Jeffrey V. Siebers
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Jeffrey V. Siebers has a total of 20 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Radhe Mohan
4 shared publicationsJong Oh Kim
2 shared publicationsMarc Lauterbach
2 shared publicationsP J Keall
Department of Radiation Oncology, Medical College of Virginia Hospitals, Virginia Commonwealth University, PO Box 980058, Richmond, VA, USA
2 shared publicationsPaul J. Keall
Department of Radiation Oncology, Virginia Commonwealth University Medical Center, Richmond, VA
2 shared publications- Paul Keall
The University of Sydney
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 14 August 2008
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 35 (9) , 4096-4105
An energy transfer method for 4D Monte Carlo dose calculation
This article presents a new method for four‐dimensional Monte Carlo dose calculations which properly addresses dose mapping for deforming anatomy. The method, called the energy transfer method (ETM), separates the particle transport and particle scoring geometries: Particle transport takes place in the typical rectilinear coordinate system of the source image, while energy deposition scoring takes place in a desired reference image via use of deformable image registration. Dose is the energy deposited per unit mass in the reference image. ETM has been implemented into DOSXYZnrc and compared with a conventional dose interpolation method (DIM) on deformable phantoms. For voxels whose contents merge in the deforming phantom, the doses calculated by ETM are exactly the same as an analytical solution, contrasting to the DIM which has an average 1.1% dose discrepancy in the beam direction with a maximum error of 24.9% found in the penumbra of a beam. The DIM error observed persists even if voxel subdivision is used. The ETM is computationally efficient and will be useful for 4D dose addition and benchmarking alternative 4D dose addition algorithms.
- 14 August 2008
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 35 (9) , 4096-4105
An energy transfer method for 4D Monte Carlo dose calculation
This article presents a new method for four‐dimensional Monte Carlo dose calculations which properly addresses dose mapping for deforming anatomy. The method, called the energy transfer method (ETM), separates the particle transport and particle scoring geometries: Particle transport takes place in the typical rectilinear coordinate system of the source image, while energy deposition scoring takes place in a desired reference image via use of deformable image registration. Dose is the energy deposited per unit mass in the reference image. ETM has been implemented into DOSXYZnrc and compared with a conventional dose interpolation method (DIM) on deformable phantoms. For voxels whose contents merge in the deforming phantom, the doses calculated by ETM are exactly the same as an analytical solution, contrasting to the DIM which has an average 1.1% dose discrepancy in the beam direction with a maximum error of 24.9% found in the penumbra of a beam. The DIM error observed persists even if voxel subdivision is used. The ETM is computationally efficient and will be useful for 4D dose addition and benchmarking alternative 4D dose addition algorithms.
- 1 February 2008
- Published by IOP Publishing in Journal of Physics: Conference Series
- Vol. 102 (1) , 012020
The effect of statistical noise on IMRT plan quality and convergence for MC-based and MC-correction-based optimized treatment plans
Monte Carlo (MC) is rarely used for IMRT plan optimization outside of research centres due to the extensive computational resources or long computation times required to complete the process. Time can be reduced by degrading the statistical precision of the MC dose calculation used within the optimization loop. However, this eventually introduces optimization convergence errors (OCEs). This study determines the statistical noise levels tolerated during MC-IMRT optimization under the condition that the optimized plan has OCEs D>0.5Dmax. The MC dose computation time for the OC-optimization is only 6.2 minutes on a single 3 Ghz processor with results clinically equivalent to high precision MC computations.
- 1 February 2008
- Published by IOP Publishing in Journal of Physics: Conference Series
- Vol. 102 (1) , 012020
The effect of statistical noise on IMRT plan quality and convergence for MC-based and MC-correction-based optimized treatment plans
Monte Carlo (MC) is rarely used for IMRT plan optimization outside of research centres due to the extensive computational resources or long computation times required to complete the process. Time can be reduced by degrading the statistical precision of the MC dose calculation used within the optimization loop. However, this eventually introduces optimization convergence errors (OCEs). This study determines the statistical noise levels tolerated during MC-IMRT optimization under the condition that the optimized plan has OCEs D>0.5Dmax. The MC dose computation time for the OC-optimization is only 6.2 minutes on a single 3 Ghz processor with results clinically equivalent to high precision MC computations.
