Federico Toth
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Federico Toth has a total of 26 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Giliberto Capano
University of Bologna
9 shared publications - Anthony R. Zito
Newcastle University
8 shared publications - Jeremy Rayner
University of Saskatchewan
8 shared publications - Stefania Profeti
Department of Political and Social Sciences University of Bologna Bologna Italy
4 shared publications - Alexandra D'ANgelo
University of Padova Italy
1 shared publication - Angelo Capodici
Interdisciplinary Research Center for Health Science, Sant’Anna School of Advanced Studies , 56127 Pisa
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 26 October 2026
- Published by Wiley in Australian Journal of Public Administration
The global spread of lean management in the public sector: A systematic mapping review of practices, patterns, and regional variations
This article presents a systematic mapping review examining the global diffusion of lean management practices in the public sector. While previous systematic reviews have generally treated lean as a unitary managerial approach, this study unpacks lean management into four analytically distinct pillars: pull logic, muda elimination, kaizen, and employee empowerment. Drawing on 85 articles published between 2003 and 2023, it analyses how these pillars have been selectively adopted across different geographical regions and policy sectors. The findings reveal growing scholarly interest in lean public management across multiple countries, with healthcare emerging as the dominant application sector (60%). While muda elimination appears in 92% of the analysed articles, the remaining pillars show substantially lower levels of adoption, suggesting that lean is typically implemented through selective combinations of individual principles rather than as a comprehensive managerial philosophy. Distinct patterns of adoption also emerge across geographical regions and policy sectors. By analysing lean management through the four‐pillar framework, this article offers a more nuanced understanding of how lean public management has been interpreted in the literature and provides a framework for analysing its heterogeneous diffusion across public sector contexts. Points for practitioners: Lean management is not implemented as a single, standardised model across the public sector. Public organisations adopt different combinations of lean principles depending on their organisational priorities and policy context. Managers should therefore avoid assuming that all lean initiatives pursue the same objectives or require the same implementation strategy. The four‐pillar framework developed in this article (pull logic, waste elimination, continuous improvement, and employee empowerment) can be used as a practical diagnostic tool for planning, evaluating, or reviewing lean initiatives. Identifying which pillars are emphasised—and which receive less attention—can help practitioners better understand the strategic orientation of organisational reforms. Lean initiatives place different emphasis on efficiency, user orientation, organisational learning, and employee involvement. Recognising these different configurations can help public managers align lean practices with the specific challenges and objectives of their organisations, rather than treating lean as a fixed set of managerial tools.
- 26 October 2026
- Published by Wiley in Australian Journal of Public Administration
Open AccessThe global spread of lean management in the public sector: A systematic mapping review of practices, patterns, and regional variations
This article presents a systematic mapping review examining the global diffusion of lean management practices in the public sector. While previous systematic reviews have generally treated lean as a unitary managerial approach, this study unpacks lean management into four analytically distinct pillars: pull logic, muda elimination, kaizen, and employee empowerment. Drawing on 85 articles published between 2003 and 2023, it analyses how these pillars have been selectively adopted across different geographical regions and policy sectors. The findings reveal growing scholarly interest in lean public management across multiple countries, with healthcare emerging as the dominant application sector (60%). While muda elimination appears in 92% of the analysed articles, the remaining pillars show substantially lower levels of adoption, suggesting that lean is typically implemented through selective combinations of individual principles rather than as a comprehensive managerial philosophy. Distinct patterns of adoption also emerge across geographical regions and policy sectors. By analysing lean management through the four‐pillar framework, this article offers a more nuanced understanding of how lean public management has been interpreted in the literature and provides a framework for analysing its heterogeneous diffusion across public sector contexts. Points for practitioners: Lean management is not implemented as a single, standardised model across the public sector. Public organisations adopt different combinations of lean principles depending on their organisational priorities and policy context. Managers should therefore avoid assuming that all lean initiatives pursue the same objectives or require the same implementation strategy. The four‐pillar framework developed in this article (pull logic, waste elimination, continuous improvement, and employee empowerment) can be used as a practical diagnostic tool for planning, evaluating, or reviewing lean initiatives. Identifying which pillars are emphasised—and which receive less attention—can help practitioners better understand the strategic orientation of organisational reforms. Lean initiatives place different emphasis on efficiency, user orientation, organisational learning, and employee involvement. Recognising these different configurations can help public managers align lean practices with the specific challenges and objectives of their organisations, rather than treating lean as a fixed set of managerial tools.
