Tobias Knopp
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Tobias Knopp has a total of 50 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Tie Wei
New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology
4 shared publications A. Schröder
German Aerospace Center (DLR)
3 shared publicationsAndreas Schröder
Institute of Aerodynamics and Flow Technology
3 shared publicationsD. Schanz
German Aerospace Center (DLR)
3 shared publicationsDaniel Schanz
Institute of Aerodynamics and Flow Technology
3 shared publications- Matteo Novara
Department Experimental Methods, Institute of Aerodynamics and Flow Technology, German Aerospace Center (DLR), Göttingen, Germany
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 24 February 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 694-705
Modification of the SSG/LRR-$\omega $ Model for Separated Shear Flows and Prospects for Future Improvements- 24 February 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 694-705
Modification of the SSG/LRR-$\omega $ Model for Separated Shear Flows and Prospects for Future Improvements- 15 October 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 1021, A21
Properties of the mean-momentum balance in turbulent boundary layer flows subjected to pressure gradients
This study applies the scaling patch approach to investigate the influence of pressure gradients on the mean-momentum balance in turbulent boundary layers (TBLs). Under strong pressure gradients, the force balance in the outer region is dominated by advective and pressure forces, with gradients of Reynolds stresses playing a minimal role. To retain the relevance of Reynolds stress gradients within the scaling patch framework, we propose a redistribution of the component $U_e \textrm {d}U_e/\textrm {d}x$ from the advective term to the pressure-gradient term. Here, $U_e$ is the mean streamwise velocity at the boundary layer edge. This reformulation enhances the outer-scaling framework of Wei & Knopp (2023 J. Fluid Mech. 958, 1–21), ensuring consistency across a wide range of pressure gradients, including those involving flow separation. Remarkably, the new outer-scaled gradient of Reynolds shear stress in TBLs under a pressure gradient closely resembles that observed in zero-pressure-gradient TBLs. In the inner region, the impact of pressure gradient is well captured by the Stratford–Mellor parameter $\beta _{\textit{in}}$ . For weak pressure gradients ( $|\beta _{\textit{in}}| \ll 0.07$ ), traditional inner scaling remains valid. However, for stronger pressure gradients $|\beta _{\textit{in}}| \gtrsim 0.07$ , the near-wall dynamics is governed by a balance between pressure gradient and viscous force, as described by Stratford (1959 J. Fluid Mech. 5, 1–16) and Mellor (1966 J. Fluid Mech. 24, 255–274). In this sub-layer, viscosity and the imposed wall pressure gradient dictate the relevant velocity and length scales. Moreover, when $|\beta _{\textit{in}}| \gtrsim 0.7$ and the wall pressure $P_{w\textit{all}}$ gradient $\textrm { d}P_{w\textit{all}}/\textrm {d}x \gt 0$ , a distinct sub-layer emerges outside the pressure–viscous balance region, characterised by a dominant balance between the imposed pressure gradient and the gradient of the Reynolds shear stress. In this region, the Reynolds shear stress increases linearly with distance from the wall. These findings provide new insights into the structure of TBLs under pressure gradients and establish a refined framework for modelling their dynamics.- 15 October 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 1021, A21
Properties of the mean-momentum balance in turbulent boundary layer flows subjected to pressure gradients
This study applies the scaling patch approach to investigate the influence of pressure gradients on the mean-momentum balance in turbulent boundary layers (TBLs). Under strong pressure gradients, the force balance in the outer region is dominated by advective and pressure forces, with gradients of Reynolds stresses playing a minimal role. To retain the relevance of Reynolds stress gradients within the scaling patch framework, we propose a redistribution of the component $U_e \textrm {d}U_e/\textrm {d}x$ from the advective term to the pressure-gradient term. Here, $U_e$ is the mean streamwise velocity at the boundary layer edge. This reformulation enhances the outer-scaling framework of Wei & Knopp (2023 J. Fluid Mech. 958, 1–21), ensuring consistency across a wide range of pressure gradients, including those involving flow separation. Remarkably, the new outer-scaled gradient of Reynolds shear stress in TBLs under a pressure gradient closely resembles that observed in zero-pressure-gradient TBLs. In the inner region, the impact of pressure