- 15 June 2007
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 34 (7) , 2853-2863
Performance of a hybrid MC dose algorithm for IMRT optimization dose evaluation
This paper presents a hybrid intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) optimization strategy which combines the speed of pencil beam (PB) and the accuracy of Monte Carlo (MC) dose calculations. After an initial deliverable‐based optimization using a PB algorithm, doses are recomputed using theMC code to determine dose correction factors, which are then utilized during further PB‐based optimization. The hybrid method is benchmarked with respect to full MC deliverable‐based optimization for ten prostate and ten head‐and‐neck IMRT plans. Final optimized plans are compared in terms of dose‐volume indices used for the plan optimization. Dose prediction errors (DPEs) and optimization convergence errors (OCEs) at intermediate steps of the hybrid sequence are evaluated. The hybrid method is found to produce optimized plans that are clinically equivalent to full MC‐based optimization, yet requires only 40% of the number of MC dose calculations. With the hybrid strategy presented here, MC‐based optimization results are achieved inor less on a modest computing cluster. While the initial PB‐deliverable‐based optimization is found to have DPEs and OCEs of up torelative to theprescription doses, application of the first MC correction reduces the average DPEs to less thanfor the prostate plans and less thanfor the head and neck plans. The maximum observed DPE or OCE isafter 1 MC dose correction, indicating that a single MC dose calculation correction might be sufficient for IMRT optimization.
- 15 June 2007
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 34 (7) , 2853-2863
Performance of a hybrid MC dose algorithm for IMRT optimization dose evaluation
This paper presents a hybrid intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) optimization strategy which combines the speed of pencil beam (PB) and the accuracy of Monte Carlo (MC) dose calculations. After an initial deliverable‐based optimization using a PB algorithm, doses are recomputed using theMC code to determine dose correction factors, which are then utilized during further PB‐based optimization. The hybrid method is benchmarked with respect to full MC deliverable‐based optimization for ten prostate and ten head‐and‐neck IMRT plans. Final optimized plans are compared in terms of dose‐volume indices used for the plan optimization. Dose prediction errors (DPEs) and optimization convergence errors (OCEs) at intermediate steps of the hybrid sequence are evaluated. The hybrid method is found to produce optimized plans that are clinically equivalent to full MC‐based optimization, yet requires only 40% of the number of MC dose calculations. With the hybrid strategy presented here, MC‐based optimization results are achieved inor less on a modest computing cluster. While the initial PB‐deliverable‐based optimization is found to have DPEs and OCEs of up torelative to theprescription doses, application of the first MC correction reduces the average DPEs to less thanfor the prostate plans and less thanfor the head and neck plans. The maximum observed DPE or OCE isafter 1 MC dose correction, indicating that a single MC dose calculation correction might be sufficient for IMRT optimization.
- 9 May 2007
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 34 (6Part1) , 1944-1951
A strategy to correct for intrafraction target translation in conformal prostate radiotherapy: Simulation results
A strategy is proposed in which intrafraction internal target translation is corrected for by repositioning the multileaf collimator position aperture to conform to the new target pose in the beam projection, and the beam monitor units are adjusted to account for the change in the geometric relationship between the target and the beam. The purpose of this study was to investigate the dosimetric stability of the prostate and critical structures in the presence of internal target translation using the dynamic compensation strategy. Twenty-five previously treated prostate cancer patients were replanned using a four-field conformal technique to deliver 72 Gy to 95% of the planning target volume (PTV). Internal translation was introduced by displacing the prostate PTV (no rotation or deformation was considered). Thirty-six randomly selected isotropic displacements of magnitude 0.5, 1.0, 1.5 and 2.0 cm were sampled for each patient, for a total of 3600 errors. Due to their anatomic relation to the prostate, the rectum and bladder contours were also moved with the same magnitude and direction as the prostate. The dynamic compensation strategy was used to correct each of these errors by conforming the beam apertures to the new target pose and adjusting the monitor units using inverse-square and off-axis factor corrections. The dynamic compensation strategy plans were then compared to the original treatment plans via dose-volume histogram (DVH) analysis. Changes of more than 5% of the prescription dose (3.6 Gy) were deemed clinically significant. Compared to the original treatment plans, the dynamic compensation strategy produced small discrepancies in isodose distributions and DVH analyses for all structures considered apart from the femoral heads. These differences increased with the magnitude of the internal motion. Coverage of the PTV was excellent: D5, D95, and Dmean were not increased or decreased by more than 5% of the prescription dose for any of the 3600 simulated internal motion shifts. Dose increases for adjacent organs at risk were rare. D33 of the rectum and D20 of the bladder were increased by more than 5% of the prescription dose in 9 and 1 instances of the 3600 sampled internal motion shifts, respectively. Dmean of the right femoral head increased by more than 5% of the prescription dose in 651 (18%) internal motion shifts, predominantly due to the projection of the lateral beams through the femoral head for anterior prostate motion. However, D2 was not increased by more than 5% for any of the internal motion shifts. These data demonstrate the robustness of the proposed dynamic compensation strategy for correction of internal motion in conformal prostate radiotherapy, with minimal deviation from the original treatment plans even for errors exceeding those commonly encountered in the clinic. The compensation strategy could be performed automatically with appropriate enhancements to available delivery software.
