Kevin Kwok-Yin Cheng
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Kevin Kwok-Yin Cheng has a total of 10 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Wing Hong Chui
The Hong Kong Polytechnic University
10 shared publications Sayaka Ri
Harvard Law School, University of Harvard, United States
5 shared publications- Rebecca Ong
City University of Hong Kong
4 shared publications Zachary Bok-Hin Chan
The Chinese University of Hong Kong
3 shared publicationsNatasha Pushkarna
2 shared publicationsBecky Po-Yee Leung
The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 5 March 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Legal Studies
- Vol. 46 (1) , 16-45
Sentencing with or without guidelines: a cross-jurisdictional analysis of England & Wales and Hong Kong
Prevailing wisdom suggests that sentencing guidelines may constrain judicial discretion and hinder individualised justice; however, our cross-jurisdictional analysis indicates that they might actually better protect these principles than unrestricted discretion. Utilising two large-scale datasets from England and Wales, and Hong Kong, we examine sentences for burglary, assault, and drug trafficking. The results reveal a paradox: guidelines in England and Wales contributed to greater consistency in retributive proportionality and enhanced consideration of personal mitigating factors. Conversely, Hong Kong’s discretionary approach resulted in inconsistent application of sentencing considerations and personal mitigating factors. Both systems prioritised procedural efficiency, with guilty pleas markedly reducing sentences across various offences. These findings challenge the ‘bias effect’ critique by demonstrating that well-structured guidelines can safeguard individualised justice better than unfettered discretion can. The study offers robust empirical evidence for institutional design in criminal justice systems.
- 5 March 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Legal Studies
- Vol. 46 (1) , 16-45
Open AccessSentencing with or without guidelines: a cross-jurisdictional analysis of England & Wales and Hong Kong
Prevailing wisdom suggests that sentencing guidelines may constrain judicial discretion and hinder individualised justice; however, our cross-jurisdictional analysis indicates that they might actually better protect these principles than unrestricted discretion. Utilising two large-scale datasets from England and Wales, and Hong Kong, we examine sentences for burglary, assault, and drug trafficking. The results reveal a paradox: guidelines in England and Wales contributed to greater consistency in retributive proportionality and enhanced consideration of personal mitigating factors. Conversely, Hong Kong’s discretionary approach resulted in inconsistent application of sentencing considerations and personal mitigating factors. Both systems prioritised procedural efficiency, with guilty pleas markedly reducing sentences across various offences. These findings challenge the ‘bias effect’ critique by demonstrating that well-structured guidelines can safeguard individualised justice better than unfettered discretion can. The study offers robust empirical evidence for institutional design in criminal justice systems.
- Open Access
- 7 June 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Law & Empirical Analysis
- Vol. 2 (2) , 203-218
In-Group Favoritism in Sentencing Among the Courtroom Workgroup? Evidence From Hong Kong
Understanding the impact of legal professionals on sentencing outcomes is currently limited. This study uses the social psychology theory of in-group favoritism, the courtroom workgroup theory, and the experience/skill of legal professionals to analyze how the roles of lawyers, prosecutors, and judges affect plea and sentencing outcomes. It goes beyond existing literature, which mainly distinguishes between privately retained lawyers and legal aid lawyers, by also including public prosecutors and prosecutors on fiat (defense lawyers working as prosecutors on an ad-hoc basis) and full-time and deputy judges. By examining court sentencing data from Hong Kong, it was found that legal aid lawyers significantly correlated with more lenient sentences, whereas public prosecutors significantly correlated with more severe sentences. However, upon examining plea cases exclusively, it was discovered that only public prosecutors demonstrated a significant association with a higher number of guilty pleas and more severe sentences. The findings partially support in-group favoritism and courtroom workgroup theories, suggesting that legal professionals viewed as “insiders” in the court system achieve more favorable sentencing outcomes aligned with their professional goals. The differences highlighted in this research may stem from Hong Kong’s unique plea bargaining environment, which varies from that in other Western jurisdictions.
- 7 June 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Law & Empirical Analysis
- Vol. 2 (2) , 203-218
Open AccessIn-Group Favoritism in Sentencing Among the Courtroom Workgroup? Evidence From Hong Kong
Understanding the impact of legal professionals on sentencing outcomes is currently limited. This study uses the social psychology theory of in-group favoritism, the courtroom workgroup theory, and the experience/skill of legal professionals to analyze how the roles of lawyers, prosecutors, and judges affect plea and sentencing outcomes. It goes beyond existing literature, which mainly distinguishes between privately retained lawyers and legal aid lawyers, by also including public prosecutors and prosecutors on fiat (defense lawyers working as prosecutors on an ad-hoc basis) and full-time and deputy judges. By examining court sentencing data from Hong Kong, it was found that legal aid lawyers significantly correlated with more lenient sentences, whereas public prosecutors significantly correlated with more severe sentences. However, upon examining plea cases exclusively, it was discovered that only public prosecutors demonstrated a significant association with a higher number of guilty pleas and more severe sentences. The findings partially support in-group favoritism and courtroom workgroup theories, suggesting that legal professionals viewed as “insiders” in the court system achieve more favorable sentencing outcomes aligned with their professional goals. The differences highlighted in this research may stem from Hong Kong’s unique plea bargaining environment, which varies from that in other Western jurisdictions.