gradient is well captured by the Stratford–Mellor parameter $\beta _{\textit{in}}$ . For weak pressure gradients ( $|\beta _{\textit{in}}| \ll 0.07$ ), traditional inner scaling remains valid. However, for stronger pressure gradients $|\beta _{\textit{in}}| \gtrsim 0.07$ , the near-wall dynamics is governed by a balance between pressure gradient and viscous force, as described by Stratford (1959 J. Fluid Mech. 5, 1–16) and Mellor (1966 J. Fluid Mech. 24, 255–274). In this sub-layer, viscosity and the imposed wall pressure gradient dictate the relevant velocity and length scales. Moreover, when $|\beta _{\textit{in}}| \gtrsim 0.7$ and the wall pressure $P_{w\textit{all}}$ gradient $\textrm { d}P_{w\textit{all}}/\textrm {d}x \gt 0$ , a distinct sub-layer emerges outside the pressure–viscous balance region, characterised by a dominant balance between the imposed pressure gradient and the gradient of the Reynolds shear stress. In this region, the Reynolds shear stress increases linearly with distance from the wall. These findings provide new insights into the structure of TBLs under pressure gradients and establish a refined framework for modelling their dynamics.- Open Access
- 8 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Flow, Turbulence and Combustion
- Vol. 115 (1) , 141-167
Towards Efficient Hybrid RANS–LES for Industrial Aeronautical Applications
Three complementary approaches for reducing the grid-resolution requirements in hybrid RANS–LES computations, namely (a) the use of wall functions, (b) the application of locally embedded WMLES instead of global WMLES, as well as (c) local grid adaptation in LES regions, are assessed for different test cases up to an industry-relevant aeronautical flow. In this context, targeted improvements and an extension to general 3D geometries of an embedded WMLES method in a second-order accurate, unstructured compressible finite-volume solver are presented. For the wall functions and the embedded WMLES, which are applied to the NASA hump flow and the CRM-HL aircraft configuration, significant computational efficiency gains relative to corresponding reference simulations are demonstrated, while the loss of predictive accuracy compared to experiments can be limited to acceptable levels. Using a refinement indicator based on the locally resolved turbulent kinetic energy, the grid adaptation applied to the NASA hump flow and the NACA0021 at stall conditions yields partly even improved results compared to computations on globally-refined fixed grids, but the computational overhead due to the iterative refinement and averaging process was not yet included in this study. With grid-point savings ranging between 1/3 and more than 2/3 of grid points compared to respective reference meshes, all considered methods offer potential towards more efficient hybrid RANS–LES simulations of complex flows, although their accumulated potential through combination still needs to be explored.
- 8 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Flow, Turbulence and Combustion
- Vol. 115 (1) , 141-167
Open AccessTowards Efficient Hybrid RANS–LES for Industrial Aeronautical Applications
Three complementary approaches for reducing the grid-resolution requirements in hybrid RANS–LES computations, namely (a) the use of wall functions, (b) the application of locally embedded WMLES instead of global WMLES, as well as (c) local grid adaptation in LES regions, are assessed for different test cases up to an industry-relevant aeronautical flow. In this context, targeted improvements and an extension to general 3D geometries of an embedded WMLES method in a second-order accurate, unstructured compressible finite-volume solver are presented. For the wall functions and the embedded WMLES, which are applied to the NASA hump flow and the CRM-HL aircraft configuration, significant computational efficiency gains relative to corresponding reference simulations are demonstrated, while the loss of predictive accuracy compared to experiments can be limited to acceptable levels. Using a refinement indicator based on the locally resolved turbulent kinetic energy, the grid adaptation applied to the NASA hump flow and the NACA0021 at stall conditions yields partly even improved results compared to computations on globally-refined fixed grids, but the computational overhead due to the iterative refinement and averaging process was not yet included in this study. With grid-point savings ranging between 1/3 and more than 2/3 of grid points compared to respective reference meshes, all considered methods offer potential towards more efficient hybrid RANS–LES simulations of complex flows, although their accumulated potential through combination still needs to be explored.
