Margit Malmmose
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Margit Malmmose has a total of 9 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Mai Skjøtt Linneberg
Department of Management, Aarhus University, Aarhus, Denmark
2 shared publications- Hanne Nørreklit
Aarhus University Department of Management, School of Business and Social Sciences Aarhus and Sant’Anna School of Advanced Studies, Institute of Management, Pisa, Italy
1 shared publication - Jakob Mathias Liboriussen
Aarhus University Department of Business Development and Technology Aarhus
1 shared publication Jogvan Pauli Lydersen
Ringkjøbing Landbobank
1 shared publication- Jogvan Pauli Lydersen
Cand.Oecon, Ringkjøbing Landbobank, Ringkøbing, Denmark
1 shared publication Kristoffer Dahl Møberg
Department of Management Aarhus University Aarhus Denmark
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 27 May 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Accounting Forum
- Vol. 49 (3) , 606-633
Balancing autonomy and accountability in national public hospitals – a qualitative case study
- 27 May 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Accounting Forum
- Vol. 49 (3) , 606-633
Open AccessBalancing autonomy and accountability in national public hospitals – a qualitative case study
- Open Access
- 7 June 2024
- Published by Wiley in Financial Accountability & Management
- Vol. 41 (1) , 19-41
A value‐based healthcare approach
This study explores the interpretations of a recently implemented value‐based healthcare (VBHC) approach within a Danish healthcare region. We examine managerial perceptions of VBHC and how it seeks to balance quality and cost while incorporating patient perspectives. Our research involves interviews with hospital managers at different organizational levels, where we delve into their explanations of how they approach VBHC. Applying institutional logics, our case study reveals the complexities inherent in public healthcare management's understanding of integrating patient perspectives. We find that at the regional level, VBHC guidelines primarily emphasize quality indicators, suggesting a strategic focus on quality over finances due to the absence of cost guidelines. Consequently, we identify a unified accentuated willingness among managers to transcend the traditional focus on productivity associated with New Public Management. In this context, department managers highlight intuitive decision‐making approaches and innovative initiatives, which are decoupled from cost information. This decoupling is attributed to a lack of financial expertise at the department level. These managers rely heavily on notions of appropriateness in their reflections on VBHC. On a department level, the term “value” is interpreted as representing the patient perspective, rather than being solely a monetary value of outcomes. Although the latter is often indirectly embedded in decision‐making processes, we posit that nuanced aspects of decision‐making and the collective logics mobilized at various levels of hospital management, particularly in relation to VBHC, remain underexplored areas in the accounting literature.
- 7 June 2024
- Published by Wiley in Financial Accountability & Management
- Vol. 41 (1) , 19-41
Open AccessA value‐based healthcare approach
This study explores the interpretations of a recently implemented value‐based healthcare (VBHC) approach within a Danish healthcare region. We examine managerial perceptions of VBHC and how it seeks to balance quality and cost while incorporating patient perspectives. Our research involves interviews with hospital managers at different organizational levels, where we delve into their explanations of how they approach VBHC. Applying institutional logics, our case study reveals the complexities inherent in public healthcare management's understanding of integrating patient perspectives. We find that at the regional level, VBHC guidelines primarily emphasize quality indicators, suggesting a strategic focus on quality over finances due to the absence of cost guidelines. Consequently, we identify a unified accentuated willingness among managers to transcend the traditional focus on productivity associated with New Public Management. In this context, department managers highlight intuitive decision‐making approaches and innovative initiatives, which are decoupled from cost information. This decoupling is attributed to a lack of financial expertise at the department level. These managers rely heavily on notions of appropriateness in their reflections on VBHC. On a department level, the term “value” is interpreted as representing the patient perspective, rather than being solely a monetary value of outcomes. Although the latter is often indirectly embedded in decision‐making processes, we posit that nuanced aspects of decision‐making and the collective logics mobilized at various levels of hospital management, particularly in relation to VBHC, remain underexplored areas in the accounting literature.
