Lilie L. W. Wang
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Lilie L. W. Wang has a total of 3 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- David W. O. Rogers
Physics Department, Carleton University, Ottawa, Ontario K1S 5B6, Canada
3 shared publications - Daniel La Russa
Medical Physics, Ottawa Hospital, Ottawa, Ontario, CANADA
1 shared publication Konrad Leszczynski
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 5 May 2009
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 36 (6Part1) , 2034-2042
Study of the effective point of measurement for ion chambers in electron beams by Monte Carlo simulation
In current dosimetry protocols for electron beams, for plane‐parallel chambers, the effective point of measurement is at the front face of the cavity, and, for cylindrical chambers, it is at a point shifted upstream from the cavity center. In this study, Monte Carlo simulations are employed to study the issue of effective point of measurement for both plane‐parallel chambers and cylindrical thimble chambers in electron beams. It is found that there are two ways of determining the position of the effective point of measurement: One is to match the calculated depth‐ionization curve obtained from a modeled chamber to a calculated depth‐dose curve; the other is to match the electron fluence spectrum in the chamber cavity to that in the phantom. For plane‐parallel chambers, the effective point of measurement determined by the first method is generally not at the front face of the chamber cavity, which is obtained by the second method, but shifted downstream toward the cavity center by an amount that could be larger than one‐half a millimeter. This should not be ignored when measuring depth‐dose curves in electron beams. For cylindrical chambers, these two methods also give different positions of the effective point of measurement: The first gives a shift of , which is in agreement with measurements for high‐energy beams and is the same as the value currently used in major dosimetry protocols; the latter gives a shift of , which is closer to the value predicted by a theoretical calculation assuming no‐scatter conditions. The results also show that the shift of is more appropriate if the cylindrical chamber is to be considered as a Spencer‐Attix cavity. In electron beams, since the water/air stopping‐power ratio changes with depth in a water phantom, the difference of the two shifts will lead to an incorrect evaluation of the water/air stopping‐power ratio at the point of measurement, thus resulting in a systematic error in determining the absorbed dose by cylindrical chambers. It is suggested that a shift of be used for electron beam calibrations with cylindrical chambers and a shift of be used for depth‐dose measurements.
- 5 May 2009
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 36 (6Part1) , 2034-2042
Study of the effective point of measurement for ion chambers in electron beams by Monte Carlo simulation
In current dosimetry protocols for electron beams, for plane‐parallel chambers, the effective point of measurement is at the front face of the cavity, and, for cylindrical chambers, it is at a point shifted upstream from the cavity center. In this study, Monte Carlo simulations are employed to study the issue of effective point of measurement for both plane‐parallel chambers and cylindrical thimble chambers in electron beams. It is found that there are two ways of determining the position of the effective point of measurement: One is to match the calculated depth‐ionization curve obtained from a modeled chamber to a calculated depth‐dose curve; the other is to match the electron fluence spectrum in the chamber cavity to that in the phantom. For plane‐parallel chambers, the effective point of measurement determined by the first method is generally not at the front face of the chamber cavity, which is obtained by the second method, but shifted downstream toward the cavity center by an amount that could be larger than one‐half a millimeter. This should not be ignored when measuring depth‐dose curves in electron beams. For cylindrical chambers, these two methods also give different positions of the effective point of measurement: The first gives a shift of , which is in agreement with measurements for high‐energy beams and is the same as the value currently used in major dosimetry protocols; the latter gives a shift of , which is closer to the value predicted by a theoretical calculation assuming no‐scatter conditions. The results also show that the shift of is more appropriate if the cylindrical chamber is to be considered as a Spencer‐Attix cavity. In electron beams, since the water/air stopping‐power ratio changes with depth in a water phantom, the difference of the two shifts will lead to an incorrect evaluation of the water/air stopping‐power ratio at the point of measurement, thus resulting in a systematic error in determining the absorbed dose by cylindrical chambers. It is suggested that a shift of be used for electron beam calibrations with cylindrical chambers and a shift of be used for depth‐dose measurements.
- 21 April 2009
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 36 (5) , 1785-1789
Systematic uncertainties in the Monte Carlo calculation of ion chamber replacement correction factors
In a previous study [Med. Phys. 35, 1747-1755 (2008)], the authors proposed two direct methods of calculating the replacement correction factors (P(repl) or P(cav)P(dis)) for ion chambers by Monte Carlo calculation. By "direct" we meant the stopping-power ratio evaluation is not necessary. The two methods were named as the high-density air (HDA) and low-density water (LDW) methods. Although the accuracy of these methods was briefly discussed, it turns out that the assumption made regarding the dose in an HDA slab as a function of slab thickness is not correct. This issue is reinvestigated in the current study, and the accuracy of the LDW method applied to ion chambers in a 60Co photon beam is also studied. It is found that the two direct methods are in fact not completely independent of the stopping-power ratio of the two materials involved. There is an implicit dependence of the calculated P(repl) values upon the stopping-power ratio evaluation through the choice of an appropriate energy cutoff delta, which characterizes a cavity size in the Spencer-Attix cavity theory. Since the delta value is not accurately defined in the theory, this dependence on the stopping-power ratio results in a systematic uncertainty on the calculated P(repl) values. For phantom materials of similar effective atomic number to air, such as water and graphite, this systematic uncertainty is at most 0.2% for most commonly used chambers for either electron or photon beams. This uncertainty level is good enough for current ion chamber dosimetry, and the merits of the two direct methods of calculating P(repl) values are maintained, i.e., there is no need to do a separate stopping-power ratio calculation. For high-Z materials, the inherent uncertainty would make it practically impossible to calculate reliable P(repl) values using the two direct methods.
