César Caballero-Gaudes
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
César Caballero-Gaudes has a total of 416 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Stefano Moia
Maastricht University
14 shared publications - Eneko Uruñuela
Basque Centre on Cognition, Brain and Language
13 shared publications - Javier Gonzalez-Castillo
Section on Functional Imaging Methods, Laboratory of Brain and Cognition, National Institute of Mental Health, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD, USA
11 shared publications - Molly G. Bright
Department of Biomedical Engineering, McCormick School of Engineering and Applied Sciences, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL, United States
8 shared publications - Peter A. Bandettini
National Institute of Mental Health, Bethesda, MD, USA
8 shared publications - Manuel Carreiras
Basque Center on Cognition, Brain and Language
7 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Sensitivity of Pulmonary 4D Flow MRI Biomarkers to Controlled Spatial and Temporal Degradation in a CFD Benchmark
Purpose: To quantify, in a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) benchmark, how spatial degradation, temporal acquisition and noise change the error of plane-based pulmonary-artery flow endpoints. Methods: Twenty-two historical, non-converged CFD simulations (11 geometry families) were voxelised at 2 mm with 80 frames per cycle. Simulations with numerical divergence were excluded, leaving 13 (7 families). Fields were degraded to 4 and 8mm and with noise, plane waveforms were sampled at 20 phases with one-interval averaging, and errors were computed against the noise-free reference waveform on 66 geometric planes. Family-mean paired differences are reported with t-based 95% confidence intervals under an analysis plan fixed in advance. Results: Spatial degradation from 2 to 4mm increased full-waveform nRMSE by 0.0032 [0.0021, 0.0043], in 7 of 7 families; cycle-mean flow bias accounted for 23% of the squared error, against 60% at 8 mm. With SNR scaled to voxel volume, the increase was not resolved (0.0002 [−0.0012, 0.0015]). Twenty-phase acquisition increased PI error (0.0223 [0.0214, 0.0233]) and diastolic-trough timing error (0.63 [0.52, 0.74] frames) more than spatial degradation, and its point estimates for these endpoints were larger with every recovery method; the nRMSE ordering and peak timing depended on the recovery method. The implementation of the downsampling operator mattered: an alternative, corner-aligned implementation of the same 4mm degradation gave a larger spatial effect (nRMSE difference 0.0010 [0.0002, 0.0017]). Conclusion: In this benchmark, a 2 to 4mm degradation produced a small, consistent, mostly shape-related nRMSE increase that depended on the noise model, whereas 20-phase acquisition changed PI error and trough timing more. The results describe benchmark behaviour, not clinical acquisition requirements.
Open AccessSensitivity of Pulmonary 4D Flow MRI Biomarkers to Controlled Spatial and Temporal Degradation in a CFD Benchmark
Purpose: To quantify, in a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) benchmark, how spatial degradation, temporal acquisition and noise change the error of plane-based pulmonary-artery flow endpoints. Methods: Twenty-two historical, non-converged CFD simulations (11 geometry families) were voxelised at 2 mm with 80 frames per cycle. Simulations with numerical divergence were excluded, leaving 13 (7 families). Fields were degraded to 4 and 8mm and with noise, plane waveforms were sampled at 20 phases with one-interval averaging, and errors were computed against the noise-free reference waveform on 66 geometric planes. Family-mean paired differences are reported with t-based 95% confidence intervals under an analysis plan fixed in advance. Results: Spatial degradation from 2 to 4mm increased full-waveform nRMSE by 0.0032 [0.0021, 0.0043], in 7 of 7 families; cycle-mean flow bias accounted for 23% of the squared error, against 60% at 8 mm. With SNR scaled to voxel volume, the increase was not resolved (0.0002 [−0.0012, 0.0015]). Twenty-phase acquisition increased PI error (0.0223 [0.0214, 0.0233]) and diastolic-trough timing error (0.63 [0.52, 0.74] frames) more than spatial degradation, and its point estimates for these endpoints were larger with every recovery method; the nRMSE ordering and peak timing depended on the recovery method. The implementation of the downsampling operator mattered: an alternative, corner-aligned implementation of the same 4mm degradation gave a larger spatial effect (nRMSE difference 0.0010 [0.0002, 0.0017]). Conclusion: In this benchmark, a 2 to 4mm degradation produced a small, consistent, mostly shape-related nRMSE increase that depended on the noise model, whereas 20-phase acquisition changed PI error and trough timing more. The results describe benchmark behaviour, not clinical acquisition requirements.