- Open Access
- 15 October 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Health Economics, Policy and Law
- p. 1-19
Multiple paths to privatisation in healthcare? Comparing England and Italy beyond the public–private divide
English and Italian national health systems are predominantly funded by general taxation and treat patients primarily free at the point of delivery. Both healthcare systems are facing increasing financial pressures given population ageing, the rise in chronic and non-communicable diseases, and fiscal restraint. In recent years, pressures on public healthcare have revived debate around the role of the private sector, but discussion is mired in a lack of conceptual clarity. We seek to bring greater analytical order by distinguishing seven distinct ‘trajectories of privatisation’, each reflecting different modes and logics of interaction between public and private actors. We examine two similar health systems – England and Italy – highlight their similarities and differences regarding emerging and established trajectories. There is less evidence of ‘hard privatisation’, seen as the private share of overall spending; however, both countries are experiencing greater use of on-demand staff and financialisation. In both systems subtler privatisation dynamics (public-private partnerships, managerialism, and entrepreneurialism) are redefining and blurring the boundaries between public and private provision. Public perceptions of perceived privatisation are shaped by direct, tangible experiences of care and out-of-pocket spending. Some privatisation dynamics are mainly driven by behaviour of patients, professionals, and investors rather than by policies.
- 15 October 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Health Economics, Policy and Law
- p. 1-19
Open AccessMultiple paths to privatisation in healthcare? Comparing England and Italy beyond the public–private divide
English and Italian national health systems are predominantly funded by general taxation and treat patients primarily free at the point of delivery. Both healthcare systems are facing increasing financial pressures given population ageing, the rise in chronic and non-communicable diseases, and fiscal restraint. In recent years, pressures on public healthcare have revived debate around the role of the private sector, but discussion is mired in a lack of conceptual clarity. We seek to bring greater analytical order by distinguishing seven distinct ‘trajectories of privatisation’, each reflecting different modes and logics of interaction between public and private actors. We examine two similar health systems – England and Italy – highlight their similarities and differences regarding emerging and established trajectories. There is less evidence of ‘hard privatisation’, seen as the private share of overall spending; however, both countries are experiencing greater use of on-demand staff and financialisation. In both systems subtler privatisation dynamics (public-private partnerships, managerialism, and entrepreneurialism) are redefining and blurring the boundaries between public and private provision. Public perceptions of perceived privatisation are shaped by direct, tangible experiences of care and out-of-pocket spending. Some privatisation dynamics are mainly driven by behaviour of patients, professionals, and investors rather than by policies.
- Open Access
- 5 April 2026
- Published by Wiley in Risk, Hazards & Crisis in Public Policy
- Vol. 17 (2) , e70057
The Essence of Crisis Decision‐Making: Saving Ravenna During the 2023 Floods
This article explores decision‐making processes in crisis situations by proposing an interpretive framework grounded in multiple criteria of rationality. Crises, characterized by uncertainty, urgency, and ethical dilemmas, require critical choices that go beyond standard procedures. To investigate the dynamics that unfold in crisis decision‐making, the study examines the management of the 2023 floods in Ravenna, focusing on the controversial decision to deliberately inundate certain agricultural areas in order to protect the historic city center. Adopting a multi‐perspective thinking approach, the article develops three alternative interpretations of the same decision, showing how different forms of rationality often coexist in practice. The empirical analysis is based on semi‐structured interviews with key actors, complemented by official documents and media reports. The findings reveal the complexity and ambiguity that characterize decision‐making in crisis situations, in which multiple criteria of rationality intertwine rather than exclude one another.
