Robbie Robinson
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Robbie Robinson has a total of 2 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Bradley Shaun Smith
Faculty of Law, University of the Free State
1 shared publication - Ronelle Prinsloo1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 23 November 2023
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
- Vol. 26
Chief Justice Coke: Common Law v Royal Absolutism
In this contribution Chief Justice Coke's character and contribution to the development of the English law are considered. More specifically the focus falls on his profound knowledge of the Common Law and the concomitant emphasizing of human freedom. Coke's emphasizing of the Common Law was the cause of continuous conflict between himself and King James 1 and later also King Charles 1. True to the Royal approach in this era they strongly endorsed Royal absolutism, believing it stemmed from a divine origin. James 1 enjoyed the support of Sir Francis Bacon. Also between him and Coke intense rivalry, also of a personal nature, existed. Against James 1 and Bacon's continuing attacks on his views, Coke could only turn to the common law.
- 23 November 2023
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
- Vol. 26
Open AccessChief Justice Coke: Common Law v Royal Absolutism
In this contribution Chief Justice Coke's character and contribution to the development of the English law are considered. More specifically the focus falls on his profound knowledge of the Common Law and the concomitant emphasizing of human freedom. Coke's emphasizing of the Common Law was the cause of continuous conflict between himself and King James 1 and later also King Charles 1. True to the Royal approach in this era they strongly endorsed Royal absolutism, believing it stemmed from a divine origin. James 1 enjoyed the support of Sir Francis Bacon. Also between him and Coke intense rivalry, also of a personal nature, existed. Against James 1 and Bacon's continuing attacks on his views, Coke could only turn to the common law.
- Open Access
- 9 April 2020
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
- Vol. 23, 1-30
Die Status en Beskerming van Meerderjariges met Beperkte Handelingsbevoegdheid / The Status and Protection of Majors with Impaired Capacity to Act
In this contribution the focus falls on the capacity to act of majors who, due to mental or physical disabilities lack the ability to make sound decisions in respect of their estate, conclude juristic acts that lead to undue harsh consequences for themselves. The question that arises is how to apply the boni mores as the concept has been developed constitutionally to protect such persons. In this respect it is shown that Dutch law may fruitfully be consulted to comply with courts' discretion to consult foreign law. Mentorskap and the beschermingsbewind qua measures that are aimed specifically at the protection of the non-patrimonial interests of (typically) patients and the patrimonial interests of such people are of specific relevance.
- 9 April 2020
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
- Vol. 23, 1-30
Open AccessDie Status en Beskerming van Meerderjariges met Beperkte Handelingsbevoegdheid / The Status and Protection of Majors with Impaired Capacity to Act
In this contribution the focus falls on the capacity to act of majors who, due to mental or physical disabilities lack the ability to make sound decisions in respect of their estate, conclude juristic acts that lead to undue harsh consequences for themselves. The question that arises is how to apply the boni mores as the concept has been developed constitutionally to protect such persons. In this respect it is shown that Dutch law may fruitfully be consulted to comply with courts' discretion to consult foreign law. Mentorskap and the beschermingsbewind qua measures that are aimed specifically at the protection of the non-patrimonial interests of (typically) patients and the patrimonial interests of such people are of specific relevance.
- Open Access
- 10 April 2018
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
- Vol. 21, 1-31
The Legal Nature of the Embryo: Legal Subject or Legal Object?
This contribution addresses the question regarding the legal nature of a cryopreserved embryo. Such preservation is a relatively modern development in the medical field. Neither Tennessee (USA) law nor European law provides an acceptable explanation regarding its legal nature. It is argued herein that this is mainly due to the fact that rather unscientific language is applied. It is suggested that the using of concise legal terminology may contribute to a better understanding. The terms legal subject and object and legal subjectivity are well-known and have definite legal content. By drawing an analogy between the legal status of an infant and such embryos, the conclusion is reached that embryos are not legal subjects sui iuris but indeed share the legal subjectivity of their parents.
- 10 April 2018
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
- Vol. 21, 1-31
Open AccessThe Legal Nature of the Embryo: Legal Subject or Legal Object?