- 5 December 2024
- Published by Elsevier in International Journal of Law, Crime and Justice
- Vol. 80
Leniency for otherwise law-abiding citizens? Testing the lapse theory and sentencing in England and Wales
- 5 December 2024
- Published by Elsevier in International Journal of Law, Crime and Justice
- Vol. 80
Leniency for otherwise law-abiding citizens? Testing the lapse theory and sentencing in England and Wales
- 25 June 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 177-199
The Courts, the Prosecution, and the Defence in Plea-Based Case Dispositions in Hong Kong
- 25 June 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 177-199
The Courts, the Prosecution, and the Defence in Plea-Based Case Dispositions in Hong Kong
- 8 May 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Criminal Justice
- Vol. 92
Criminal record and sentencing: A comparative perspective between England and Wales and Hong Kong
- 8 May 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Criminal Justice
- Vol. 92
Criminal record and sentencing: A comparative perspective between England and Wales and Hong Kong
- 19 July 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Criminology & Criminal Justice
- Vol. 25 (4) , 1244-1261
Judges’ characteristics and sentencing in Hong Kong
The influence of judges’ characteristics on sentencing remains an understudied area particularly in Asian contexts. Previous studies typically focus on the effects of judges’ demographic characteristics in the context of the United States. This study extends the literature by investigating the effects of demographic characteristics, including similarity of the judges with defendants in terms of demographic characteristics and judges’ previous experience on sentence outcomes in Hong Kong. Data are drawn from the Hong Kong Judiciary’s Reason for Sentence, imported into an original coded data set of judgments. The results show that older judges render more severe sentences in general while also being more lenient toward older defendants. In addition, a judge’s education and prior working experience are significant on sentence length, such that, judges with education abroad are more likely to be harsher than those educated locally, whereas judges who were former prosecutors are more lenient in their sentencing than defense lawyers.
- 19 July 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Criminology & Criminal Justice
- Vol. 25 (4) , 1244-1261
Judges’ characteristics and sentencing in Hong Kong
The influence of judges’ characteristics on sentencing remains an understudied area particularly in Asian contexts. Previous studies typically focus on the effects of judges’ demographic characteristics in the context of the United States. This study extends the literature by investigating the effects of demographic characteristics, including similarity of the judges with defendants in terms of demographic characteristics and judges’ previous experience on sentence outcomes in Hong Kong. Data are drawn from the Hong Kong Judiciary’s Reason for Sentence, imported into an original coded data set of judgments. The results show that older judges render more severe sentences in general while also being more lenient toward older defendants. In addition, a judge’s education and prior working experience are significant on sentence length, such that, judges with education abroad are more likely to be harsher than those educated locally, whereas judges who were former prosecutors are more lenient in their sentencing than defense lawyers.
- Open Access
- 20 May 2022
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Asian Journal of Comparative Law
- Vol. 17 (1) , 167-190
Testing the Drugs’ Sentencing Guidelines: A Comparison between England and Wales and Hong Kong
In the era of sentencing guidelines, the punishment for traffickers is primarily based on the offenders’ culpability and the drug weight. Existing literature tend to focus on the issue of proportionality as it relates to the roles and culpability of offenders. However, little attention has been drawn to the quantity of drugs. England and Wales have incorporated offender roles into their sentencing guidelines, while Hong Kong uses drug tariffs strictly based on drug weight to calculate the starting point of a sentence. Using a novel equation called ‘the arithmetic starting point of sentence’, this study examines the starting sentence based on each gram of drugs by undertaking a comparative analysis of the respective jurisdictions. The results show that both jurisdictions have adopted sentencing guidelines that exhibit a logarithmic curve. This implies that the scale used to measure the quantity of drugs is disproportionate, penalising smaller quantities more harshly than larger quantities.
- 20 May 2022
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Asian Journal of Comparative Law
- Vol. 17 (1) , 167-190
Open AccessTesting the Drugs’ Sentencing Guidelines: A Comparison between England and Wales and Hong Kong
In the era of sentencing guidelines, the punishment for traffickers is primarily based on the offenders’ culpability and the drug weight. Existing literature tend to focus on the issue of proportionality as it relates to the roles and culpability of offenders. However, little attention has been drawn to the quantity of drugs. England and Wales have incorporated offender roles into their sentencing guidelines, while Hong Kong uses drug tariffs strictly based on drug weight to calculate the starting point of a sentence. Using a novel equation called ‘the arithmetic starting point of sentence’, this study examines the starting sentence based on each gram of drugs by undertaking a comparative analysis of the respective jurisdictions. The results show that both jurisdictions have adopted sentencing guidelines that exhibit a logarithmic curve. This implies that the scale used to measure the quantity of drugs is disproportionate, penalising smaller quantities more harshly than larger quantities.
