Worldview Silencing: Recognizing Reasoned Objections to Brain Death
Open Access
Abstract
The determination of death by neurologic criteria (brain death) has increasingly become a topic of controversy. Here we address a question that provokes clinical ethics consultations and scholarly debate: “how should objections to the declaration of neurologic death be handled?” While much of the discourse on this question has focused on the legitimacy of the criteria for brain death determinations or the motivations of individuals' objections to declarations of death, our analysis addresses a deeper issue inherent in the conflicts in clinical settings. We argue that some objections to brain death cannot be explained away as grief, misunderstanding, or different religious beliefs. Rather, tensions between worldviews—fundamental standpoints or lenses through which humans experience and conceptualize the world around them—may drive conflicts around brain death. In what follows, we introduce the concept of worldview silencing as a means of recognizing the injustice that can occur when brain death objections grounded in alternative ontologies of death are unfairly dismissed or disrespected. Ultimately, we contend that the concept of worldview silencing offers moral guidance for just recognition of objections to brain death in practice, education, and policy.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Taxonomy of Objections to Brain Death DeterminationNeurocritical Care, 2022
- Should the Revised Uniform Determination of Death Act Address Objections to the Use of Neurologic Criteria to Declare Death?Neurocritical Care, 2022
- The Uniform Determination of Death Act is Being RevisedNeurocritical Care, 2022
- Requests for Accommodation in Brain Death Cases: Emerging Role for Pediatric Palliative CareJournal of Pain and Symptom Management, 2021
- Controversies in defining death: a case for choiceTheoretical Medicine and Bioethics, 2019
- The 50-Year Legacy of the Harvard Report on Brain DeathJAMA, 2018
- Brain death and disorders of consciousnessCurrent Biology, 2016
- The Case for Reasonable Accommodation of Conscientious Objections to Declarations of Brain DeathJournal of Bioethical Inquiry, 2016
- East–West Differences in Perception of Brain DeathJournal of Bioethical Inquiry, 2014
- Epistemic injustice in healthcare: a philosophial analysisMedicine, Health Care and Philosophy, 2014