Abstract
Shape modification of low Reynolds number airfoils is often measured by lift-to-drag ratio increase but the change in geometric envelope available for load carrying blade structure is rarely quantified. In this study a reliability qualified post optimization framework is developed to quantify this tradeoff using five smallwind turbine airfoils (E387, RG15, S2055, SD6060 and BW-3) and their previously reported modified geometries. Coordinate maximum thickness camber enclosed sectional area centroidal second moments of area conservative section modulus proxies local section depth were evaluated for the ten endpoint geometries. Reliability qualified endpoint aerodynamic performance was considered over Re= 1×10 5-1×10 6. Intermediate states at λ= 0 , 0.25 , 0.50 , 0.75 , and 1.00 were also studied at Re = 2×10 5 , 5×10 5 and 9×105 to investigate evolution between baseline and modified geometries giving a total of 75 morphingpath aerodynamic cases. The endpoint geometric penalties were highly non-uniform: BW-3 reduced normalized enclosed area by about 58.2%, Ixx * by 56.3% and minimum section-modulus proxy by 52.2% but only about 32.0% was retained for minimum sampled local depth. Morphing trajectories also showed that aerodynamic benefit was not always proportional to the degree of geometric modification: at Re = 9 × 10 5 SD6060 gave about 49.5% improvement in peak aerodynamic efficiency at a geometric sectionmodulus cost of about 15.0% whereas BW-3 gave similar 48.9% improvement at about 52.2%. Of the 75 morphing simulations, 43 were complete; 29 peak valid incomplete; two peak uncertain and one invalid. Sampled path non-dominance analysis also showed that fully modified endpoints were not always retained: intermediate states dominated the final S2055 geometry under all three Reynolds numbers and late E387 states under several conditions. Hence our proposed framework provides a geometry-resolved screening technique to identify modifications that preserve relatively larger section level geometric capacity without implying full blade level structural performance.