- 31 January 2024
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal
- Vol. 37 (6) , 1558-1594
Patient, productivity, and quality representation in healthcare non-financial disclosure
Purpose: The objective of this study is to examine developments in the discursive practice of non-financial reporting in the public healthcare sector. In doing so, the authors investigate how the main reform foci of productivity and quality are represented, with a specific focus on the patient.Design/methodology/approach: Drawing on critical discourse analysis (CDA), the authors conduct a longitudinal study (2007–2018) of healthcare reporting foci across the five administrative regions responsible for public hospitals in Denmark. The study analyses sixty annual reports and draws on contemporary reform documents over this period. CDA enables a micro-textual analysis, combined with macro-insights and discussions on social practice.Findings: The findings show complex webs of presentation strategies, but in particular two changes occur during the period. First, the patient is centred throughout but the framing changes from productivity and waiting lists to quality and dialogue. Second, in the first years, the regions present themselves as actively highlighting financial and quality concerns, which changes to a passive and indirect form of presentation steered by indicators and patient legislation enforced by central government. This enhances passivity and distance in healthcare regional non-financial reporting where the regions seek to conform to such demands. Simultaneously, however, the authors find a tendency to highlight very different local initiatives, which shows an attempt to go beyond a pure automatic mode of reporting found in earlier studies.Originality/value: Responding to the literature on both healthcare and financial reporting, this study identifies novel links between micro-level texts and macro-level social practices, enabling insights into the potentially intertwined impacts of public-sector reporting. The authors offer insights into the complexity of the construction of non-financial reporting in the public sector, which has a wider impact and different intentions than private-sector reporting.
- 31 January 2024
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal
- Vol. 37 (6) , 1558-1594
Patient, productivity, and quality representation in healthcare non-financial disclosure
Purpose: The objective of this study is to examine developments in the discursive practice of non-financial reporting in the public healthcare sector. In doing so, the authors investigate how the main reform foci of productivity and quality are represented, with a specific focus on the patient.Design/methodology/approach: Drawing on critical discourse analysis (CDA), the authors conduct a longitudinal study (2007–2018) of healthcare reporting foci across the five administrative regions responsible for public hospitals in Denmark. The study analyses sixty annual reports and draws on contemporary reform documents over this period. CDA enables a micro-textual analysis, combined with macro-insights and discussions on social practice.Findings: The findings show complex webs of presentation strategies, but in particular two changes occur during the period. First, the patient is centred throughout but the framing changes from productivity and waiting lists to quality and dialogue. Second, in the first years, the regions present themselves as actively highlighting financial and quality concerns, which changes to a passive and indirect form of presentation steered by indicators and patient legislation enforced by central government. This enhances passivity and distance in healthcare regional non-financial reporting where the regions seek to conform to such demands. Simultaneously, however, the authors find a tendency to highlight very different local initiatives, which shows an attempt to go beyond a pure automatic mode of reporting found in earlier studies.Originality/value: Responding to the literature on both healthcare and financial reporting, this study identifies novel links between micro-level texts and macro-level social practices, enabling insights into the potentially intertwined impacts of public-sector reporting. The authors offer insights into the complexity of the construction of non-financial reporting in the public sector, which has a wider impact and different intentions than private-sector reporting.
- 12 January 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 243-258
Governance in public health care: measurement (in)completeness
During the past 30-40 years, we have witnessed the continuous struggle to balance health care management’s focus on cost and quality, where countries face similar challenges and public pressures despite differences in socio-political set-ups. The major financial performance measurement tool developed is that of diagnosis-related group systems, which have steered hospitals to become more productive and cost efficient. An alternative tool is that of activity-based costing, which, however, is more sporadically applied. Quality in health care governance appears more complex and we have witnessed the development from standardised accreditation systems, central quality indicator systems but also a larger focus on quality improvement centring the individual patient in later years. Thus, we see a progression towards a wish for more completely capturing both financial resource management and constraints as well as individual patient-level needs and expectations in contemporary performance measurement systems while simultaneously struggling with the incompleteness of such systems.
