Judicial Disparity, Deviation, and Departures from Sentencing Guidelines: The Case of Hong Kong
Authors:
- Kevin Kwok‐Yin ChengKCKevin Kwok‐Yin Cheng
- Sayaka RiSRSayaka Ri
- Natasha PushkarnaNPNatasha Pushkarna
- 28 August 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Empirical Legal Studies
- Vol. 17 (3) , 580-614
Abstract
Analyzing sentencing disparity calls for more calibrated measures to capture the nuances of judicial discretion within jurisdictions that adopt strict sentencing guidelines. This article uses an unconventional outcome variable, percent deviation, to investigate guideline digressions in a nested, multilevel model. Percent deviation is calculated based on the difference between the guidelines’ “arithmetic starting point” and the actual starting point that a judge adopts. Two equations were used to measure percent deviation from the arithmetic starting point before and after adjustment for guilty plea sentence reductions. Extracting data on drug trafficking cases from an open‐source database from the Hong Kong Judiciary (n = 356), we illustrate how percent deviation can be employed as a measure of inter‐judge disparity using hierarchical linear models (HLMs). Our findings suggest that approximately 8 to 10 percent of the deviation in sentence length can be attributed to judges’ differential sentencing behaviors. The deviation is affected by case characteristics as well as judicial characteristics. Due to the wide guideline ranges, departures from said guidelines’ ranges are not common. This indicates that the guideline ranges mask the deviation and inter‐judge disparity that exist and recur.Keywords
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Sentencing Guidelines and Judicial Discretion: Quasi‐Experimental Evidence from Human Calculation ErrorsJournal of Empirical Legal Studies, 2012
- Recent Developments and New Directions in Sentencing ResearchJustice Quarterly, 2011
- JUDGES' UNEQUAL CONTRIBUTIONS TO EXTRALEGAL DISPARITIES IN IMPRISONMENT*Criminology, 2010
- A Sentencing Exception? Changing Sentencing Policy in ScotlandFederal Sentencing Reporter, 2010
- Lawlessness in the Federal Sentencing Process: A Test for Uniformity and Consistency in Sentence OutcomesJustice Quarterly, 2009
- Courtroom Workgroups and SentencingCrime & Delinquency, 2008
- MODELING THE EFFECTS OF LEGALLY RELEVANT AND EXTRALEGAL FACTORS UNDER SENTENCING GUIDELINES: THE RULES HAVE CHANGED*Criminology, 2000
- Measuring Interjudge Sentencing Disparity: Before and After the Federal Sentencing GuidelinesThe Journal of Law and Economics, 1999
- The Effect of the Federal Sentencing Guidelines on Inter-Judge Sentencing DisparityThe Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology (1973-), 1999
- Social Background as an Indicator to the Votes of Supreme Court Justices in Criminal Cases: 1947-1956 TermsAmerican Journal of Political Science, 1973