Dongsoo Shin
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Dongsoo Shin has a total of 18 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Roland Strausz
Berlin School of Economics , 9373 Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin , Berlin , Germany
4 shared publications - Martin Peitz
Department of Economics and MaCCI, University of Mannheim , 68131 Mannheim
3 shared publications - Doyoung Kim
Department of Economics, Finance, and IS University of Idaho Moscow, ID 83844
2 shared publications - Gorkem Celik
ESSEC Business School France
2 shared publications - Jaesoo Kim
Department of Economics, Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis, Indianapolis, IN 46202, USA
2 shared publications Aaron Finkle
Department of Economics University of Maryland College Park Maryland
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 1 June 2024
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in The B.E. Journal of Theoretical Economics
- Vol. 24 (2) , 519-553
Motivating Loyal Bureaucrats in Sequential Agency
We study a principal–agent model in which a legislature and a bureaucrat sequentially play the principal’s role. In the first stage, the legislature offers a menu of transfer payments to the bureaucrat for implementing a public project. In the second stage, the bureaucrat offers a menu of the project attribute levels to the legislature. Then, the legislature decides whether to go forward with the project and aggregates information on the public’s valuation of the project. The key trade-off in this paper is information versus the bureaucrat’s loyalty. We show that when the bureaucrat is loyal enough to the public, taking advantage of his loyalty requires inducing him to make his decision independent of the public’s valuation.
- 1 June 2024
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in The B.E. Journal of Theoretical Economics
- Vol. 24 (2) , 519-553
Motivating Loyal Bureaucrats in Sequential Agency
We study a principal–agent model in which a legislature and a bureaucrat sequentially play the principal’s role. In the first stage, the legislature offers a menu of transfer payments to the bureaucrat for implementing a public project. In the second stage, the bureaucrat offers a menu of the project attribute levels to the legislature. Then, the legislature decides whether to go forward with the project and aggregates information on the public’s valuation of the project. The key trade-off in this paper is information versus the bureaucrat’s loyalty. We show that when the bureaucrat is loyal enough to the public, taking advantage of his loyalty requires inducing him to make his decision independent of the public’s valuation.
- Open Access
- 26 February 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Economics & Management Strategy
- Vol. 33 (3) , 509-538
Insourcing versus outsourcing in a vertical structure
We study an agency model with vertical hierarchy—the principal, the prime‐agent and the subagent. The principal faces a project that needs both agents' services. Due to costly communication, the principal receives a report only from the prime‐agent, who receives a report from the subagent. The principal can directly incentivize each agent by setting individual transfers (insourcing), or sets only one overall transfer to an independent organization in which the prime‐agent hires the subagent (outsourcing). We show that insourcing is always optimal when the principal can perfectly process the prime‐agent's report. When the principal's information process is limited, however, outsourcing can be the prevailing mode of operation. In addition, insourcing under limited information process is prone to collusion between the agents, whereas no possibility of collusion arises with outsourcing.
- 26 February 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Economics & Management Strategy
- Vol. 33 (3) , 509-538
Open AccessInsourcing versus outsourcing in a vertical structure
We study an agency model with vertical hierarchy—the principal, the prime‐agent and the subagent. The principal faces a project that needs both agents' services. Due to costly communication, the principal receives a report only from the prime‐agent, who receives a report from the subagent. The principal can directly incentivize each agent by setting individual transfers (insourcing), or sets only one overall transfer to an independent organization in which the prime‐agent hires the subagent (outsourcing). We show that insourcing is always optimal when the principal can perfectly process the prime‐agent's report. When the principal's information process is limited, however, outsourcing can be the prevailing mode of operation. In addition, insourcing under limited information process is prone to collusion between the agents, whereas no possibility of collusion arises with outsourcing.
- Open Access
Vertical Relationships with Hidden Interactions
In an agency model with adverse selection, we study how hidden interactions between agents affect the optimal contract. The principal employs two agents who learn their task environments through their involvement. The principal cannot observe the task environments. It is important to note that hidden interactions, such as acts of sabotage or help between the agents, have the potential to alter each other’s task environments. Our analysis encompasses two distinct organizational structures: competition and cooperation. Without hidden interactions, the competitive structure is optimal because the cooperative structure only provides the agents with more flexibility to collusively misrepresent their task environments. With hidden interactions, however, the cooperative structure induces the agents to help each other to improve the task environments while removing sabotaging incentives at no cost once collusion is deterred. As a result, the cooperative structure can be optimal in such a case. We discuss the link between production technology and organizational structure, finding that complementarity in production favors cooperative structures.