- 12 January 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 243-258
Governance in public health care: measurement (in)completeness
During the past 30-40 years, we have witnessed the continuous struggle to balance health care management’s focus on cost and quality, where countries face similar challenges and public pressures despite differences in socio-political set-ups. The major financial performance measurement tool developed is that of diagnosis-related group systems, which have steered hospitals to become more productive and cost efficient. An alternative tool is that of activity-based costing, which, however, is more sporadically applied. Quality in health care governance appears more complex and we have witnessed the development from standardised accreditation systems, central quality indicator systems but also a larger focus on quality improvement centring the individual patient in later years. Thus, we see a progression towards a wish for more completely capturing both financial resource management and constraints as well as individual patient-level needs and expectations in contemporary performance measurement systems while simultaneously struggling with the incompleteness of such systems.
- Open Access
- 7 May 2023
- Published by Wiley in Financial Accountability & Management
- Vol. 40 (1) , 58-84
University research by the numbers: Epistemic methods of using digitized performance measures and their implications for research practices
This paper explores the way by which universities create meaning of digitized performance measures on research quality and their effects on university scholars’ actions. Drawing on pragmatic constructivism, we scrutinize the epistemic methods by which the digitized performance measures of research quality are handled and used in the governance of research activities in two disciplinary fields in two university settings (Denmark and Italy) and their implications for constructing scholarly research practices. The analysis elucidates exemplars of two epistemic methods of building meaning of and using digitized performance measures: one reflective and interactive, and one authoritative and mechanical. The latter constrains the researchers’ scholarly reasoning and communication and, hence, infringes upon the scholarly fundamentals of university practices. The paper concludes that if the issues of misconceptions of research quality related to the transitions from analog to digital language are neglected, the digital transformation results in dysfunctional human and social practices.
- 7 May 2023
- Published by Wiley in Financial Accountability & Management
- Vol. 40 (1) , 58-84
Open AccessUniversity research by the numbers: Epistemic methods of using digitized performance measures and their implications for research practices
This paper explores the way by which universities create meaning of digitized performance measures on research quality and their effects on university scholars’ actions. Drawing on pragmatic constructivism, we scrutinize the epistemic methods by which the digitized performance measures of research quality are handled and used in the governance of research activities in two disciplinary fields in two university settings (Denmark and Italy) and their implications for constructing scholarly research practices. The analysis elucidates exemplars of two epistemic methods of building meaning of and using digitized performance measures: one reflective and interactive, and one authoritative and mechanical. The latter constrains the researchers’ scholarly reasoning and communication and, hence, infringes upon the scholarly fundamentals of university practices. The paper concludes that if the issues of misconceptions of research quality related to the transitions from analog to digital language are neglected, the digital transformation results in dysfunctional human and social practices.
- 26 April 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Review of Administrative Sciences
- Vol. 90 (2) , 419-436
“Money is not an issue!”: Hospital CFOs’ narratives about handling a sudden shift in managerial focus
The sustained political and managerial focus on cost containment and efficiency in hospitals has been altered by COVID-19-related concerns about public health. Through a novel qualitative study in Denmark, we explore CFOs’ narratives of their experiences during a sudden shift in managerial logic. All of the CFOs describe engagement in key operational procedures and change management that was fostered by the constant search for stability that strongly depended on bottom-up decision-making and flexibility. During this process, the existing competing logics of managerialism and medical professionalism vanished. The CFOs describe new forms of dynamic and collaborative approaches. The possibility of adhering to the core logic of administrative accounting techniques combined with urgency and emotional encounters appears to enable this approach. Thus, we document a moment when well-known opposing logics were suspended by exogenous urgency. This finding suggests possibilities for moving beyond deep-rooted views on established public administration structures and logics. Points for practitioners: Financial managers show administrative skills that are useful for public administration changes in both administration and daily operations. These managers appear to have a strong core identity and willingness to dynamically engage with and facilitate acute frontline operational issues. In an emergency situation such as COVID-19, we find co-dependency across subject fields (administration and medical professions) which enables collaborations.