- 21 April 2009
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 36 (5) , 1785-1789
Systematic uncertainties in the Monte Carlo calculation of ion chamber replacement correction factors
In a previous study [Med. Phys. 35, 1747-1755 (2008)], the authors proposed two direct methods of calculating the replacement correction factors (P(repl) or P(cav)P(dis)) for ion chambers by Monte Carlo calculation. By "direct" we meant the stopping-power ratio evaluation is not necessary. The two methods were named as the high-density air (HDA) and low-density water (LDW) methods. Although the accuracy of these methods was briefly discussed, it turns out that the assumption made regarding the dose in an HDA slab as a function of slab thickness is not correct. This issue is reinvestigated in the current study, and the accuracy of the LDW method applied to ion chambers in a 60Co photon beam is also studied. It is found that the two direct methods are in fact not completely independent of the stopping-power ratio of the two materials involved. There is an implicit dependence of the calculated P(repl) values upon the stopping-power ratio evaluation through the choice of an appropriate energy cutoff delta, which characterizes a cavity size in the Spencer-Attix cavity theory. Since the delta value is not accurately defined in the theory, this dependence on the stopping-power ratio results in a systematic uncertainty on the calculated P(repl) values. For phantom materials of similar effective atomic number to air, such as water and graphite, this systematic uncertainty is at most 0.2% for most commonly used chambers for either electron or photon beams. This uncertainty level is good enough for current ion chamber dosimetry, and the merits of the two direct methods of calculating P(repl) values are maintained, i.e., there is no need to do a separate stopping-power ratio calculation. For high-Z materials, the inherent uncertainty would make it practically impossible to calculate reliable P(repl) values using the two direct methods.
- 11 April 2008
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 35 (5) , 1747-1755
Calculation of the replacement correction factors for ion chambers in megavoltage beams by Monte Carlo simulation
This article describes four methods of calculating the replacement correction factor, (or the product in the IAEA's notation), for a plane‐parallel chamber in both electron and photon beams, and for a Farmer chamber in photon beams, by using the EGSnrc Monte Carlo code. The accuracy of underlying assumptions and relative merits of each technique are assessed. With careful selection of parameters it appears that all four methods give reasonable answers although the direct methods are more intellectually satisfying and more accurate in some cases. The direct methods are shown to have an accuracy of when appropriate calculation parameters are selected. The depth dependence of for the NACP02 plane‐parallel chamber has been calculated in both 6 and 18 MeV electron beams. At the reference depth is 0.9964 for the 6 MeV beam and 1.0005 for the 18 MeV beam for this well‐guarded chamber; at the depth of maximum dose for the 18 MeV beam, is 1.0010. is also calculated for the NACP02 chamber and a Farmer chamber (diameter 6 mm) at a depth of 5 cm in a photon beam, giving values of 1.0063 and 0.9964, respectively. For the Farmer chamber, is about half a percent higher than the value (0.992) recommended by the AAPM dosimetry protocol. It is found that the dosimetry protocols may have adopted an incorrect value of for cylindrical chambers in photon beams. The nonunity values of for plane‐parallel chambers in lower energy electron beams imply a variety of values used in dosimetry protocols must be reassessed.
- 11 April 2008
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 35 (5) , 1747-1755
Calculation of the replacement correction factors for ion chambers in megavoltage beams by Monte Carlo simulation
This article describes four methods of calculating the replacement correction factor, (or the product in the IAEA's notation), for a plane‐parallel chamber in both electron and photon beams, and for a Farmer chamber in photon beams, by using the EGSnrc Monte Carlo code. The accuracy of underlying assumptions and relative merits of each technique are assessed. With careful selection of parameters it appears that all four methods give reasonable answers although the direct methods are more intellectually satisfying and more accurate in some cases. The direct methods are shown to have an accuracy of when appropriate calculation parameters are selected. The depth dependence of for the NACP02 plane‐parallel chamber has been calculated in both 6 and 18 MeV electron beams. At the reference depth is 0.9964 for the 6 MeV beam and 1.0005 for the 18 MeV beam for this well‐guarded chamber; at the depth of maximum dose for the 18 MeV beam, is 1.0010. is also calculated for the NACP02 chamber and a Farmer chamber (diameter 6 mm) at a depth of 5 cm in a photon beam, giving values of 1.0063 and 0.9964, respectively. For the Farmer chamber, is about half a percent higher than the value (0.992) recommended by the AAPM dosimetry protocol. It is found that the dosimetry protocols may have adopted an incorrect value of for cylindrical chambers in photon beams. The nonunity values of for plane‐parallel chambers in lower energy electron beams imply a variety of values used in dosimetry protocols must be reassessed.
- 17 January 2007
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 34 (2) , 485-488
Estimation of the focal spot size and shape for a medical linear accelerator by Monte Carlo simulation
The focal spot size and shape of a medical linac are important parameters that determine the dose profiles, especially in the penumbral region. A relationship between the focal spot size and the dose profile penumbra has been studied and established from simulation results of the EGSnrc Monte Carlo code. A simple method is proposed to estimate the size and the shape of a linac's focal spot from the measured dose profile data.
- 17 January 2007
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 34 (2) , 485-488
Estimation of the focal spot size and shape for a medical linear accelerator by Monte Carlo simulation
The focal spot size and shape of a medical linac are important parameters that determine the dose profiles, especially in the penumbral region. A relationship between the focal spot size and the dose profile penumbra has been studied and established from simulation results of the EGSnrc Monte Carlo code. A simple method is proposed to estimate the size and the shape of a linac's focal spot from the measured dose profile data.