- 13 January 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 1003, A7
Energy thickness in turbulent boundary layer flows
In this study, we investigate the properties of energy thickness $\delta _3$ in turbulent boundary layer (TBL) flows, a parameter derived solely from the mean streamwise velocity ( $U$ ) profile. Through an analysis of the energy integral equation for zero pressure gradient TBLs, we establish a close relationship between turbulent kinetic energy (TKE) production and $\delta _3$ , offering a practical method to estimate TKE production, which is particularly useful in physical experiments where direct measurements are challenging. The significance of $\delta _3$ becomes even more pronounced in TBLs under pressure gradient. Through extensive analysis of numerical and experimental data, we show that the ratio between $\delta _3$ and the momentum thickness $\delta _2$ is a promising criterion for predicting flow separation. Moreover, we derive a new energy integral equation for TBLs under arbitrary pressure gradients, and provide approximations for TKE productions terms by $R_{uv}\,\partial U/\partial y$ and $R_{uu}\,\partial U/\partial x$ , and dissipation term by the mean shear. Here, $x, y$ represent the streamwise and wall-normal directions, respectively, and $R_{uu}$ and $R_{uv}$ are the Reynolds normal and shear stresses. The accuracy and robustness of the new energy integral equation and the approximation equations are validated using direct numerical simulations data. Our results show that the TKE production by $R_{uv}\,\partial U/\partial y$ and the overall productions consistently remain positive, reflecting a continuous conversion of mean kinetic energy into TKE across all TBLs. However, under strong favourable pressure gradients, TKE production by $R_{uu}\,\partial U/\partial x$ becomes negative, indicating a reverse energy transfer from TKE to mean kinetic energy.- 13 January 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 1003, A7
Energy thickness in turbulent boundary layer flows
In this study, we investigate the properties of energy thickness $\delta _3$ in turbulent boundary layer (TBL) flows, a parameter derived solely from the mean streamwise velocity ( $U$ ) profile. Through an analysis of the energy integral equation for zero pressure gradient TBLs, we establish a close relationship between turbulent kinetic energy (TKE) production and $\delta _3$ , offering a practical method to estimate TKE production, which is particularly useful in physical experiments where direct measurements are challenging. The significance of $\delta _3$ becomes even more pronounced in TBLs under pressure gradient. Through extensive analysis of numerical and experimental data, we show that the ratio between $\delta _3$ and the momentum thickness $\delta _2$ is a promising criterion for predicting flow separation. Moreover, we derive a new energy integral equation for TBLs under arbitrary pressure gradients, and provide approximations for TKE productions terms by $R_{uv}\,\partial U/\partial y$ and $R_{uu}\,\partial U/\partial x$ , and dissipation term by the mean shear. Here, $x, y$ represent the streamwise and wall-normal directions, respectively, and $R_{uu}$ and $R_{uv}$ are the Reynolds normal and shear stresses. The accuracy and robustness of the new energy integral equation and the approximation equations are validated using direct numerical simulations data. Our results show that the TKE production by $R_{uv}\,\partial U/\partial y$ and the overall productions consistently remain positive, reflecting a continuous conversion of mean kinetic energy into TKE across all TBLs. However, under strong favourable pressure gradients, TKE production by $R_{uu}\,\partial U/\partial x$ becomes negative, indicating a reverse energy transfer from TKE to mean kinetic energy.- Open Access
On the Generalization Capability of a Data-Driven Turbulence Model by Field Inversion and Machine Learning
This paper discusses the generalizability of a data-augmented turbulence model with a focus on the field inversion and machine learning approach. It is highlighted that the augmented model based on two-dimensional (2D) separated airfoil flows gives poor predictive capability for a different class of separated flows (NASA wall-mounted hump) compared to the baseline model due to extrapolation. We demonstrate a sensor-based approach to localize the data-driven model correction to tackle this generalizability issue. Furthermore, the applicability of the augmented model to a more complex aeronautical three-dimensional case, the NASA Common Research Model configuration, is studied. Observations on the pressure coefficient predictions and the model correction field suggest that the present 2D-based augmentation is to some extent applicable to a three-dimensional aircraft flow.
Open AccessOn the Generalization Capability of a Data-Driven Turbulence Model by Field Inversion and Machine Learning
This paper discusses the generalizability of a data-augmented turbulence model with a focus on the field inversion and machine learning approach. It is highlighted that the augmented model based on two-dimensional (2D) separated airfoil flows gives poor predictive capability for a different class of separated flows (NASA wall-mounted hump) compared to the baseline model due to extrapolation. We demonstrate a sensor-based approach to localize the data-driven model correction to tackle this generalizability issue. Furthermore, the applicability of the augmented model to a more complex aeronautical three-dimensional case, the NASA Common Research Model configuration, is studied. Observations on the pressure coefficient predictions and the model correction field suggest that the present 2D-based augmentation is to some extent applicable to a three-dimensional aircraft flow.
- 16 November 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 975, A27
The mean wall-normal velocity in turbulent boundary layer flows under pressure gradient
Using a combination of proper variable transformation and integral methods, we rigorously derive an analytical formulation for the mean wall-normal velocity in turbulent boundary layers (TBLs) subjected to arbitrary pressure gradients. The accuracy and robustness of this novel formulation are validated extensively through comparisons with two independent sets of numerical simulation data, demonstrating excellent agreement in both near-equilibrium and non-equilibrium TBLs. In addition, the robustness of the analytical formulations to various choices of boundary-layer edge definition is further confirmed in non-equilibrium TBLs. Our formulation includes a streamwise derivative term, which has minimal significance in near-equilibrium TBLs but plays a crucial role in determining the mean wall-normal velocity in non-equilibrium TBLs. Moreover, we investigate the physical significance of the pre-factors associated with the mean wall-normal velocity components, and unveil a close connection between a previously defined pressure gradient parameter and the ratio of these pre-factors in the analytical equation governing the mean wall-normal velocity. The insights gained from the examination of the pre-factors and their connection to the pressure gradient parameter offer valuable knowledge for interpreting and predicting the behaviour of turbulent boundary layers in various practical applications.