- 9 May 2007
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 34 (6Part1) , 1944-1951
A strategy to correct for intrafraction target translation in conformal prostate radiotherapy: Simulation results
A strategy is proposed in which intrafraction internal target translation is corrected for by repositioning the multileaf collimator position aperture to conform to the new target pose in the beam projection, and the beam monitor units are adjusted to account for the change in the geometric relationship between the target and the beam. The purpose of this study was to investigate the dosimetric stability of the prostate and critical structures in the presence of internal target translation using the dynamic compensation strategy. Twenty-five previously treated prostate cancer patients were replanned using a four-field conformal technique to deliver 72 Gy to 95% of the planning target volume (PTV). Internal translation was introduced by displacing the prostate PTV (no rotation or deformation was considered). Thirty-six randomly selected isotropic displacements of magnitude 0.5, 1.0, 1.5 and 2.0 cm were sampled for each patient, for a total of 3600 errors. Due to their anatomic relation to the prostate, the rectum and bladder contours were also moved with the same magnitude and direction as the prostate. The dynamic compensation strategy was used to correct each of these errors by conforming the beam apertures to the new target pose and adjusting the monitor units using inverse-square and off-axis factor corrections. The dynamic compensation strategy plans were then compared to the original treatment plans via dose-volume histogram (DVH) analysis. Changes of more than 5% of the prescription dose (3.6 Gy) were deemed clinically significant. Compared to the original treatment plans, the dynamic compensation strategy produced small discrepancies in isodose distributions and DVH analyses for all structures considered apart from the femoral heads. These differences increased with the magnitude of the internal motion. Coverage of the PTV was excellent: D5, D95, and Dmean were not increased or decreased by more than 5% of the prescription dose for any of the 3600 simulated internal motion shifts. Dose increases for adjacent organs at risk were rare. D33 of the rectum and D20 of the bladder were increased by more than 5% of the prescription dose in 9 and 1 instances of the 3600 sampled internal motion shifts, respectively. Dmean of the right femoral head increased by more than 5% of the prescription dose in 651 (18%) internal motion shifts, predominantly due to the projection of the lateral beams through the femoral head for anterior prostate motion. However, D2 was not increased by more than 5% for any of the internal motion shifts. These data demonstrate the robustness of the proposed dynamic compensation strategy for correction of internal motion in conformal prostate radiotherapy, with minimal deviation from the original treatment plans even for errors exceeding those commonly encountered in the clinic. The compensation strategy could be performed automatically with appropriate enhancements to available delivery software.