- Open Access
Biomarker-Aware Super-Resolution for 4D Flow MRI in a Synthetic Pulmonary-Artery Benchmark
Purpose: To evaluate, within a synthetic pulmonary-artery benchmark, whether biomarker-aware super-resolution improves hemodynamic endpoint fidelity in 4D flow MRI. Methods: A 3D residual channel attention network (RCAN) was trained on 22 CFD simulations from 11 pulmonary-artery geometries with 2× spatial degradation. The original primary comparison evaluated full biomarker-aware training against a combined divergence–temporal-regularization control across 14 matched seeds on a fixed six-case test set. Additional matched analyses subsequently separated divergence and adjacent-frame temporal-difference regularization and evaluated biomarker supervision in a controlled 2×2 design with a common reconstruction schedule. Results: In the original primary comparison, biomarker-aware training reduced PI error relative to the matched combined-regularization control (12.76 ± 2.34% vs. 17.12 ± 1.23%; paired difference −4.35 percentage points [95% CI −5.58, −3.09]; p = 0.0015). In the matched factorial analysis, biomarker supervision reduced PI error without (−2.235 percentage points [95% CI −3.514, −0.849]) and with (−4.125 percentage points [95% CI −5.392, −2.732]) combined regularization. PI improvement was not mirrored by uniformly improved reconstruction metrics: PSNR changed by −0.058 ( p = 0.50) and +0.144 dB ( p = 0.28), while SSIM decreased by 0.009 ( p = 0.004) and 0.007 ( p = 0.009), respectively. Divergence alone changed PI by +0.034 percentage points [95% CI −0.705, 0.809] while reducing DivRMS by 1.869 percentage points; temporal-difference regularization increased PI error by 1.562 percentage points [95% CI 0.594, 2.439]. Conclusion: Within this synthetic, fixed-case RCAN benchmark, biomarker supervision improved PI under both regularization conditions. PI improvement was not mirrored by uniformly improved reconstruction metrics. Temporal-difference—not divergence—regularization was the only isolated component associated with reproducible PI deterioration. These findings are configuration-specific and require geometry-independent and in vivo validation.
Open AccessBiomarker-Aware Super-Resolution for 4D Flow MRI in a Synthetic Pulmonary-Artery Benchmark
Purpose: To evaluate, within a synthetic pulmonary-artery benchmark, whether biomarker-aware super-resolution improves hemodynamic endpoint fidelity in 4D flow MRI. Methods: A 3D residual channel attention network (RCAN) was trained on 22 CFD simulations from 11 pulmonary-artery geometries with 2× spatial degradation. The original primary comparison evaluated full biomarker-aware training against a combined divergence–temporal-regularization control across 14 matched seeds on a fixed six-case test set. Additional matched analyses subsequently separated divergence and adjacent-frame temporal-difference regularization and evaluated biomarker supervision in a controlled 2×2 design with a common reconstruction schedule. Results: In the original primary comparison, biomarker-aware training reduced PI error relative to the matched combined-regularization control (12.76 ± 2.34% vs. 17.12 ± 1.23%; paired difference −4.35 percentage points [95% CI −5.58, −3.09]; p = 0.0015). In the matched factorial analysis, biomarker supervision reduced PI error without (−2.235 percentage points [95% CI −3.514, −0.849]) and with (−4.125 percentage points [95% CI −5.392, −2.732]) combined regularization. PI improvement was not mirrored by uniformly improved reconstruction metrics: PSNR changed by −0.058 ( p = 0.50) and +0.144 dB ( p = 0.28), while SSIM decreased by 0.009 ( p = 0.004) and 0.007 ( p = 0.009), respectively. Divergence alone changed PI by +0.034 percentage points [95% CI −0.705, 0.809] while reducing DivRMS by 1.869 percentage points; temporal-difference regularization increased PI error by 1.562 percentage points [95% CI 0.594, 2.439]. Conclusion: Within this synthetic, fixed-case RCAN benchmark, biomarker supervision improved PI under both regularization conditions. PI improvement was not mirrored by uniformly improved reconstruction metrics. Temporal-difference—not divergence—regularization was the only isolated component associated with reproducible PI deterioration. These findings are configuration-specific and require geometry-independent and in vivo validation.