- 16 November 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 975, A27
The mean wall-normal velocity in turbulent boundary layer flows under pressure gradient
Using a combination of proper variable transformation and integral methods, we rigorously derive an analytical formulation for the mean wall-normal velocity in turbulent boundary layers (TBLs) subjected to arbitrary pressure gradients. The accuracy and robustness of this novel formulation are validated extensively through comparisons with two independent sets of numerical simulation data, demonstrating excellent agreement in both near-equilibrium and non-equilibrium TBLs. In addition, the robustness of the analytical formulations to various choices of boundary-layer edge definition is further confirmed in non-equilibrium TBLs. Our formulation includes a streamwise derivative term, which has minimal significance in near-equilibrium TBLs but plays a crucial role in determining the mean wall-normal velocity in non-equilibrium TBLs. Moreover, we investigate the physical significance of the pre-factors associated with the mean wall-normal velocity components, and unveil a close connection between a previously defined pressure gradient parameter and the ratio of these pre-factors in the analytical equation governing the mean wall-normal velocity. The insights gained from the examination of the pre-factors and their connection to the pressure gradient parameter offer valuable knowledge for interpreting and predicting the behaviour of turbulent boundary layers in various practical applications.
- Open Access
- 22 July 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Flow, Turbulence and Combustion
- Vol. 111 (2) , 409-438
Modification of the SSG/LRR-Omega Model for Turbulent Boundary Layer Flows in an Adverse Pressure Gradient
A modification of the RANS turbulence model SSG/LRR- $$\omega $$ for turbulent boundary layers in an adverse pressure gradient is presented. The modification is based on a wall law for the mean velocity, in which the log law is progressively eroded in an adverse pressure gradient and an extended wall law (designated loosely as a half-power law) emerges above the log law. An augmentation term for the half-power law region is derived from the analysis of the boundary-layer equation for the specific rate of dissipation $$\omega $$ . An extended data structure within the RANS solver provides, for each viscous wall point, the field points on a wall-normal line. This enables the evaluation of characteristic boundary layer parameters for the local activation of the augmentation term. The modification is calibrated using a joint DLR/UniBw turbulent boundary layer experiment. The modified model yields an improved predictive accuracy for flow separation. Finally, the applicability of the modified model to a 3D wing-body configuration is demonstrated.- 22 July 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Flow, Turbulence and Combustion
- Vol. 111 (2) , 409-438
Open AccessModification of the SSG/LRR-Omega Model for Turbulent Boundary Layer Flows in an Adverse Pressure Gradient
A modification of the RANS turbulence model SSG/LRR- $$\omega $$ for turbulent boundary layers in an adverse pressure gradient is presented. The modification is based on a wall law for the mean velocity, in which the log law is progressively eroded in an adverse pressure gradient and an extended wall law (designated loosely as a half-power law) emerges above the log law. An augmentation term for the half-power law region is derived from the analysis of the boundary-layer equation for the specific rate of dissipation $$\omega $$ . An extended data structure within the RANS solver provides, for each viscous wall point, the field points on a wall-normal line. This enables the evaluation of characteristic boundary layer parameters for the local activation of the augmentation term. The modification is calibrated using a joint DLR/UniBw turbulent boundary layer experiment. The modified model yields an improved predictive accuracy for flow separation. Finally, the applicability of the modified model to a 3D wing-body configuration is demonstrated. - 28 February 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 958, A9
Outer scaling of the mean momentum equation for turbulent boundary layers under adverse pressure gradient
A new scaling of the mean momentum equation is developed for the outer region of turbulent boundary layers (TBLs) under adverse pressure gradient (APG). The maximum Reynolds shear stress location, denoted as $y_{m}$ , is employed to determine the proper scales for the outer region of an APG TBL. An outer length scale is proposed as $\delta _e - y_{m}$ , where $\delta _e$ is the boundary layer thickness. An outer velocity scale for the mean streamwise velocity deficit is proposed as $U_e - U_{m}$ , where $U_e$ and $U_m$ are the mean streamwise velocities at the boundary layer edge and $y_{m}$ , respectively. An outer velocity scale for the mean wall-normal velocity deficit is proposed as $V_e - V_{m}$ , where $V_e$ and $V_{m}$ are the wall-normal velocities at $\delta _e$ and $y_{m}$ , respectively. The maximum Reynolds shear stress is found to scale as $(\delta _e - y_{m}) U_e \,{\rm d}U_e/{{\rm d}x}$ . The new outer scaling collapses well the experimental and numerical data on APG TBLs over a wide range of Reynolds numbers and strengths of pressure gradient. Approximations of the new scaling are developed for TBLs under strong APG and at high Reynolds numbers. The relationships between the new scales and previously proposed scales are discussed.- 28 February 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 958, A9