Open AccessVertical Relationships with Hidden Interactions
In an agency model with adverse selection, we study how hidden interactions between agents affect the optimal contract. The principal employs two agents who learn their task environments through their involvement. The principal cannot observe the task environments. It is important to note that hidden interactions, such as acts of sabotage or help between the agents, have the potential to alter each other’s task environments. Our analysis encompasses two distinct organizational structures: competition and cooperation. Without hidden interactions, the competitive structure is optimal because the cooperative structure only provides the agents with more flexibility to collusively misrepresent their task environments. With hidden interactions, however, the cooperative structure induces the agents to help each other to improve the task environments while removing sabotaging incentives at no cost once collusion is deterred. As a result, the cooperative structure can be optimal in such a case. We discuss the link between production technology and organizational structure, finding that complementarity in production favors cooperative structures.
- Open Access
- 1 March 2023
- Published by Wiley in The Journal of Industrial Economics
- Vol. 71 (1) , 256-290
Aggregate Information and Organizational Structures*
- 1 March 2023
- Published by Wiley in The Journal of Industrial Economics
- Vol. 71 (1) , 256-290
Open AccessAggregate Information and Organizational Structures*
- Open Access
- 26 May 2021
- Published by Wiley in The RAND Journal of Economics
- Vol. 52 (2) , 314-333
Public good overprovision by a manipulative provider
We study contracting between a public good provider and users with private valuations of the good. We show that, once the provider extracts the users' private information, she benefits from manipulating the collective information received from all users when communicating with them. We derive conditions under which such manipulation determines the direction of distortions in public good provision. If the provider is non‐manipulative, the public good is always underprovided, whereas overprovision occurs with a manipulative provider. With overprovision, not only high‐valuation users, but also low‐valuation users may obtain positive rents—users may prefer facing a manipulative provider.
- 26 May 2021
- Published by Wiley in The RAND Journal of Economics
- Vol. 52 (2) , 314-333
Open AccessPublic good overprovision by a manipulative provider
We study contracting between a public good provider and users with private valuations of the good. We show that, once the provider extracts the users' private information, she benefits from manipulating the collective information received from all users when communicating with them. We derive conditions under which such manipulation determines the direction of distortions in public good provision. If the provider is non‐manipulative, the public good is always underprovided, whereas overprovision occurs with a manipulative provider. With overprovision, not only high‐valuation users, but also low‐valuation users may obtain positive rents—users may prefer facing a manipulative provider.
- 1 October 2020
- Published by Wiley in The Scandinavian Journal of Economics
- Vol. 122 (4) , 1480-1509
Distorted Input Ratios in Vertical Relationships*
- 1 October 2020
- Published by Wiley in The Scandinavian Journal of Economics
- Vol. 122 (4) , 1480-1509
Distorted Input Ratios in Vertical Relationships*
- 1 July 2020
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Economics & Management Strategy
- Vol. 29 (4) , 873-891
Obstructive monitoring
We consider a principal–agent relationship in which the principal's monitoring can be obstructive to the agent, reducing the agent's productivity. We show that, with obstructive monitoring, the optimal output schedule is distorted in all directions—the high‐cost agent produces less, and the low‐cost agent produces more than the first‐best levels. Moreover, if the principal has a choice, she will make monitoring deliberately obstructive, because when monitoring is obstructive, although the agent's productivity decreases, his information rent is extracted more effectively. We also show that obstruction is optimal even when the principal is unable to commit to her monitoring strategy ex ante.
- 1 July 2020
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Economics & Management Strategy
- Vol. 29 (4) , 873-891
Obstructive monitoring
We consider a principal–agent relationship in which the principal's monitoring can be obstructive to the agent, reducing the agent's productivity. We show that, with obstructive monitoring, the optimal output schedule is distorted in all directions—the high‐cost agent produces less, and the low‐cost agent produces more than the first‐best levels. Moreover, if the principal has a choice, she will make monitoring deliberately obstructive, because when monitoring is obstructive, although the agent's productivity decreases, his information rent is extracted more effectively. We also show that obstruction is optimal even when the principal is unable to commit to her monitoring strategy ex ante.