- Open Access
A new fMRI quality metric using multi-echo information: Theory, validation and implications
Consistent, high-quality data is key to the success of fMRI studies given the many confounding factors and undesired signals that contaminate these data. Several quality assurance (QA) metrics exist for fMRI (e.g., temporal signal-to-noise ratio (TSNR), percent ghosting, motion estimates), but none of them leverage relationships between echoes that are part of multi-echo (ME) fMRI acquisitions. Here, we fill this gap by proposing a new QA metric for for ME-fMRI that quantifies the likelihood a given ME scan is dominated by BOLD (Blood Oxygenation Level-Dependent) fluctuations. We refer to this metric as p BOLD ; the probability of the signal change being primarily BOLD contrast-dominated. Having an estimate of overall BOLD weighting – both before and after preprocessing - is meaningful because BOLD is the intrinsic contrast mechanism used in fMRI to infer neural activity. We introduce p BOLD to the neuroimaging community by first describing the theoretical principles supporting the metric. Next, we validate p BOLD efficacy using a small dataset (N=7 scans) of constant- and cardiac-gated scans that have distinct levels of contributing BOLD fluctuations. Third, we apply p BOLD to a larger publicly available ME dataset (N=439 scans), to evaluate six different pre-processing pipelines, and show how p BOLD provides complementary information to TSNR. Our results show that ME-based denoising increases both p BOLD and TSNR relative to basic denoising; however, including the global signal (GS) as a regressor only improves TSNR, but worsens p BOLD . Further analyses looking at the BOLD-like characteristics of the GS and its relationship to cardiac and respiratory traces suggest that the observed decrease in p BOLD is likely due to a decrease in BOLD fluctuations of neural origin contributing to the GS, and not due to contributions from other physiological BOLD fluctuations (i.e., respiratory and cardiac function). Finally, we also demonstrate how p BOLD can be applied as a data quality metric, by showing how higher p BOLD results in better ability to predict phenotypes based on whole-brain functional connectivity matrices.
Open AccessA new fMRI quality metric using multi-echo information: Theory, validation and implications
Consistent, high-quality data is key to the success of fMRI studies given the many confounding factors and undesired signals that contaminate these data. Several quality assurance (QA) metrics exist for fMRI (e.g., temporal signal-to-noise ratio (TSNR), percent ghosting, motion estimates), but none of them leverage relationships between echoes that are part of multi-echo (ME) fMRI acquisitions. Here, we fill this gap by proposing a new QA metric for for ME-fMRI that quantifies the likelihood a given ME scan is dominated by BOLD (Blood Oxygenation Level-Dependent) fluctuations. We refer to this metric as p BOLD ; the probability of the signal change being primarily BOLD contrast-dominated. Having an estimate of overall BOLD weighting – both before and after preprocessing - is meaningful because BOLD is the intrinsic contrast mechanism used in fMRI to infer neural activity. We introduce p BOLD to the neuroimaging community by first describing the theoretical principles supporting the metric. Next, we validate p BOLD efficacy using a small dataset (N=7 scans) of constant- and cardiac-gated scans that have distinct levels of contributing BOLD fluctuations. Third, we apply p BOLD to a larger publicly available ME dataset (N=439 scans), to evaluate six different pre-processing pipelines, and show how p BOLD provides complementary information to TSNR. Our results show that ME-based denoising increases both p BOLD and TSNR relative to basic denoising; however, including the global signal (GS) as a regressor only improves TSNR, but worsens p BOLD . Further analyses looking at the BOLD-like characteristics of the GS and its relationship to cardiac and respiratory traces suggest that the observed decrease in p BOLD is likely due to a decrease in BOLD fluctuations of neural origin contributing to the GS, and not due to contributions from other physiological BOLD fluctuations (i.e., respiratory and cardiac function). Finally, we also demonstrate how p BOLD can be applied as a data quality metric, by showing how higher p BOLD results in better ability to predict phenotypes based on whole-brain functional connectivity matrices.
