A comparison of the performance of modern screen-film and digital mammography systems
Authors:
- D GutierrezDGD Gutierrez
- S BullingSBS Bulling
- D LeporiDLD Lepori
- J-F ValleyJVJ-F Valley
- F R VerdunFVF R Verdun
- 18 May 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by IOP Publishing in Physics in Medicine & Biology
- Vol. 50 (11) , 2617-2631
Abstract
This work compares the detector performance and image quality of the new Kodak Min-R EV mammography screen-film system with the Fuji CR Profect detector and with other current mammography screen-film systems from Agfa, Fuji and Kodak. Basic image quality parameters (MTF, NPS, NEQ and DQE) were evaluated for a 28 kV Mo/Mo (HVL = 0.646 mm Al) beam using different mAs exposure settings. Compared with other screen-film systems, the new Kodak Min-R EV detector has the highest contrast and a low intrinsic noise level, giving better NEQ and DQE results, especially at high optical density. Thus, the properties of the new mammography film approach those of a fine mammography detector, especially at low frequency range. Screen-film systems provide the best resolution. The presampling MTF of the digital detector has a value of 15% at the Nyquist frequency and, due to the spread size of the laser beam, the use of a smaller pixel size would not permit a significant improvement of the detector resolution. The dual collection reading technology increases significantly the low frequency DQE of the Fuji CR system that can at present compete with the most efficient mammography screen-film systems.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Evaluation of detector dynamic range in the x-ray exposure domain in mammography: A comparison between film-screen and flat panel detector systemsMedical Physics, 2003
- Full-field digital mammography designed as a complete systemEuropean Journal of Radiology, 1999
- Novel computed radiography system with improved image quality by detection of emissions from both sides of an imaging plate1999
- Advances in high-speed mammographic image quality1999
- Proportionality between Wiener spectra of quantum mottle and the squares of modulation transfer functionsPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 1999
- Classification of compressed breast shapes for the design of equalization filters in x‐ray mammographyMedical Physics, 1998
- Effects of undersampling on the proper interpretation of modulation transfer function, noise power spectra, and noise equivalent quanta of digital imaging systemsMedical Physics, 1995
- Rotary scanning equalization radiography: An efficient geometry for equalization mammographyMedical Physics, 1994
- Investigation of basic imaging properties in digital radiography. I. Modulation transfer functionMedical Physics, 1984
- The Specification of Imaging Properties by Response to a Sine Wave InputJournal of the Optical Society of America, 1954