- 26 April 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Review of Administrative Sciences
- Vol. 90 (2) , 419-436
“Money is not an issue!”: Hospital CFOs’ narratives about handling a sudden shift in managerial focus
The sustained political and managerial focus on cost containment and efficiency in hospitals has been altered by COVID-19-related concerns about public health. Through a novel qualitative study in Denmark, we explore CFOs’ narratives of their experiences during a sudden shift in managerial logic. All of the CFOs describe engagement in key operational procedures and change management that was fostered by the constant search for stability that strongly depended on bottom-up decision-making and flexibility. During this process, the existing competing logics of managerialism and medical professionalism vanished. The CFOs describe new forms of dynamic and collaborative approaches. The possibility of adhering to the core logic of administrative accounting techniques combined with urgency and emotional encounters appears to enable this approach. Thus, we document a moment when well-known opposing logics were suspended by exogenous urgency. This finding suggests possibilities for moving beyond deep-rooted views on established public administration structures and logics. Points for practitioners: Financial managers show administrative skills that are useful for public administration changes in both administration and daily operations. These managers appear to have a strong core identity and willingness to dynamically engage with and facilitate acute frontline operational issues. In an emergency situation such as COVID-19, we find co-dependency across subject fields (administration and medical professions) which enables collaborations.
- Open Access
- 22 December 2022
- Published by Det Kgl. Bibliotek/Royal Danish Library in Journal of Pragmatic Constructivism
- Vol. 12 (1) , 162-171
Managerial leeway in handling the instability of social facts
As our PhD supervisor, Hanne Nørreklit always kept us on our toes with her tremendous engagement, wit, and trust. Like a rotating vortex cloud, Hanne regularly entered our offices to engage in conversations about irregularities in the use of theory, the poor management of public resources or the misuse of organizational power with her convincing enthusiasm and presence. In this paper, we pay tribute to Hanne's scholarship, which has greatly inspired us to pursue research avenues of practical relevance, and to engage in conceptual reflections on the values of practices. In such endeavours, the concepts of facts and factual representation are central. In this modest tribute, therefore, we elaborate on these concepts using two empirical examples of how organizational actors relate to changing facts. In relation to the pragmatic constructivism perspective, Nørreklit, along with a number of co-authors, has conceptualized the ingrained relationship between fact, value, communication and possibilities (for the bases of this, see Nørreklit et al., 2010; Nørreklit, 2017). Pragmatic constructivism as a meta-theoretical approach aims to capture the practical reality of organizations. This work depicts the pervasiveness of the role of facts in relation to managerial practices (Nørreklit et al., 2013; Mitchell et al., 2012; Nørreklit, 2017; Nørreklit et al., 2016; Nørreklit et al., 2010). According to Nørreklit, facts represent the perception of the world, and durable facts will have high credibility because they are based on good evidence characterized by stability while representing a consensus over what is the truth: 'That something is a fact means that its existence is observed according to good procedures so that there is sufficient evidence to make the claim trustworthy' (2013, p. 59). Thus, when facts are based on evidence they have an element of stability, although such facts, or at least what we understand them to represent, are not necessarily fully stable: 'There is nothing one can call facts unless it has been recognized and established as facts' (Mitchell, Nielsen, Nørreklit, & Nørreklit, 2013, p. 12). Therefore, social facts are closely tied to values and belief systems. This interconnectedness is especially noticeable when an organizational change does not match the predominant fact of 'what things are', resulting in the increased instability of the fact in question. With this instability the content of the fact becomes blurred, and a gap might occur between this content and what it covers, namely its extent (Nørreklit, 1987; Linneberg, 2011). Managerial practice and organizational action are closely related to contextual facts, ongoing adaptation to which the broader organizational literature sees as imperative for organizations. For us, focusing on the concept of contextual fact rather than the generic, perhaps more palpable context emphasizes how managers, organizations, and their context and the market make certain assumptions about reality, which have factual status. A conceptual focus on the facts can create an awareness of these assumptions about distinguishing central facts. Also, focusing on socially established facts separates the otherwise overwhelming concept of context into more comprehensible parts which become more manageable. Although such parts will be interlinked, the focus on facts provides places to start reflecting on the takenfor-grantedness of a fact and how facts may represent not an objective truth, but a contextual truth. Therefore, zooming in on the changing facts may permit the prediction or earlier discovery of changes in facts to enable a comparatively speaking superior strategic reaction to them. This is central to organizational life, as a failure to introduce suitable organizational changes to match expectations may have greater impacts on organizations such as a loss of competitiveness or of legitimacy in the market. Therefore, understanding facts and their level of stability at an early stage can make organizations aware of practices that modify, omit, or initiate them.