- 1 October 2005
- Published by Elsevier in International Journal of Radiation Oncology - Biology - Physics (IJROBP)
- Vol. 63 (2) , 422-433
Effect of patient setup errors on simultaneously integrated boost head and neck IMRT treatment plans
- 1 October 2005
- Published by Elsevier in International Journal of Radiation Oncology - Biology - Physics (IJROBP)
- Vol. 63 (2) , 422-433
Effect of patient setup errors on simultaneously integrated boost head and neck IMRT treatment plans
- 24 June 2004
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 31 (7) , 2135-2146
Monte Carlo computation of dosimetric amorphous silicon electronic portal images
This study develops and tests a method to compute dosimetric images for an amorphous siliconflat‐panel detector so that an accurate quantitative comparison between measured and computed portal images may be made. An EGS4‐based Monte Carlo (MC) algorithm is developed to efficiently tally the energy deposition through the use of a virtual detector dose‐scoring methodology. The complete geometry of theimager is utilized in the MC calculation up to the imager rear housing, which is replaced with a uniform thickness material slab. The detector‐mounting hardware is modeled as a uniform backscattering material. The amount of backscatter material required to reproduce the measured backscatter is 0.98 g/cm2of water. A flood‐field irradiation, performed in the measurement imaging session, is used to cross‐calibrate the computed images with the measured images. Calibrated MC‐computed images reproduce measured field‐size dependencies of the electronic portal imaging device (EPID) response to within <1%, without the need for optical glare or other empirical corrections. A 10% dose difference between measured and computed images was observed outside the field edge for afield that was entirely blocked by the multileaf collimator (MLC). However, this error corresponded with less than 0.15% of the open‐field dose. Forfields produced by 5 and 20 mm dynamically sweeping MLC gaps, more than 98% of the points were found to have a gamma less than one with a 2%, 2 mm criteria. For an intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) patient test field, over 99% of the points were found to have a gamma less than one with a 2%, 2 mm criteria. This study demonstrates that MC can be an effective tool for predicting measuredportal images and may be useful for IMRT EPID‐based dosimetry.
- 24 June 2004
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 31 (7) , 2135-2146
Monte Carlo computation of dosimetric amorphous silicon electronic portal images
This study develops and tests a method to compute dosimetric images for an amorphous siliconflat‐panel detector so that an accurate quantitative comparison between measured and computed portal images may be made. An EGS4‐based Monte Carlo (MC) algorithm is developed to efficiently tally the energy deposition through the use of a virtual detector dose‐scoring methodology. The complete geometry of theimager is utilized in the MC calculation up to the imager rear housing, which is replaced with a uniform thickness material slab. The detector‐mounting hardware is modeled as a uniform backscattering material. The amount of backscatter material required to reproduce the measured backscatter is 0.98 g/cm2of water. A flood‐field irradiation, performed in the measurement imaging session, is used to cross‐calibrate the computed images with the measured images. Calibrated MC‐computed images reproduce measured field‐size dependencies of the electronic portal imaging device (EPID) response to within <1%, without the need for optical glare or other empirical corrections. A 10% dose difference between measured and computed images was observed outside the field edge for afield that was entirely blocked by the multileaf collimator (MLC). However, this error corresponded with less than 0.15% of the open‐field dose. Forfields produced by 5 and 20 mm dynamically sweeping MLC gaps, more than 98% of the points were found to have a gamma less than one with a 2%, 2 mm criteria. For an intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) patient test field, over 99% of the points were found to have a gamma less than one with a 2%, 2 mm criteria. This study demonstrates that MC can be an effective tool for predicting measuredportal images and may be useful for IMRT EPID‐based dosimetry.
- 20 August 2002
- Published by IOP Publishing in Physics in Medicine & Biology
- Vol. 47 (17) , 3225-3249
A method for photon beam Monte Carlo multileaf collimator particle transport
Monte Carlo (MC) algorithms are recognized as the most accurate methodology for patient dose assessment. For intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) delivered with dynamic multileaf collimators (DMLCs), accurate dose calculation, even with MC, is challenging. Accurate IMRT MC dose calculations require inclusion of the moving MLC in the MC simulation. Due to its complex geometry, full transport through the MLC can be time consuming. The aim of this work was to develop an MLC model for photon beam MC IMRT dose computations. The basis of the MC MLC model is that the complex MLC geometry can be separated into simple geometric regions, each of which readily lends itself to simplified radiation transport. For photons, only attenuation and first Compton scatter interactions are considered. The amount of attenuation material an individual particle encounters while traversing the entire MLC is determined by adding the individual amounts from each of the simplified geometric regions. Compton scatter is sampled based upon the total thickness traversed. Pair production and electron interactions (scattering and bremsstrahlung) within the MLC are ignored. The MLC model was tested for 6 MV and 18 MV photon beams by comparing it with measurements and MC simulations that incorporate the full physics and geometry for fields blocked by the MLC and with measurements for fields with the maximum possible tongue-and-groove and tongue-or-groove effects, for static test cases and for sliding windows of various widths. The MLC model predicts the field size dependence of the MLC leakage radiation within 0.1% of the open-field dose. The entrance dose and beam hardening behind a closed MLC are predicted within +/- 1% or 1 mm. Dose undulations due to differences in inter- and intra-leaf leakage are also correctly predicted. The MC MLC model predicts leaf-edge tongue-and-groove dose effect within +/- 1% or 1 mm for 95% of the points compared at 6 MV and 88% of the points compared at 18 MV. The dose through a static leaf tip is also predicted generally within +/- 1% or 1 mm. Tests with sliding windows of various widths confirm the accuracy of the MLC model for dynamic delivery and indicate that accounting for a slight leaf position error (0.008 cm for our MLC) will improve the accuracy of the model. The MLC model developed is applicable to both dynamic MLC and segmental MLC IMRT beam delivery and will be useful for patient IMRT dose calculations, pre-treatment verification of IMRT delivery and IMRT portal dose transmission dosimetry.