This contribution addresses the question regarding the legal nature of a cryopreserved embryo. Such preservation is a relatively modern development in the medical field. Neither Tennessee (USA) law nor European law provides an acceptable explanation regarding its legal nature. It is argued herein that this is mainly due to the fact that rather unscientific language is applied. It is suggested that the using of concise legal terminology may contribute to a better understanding. The terms legal subject and object and legal subjectivity are well-known and have definite legal content. By drawing an analogy between the legal status of an infant and such embryos, the conclusion is reached that embryos are not legal subjects sui iuris but indeed share the legal subjectivity of their parents.
- Open Access
- 25 August 2015
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
- Vol. 18 (5) , 1527-1544
Die Adversatiewe Stelsel van Bewyslewering en die Beste Belang van die Kind in Egskeidingsaangeleenthede: Enkele Gedagtes oor Collaborative Law ter Beslegting Van Ouerlike Geskille
In this contribution it is argued that the adversarial system of litigation does not serve the best interests of children upon divorce. After a brief analysis of the system it is concluded that other less aggressive means of litigation should be considered underupon divorce. Collaborative Law is suggested as a means to bear in mind. The fact that current practice of lawyer negotitiatons in respect of divorce is not too far removed from Collaborative Law may lead to practitioners readily accepting the concept. KEYWORDS: best interest of the child; collaborative law; adversarial system ; mediation.
- 25 August 2015
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
- Vol. 18 (5) , 1527-1544
Open AccessDie Adversatiewe Stelsel van Bewyslewering en die Beste Belang van die Kind in Egskeidingsaangeleenthede: Enkele Gedagtes oor Collaborative Law ter Beslegting Van Ouerlike Geskille
In this contribution it is argued that the adversarial system of litigation does not serve the best interests of children upon divorce. After a brief analysis of the system it is concluded that other less aggressive means of litigation should be considered underupon divorce. Collaborative Law is suggested as a means to bear in mind. The fact that current practice of lawyer negotitiatons in respect of divorce is not too far removed from Collaborative Law may lead to practitioners readily accepting the concept. KEYWORDS: best interest of the child; collaborative law; adversarial system ; mediation.
- Open Access
- 25 August 2015
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
- Vol. 18 (5) , 1669-1690
The Right of the Child to Care and Constitutional Damages for the Loss of Parental Care: Some Thoughts On M v Minister of Police and Minister of Police v Mboweni
In the a quo judgment in M v Minister of Police a radical new approach was followed in respect of claims for loss of parental care. The issue before court was whether a child whose parent has died as a result of the wrongful conduct of the South African Police Services may sue for damages arising from the child's constitutional right to parental care in terms of section 28(1)(b). The question which the Court had to answer was whether a claim for damages may be instituted on the grounds that children are as a result of the wrongful death of their father deprived of their constitutionally entrenched right to parental care. This contribution reflects on the reasoning of the different courts and the relevance of same for the debate regarding the care of children in terms of section 28(1)(b) of the Constitution and section 1 of the Children's Act 38 of 2005. KEYWORDS: parental care; Children's Act 38 of 2005; constitutional damages; appropriate relief.
- 25 August 2015
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
- Vol. 18 (5) , 1669-1690
Open AccessThe Right of the Child to Care and Constitutional Damages for the Loss of Parental Care: Some Thoughts On M v Minister of Police and Minister of Police v Mboweni
In the a quo judgment in M v Minister of Police a radical new approach was followed in respect of claims for loss of parental care. The issue before court was whether a child whose parent has died as a result of the wrongful conduct of the South African Police Services may sue for damages arising from the child's constitutional right to parental care in terms of section 28(1)(b). The question which the Court had to answer was whether a claim for damages may be instituted on the grounds that children are as a result of the wrongful death of their father deprived of their constitutionally entrenched right to parental care. This contribution reflects on the reasoning of the different courts and the relevance of same for the debate regarding the care of children in terms of section 28(1)(b) of the Constitution and section 1 of the Children's Act 38 of 2005. KEYWORDS: parental care; Children's Act 38 of 2005; constitutional damages; appropriate relief.