- 22 December 2022
- Published by Det Kgl. Bibliotek/Royal Danish Library in Journal of Pragmatic Constructivism
- Vol. 12 (1) , 162-171
Open AccessManagerial leeway in handling the instability of social facts
As our PhD supervisor, Hanne Nørreklit always kept us on our toes with her tremendous engagement, wit, and trust. Like a rotating vortex cloud, Hanne regularly entered our offices to engage in conversations about irregularities in the use of theory, the poor management of public resources or the misuse of organizational power with her convincing enthusiasm and presence. In this paper, we pay tribute to Hanne's scholarship, which has greatly inspired us to pursue research avenues of practical relevance, and to engage in conceptual reflections on the values of practices. In such endeavours, the concepts of facts and factual representation are central. In this modest tribute, therefore, we elaborate on these concepts using two empirical examples of how organizational actors relate to changing facts. In relation to the pragmatic constructivism perspective, Nørreklit, along with a number of co-authors, has conceptualized the ingrained relationship between fact, value, communication and possibilities (for the bases of this, see Nørreklit et al., 2010; Nørreklit, 2017). Pragmatic constructivism as a meta-theoretical approach aims to capture the practical reality of organizations. This work depicts the pervasiveness of the role of facts in relation to managerial practices (Nørreklit et al., 2013; Mitchell et al., 2012; Nørreklit, 2017; Nørreklit et al., 2016; Nørreklit et al., 2010). According to Nørreklit, facts represent the perception of the world, and durable facts will have high credibility because they are based on good evidence characterized by stability while representing a consensus over what is the truth: 'That something is a fact means that its existence is observed according to good procedures so that there is sufficient evidence to make the claim trustworthy' (2013, p. 59). Thus, when facts are based on evidence they have an element of stability, although such facts, or at least what we understand them to represent, are not necessarily fully stable: 'There is nothing one can call facts unless it has been recognized and established as facts' (Mitchell, Nielsen, Nørreklit, & Nørreklit, 2013, p. 12). Therefore, social facts are closely tied to values and belief systems. This interconnectedness is especially noticeable when an organizational change does not match the predominant fact of 'what things are', resulting in the increased instability of the fact in question. With this instability the content of the fact becomes blurred, and a gap might occur between this content and what it covers, namely its extent (Nørreklit, 1987; Linneberg, 2011). Managerial practice and organizational action are closely related to contextual facts, ongoing adaptation to which the broader organizational literature sees as imperative for organizations. For us, focusing on the concept of contextual fact rather than the generic, perhaps more palpable context emphasizes how managers, organizations, and their context and the market make certain assumptions about reality, which have factual status. A conceptual focus on the facts can create an awareness of these assumptions about distinguishing central facts. Also, focusing on socially established facts separates the otherwise overwhelming concept of context into more comprehensible parts which become more manageable. Although such parts will be interlinked, the focus on facts provides places to start reflecting on the takenfor-grantedness of a fact and how facts may represent not an objective truth, but a contextual truth. Therefore, zooming in on the changing facts may permit the prediction or earlier discovery of changes in facts to enable a comparatively speaking superior strategic reaction to them. This is central to organizational life, as a failure to introduce suitable organizational changes to match expectations may have greater impacts on organizations such as a loss of competitiveness or of legitimacy in the market. Therefore, understanding facts and their level of stability at an early stage can make organizations aware of practices that modify, omit, or initiate them.
