Accuracy and Reproducibility of Semidigital Versus Fully Digital Cephalometric Tracings Using a New Computer Program Versus Conventional Methods (Gold Standards): A Preliminary Study
Open Access
- 1 January 2025
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in BioMed Research International
- Vol. 2025 (1)
Abstract
Introduction: Cephalometric tracing can be done either conventionally or using computers. Digital dentistry and digital orthodontics have considerably facilitated procedures. Still, their diagnostic accuracy needs assessment. Many orthodontic programs have been developed for this purpose. The efficacy and reliability of such software are usually compared with the conventional method (gold standard). We used novel and more stringent methods of assessment to test a program in this regard. Methods: This study was performed on 10,302 tracing evaluations within 101 cases. Lateral cephalograms of 101 patients were landmarked using two methods (on paper vs. on a computer screen) and traced using three methods (completely conventionally [gold standard]; landmarks were identified on paper, but measurements were calculated by computer; landmarks were identified on the computer screen, and measurements were calculated by the computer program). A total of 15 landmarks and 17 cephalometric tracing measurements were determined via the abovementioned methods. The tracing errors were defined as differences between each pair of tracing methods, as well their absolute values (a total of 6 different tracing errors). Intraclass correlations were calculated for tracing values. Tracing errors were compared with the value 2, as the clinically acceptable range. However, they were also compared with the values zero as well as one hundredth of the mean of gold standard (as a more conservative value), using a one‐sample t ‐test ( α = 0.05). Results: All tracing errors were smaller than the clinically acceptable limits. Moreover, most simple errors were close to zero, and/or below the criterion of 1/100 of the mean of the gold standard. Furthermore, the more difficult error tests, that is, the directionless absolute errors, were all below 2; additionally, they were either below the 1/100 of absolute of the gold standard means or at the level of those means. Finally, the intraobserver reliabilities were high. All the 102 simple errors and absolute errors (on 101 lateral cephalograms) were significantly below 2 ( p < 0.0005, clinically acceptable). Conclusions: The accuracy was appropriate. Of the 51 simple tracing errors, only 9 were significantly greater than zero, and many of them were below or at the level of 1/100 of the gold standard means. All the directionless (absolute) errors were significantly greater than zero. However, in the case of those calculated as “absolute value of (gold standard subtracted by fully digital method),” all errors were below or at the level of 1/100 of the absolute of gold standards’ means. The intraobserver reliabilities were high.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Diagnostic accuracy of conventional orthodontic radiographic modalities and cone-beam computed tomography for localization of impacted maxillary canine teethScience Progress, 2024
- Reproducibility of Computerized Cephalometric Analysis Software Compared with Conventional Manual Tracing for Analyzing Skeletal Stability After Orthognathic SurgeryJournal of Maxillofacial and Oral Surgery, 2023
- On imaging modalities for cephalometric analysis: a reviewMultimedia Tools and Applications, 2023
- Evaluation of accuracy and reliability of OneCeph digital cephalometric analysis in comparison with manual cephalometric analysis—a cross-sectional studyBDJ Open, 2021
- Comparative evaluation of cephalometric measurements of monitor-displayed images by Nemoceph software and its hard copy by manual tracingJournal of Oral Biology and Craniofacial Research, 2014
- Evaluation of speed, repeatability, and reproducibility of digital radiography with manual versus computer-assisted cephalometric analysesEuropean Journal of Orthodontics, 2009
- An evaluation of the errors in cephalometric measurements on scanned cephalometric images and conventional tracingsEuropean Journal of Orthodontics, 2007
- Accuracy of digital and analogue cephalometric measurements assessed with the sandwich techniqueAmerican Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics, 2006
- The reproducibility of cephalometric measurements: a comparison of analogue and digital methodsEuropean Journal of Orthodontics, 2002
- Reproducibility of cephalometric landmarks on conventional film, hardcopy, and monitor-displayed images obtained by the storage phosphor techniqueEuropean Journal of Orthodontics, 1998