Managerial leeway in handling the instability of social facts
Authors:
Open Access
- 22 December 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Det Kgl. Bibliotek/Royal Danish Library in Journal of Pragmatic Constructivism
- Vol. 12 (1) , 162-171
Abstract
As our PhD supervisor, Hanne Nørreklit always kept us on our toes with her tremendous engagement, wit, and trust. Like a rotating vortex cloud, Hanne regularly entered our offices to engage in conversations about irregularities in the use of theory, the poor management of public resources or the misuse of organizational power with her convincing enthusiasm and presence. In this paper, we pay tribute to Hanne's scholarship, which has greatly inspired us to pursue research avenues of practical relevance, and to engage in conceptual reflections on the values of practices. In such endeavours, the concepts of facts and factual representation are central. In this modest tribute, therefore, we elaborate on these concepts using two empirical examples of how organizational actors relate to changing facts. In relation to the pragmatic constructivism perspective, Nørreklit, along with a number of co-authors, has conceptualized the ingrained relationship between fact, value, communication and possibilities (for the bases of this, see Nørreklit et al., 2010; Nørreklit, 2017). Pragmatic constructivism as a meta-theoretical approach aims to capture the practical reality of organizations. This work depicts the pervasiveness of the role of facts in relation to managerial practices (Nørreklit et al., 2013; Mitchell et al., 2012; Nørreklit, 2017; Nørreklit et al., 2016; Nørreklit et al., 2010). According to Nørreklit, facts represent the perception of the world, and durable facts will have high credibility because they are based on good evidence characterized by stability while representing a consensus over what is the truth: 'That something is a fact means that its existence is observed according to good procedures so that there is sufficient evidence to make the claim trustworthy' (2013, p. 59). Thus, when facts are based on evidence they have an element of stability, although such facts, or at least what we understand them to represent, are not necessarily fully stable: 'There is nothing one can call facts unless it has been recognized and established as facts' (Mitchell, Nielsen, Nørreklit, & Nørreklit, 2013, p. 12). Therefore, social facts are closely tied to values and belief systems. This interconnectedness is especially noticeable when an organizational change does not match the predominant fact of 'what things are', resulting in the increased instability of the fact in question. With this instability the content of the fact becomes blurred, and a gap might occur between this content and what it covers, namely its extent (Nørreklit, 1987; Linneberg, 2011). Managerial practice and organizational action are closely related to contextual facts, ongoing adaptation to which the broader organizational literature sees as imperative for organizations. For us, focusing on the concept of contextual fact rather than the generic, perhaps more palpable context emphasizes how managers, organizations, and their context and the market make certain assumptions about reality, which have factual status. A conceptual focus on the facts can create an awareness of these assumptions about distinguishing central facts. Also, focusing on socially established facts separates the otherwise overwhelming concept of context into more comprehensible parts which become more manageable. Although such parts will be interlinked, the focus on facts provides places to start reflecting on the takenfor-grantedness of a fact and how facts may represent not an objective truth, but a contextual truth. Therefore, zooming in on the changing facts may permit the prediction or earlier discovery of changes in facts to enable a comparatively speaking superior strategic reaction to them. This is central to organizational life, as a failure to introduce suitable organizational changes to match expectations may have greater impacts on organizations such as a loss of competitiveness or of legitimacy in the market. Therefore, understanding facts and their level of stability at an early stage can make organizations aware of practices that modify, omit, or initiate them.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Institutional work through empathic engagementEuropean Management Journal, 2021
- Performing business and social innovation through accounting inscriptions: An introductionAccounting, Organizations and Society, 2018
- A conceptual development of Simons’ Levers of Control frameworkManagement Accounting Research, 2012
- Scoring strategic performance: a pragmatic constructivist approach to strategic performance measurementJournal of Management and Governance, 2012
- Towards a paradigmatic foundation for accounting practiceAccounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 2010
- The design and use of performance management systems: An extended framework for analysisManagement Accounting Research, 2009
- Governing by Numbers: Why Calculative Practices Matter2004
- What does organizational change mean? Speculations on a taken for granted categoryManagement Accounting Research, 2001
- Budgeting — an unnecessary evilScandinavian Journal of Management, 1999
- Accounting numbers as “inscription”: Action at a distance and the development of accountingAccounting, Organizations and Society, 1992