- Open Access
Young children rely on visual information to process degraded speech: Evidence from behavioural and neuroimaging measures
Young children acquire language in environments where speech is often acoustically degraded, yet little is known about how developing brains adapt to reduced speech intelligibility. Using a combination of eye-tracking and functional near-infrared spectroscopy (fNIRS), we investigated young children’s attentional allocation to a speaking face at varying levels of speech intelligibility and the brain activity supporting this behaviour during development. Infants (8–10 months) and toddlers (27–30 months) viewed videos of a speaker in three conditions: producing clear speech, spectrally degraded (vocoded) speech, and silent (audio muted) speech. Visual attention to the speaker’s mouth increased when speech was degraded relative to clear speech in both age groups, indicating an early-emerging compensatory strategy. However, this shared behavioural response was supported by brain activity that differed by age. Degraded speech elicited greater recruitment of prefrontal regions associated with effortful listening, particularly in infants, whereas toddlers showed stronger engagement of posterior temporal regions implicated in audiovisual integration. In response to silent speech, there was no evidence for increased visual attention to the mouth compared to the clear speech condition, but there was reduced temporal activation and increased prefrontal brain responses, especially in infants. Together, these findings suggest that experience with audiovisual correspondences and linguistic maturity contribute to a more efficient processing of speech, particularly relevant when speech is degraded. By combining behavioural and neuroimaging measures, this study advances mechanistic accounts of audiovisual speech processing and provides insights relevant to populations experiencing spectrally degraded input, such as children using cochlear implants.
Open AccessYoung children rely on visual information to process degraded speech: Evidence from behavioural and neuroimaging measures
Young children acquire language in environments where speech is often acoustically degraded, yet little is known about how developing brains adapt to reduced speech intelligibility. Using a combination of eye-tracking and functional near-infrared spectroscopy (fNIRS), we investigated young children’s attentional allocation to a speaking face at varying levels of speech intelligibility and the brain activity supporting this behaviour during development. Infants (8–10 months) and toddlers (27–30 months) viewed videos of a speaker in three conditions: producing clear speech, spectrally degraded (vocoded) speech, and silent (audio muted) speech. Visual attention to the speaker’s mouth increased when speech was degraded relative to clear speech in both age groups, indicating an early-emerging compensatory strategy. However, this shared behavioural response was supported by brain activity that differed by age. Degraded speech elicited greater recruitment of prefrontal regions associated with effortful listening, particularly in infants, whereas toddlers showed stronger engagement of posterior temporal regions implicated in audiovisual integration. In response to silent speech, there was no evidence for increased visual attention to the mouth compared to the clear speech condition, but there was reduced temporal activation and increased prefrontal brain responses, especially in infants. Together, these findings suggest that experience with audiovisual correspondences and linguistic maturity contribute to a more efficient processing of speech, particularly relevant when speech is degraded. By combining behavioural and neuroimaging measures, this study advances mechanistic accounts of audiovisual speech processing and provides insights relevant to populations experiencing spectrally degraded input, such as children using cochlear implants.
- Open Access
- 7 July 2025
- Published by MIT Press in Imaging Neuroscience
- Vol. 3
Uncovering the Neural Correlates of the Urge-to-Blink: A Study Utilising Subjective Urge Ratings and Paradigm Free Mapping
Neuroimaging plays a significant role in understanding the neurophysiology of Tourette syndrome (TS), in particular the main symptom, tics, and the urges associated with them. Premonitory urge is thought to be a negative reinforcer of tic expression in TS. Tic expression during neuroimaging is most often required as an overt marker of increased urge-to-tic, which can lead to considerable head movement, and thus data loss. This study aims to identify the brain regions involved in urge in healthy subjects using multi-echo functional MRI and a timing-free approach to localise the BOLD response associated with the urge-to-act without information of when these events occur. Blink suppression is an analogous behaviour that can be expressed overtly in the MRI scanner which gives rise to an urge like those described by individuals with TS. We examined the urge-to-blink in 20 healthy volunteers with an experimental paradigm including two conditions, “Okay to blink” and “Suppress blinking”, to identify brain regions involved in blink suppression. Multi-echo functional MRI data was analysed using a novel approach to investigate the BOLD signal correlated with the build-up of the urge-to-blink that participants continuously reported using a rollerball device. In addition, we used the method of multi-echo paradigm free mapping (MESPFM) to identify these regions without prior specification of task timings. Subjective urge scores were correlated with activity in the right posterior and ventral-anterior insula as well as the mid-cingulate and occipital cortices. Whereas blink suppression was associated with activation in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, cerebellum, right dorsal-anterior insula, mid-cingulate cortex and thalamus. These findings illustrate that different insula subregions contribute to the urge-for-action and suppression networks. The MESPFM approach showed co-activation of the right insula and cingulate cortex. The MESPFM activation maps showed the highest overlap with activation associated with blink suppression, as identified using general linear model analysis, demonstrating that activity associated with suppression can be determined without prior knowledge of task timings.