- 20 August 2002
- Published by IOP Publishing in Physics in Medicine & Biology
- Vol. 47 (17) , 3225-3249
A method for photon beam Monte Carlo multileaf collimator particle transport
Monte Carlo (MC) algorithms are recognized as the most accurate methodology for patient dose assessment. For intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) delivered with dynamic multileaf collimators (DMLCs), accurate dose calculation, even with MC, is challenging. Accurate IMRT MC dose calculations require inclusion of the moving MLC in the MC simulation. Due to its complex geometry, full transport through the MLC can be time consuming. The aim of this work was to develop an MLC model for photon beam MC IMRT dose computations. The basis of the MC MLC model is that the complex MLC geometry can be separated into simple geometric regions, each of which readily lends itself to simplified radiation transport. For photons, only attenuation and first Compton scatter interactions are considered. The amount of attenuation material an individual particle encounters while traversing the entire MLC is determined by adding the individual amounts from each of the simplified geometric regions. Compton scatter is sampled based upon the total thickness traversed. Pair production and electron interactions (scattering and bremsstrahlung) within the MLC are ignored. The MLC model was tested for 6 MV and 18 MV photon beams by comparing it with measurements and MC simulations that incorporate the full physics and geometry for fields blocked by the MLC and with measurements for fields with the maximum possible tongue-and-groove and tongue-or-groove effects, for static test cases and for sliding windows of various widths. The MLC model predicts the field size dependence of the MLC leakage radiation within 0.1% of the open-field dose. The entrance dose and beam hardening behind a closed MLC are predicted within +/- 1% or 1 mm. Dose undulations due to differences in inter- and intra-leaf leakage are also correctly predicted. The MC MLC model predicts leaf-edge tongue-and-groove dose effect within +/- 1% or 1 mm for 95% of the points compared at 6 MV and 88% of the points compared at 18 MV. The dose through a static leaf tip is also predicted generally within +/- 1% or 1 mm. Tests with sliding windows of various widths confirm the accuracy of the MLC model for dynamic delivery and indicate that accounting for a slight leaf position error (0.008 cm for our MLC) will improve the accuracy of the model. The MLC model developed is applicable to both dynamic MLC and segmental MLC IMRT beam delivery and will be useful for patient IMRT dose calculations, pre-treatment verification of IMRT delivery and IMRT portal dose transmission dosimetry.
- 3 May 2002
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 29 (6) , 952-959
Incorporating multi‐leaf collimator leaf sequencing into iterative IMRT optimization
Intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) treatment planning typically considers beam optimization and beam delivery as separate tasks. Following optimization, a multi-leaf collimator (MLC) or other beam delivery device is used to generate fluence patterns for patient treatment delivery. Due to limitations and characteristics of the MLC, the deliverable intensity distributions often differ from those produced by the optimizer, leading to differences between the delivered and the optimized doses. Objective function parameters are then adjusted empirically, and the plan is reoptimized to achieve a desired deliverable dose distribution. The resulting plan, though usually acceptable, may not be the best achievable. A method has been developed to incorporate the MLC restrictions into the optimization process. Our in-house IMRT system has been modified to include the calculation of the deliverable intensity into the optimizer. In this process, prior to dose calculation, the MLC leaf sequencer is used to convert intensities to dynamic MLC sequences, from which the deliverable intensities are then determined. All other optimization steps remain the same. To evaluate the effectiveness of deliverable-based optimization, 17 patient cases have been studied. Compared with standard optimization plus conversion to deliverable beams, deliverable-based optimization results show improved isodose coverage and a reduced dose to critical structures. Deliverable-based optimization results are close to the original nondeliverable optimization results, suggesting that IMRT can overcome the MLC limitations by adjusting individual beamlets. The use of deliverable-based optimization may reduce the need for empirical adjustment of objective function parameters and reoptimization of a plan to achieve desired results.