- Open Access
- 18 August 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Health Services Research
- Vol. 21 (1) , 1-15
From centralized DRG costing to decentralized TDABC-assessing the feasibility of hospital cost accounting for decision-making in Denmark
Background: The objective is to examine hospital cost accounts to understand the foundation upon which healthcare decisions are based. More specifically, the aim is to add insights to accounting practices and their applicability towards a newly establish value-based agenda with a focus on patient-level cost data. Methods: We apply a cost accounting framework developed to position and understand hospital cost practices in relation to government requirements. Allocated cost account data from 2015 from all Danish hospitals were collected and analyzed. These cost accounts lay the foundation for diagnosis related group (DRG) rate setting. We further compare the data’s limitations and potential in a value-based healthcare (VBHC) agenda with the aim of implementing time-driven activity based costing (TDABC). Results: We find exceedingly aggregated department-level data that are not tied to patient information. We investigate these data and find large data skewness in the current system, mainly due to structural variances within hospitals. We further demonstrate the current costs data’s lack of suitability for VBHC but with suggestions of how cost data can become applicable for such an approach, which will increase cost data transparency and, thus, provide a better foundation for both local and national decision-making. Conclusions: The findings raise concerns about the cost accounts’ ability to provide valid information in healthcare decision-making due to a lack of transparency and obvious variances that distort budgets and production-value estimates. The standardization of costs stemming from hospitals with large organizational differences has significant implications on the fairness of resource allocation and decision-making at large. Thus, for hospitals to become more cost efficient, a substantially more detailed clinically bottom-led cost account system is essential to provide better information for prioritization in health.
- 18 August 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Health Services Research
- Vol. 21 (1) , 1-15
Open AccessFrom centralized DRG costing to decentralized TDABC-assessing the feasibility of hospital cost accounting for decision-making in Denmark
Background: The objective is to examine hospital cost accounts to understand the foundation upon which healthcare decisions are based. More specifically, the aim is to add insights to accounting practices and their applicability towards a newly establish value-based agenda with a focus on patient-level cost data. Methods: We apply a cost accounting framework developed to position and understand hospital cost practices in relation to government requirements. Allocated cost account data from 2015 from all Danish hospitals were collected and analyzed. These cost accounts lay the foundation for diagnosis related group (DRG) rate setting. We further compare the data’s limitations and potential in a value-based healthcare (VBHC) agenda with the aim of implementing time-driven activity based costing (TDABC). Results: We find exceedingly aggregated department-level data that are not tied to patient information. We investigate these data and find large data skewness in the current system, mainly due to structural variances within hospitals. We further demonstrate the current costs data’s lack of suitability for VBHC but with suggestions of how cost data can become applicable for such an approach, which will increase cost data transparency and, thus, provide a better foundation for both local and national decision-making. Conclusions: The findings raise concerns about the cost accounts’ ability to provide valid information in healthcare decision-making due to a lack of transparency and obvious variances that distort budgets and production-value estimates. The standardization of costs stemming from hospitals with large organizational differences has significant implications on the fairness of resource allocation and decision-making at large. Thus, for hospitals to become more cost efficient, a substantially more detailed clinically bottom-led cost account system is essential to provide better information for prioritization in health.
- Open Access
- 1 December 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Assessing hospital cost data quality in the quest for a cost-effective health care
Background: The objective is to examine hospital cost accounts in order to understand the foundation upon which large-scale health care decisions are based. More specifically, the aim is to add insights to accounting practices and their applicability towards a newly establish value-based agenda with a focus on patient-level cost data. Methods: We apply a cost accounting framework developed to position and understand hospital cost practices in relation to government requirements. Allocated cost account data from 2015 from all Danish hospitals were collected and analysed. Results: We find exceedingly aggregated department-level data that are not tied to patient information. We further observe variations in integrated cost centre definitions and allocation methods, as well as a melding of both overhead and indirect costs with direct costs at the department level. Additionally, we find large structural variances within hospitals. Conclusions: The findings raise concern about the cost accounts’ ability to provide valid information in health care decision-making due to a lack of transparency. Additionally, standardisation of costs stemming from hospitals with large organisational differences has significant implications on the fairness of resource allocation and decision-making at large. Thus, for hospitals to become more cost efficient, a substantially more detailed cost account system is essential.