- 7 July 2025
- Published by MIT Press in Imaging Neuroscience
- Vol. 3
Open AccessUncovering the Neural Correlates of the Urge-to-Blink: A Study Utilising Subjective Urge Ratings and Paradigm Free Mapping
Neuroimaging plays a significant role in understanding the neurophysiology of Tourette syndrome (TS), in particular the main symptom, tics, and the urges associated with them. Premonitory urge is thought to be a negative reinforcer of tic expression in TS. Tic expression during neuroimaging is most often required as an overt marker of increased urge-to-tic, which can lead to considerable head movement, and thus data loss. This study aims to identify the brain regions involved in urge in healthy subjects using multi-echo functional MRI and a timing-free approach to localise the BOLD response associated with the urge-to-act without information of when these events occur. Blink suppression is an analogous behaviour that can be expressed overtly in the MRI scanner which gives rise to an urge like those described by individuals with TS. We examined the urge-to-blink in 20 healthy volunteers with an experimental paradigm including two conditions, “Okay to blink” and “Suppress blinking”, to identify brain regions involved in blink suppression. Multi-echo functional MRI data was analysed using a novel approach to investigate the BOLD signal correlated with the build-up of the urge-to-blink that participants continuously reported using a rollerball device. In addition, we used the method of multi-echo paradigm free mapping (MESPFM) to identify these regions without prior specification of task timings. Subjective urge scores were correlated with activity in the right posterior and ventral-anterior insula as well as the mid-cingulate and occipital cortices. Whereas blink suppression was associated with activation in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, cerebellum, right dorsal-anterior insula, mid-cingulate cortex and thalamus. These findings illustrate that different insula subregions contribute to the urge-for-action and suppression networks. The MESPFM approach showed co-activation of the right insula and cingulate cortex. The MESPFM activation maps showed the highest overlap with activation associated with blink suppression, as identified using general linear model analysis, demonstrating that activity associated with suppression can be determined without prior knowledge of task timings.
- Open Access
NEUROLINGUA: A Neuroimaging Database Tailored to Unravel the Complexity of Multilingual Comprehension
The neural mechanisms underlying language processing involve a well-defined brain network, including mainly left perisylvian areas. Yet, the extent of its individual variability remains largely unexplored, particularly in bilingual and multilingual contexts. Differences in linguistic profiles (e.g., age of acquisition, exposure, proficiency) provide an opportunity to assess how network topology adapts to sociolinguistic factors. To address this, we developed NEUROLINGUA, a comprehensive database of functional and structural MRI data, enriched with sociodemographic, sociolinguistic, and behavioral information. It includes 725 healthy individuals aged 18-82 immersed in a Basque-Spanish multilingual environment, ranging from near-monolinguals to highly proficient multilinguals. Participants completed a functional MRI language localizer with both auditory and visual comprehension tasks, enabling cross-modal comparisons. Additionally, this localizer included sentences involving arithmetic problem-solving. Exploratory analyses confirmed associations between structural MRI, sociodemographic, and cognitive measures. Functional MRI validated NEUROLINGUA's capacity to localize the language comprehension network and capture linguistic profile effects. This integrative dataset offers an unparalleled resource to investigate the factors influencing language network adaptability and variability in diverse sociolinguistic contexts.
Open AccessNEUROLINGUA: A Neuroimaging Database Tailored to Unravel the Complexity of Multilingual Comprehension
The neural mechanisms underlying language processing involve a well-defined brain network, including mainly left perisylvian areas. Yet, the extent of its individual variability remains largely unexplored, particularly in bilingual and multilingual contexts. Differences in linguistic profiles (e.g., age of acquisition, exposure, proficiency) provide an opportunity to assess how network topology adapts to sociolinguistic factors. To address this, we developed NEUROLINGUA, a comprehensive database of functional and structural MRI data, enriched with sociodemographic, sociolinguistic, and behavioral information. It includes 725 healthy individuals aged 18-82 immersed in a Basque-Spanish multilingual environment, ranging from near-monolinguals to highly proficient multilinguals. Participants completed a functional MRI language localizer with both auditory and visual comprehension tasks, enabling cross-modal comparisons. Additionally, this localizer included sentences involving arithmetic problem-solving. Exploratory analyses confirmed associations between structural MRI, sociodemographic, and cognitive measures. Functional MRI validated NEUROLINGUA's capacity to localize the language comprehension network and capture linguistic profile effects. This integrative dataset offers an unparalleled resource to investigate the factors influencing language network adaptability and variability in diverse sociolinguistic contexts.