- Open Access
- 12 June 2015
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
- Vol. 18 (4) , 1251-1254
International Law and Child Soldiers by Gus Waschefort
International Law and Child Soldiers by Gus Waschefort
- 12 June 2015
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
- Vol. 18 (4) , 1251-1254
Open AccessInternational Law and Child Soldiers by Gus Waschefort
International Law and Child Soldiers by Gus Waschefort
- Open Access
- 31 March 2015
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
- Vol. 18 (2) , 332-361
Provisional Thoughts on Limitations to the Right to Procreate
The constantly increasing human population results in severe ecological, psychological, political, economic and sociological ramifications. These negative implications raise the question whether the constitutionally entrenched right to make decisions concerning reproduction may be limited, as the continued existence of the State may ultimately be jeopardised if the population is not kept "[d]own to the means of subsistence". An analysis of relevant constitutional provisions shows that in essence it is the "inner sanctum" of the individual which is shielded from erosion by conflicting rights of the community, and that the outward manifestation of the right (procreation) may indeed be limited. However, the so-called Chinese experience shows that negative measures have the desired results but also had a severe non-intended impact on the social and economic situation in China. It is suggested, therefore, that positive measures (eg proper education and social provision) be considered to limit population growth. KEYWORDS: Limitation of rights; right to procreate; overpopulation; limitation of the right to procreate; procreation.
- 31 March 2015
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
- Vol. 18 (2) , 332-361
Open AccessProvisional Thoughts on Limitations to the Right to Procreate
The constantly increasing human population results in severe ecological, psychological, political, economic and sociological ramifications. These negative implications raise the question whether the constitutionally entrenched right to make decisions concerning reproduction may be limited, as the continued existence of the State may ultimately be jeopardised if the population is not kept "[d]own to the means of subsistence". An analysis of relevant constitutional provisions shows that in essence it is the "inner sanctum" of the individual which is shielded from erosion by conflicting rights of the community, and that the outward manifestation of the right (procreation) may indeed be limited. However, the so-called Chinese experience shows that negative measures have the desired results but also had a severe non-intended impact on the social and economic situation in China. It is suggested, therefore, that positive measures (eg proper education and social provision) be considered to limit population growth. KEYWORDS: Limitation of rights; right to procreate; overpopulation; limitation of the right to procreate; procreation.
- Open Access
- 17 August 2012
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
- Vol. 15 (2) , 148-205
The relevance of a contextualisation of the state-individual relationship for child victims of armed Conflict
The relationship between the individual and the State is discussed in this contribution. The argument is put forward that both the State and the individual are legal subjects endowed with legal subjectivity. In their relationship it must be accepted that the State is not only endowed with State sovereignty, but also that it prescriptively makes use of its authority. However, theirs is a legal relationship characterised by reciprocal rights and duties so that the balance point in their relationship must as a matter of course be determined legally. As an explanatory model the theory of public subjective rights, which is of German origin, is applied. This theory can serve only as a starting point, though, as it fails to address certain fundamental questions. The viewpoints of authors of the so-called Reformed Tradition will therefore be applied to elaborate on the theory. By adopting this approach it is endeavoured to explain that the relationship between the State and the individual may not be viewed as one characterised by the abuse of State authority or excessive individual claims against the State.
- 17 August 2012
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
- Vol. 15 (2) , 148-205
Open AccessThe relevance of a contextualisation of the state-individual relationship for child victims of armed Conflict
The relationship between the individual and the State is discussed in this contribution. The argument is put forward that both the State and the individual are legal subjects endowed with legal subjectivity. In their relationship it must be accepted that the State is not only endowed with State sovereignty, but also that it prescriptively makes use of its authority. However, theirs is a legal relationship characterised by reciprocal rights and duties so that the balance point in their relationship must as a matter of course be determined legally. As an explanatory model the theory of public subjective rights, which is of German origin, is applied. This theory can serve only as a starting point, though, as it fails to address certain fundamental questions. The viewpoints of authors of the so-called Reformed Tradition will therefore be applied to elaborate on the theory. By adopting this approach it is endeavoured to explain that the relationship between the State and the individual may not be viewed as one characterised by the abuse of State authority or excessive individual claims against the State.
- Open Access
- 29 March 2012
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
- Vol. 15 (1) , 45-101
The Right of Child Victims of Armed Conflict to Reintegration and Recovery
Article 39 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child provides for the right to recovery and reintegration of child victims of armed conflict. In this publication an explanation is tendered of when children are considered to be victims of armed conflict. Specific reference is made to the question of whether or not a former child soldier may be viewed as such a child victim. In addition the question is addressed of how a monist or dualist approach in terms of which treaty law is incorporated into municipal law influences the rights of child victims in terms of article 39 of the Convention of the Rights of the Child. Thirdly, article 39 is discussed against the background of the international human rights instrument, the Convention on the Rights of the Child.