- 9 April 2019
- Published by Wiley in Economic Inquiry
- Vol. 57 (3) , 1510-1525
MANAGING R&D IN VERTICAL RELATIONSHIPS
We study the optimal strategy for research and development (R&D) in a buyer‐supplier relationship. The buyer chooses whether to (1) insource a cost‐reducing R&D to its own research‐subunit or to (2) outsource it to its manufacturing supplier. The buyer cannot observe the R&D effort in either case, but can better observe the R&D result when the R&D is conducted internally. According to our analysis, the buyer prefers insourcing R&D to mitigate information asymmetry when the R&D cost is either small or large. When the R&D cost is intermediate, however, the buyer prefers outsourcing R&D, and can achieve the full information outcome (first‐best outcome) despite the information asymmetry associated with outsourcing R&D. Moreover, the buyer's preference for outsourcing high‐cost R&D increases when the R&D is more likely to succeed or to generate significant cost reductions, or the R&D result is more difficult to predict. Our analysis provides a theoretical explanation for the increasing trend of outsourcing innovation to manufacturing suppliers. (JEL D82, L22, L23)
- 9 April 2019
- Published by Wiley in Economic Inquiry
- Vol. 57 (3) , 1510-1525
MANAGING R&D IN VERTICAL RELATIONSHIPS
We study the optimal strategy for research and development (R&D) in a buyer‐supplier relationship. The buyer chooses whether to (1) insource a cost‐reducing R&D to its own research‐subunit or to (2) outsource it to its manufacturing supplier. The buyer cannot observe the R&D effort in either case, but can better observe the R&D result when the R&D is conducted internally. According to our analysis, the buyer prefers insourcing R&D to mitigate information asymmetry when the R&D cost is either small or large. When the R&D cost is intermediate, however, the buyer prefers outsourcing R&D, and can achieve the full information outcome (first‐best outcome) despite the information asymmetry associated with outsourcing R&D. Moreover, the buyer's preference for outsourcing high‐cost R&D increases when the R&D is more likely to succeed or to generate significant cost reductions, or the R&D result is more difficult to predict. Our analysis provides a theoretical explanation for the increasing trend of outsourcing innovation to manufacturing suppliers. (JEL D82, L22, L23)
- 14 December 2016
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Economics & Management Strategy
- Vol. 26 (2) , 429-453
Optimal Loyalty‐Based Management
We study an agency model in which an entrepreneur selects a manager from a candidate set. The selected manager's effort improves the project's potential environment, and is a hidden action. The realized project environment is the entrepreneur's private information. A manager's utility has two components—(i) loyalty, with which the manager values the organization's profit, and (ii) selfishness, with which the manager values the monetary transfer he receives from the entrepreneur. We find that if the manager's task is easy enough, it is optimal to use a purely loyal manager. Otherwise, it can be optimal to use a manager with mixture of loyalty and selfishness—the manager's mixed motivation alleviates the entrepreneur's misrepresenting incentive, and as a result, the output distortion in the optimal contract can be reduced. In addition, when it is optimal to use a manager with mixed motivations, the entrepreneur selects someone who is more selfish than loyal.
- 14 December 2016
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Economics & Management Strategy
- Vol. 26 (2) , 429-453
Optimal Loyalty‐Based Management
We study an agency model in which an entrepreneur selects a manager from a candidate set. The selected manager's effort improves the project's potential environment, and is a hidden action. The realized project environment is the entrepreneur's private information. A manager's utility has two components—(i) loyalty, with which the manager values the organization's profit, and (ii) selfishness, with which the manager values the monetary transfer he receives from the entrepreneur. We find that if the manager's task is easy enough, it is optimal to use a purely loyal manager. Otherwise, it can be optimal to use a manager with mixture of loyalty and selfishness—the manager's mixed motivation alleviates the entrepreneur's misrepresenting incentive, and as a result, the output distortion in the optimal contract can be reduced. In addition, when it is optimal to use a manager with mixed motivations, the entrepreneur selects someone who is more selfish than loyal.
- 1 December 2016
- Published by Wiley in The Journal of Industrial Economics
- Vol. 64 (4) , 773-807
Price Discrimination with Demarketing
We study how demarketing interacts with pricing decisions to explain why and when it can be employed as the seller's optimal strategy. In our model, a monopolistic seller offers different price‐quality bundles of the product. A consumer's preference is private information. With demarketing, consumers must make a costly effort to purchase and/or utilize the product, whereas with marketing, the seller instead makes the effort so that the consumer's purchasing decision is independent of the cost of effort. Our result suggests that, for small or large effort costs, it is optimal for the seller to engage in marketing. For intermediate effort costs, however, demarketing can be optimal. With demarketing, the seller induces only the consumers with high valuation to make transaction effort. By doing so, the seller can price discriminate more effectively, thus extracting more surplus. We extend our analysis to the case where the seller can offer special deals through exclusive sales channels along with demarketing. Then, demarketing can be optimal even for large costs of effort.
- 1 December 2016
- Published by Wiley in The Journal of Industrial Economics
- Vol. 64 (4) , 773-807
Price Discrimination with Demarketing
We study how demarketing interacts with pricing decisions to explain why and when it can be employed as the seller's optimal strategy. In our model, a monopolistic seller offers different price‐quality bundles of the product. A consumer's preference is private information. With demarketing, consumers must make a costly effort to purchase and/or utilize the product, whereas with marketing, the seller instead makes the effort so that the consumer's purchasing decision is independent of the cost of effort. Our result suggests that, for small or large effort costs, it is optimal for the seller to engage in marketing. For intermediate effort costs, however, demarketing can be optimal. With demarketing, the seller induces only the consumers with high valuation to make transaction effort. By doing so, the seller can price discriminate more effectively, thus extracting more surplus. We extend our analysis to the case where the seller can offer special deals through exclusive sales channels along with demarketing. Then, demarketing can be optimal even for large costs of effort.