- Open Access
Disrupted salience network dynamics during the imagery of migraine attacks
Moderate to severe head pain is a hallmark of recurring migraine attacks. However, it is challenging to study patients during spontaneous attacks and most research on the brain mechanisms of pain in migraine patients has been limited to the processing of painful stimuli between attacks. Here, we hypothesize that the experience of a migraine attack extends beyond the response to painful stimuli and is associated with specific impairments of the salience network (SN), which integrates sensory, emotional and cognitive information in relation to salient stimuli. To test this hypothesis, we analysed the SN dynamics of a group of patients with episodic migraine in three distinct conditions: at rest during a spontaneous migraine attack (ictal phase); while performing an imagery task aiming to elicit the experience of a previous attack, during the interictal phase; and at rest, during the interictal phase. For comparison, we also studied a group of healthy controls in three matching conditions, including rest as well as an imagery task of a (non-migraine) head pain experience. We collected functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) data and used a dynamic functional connectivity (dFC) analysis to examine the temporal features of the SN from a total of 78 samples. Compared to healthy controls, the SN had a significantly shorter lifetime in patients during the pain imagery task, but not during a migraine attack or interictal resting state. Our results support the disruption of the SN in migraine, and indicate that pain imagery may be a useful paradigm for isolating the emotional and cognitive aspects of pain and investigating SN dynamics.
Open AccessDisrupted salience network dynamics during the imagery of migraine attacks
Moderate to severe head pain is a hallmark of recurring migraine attacks. However, it is challenging to study patients during spontaneous attacks and most research on the brain mechanisms of pain in migraine patients has been limited to the processing of painful stimuli between attacks. Here, we hypothesize that the experience of a migraine attack extends beyond the response to painful stimuli and is associated with specific impairments of the salience network (SN), which integrates sensory, emotional and cognitive information in relation to salient stimuli. To test this hypothesis, we analysed the SN dynamics of a group of patients with episodic migraine in three distinct conditions: at rest during a spontaneous migraine attack (ictal phase); while performing an imagery task aiming to elicit the experience of a previous attack, during the interictal phase; and at rest, during the interictal phase. For comparison, we also studied a group of healthy controls in three matching conditions, including rest as well as an imagery task of a (non-migraine) head pain experience. We collected functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) data and used a dynamic functional connectivity (dFC) analysis to examine the temporal features of the SN from a total of 78 samples. Compared to healthy controls, the SN had a significantly shorter lifetime in patients during the pain imagery task, but not during a migraine attack or interictal resting state. Our results support the disruption of the SN in migraine, and indicate that pain imagery may be a useful paradigm for isolating the emotional and cognitive aspects of pain and investigating SN dynamics.
- Open Access
Uncovering the Neural Correlates of the Urge-to-Blink: A Study Utilising Subjective Urge Ratings and Paradigm Free Mapping
Neuroimaging plays a significant role in understanding the neurophysiology of Tourette syndrome (TS), in particular the main symptom, tics, and the urges associated with them. Premonitory urge is thought to be a negative reinforcer of tic expression in TS. Tic expression during neuroimaging is most often required as an overt marker of increased urge-to-tic, which can lead to considerable head movement, and thus data loss. This study aims to identify the brain regions involved in urge in healthy subjects using multi-echo functional MRI and a timing- free approach to localise the BOLD response associated with the urge-to-act without information of when these events occur. Blink suppression is an analogous behaviour that can be expressed overtly in the MRI scanner which gives rise to an urge like those described by individuals with TS. We examined the urge-to-blink in 20 healthy volunteers with an experimental paradigm including two conditions, “Okay to blink” and “Suppress blinking”, to identify brain regions involved in blink suppression. Multi-echo functional MRI data was analysed using a novel approach to investigate the BOLD signal correlated with the build-up of the urge-to-blink that participants continuously reported using a rollerball device. In addition, we used the method of multi-echo paradigm free mapping (MESPFM) to identify these regions without prior specification of task timings. Subjective urge scores were correlated with activity in the right posterior and ventral-anterior insula as well as the mid-cingulate and occipital cortices. Furthermore, blink suppression was associated with activation in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, cerebellum, right dorsal-anterior insula, mid-cingulate cortex and thalamus. These findings illustrate that different insula subregions contribute to the urge-for-action and suppression networks. The MESPFM approach showed co-activation of the right insula and cingulate cortex. The MESPFM activation maps showed the highest overlap with activation associated with blink suppression, as identified using general linear model analysis, demonstrating that activity associated with suppression can be determined without prior knowledge of task timings.
