Opportunity Gap at the Intersection of Language, Disability, and Science
- 4 September 2025
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Science Education
- Vol. 110 (2) , 400-417
Abstract
In response to the limited research on English learners (ELs) with disabilities, we conducted a series of studies focused on their academic achievement across core content areas. This study reports on science achievement of ELs using longitudinal National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) data from 2009 to 2019, in Grades 4 and 8. Comparing patterns in student performance across grades is particularly important in science, where conceptual understandings build on each other over time with an increasing level of complexity. NAEP science was administered to 4th graders in 2009, 2015, and 2019 ( N = 159,980, 117,300, and 30,990, respectively); and to 8th graders in 2009, 2011, 2015, and 2019 ( N = 154,660, 124,170, 112,740, and 31,960, respectively). Persistent lower science performance is noticed over the past decade in ELs and students with disabilities, with ELs with disabilities being the most academically vulnerable student group across years and grade levels. Both EL and student with disabilities statuses explained 15%–20% of the variance in student science performance, with increasing impacts over the past decade. Controlling for socioeconomic status, the percent of variance explained increased to 26‐29%. School location accounted for 16%–20% of the variance in student performance, with increasing impacts over the past decade. Findings have implications for expanding access to grade‐level science curriculum and linguistically‐responsive science instruction and call for closing the opportunity gap for ELs with disabilities, beginning with teacher education programs promoting shared responsibility of all students.Keywords
This publication has 66 references indexed in Scilit:
- The ideal versus the real: Mismatches in reading instruction for emergent bilinguals in secondary science classroomsScience Education, 2024
- Call for papers: Journal of Research in Science Teaching—Special issue on “Examining translanguaging in science and engineering education research”Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 2022
- Unpacking Contributions of Morphosyntactic Awareness and Vocabulary to Science Reading Comprehension among Linguistically Diverse StudentsTESOL Quarterly, 2021
- Preservice secondary science teachers’ understanding of academic language: Moving beyond “just the vocabulary”Science Education, 2020
- Disentangling language from disability: Teacher implementation of Tier 1 English language development policies for ELs with suspected disabilitiesTeaching and Teacher Education, 2019
- Breaking One Law to Uphold Another: How Schools Provide Services to English Learners with DisabilitiesTESOL Quarterly, 2018
- Research in Science Education for Students with Special Education Needs2017
- Student background determinants of reading achievement in Italy. A quantile regression analysisInternational Journal of Educational Development, 2015
- Pipeline persistence: Examining the association of educational experiences with earned degrees in STEM among U.S. studentsScience Education, 2011
- Message from the “Island group”: What is literacy in science literacy?Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 2003