- 29 March 2012
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
- Vol. 15 (1) , 45-101
Open AccessThe Right of Child Victims of Armed Conflict to Reintegration and Recovery
Article 39 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child provides for the right to recovery and reintegration of child victims of armed conflict. In this publication an explanation is tendered of when children are considered to be victims of armed conflict. Specific reference is made to the question of whether or not a former child soldier may be viewed as such a child victim. In addition the question is addressed of how a monist or dualist approach in terms of which treaty law is incorporated into municipal law influences the rights of child victims in terms of article 39 of the Convention of the Rights of the Child. Thirdly, article 39 is discussed against the background of the international human rights instrument, the Convention on the Rights of the Child.
- Open Access
- 27 August 2010
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
- Vol. 13 (2) , 29-75
An Embarrassment of Riches or a Profusion of Confusion An Evaluation of the Continued Existence of the Civil Union Act of 2006 in the Light of Prospective Domestic Partnerships Legislation in South Africa
As it stands, South African family law currently holds that the Marriage Act 25 of 1961 applies exclusively to the solemnisation of heterosexual civil marriages while same-sex couples have no choice but to formalise their relationships in terms of the Civil Union Act 17 of 2006. In addition, the legal position is complicated by the fact that the latter Act not only allows both heterosexual and homosexual couples to conclude a civil union, but also provides that a civil union may take the form of either a marriage or a civil partnership, both of which enjoy the same legal recognition as, and give rise to the same legal consequences, as a civil marriage under the Marriage Act. In January 2008, a draft Domestic Partnerships Bill saw the light of day, the potential enactment of which casts significant doubt as to whether the prevailing framework should be retained. With this potential development in mind, this paper considers the desirability of maintaining the "separate but equal" status quo by: (a) comparing the South African Law Reform Commission's pre-Civil Union Act proposals with the approach eventually adopted by the legislature; (b) comparing and contrasting the post-Civil Union Act position in South Africa with that of an established and well-ordered jurisdiction such as the Netherlands and, in the light hereof, considering the cases for and against repealing the Civil Union Act; and (c) by considering the desirability and practicality of the civil partnership's potential co-existence with the Domestic Partnerships Bill (as modified in accordance with a recent study). A proposal is made that could provide a less complex and better streamlined family law dispensation in South Africa.
- 27 August 2010
- Published by Academy of Science of South Africa in Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
- Vol. 13 (2) , 29-75
Open AccessAn Embarrassment of Riches or a Profusion of Confusion An Evaluation of the Continued Existence of the Civil Union Act of 2006 in the Light of Prospective Domestic Partnerships Legislation in South Africa
As it stands, South African family law currently holds that the Marriage Act 25 of 1961 applies exclusively to the solemnisation of heterosexual civil marriages while same-sex couples have no choice but to formalise their relationships in terms of the Civil Union Act 17 of 2006. In addition, the legal position is complicated by the fact that the latter Act not only allows both heterosexual and homosexual couples to conclude a civil union, but also provides that a civil union may take the form of either a marriage or a civil partnership, both of which enjoy the same legal recognition as, and give rise to the same legal consequences, as a civil marriage under the Marriage Act. In January 2008, a draft Domestic Partnerships Bill saw the light of day, the potential enactment of which casts significant doubt as to whether the prevailing framework should be retained. With this potential development in mind, this paper considers the desirability of maintaining the "separate but equal" status quo by: (a) comparing the South African Law Reform Commission's pre-Civil Union Act proposals with the approach eventually adopted by the legislature; (b) comparing and contrasting the post-Civil Union Act position in South Africa with that of an established and well-ordered jurisdiction such as the Netherlands and, in the light hereof, considering the cases for and against repealing the Civil Union Act; and (c) by considering the desirability and practicality of the civil partnership's potential co-existence with the Domestic Partnerships Bill (as modified in accordance with a recent study). A proposal is made that could provide a less complex and better streamlined family law dispensation in South Africa.