- 3 May 2002
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 29 (6) , 952-959
Incorporating multi‐leaf collimator leaf sequencing into iterative IMRT optimization
Intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) treatment planning typically considers beam optimization and beam delivery as separate tasks. Following optimization, a multi-leaf collimator (MLC) or other beam delivery device is used to generate fluence patterns for patient treatment delivery. Due to limitations and characteristics of the MLC, the deliverable intensity distributions often differ from those produced by the optimizer, leading to differences between the delivered and the optimized doses. Objective function parameters are then adjusted empirically, and the plan is reoptimized to achieve a desired deliverable dose distribution. The resulting plan, though usually acceptable, may not be the best achievable. A method has been developed to incorporate the MLC restrictions into the optimization process. Our in-house IMRT system has been modified to include the calculation of the deliverable intensity into the optimizer. In this process, prior to dose calculation, the MLC leaf sequencer is used to convert intensities to dynamic MLC sequences, from which the deliverable intensities are then determined. All other optimization steps remain the same. To evaluate the effectiveness of deliverable-based optimization, 17 patient cases have been studied. Compared with standard optimization plus conversion to deliverable beams, deliverable-based optimization results show improved isodose coverage and a reduced dose to critical structures. Deliverable-based optimization results are close to the original nondeliverable optimization results, suggesting that IMRT can overcome the MLC limitations by adjusting individual beamlets. The use of deliverable-based optimization may reduce the need for empirical adjustment of objective function parameters and reoptimization of a plan to achieve desired results.
- 25 January 2002
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 29 (2) , 231-237
Reducing dose calculation time for accurate iterative IMRT planning
A time-consuming component of IMRToptimization is the dose computation required in each iteration for the evaluation of the objective function. Accurate superposition/convolution (SC) and Monte Carlo (MC) dose calculations are currently considered too time-consuming for iterative IMRT dose calculation. Thus, fast, but less accurate algorithms such as pencil beam (PB) algorithms are typically used in most current IMRT systems. This paper describes two hybrid methods that utilize the speed of fast PB algorithms yet achieve the accuracy of optimizing based upon SC algorithms via the application of dose correction matrices. In one method, the ratio method, an infrequently computed voxel-by-voxel dose ratio matrix (R=D SC /D PB ) is applied for each beam to the dose distributions calculated with the PB method during the optimization. That is, D PB ×R is used for the dose calculation during the optimization. The optimization proceeds until both the IMRT beam intensities and the dose correction ratio matrix converge. In the second method, the correction method, a periodically computed voxel-by-voxel correction matrix for each beam, defined to be the difference between the SC and PB dose computations, is used to correct PB dose distributions. To validate the methods, IMRT treatment plans developed with the hybrid methods are compared with those obtained when the SC algorithm is used for all optimizationiterations and with those obtained when PB-based optimization is followed by SC-based optimization. In the 12 patient cases studied, no clinically significant differences exist in the final treatment plans developed with each of the dose computation methodologies. However, the number of time-consuming SC iterations is reduced from 6-32 for pure SC optimization to four or less for the ratio matrix method and five or less for the correction method. Because the PB algorithm is faster at computing dose, this reduces the inverse planning optimization time for our implementation by a factor of 2 to 8 compared with pure SC optimization, without compromising the quality or accuracy of the final treatment plan.