- 7 February 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Asian Journal of Criminology
- Vol. 17 (2) , 237-261
Plea Discount Deviations: a Mechanism for Gender Disparities in Hong Kong
- 7 February 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Asian Journal of Criminology
- Vol. 17 (2) , 237-261
Plea Discount Deviations: a Mechanism for Gender Disparities in Hong Kong
- 28 August 2020
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Empirical Legal Studies
- Vol. 17 (3) , 580-614
Judicial Disparity, Deviation, and Departures from Sentencing Guidelines: The Case of Hong Kong
Analyzing sentencing disparity calls for more calibrated measures to capture the nuances of judicial discretion within jurisdictions that adopt strict sentencing guidelines. This article uses an unconventional outcome variable, percent deviation, to investigate guideline digressions in a nested, multilevel model. Percent deviation is calculated based on the difference between the guidelines’ “arithmetic starting point” and the actual starting point that a judge adopts. Two equations were used to measure percent deviation from the arithmetic starting point before and after adjustment for guilty plea sentence reductions. Extracting data on drug trafficking cases from an open‐source database from the Hong Kong Judiciary (n = 356), we illustrate how percent deviation can be employed as a measure of inter‐judge disparity using hierarchical linear models (HLMs). Our findings suggest that approximately 8 to 10 percent of the deviation in sentence length can be attributed to judges’ differential sentencing behaviors. The deviation is affected by case characteristics as well as judicial characteristics. Due to the wide guideline ranges, departures from said guidelines’ ranges are not common. This indicates that the guideline ranges mask the deviation and inter‐judge disparity that exist and recur.
- 28 August 2020
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Empirical Legal Studies
- Vol. 17 (3) , 580-614
Judicial Disparity, Deviation, and Departures from Sentencing Guidelines: The Case of Hong Kong
Analyzing sentencing disparity calls for more calibrated measures to capture the nuances of judicial discretion within jurisdictions that adopt strict sentencing guidelines. This article uses an unconventional outcome variable, percent deviation, to investigate guideline digressions in a nested, multilevel model. Percent deviation is calculated based on the difference between the guidelines’ “arithmetic starting point” and the actual starting point that a judge adopts. Two equations were used to measure percent deviation from the arithmetic starting point before and after adjustment for guilty plea sentence reductions. Extracting data on drug trafficking cases from an open‐source database from the Hong Kong Judiciary (n = 356), we illustrate how percent deviation can be employed as a measure of inter‐judge disparity using hierarchical linear models (HLMs). Our findings suggest that approximately 8 to 10 percent of the deviation in sentence length can be attributed to judges’ differential sentencing behaviors. The deviation is affected by case characteristics as well as judicial characteristics. Due to the wide guideline ranges, departures from said guidelines’ ranges are not common. This indicates that the guideline ranges mask the deviation and inter‐judge disparity that exist and recur.
- 1 May 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in Punishment & Society
- Vol. 22 (5) , 617-636
Enhancing the legitimacy of sentences in the minds of the public: Evidence from a public opinion survey in Hong Kong
Legal and criminology scholars have devoted a great deal of attention towards measuring public confidence in the courts and sentencing. However, little is known about how attitudes toward sentencing relate to the more complex concept of legitimacy. Departing from conventional measurements of the public’s confidence in the courts and their support for various sentence outcomes, this study centres on the process of sentencing and its relation to ‘sentence legitimacy’. The central question posed in this article is what makes sentence outcomes legitimate? Survey responses from the Hong Kong public revealed that the public viewed court sentences as legitimate through the courts’ overall adherence to procedural justice when making sentencing decisions and the perceived effectiveness of those sentences. Distributive justice of sentencing decisions was not found to influence sentence legitimacy. This article concludes with implications for the courts when delivering sentences.
- 1 May 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in Punishment & Society
- Vol. 22 (5) , 617-636
Enhancing the legitimacy of sentences in the minds of the public: Evidence from a public opinion survey in Hong Kong
Legal and criminology scholars have devoted a great deal of attention towards measuring public confidence in the courts and sentencing. However, little is known about how attitudes toward sentencing relate to the more complex concept of legitimacy. Departing from conventional measurements of the public’s confidence in the courts and their support for various sentence outcomes, this study centres on the process of sentencing and its relation to ‘sentence legitimacy’. The central question posed in this article is what makes sentence outcomes legitimate? Survey responses from the Hong Kong public revealed that the public viewed court sentences as legitimate through the courts’ overall adherence to procedural justice when making sentencing decisions and the perceived effectiveness of those sentences. Distributive justice of sentencing decisions was not found to influence sentence legitimacy. This article concludes with implications for the courts when delivering sentences.