2008
- The ‘Inevitability’ of Same-Sex Marriage in South Africa’s Post-Apartheid StateSouth African Journal on Human Rights, 2007
- Losing the Feminist Voice? Debates on The Legal Recognition of Same Sex Partnerships in CanadaFeminist Legal Studies, 2006
- NOT (QUITE) A HORSE AND CARRIAGEFeminist Legal Studies, 2006
- Same Sex Intimacies2003
- Accommodating Gender, Race, Culture and Religion: Outside Legal SubjectivitySouth African Journal on Human Rights, 2002
- Family, Law and Sexuality: Feminist EngagementsSocial & Legal Studies, 1999
- Heterosexism, Misrecognition, and Capitalism: A Response to Judith ButlerSocial Text, 1997