- 25 January 2002
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 29 (2) , 231-237
Reducing dose calculation time for accurate iterative IMRT planning
A time-consuming component of IMRToptimization is the dose computation required in each iteration for the evaluation of the objective function. Accurate superposition/convolution (SC) and Monte Carlo (MC) dose calculations are currently considered too time-consuming for iterative IMRT dose calculation. Thus, fast, but less accurate algorithms such as pencil beam (PB) algorithms are typically used in most current IMRT systems. This paper describes two hybrid methods that utilize the speed of fast PB algorithms yet achieve the accuracy of optimizing based upon SC algorithms via the application of dose correction matrices. In one method, the ratio method, an infrequently computed voxel-by-voxel dose ratio matrix (R=D SC /D PB ) is applied for each beam to the dose distributions calculated with the PB method during the optimization. That is, D PB ×R is used for the dose calculation during the optimization. The optimization proceeds until both the IMRT beam intensities and the dose correction ratio matrix converge. In the second method, the correction method, a periodically computed voxel-by-voxel correction matrix for each beam, defined to be the difference between the SC and PB dose computations, is used to correct PB dose distributions. To validate the methods, IMRT treatment plans developed with the hybrid methods are compared with those obtained when the SC algorithm is used for all optimizationiterations and with those obtained when PB-based optimization is followed by SC-based optimization. In the 12 patient cases studied, no clinically significant differences exist in the final treatment plans developed with each of the dose computation methodologies. However, the number of time-consuming SC iterations is reduced from 6-32 for pure SC optimization to four or less for the ratio matrix method and five or less for the correction method. Because the PB algorithm is faster at computing dose, this reduces the inverse planning optimization time for our implementation by a factor of 2 to 8 compared with pure SC optimization, without compromising the quality or accuracy of the final treatment plan.
- 17 March 2000
- Published by IOP Publishing in Physics in Medicine & Biology
- Vol. 45 (4) , 983-995
Converting absorbed dose to medium to absorbed dose to water for Monte Carlo based photon beam dose calculations
Current clinical experience in radiation therapy is based upon dose computations that report the absorbed dose to water, even though the patient is not made of water but of many different types of tissue. While Monte Carlo dose calculation algorithms have the potential for higher dose accuracy, they usually transport particles in and compute the absorbed dose to the patient media such as soft tissue, lung or bone. Therefore, for dose calculation algorithm comparisons, or to report dose to water or tissue contained within a bone matrix for example, a method to convert dose to the medium to dose to water is required. This conversion has been developed here by applying Bragg-Gray cavity theory. The dose ratio for 6 and 18 MV photon beams was determined by computing the average stopping power ratio for the primary electron spectrum in the transport media. For soft tissue, the difference between dose to medium and dose to water is approximately 1.0%, while for cortical bone the dose difference exceeds 10%. The variation in the dose ratio as a function of depth and position in the field indicates that for photon beams a single correction factor can be used for each particular material throughout the field for a given photon beam energy. The only exception to this would be for the clinically non-relevant dose to air. Pre-computed energy spectra for 60Co to 24 MV are used to compute the dose ratios for these photon beams and to determine an effective energy for evaluation of the dose ratio.
- 17 March 2000
- Published by IOP Publishing in Physics in Medicine & Biology
- Vol. 45 (4) , 983-995
Converting absorbed dose to medium to absorbed dose to water for Monte Carlo based photon beam dose calculations
Current clinical experience in radiation therapy is based upon dose computations that report the absorbed dose to water, even though the patient is not made of water but of many different types of tissue. While Monte Carlo dose calculation algorithms have the potential for higher dose accuracy, they usually transport particles in and compute the absorbed dose to the patient media such as soft tissue, lung or bone. Therefore, for dose calculation algorithm comparisons, or to report dose to water or tissue contained within a bone matrix for example, a method to convert dose to the medium to dose to water is required. This conversion has been developed here by applying Bragg-Gray cavity theory. The dose ratio for 6 and 18 MV photon beams was determined by computing the average stopping power ratio for the primary electron spectrum in the transport media. For soft tissue, the difference between dose to medium and dose to water is approximately 1.0%, while for cortical bone the dose difference exceeds 10%. The variation in the dose ratio as a function of depth and position in the field indicates that for photon beams a single correction factor can be used for each particular material throughout the field for a given photon beam energy. The only exception to this would be for the clinically non-relevant dose to air. Pre-computed energy spectra for 60Co to 24 MV are used to compute the dose ratios for these photon beams and to determine an effective energy for evaluation of the dose ratio.