Outer scaling of the mean momentum equation for turbulent boundary layers under adverse pressure gradient
A new scaling of the mean momentum equation is developed for the outer region of turbulent boundary layers (TBLs) under adverse pressure gradient (APG). The maximum Reynolds shear stress location, denoted as $y_{m}$ , is employed to determine the proper scales for the outer region of an APG TBL. An outer length scale is proposed as $\delta _e - y_{m}$ , where $\delta _e$ is the boundary layer thickness. An outer velocity scale for the mean streamwise velocity deficit is proposed as $U_e - U_{m}$ , where $U_e$ and $U_m$ are the mean streamwise velocities at the boundary layer edge and $y_{m}$ , respectively. An outer velocity scale for the mean wall-normal velocity deficit is proposed as $V_e - V_{m}$ , where $V_e$ and $V_{m}$ are the wall-normal velocities at $\delta _e$ and $y_{m}$ , respectively. The maximum Reynolds shear stress is found to scale as $(\delta _e - y_{m}) U_e \,{\rm d}U_e/{{\rm d}x}$ . The new outer scaling collapses well the experimental and numerical data on APG TBLs over a wide range of Reynolds numbers and strengths of pressure gradient. Approximations of the new scaling are developed for TBLs under strong APG and at high Reynolds numbers. The relationships between the new scales and previously proposed scales are discussed.- Open Access
- 13 September 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Flow, Turbulence and Combustion
- Vol. 109 (3) , 571-601
An Empirical Wall Law for the Mean Velocity in an Adverse Pressure Gradient for RANS Turbulence Modelling
An empirical wall law for the mean velocity in an adverse pressure gradient is presented, with the ultimate goal of aiming at the improvement of RANS turbulence models and wall functions. For this purpose a large database of turbulent boundary-layer flows in adverse pressure gradients from wind tunnel experiments is considered, and the mean velocity in the inner layer is analysed. The log law in the mean velocity is found to be a robust feature. The extent of the log-law region is reduced in ratio to the boundary layer thickness with increasing strength of the pressure gradient. An extended wall law emerges above the log law, extending up to the outer edge of the inner layer. An empirical correlation to describe the reduction of the log-law region is proposed, depending on the pressure-gradient parameter and on the Reynolds number in inner viscous scaling, whose functional form is motivated by similarity and scaling arguments. Finally, there is a discussion of the conjecture of the existence of a wall law for the mean velocity, which is governed mainly by local parameters and whose leading order effects are the pressure gradient and the Reynolds number, but whose details can be perturbed by higher-order local and history effects.
- 13 September 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Flow, Turbulence and Combustion
- Vol. 109 (3) , 571-601
Open AccessAn Empirical Wall Law for the Mean Velocity in an Adverse Pressure Gradient for RANS Turbulence Modelling
An empirical wall law for the mean velocity in an adverse pressure gradient is presented, with the ultimate goal of aiming at the improvement of RANS turbulence models and wall functions. For this purpose a large database of turbulent boundary-layer flows in adverse pressure gradients from wind tunnel experiments is considered, and the mean velocity in the inner layer is analysed. The log law in the mean velocity is found to be a robust feature. The extent of the log-law region is reduced in ratio to the boundary layer thickness with increasing strength of the pressure gradient. An extended wall law emerges above the log law, extending up to the outer edge of the inner layer. An empirical correlation to describe the reduction of the log-law region is proposed, depending on the pressure-gradient parameter and on the Reynolds number in inner viscous scaling, whose functional form is motivated by similarity and scaling arguments. Finally, there is a discussion of the conjecture of the existence of a wall law for the mean velocity, which is governed mainly by local parameters and whose leading order effects are the pressure gradient and the Reynolds number, but whose details can be perturbed by higher-order local and history effects.
- 14 July 2021
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 58-67
Study of RANS Turbulence Models for Turbulent Wake Flow in Adverse Pressure Gradient
- 14 July 2021
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 58-67
Study of RANS Turbulence Models for Turbulent Wake Flow in Adverse Pressure Gradient