Impact of Compliance on Constant-Height Simple Shear Tests
- 1 December 2026
- journal article
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering
- Vol. 152 (12) , 04026125
Abstract
Simple shear testing is an important laboratory tool in geotechnical engineering, providing insights into soil behavior under conditions relevant to landslides, foundation instability, and earthquake loading. Undrained conditions are often reproduced by imposing constant volume in simple shear tests, where maintaining constant height is essential. However, compliance stemming from deformations in device components can seriously affect results, often causing overestimation of strength. This study quantifies compliance in simple shear equipment and evaluates its impact on monotonic and cyclic tests. It demonstrates that measured vertical strain (nominal compliance) often meets the ASTM standard ( ± 0.05 % of the specimen’s pre-shear height), while actual compliance, which represents the specimen’s actual vertical strain, can easily exceed the ASTM threshold. The consequence for monotonic tests is a subdued response, manifested as less contraction in contractive specimens and less dilation in dilative specimens, resulting in lower peaks and higher troughs in the measured shear stress. A height correction feedback loop was implemented to correct compliance errors in cyclic tests to eliminate the difference between nominal and actual compliance. The findings indicate that compliance delays liquefaction and causes the cyclic resistance ratio to be overestimated. These observations highlight the need to improve compliance control in commercially available simple shear equipment and to improve how constant-height control is evaluated and reported. A stress-based criterion is proposed to replace the current ASTM approach.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Cyclic Resistance of Ottawa F-65 Sand: Experiments & ANN ModelingGeotechnical and Geological Engineering, 2025
- Factors Affecting Liquefaction Triggering of Granular Soils in Laboratory TestingJournal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, 2025
- A Liquefaction Triggering Surface for Ottawa F65 Sand: Cyclic DSS Results and PM4Sand Calibration2024
- Stress-strain behavior of Ottawa sand in cyclic direct simple shear and modeling of cyclic strength using Artificial Neural NetworksSoil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 2022
- Effects of Imperfect Simple Shear Test Boundary Conditions on Monotonic and Cyclic Measurements in SandJournal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, 2022
- Grain Size Analysis and Maximum and Minimum Dry Density Testing of Ottawa F-65 Sand for LEAP-UCD-20172019
- On the Effects of Inadequate Height Control in Constant Volume Monotonic and Cyclic Direct Simple Shear Test2019
- A Critique of b-Values Used for Computing Magnitude Scaling Factors2018
- Cyclic Strength of Ottawa F-65 Sand: Laboratory Testing and Constitutive Model Calibration2018
- Magnitude scaling factors in liquefaction triggering proceduresSoil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 2015