Open AccessUncovering the Neural Correlates of the Urge-to-Blink: A Study Utilising Subjective Urge Ratings and Paradigm Free Mapping
Neuroimaging plays a significant role in understanding the neurophysiology of Tourette syndrome (TS), in particular the main symptom, tics, and the urges associated with them. Premonitory urge is thought to be a negative reinforcer of tic expression in TS. Tic expression during neuroimaging is most often required as an overt marker of increased urge-to-tic, which can lead to considerable head movement, and thus data loss. This study aims to identify the brain regions involved in urge in healthy subjects using multi-echo functional MRI and a timing- free approach to localise the BOLD response associated with the urge-to-act without information of when these events occur. Blink suppression is an analogous behaviour that can be expressed overtly in the MRI scanner which gives rise to an urge like those described by individuals with TS. We examined the urge-to-blink in 20 healthy volunteers with an experimental paradigm including two conditions, “Okay to blink” and “Suppress blinking”, to identify brain regions involved in blink suppression. Multi-echo functional MRI data was analysed using a novel approach to investigate the BOLD signal correlated with the build-up of the urge-to-blink that participants continuously reported using a rollerball device. In addition, we used the method of multi-echo paradigm free mapping (MESPFM) to identify these regions without prior specification of task timings. Subjective urge scores were correlated with activity in the right posterior and ventral-anterior insula as well as the mid-cingulate and occipital cortices. Furthermore, blink suppression was associated with activation in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, cerebellum, right dorsal-anterior insula, mid-cingulate cortex and thalamus. These findings illustrate that different insula subregions contribute to the urge-for-action and suppression networks. The MESPFM approach showed co-activation of the right insula and cingulate cortex. The MESPFM activation maps showed the highest overlap with activation associated with blink suppression, as identified using general linear model analysis, demonstrating that activity associated with suppression can be determined without prior knowledge of task timings.
- Open Access
Individual variability in the relationship between physiological and resting-state fMRI metrics
Cerebrovascular Reactivity (CVR), the brain’s vascular response to a vasodilatory stimulus, can be measured using fMRI during breathing challenges that modulate arterial CO 2 levels. CVR is an important indicator of cerebrovascular health, although its estimation can be challenging due to the extra experimental setup and/or the subject compliance required. To overcome these limitations, summary metrics based on resting state fluctuations (RSF), such as the (fractional) amplitude of low frequency fluctuations (f/ALFF) and the resting state fluctuation amplitude (RSFA), have been proposed as alternative estimates of CVR, as they are frequently associated with vascular and physiological factors. Previous studies have reported a significant relationship between CVR estimates obtained by means of respiratory paradigms and RSF metrics. However, the total sample sizes, considering both subjects and sessions, are typically small, and not all studies agree on the degree of the relationship. Furthermore, to our knowledge, these studies have only reported cross-sectional analyses, whereas intra-subject longitudinal relationships between CVR estimates and RSF metrics are unknown. Leveraging a unique dense sampling dataset in which resting state and breath-hold multi-echo fMRI were collected in 7 subjects with 10 sessions each, we provide evidence of high individual variability in the inter-session (i.e. intra-subject) relationship between RSF metrics and CVR. These results indicate that RSF metrics might not be a suitable proxy of CVR in clinical settings or for BOLD signal calibration as they may not properly account for intra-individual physiological variations in BOLD fMRI data.