- 1 December 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Open AccessAssessing hospital cost data quality in the quest for a cost-effective health care
Background: The objective is to examine hospital cost accounts in order to understand the foundation upon which large-scale health care decisions are based. More specifically, the aim is to add insights to accounting practices and their applicability towards a newly establish value-based agenda with a focus on patient-level cost data. Methods: We apply a cost accounting framework developed to position and understand hospital cost practices in relation to government requirements. Allocated cost account data from 2015 from all Danish hospitals were collected and analysed. Results: We find exceedingly aggregated department-level data that are not tied to patient information. We further observe variations in integrated cost centre definitions and allocation methods, as well as a melding of both overhead and indirect costs with direct costs at the department level. Additionally, we find large structural variances within hospitals. Conclusions: The findings raise concern about the cost accounts’ ability to provide valid information in health care decision-making due to a lack of transparency. Additionally, standardisation of costs stemming from hospitals with large organisational differences has significant implications on the fairness of resource allocation and decision-making at large. Thus, for hospitals to become more cost efficient, a substantially more detailed cost account system is essential.
- 10 September 2018
- Published by Wiley in Financial Accountability & Management
- Vol. 35 (1) , 90-114
Accounting research on health care – Trends and gaps
This study reviews 317 accounting studies in health care from the past 40 years. In addition to a traditional description of the theory and methods applied, this review focuses on the countries that have been studied, the stakeholder perspectives that have been represented through data collection and the longitudinal accounting topic focuses that have been developed. The findings illuminate trends and gaps in the literature. Specifically, this study identifies a growing trend of applying interviews as a method of data collection, which increases the possibility of representing individual stakeholders. Predominantly, administrators’ and doctors’ viewpoints are presented, whereas a lack of perspectives among nurses, patients, and politicians raises opportunities for future research. Additionally, there has been an increase in the number of countries represented in studies. Whereas Scandinavian countries are well represented in this literature review, studies of non‐English‐speaking countries are still significantly lacking. The accounting topic in focus has seen a natural development with New Public Management (NPM) reform developments. A majority of costing and budgeting studies in the 1980s and 1990s have gradually changed to a performance measure focus and different atypical areas, signaling increased nuances in the role of accounting in the health care sector. Thus, although the majority of the existing accounting literature has focused on NPM market reforms, NPM health care reform is far from exhausted, and ample opportunities exist for future research in health care accounting.
- 10 September 2018
- Published by Wiley in Financial Accountability & Management
- Vol. 35 (1) , 90-114
Accounting research on health care – Trends and gaps
This study reviews 317 accounting studies in health care from the past 40 years. In addition to a traditional description of the theory and methods applied, this review focuses on the countries that have been studied, the stakeholder perspectives that have been represented through data collection and the longitudinal accounting topic focuses that have been developed. The findings illuminate trends and gaps in the literature. Specifically, this study identifies a growing trend of applying interviews as a method of data collection, which increases the possibility of representing individual stakeholders. Predominantly, administrators’ and doctors’ viewpoints are presented, whereas a lack of perspectives among nurses, patients, and politicians raises opportunities for future research. Additionally, there has been an increase in the number of countries represented in studies. Whereas Scandinavian countries are well represented in this literature review, studies of non‐English‐speaking countries are still significantly lacking. The accounting topic in focus has seen a natural development with New Public Management (NPM) reform developments. A majority of costing and budgeting studies in the 1980s and 1990s have gradually changed to a performance measure focus and different atypical areas, signaling increased nuances in the role of accounting in the health care sector. Thus, although the majority of the existing accounting literature has focused on NPM market reforms, NPM health care reform is far from exhausted, and ample opportunities exist for future research in health care accounting.