Open AccessIndividual variability in the relationship between physiological and resting-state fMRI metrics
Cerebrovascular Reactivity (CVR), the brain’s vascular response to a vasodilatory stimulus, can be measured using fMRI during breathing challenges that modulate arterial CO 2 levels. CVR is an important indicator of cerebrovascular health, although its estimation can be challenging due to the extra experimental setup and/or the subject compliance required. To overcome these limitations, summary metrics based on resting state fluctuations (RSF), such as the (fractional) amplitude of low frequency fluctuations (f/ALFF) and the resting state fluctuation amplitude (RSFA), have been proposed as alternative estimates of CVR, as they are frequently associated with vascular and physiological factors. Previous studies have reported a significant relationship between CVR estimates obtained by means of respiratory paradigms and RSF metrics. However, the total sample sizes, considering both subjects and sessions, are typically small, and not all studies agree on the degree of the relationship. Furthermore, to our knowledge, these studies have only reported cross-sectional analyses, whereas intra-subject longitudinal relationships between CVR estimates and RSF metrics are unknown. Leveraging a unique dense sampling dataset in which resting state and breath-hold multi-echo fMRI were collected in 7 subjects with 10 sessions each, we provide evidence of high individual variability in the inter-session (i.e. intra-subject) relationship between RSF metrics and CVR. These results indicate that RSF metrics might not be a suitable proxy of CVR in clinical settings or for BOLD signal calibration as they may not properly account for intra-individual physiological variations in BOLD fMRI data.
- Open Access
Bayesian Modelling Approaches for Breath-Hold Induced Cerebrovascular Reactivity
Cerebrovascular reactivity (CVR) reflects the ability of blood vessels to dilate and constrict in response to a vasoactive stimulus and is an important indicator of cerebrovascular health. CVR can be mapped non-invasively with functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) based on blood oxygen level-dependent (BOLD) contrast in combination with a breath-hold (BH) task. There are several ways to analyse this type of data and retrieve individual CVR amplitude and timing information. The most common approach involves employing a time-shifted general linear model with the measured end-tidal carbon dioxide signal as a regressor of interest. In this work, we introduce a novel method for CVR mapping based on a variational Bayesian approach. We analysed BOLD fMRI data from six participants that performed a BH task in ten different sessions each, and computed the corresponding CVR amplitude and delay maps for each session/subject. No statistically significant differences were observed between the modelling approaches in the CVR delay and amplitude maps in grey matter. Notably, the largest difference between methods was apparent in the case of low CVR amplitude, attributed to how each method addressed noisy voxels, particularly in white matter and cerebral spinal fluid. Both approaches showed highly reproducible CVR amplitude maps where between-subject variability was significantly larger than between-session variability. Furthermore, our results illustrated that the Bayesian approach is more computationally efficient, and future implementations could incorporate more complex noise models, non-linear fitting, and physiologically meaningful information into the model in the form of priors. This work demonstrates the utility of variational Bayesian modelling for CVR mapping and highlights its potential for characterising BOLD fMRI dynamics in the study of cerebrovascular health and its application to clinical settings.
Open AccessBayesian Modelling Approaches for Breath-Hold Induced Cerebrovascular Reactivity
Cerebrovascular reactivity (CVR) reflects the ability of blood vessels to dilate and constrict in response to a vasoactive stimulus and is an important indicator of cerebrovascular health. CVR can be mapped non-invasively with functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) based on blood oxygen level-dependent (BOLD) contrast in combination with a breath-hold (BH) task. There are several ways to analyse this type of data and retrieve individual CVR amplitude and timing information. The most common approach involves employing a time-shifted general linear model with the measured end-tidal carbon dioxide signal as a regressor of interest. In this work, we introduce a novel method for CVR mapping based on a variational Bayesian approach. We analysed BOLD fMRI data from six participants that performed a BH task in ten different sessions each, and computed the corresponding CVR amplitude and delay maps for each session/subject. No statistically significant differences were observed between the modelling approaches in the CVR delay and amplitude maps in grey matter. Notably, the largest difference between methods was apparent in the case of low CVR amplitude, attributed to how each method addressed noisy voxels, particularly in white matter and cerebral spinal fluid. Both approaches showed highly reproducible CVR amplitude maps where between-subject variability was significantly larger than between-session variability. Furthermore, our results illustrated that the Bayesian approach is more computationally efficient, and future implementations could incorporate more complex noise models, non-linear fitting, and physiologically meaningful information into the model in the form of priors. This work demonstrates the utility of variational Bayesian modelling for CVR mapping and highlights its potential for characterising BOLD fMRI dynamics in the study of cerebrovascular health and its application to clinical settings.