- 5 April 2026
- Published by Wiley in Risk, Hazards & Crisis in Public Policy
- Vol. 17 (2) , e70057
Open AccessThe Essence of Crisis Decision‐Making: Saving Ravenna During the 2023 Floods
This article explores decision‐making processes in crisis situations by proposing an interpretive framework grounded in multiple criteria of rationality. Crises, characterized by uncertainty, urgency, and ethical dilemmas, require critical choices that go beyond standard procedures. To investigate the dynamics that unfold in crisis decision‐making, the study examines the management of the 2023 floods in Ravenna, focusing on the controversial decision to deliberately inundate certain agricultural areas in order to protect the historic city center. Adopting a multi‐perspective thinking approach, the article develops three alternative interpretations of the same decision, showing how different forms of rationality often coexist in practice. The empirical analysis is based on semi‐structured interviews with key actors, complemented by official documents and media reports. The findings reveal the complexity and ambiguity that characterize decision‐making in crisis situations, in which multiple criteria of rationality intertwine rather than exclude one another.
- Open Access
- 5 February 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in European Journal of Ageing
- Vol. 23 (1)
Policies for supporting caregivers of older adults with long-term care needs in EU countries: a systematic review
In the context of population ageing, increasing long-term care needs and constraints on welfare spending, informal caregivers assume a pivotal role as providers of long-term care. This systematic review synthesises reported data on the diverse support policies implemented across the European Union (EU) to assist them. Findings from 35 studies and reports published between 2011 and 2025 suggest that, despite similar demographic challenges, policies diverge significantly, with some EU countries to have established mechanisms beyond financial assistance to support carers, while others, particularly those located in Eastern and Southern EU, to offer less comprehensive support. While the frameworks of defamilialisation (Nordic), supported familialism (Continental), and familialism by default (Southern and Eastern Europe) provide a useful analytical lens to our findings, the review also identifies significant heterogeneities within welfare regimes and even within countries, often driven by decentralisation and regional disparities. Across all models, financial support via cash-for-care schemes and in-kind respite care are the most common instruments, though their generosity and comprehensiveness vary substantially. In contrast, policies such as training, counselling, and flexible work guarantees are less developed, with their availability and access, however, varying significantly across the EU. Furthermore, the review identifies critical gaps in the geographical coverage of existing literature, with certain Southern and Eastern EU countries being particularly understudied. The synthesised evidence provides key implications for policymaking, thoroughly mapping the implementation of diverse social care policies as reported in the international literature.
- 5 February 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in European Journal of Ageing
- Vol. 23 (1)
Open AccessPolicies for supporting caregivers of older adults with long-term care needs in EU countries: a systematic review
In the context of population ageing, increasing long-term care needs and constraints on welfare spending, informal caregivers assume a pivotal role as providers of long-term care. This systematic review synthesises reported data on the diverse support policies implemented across the European Union (EU) to assist them. Findings from 35 studies and reports published between 2011 and 2025 suggest that, despite similar demographic challenges, policies diverge significantly, with some EU countries to have established mechanisms beyond financial assistance to support carers, while others, particularly those located in Eastern and Southern EU, to offer less comprehensive support. While the frameworks of defamilialisation (Nordic), supported familialism (Continental), and familialism by default (Southern and Eastern Europe) provide a useful analytical lens to our findings, the review also identifies significant heterogeneities within welfare regimes and even within countries, often driven by decentralisation and regional disparities. Across all models, financial support via cash-for-care schemes and in-kind respite care are the most common instruments, though their generosity and comprehensiveness vary substantially. In contrast, policies such as training, counselling, and flexible work guarantees are less developed, with their availability and access, however, varying significantly across the EU. Furthermore, the review identifies critical gaps in the geographical coverage of existing literature, with certain Southern and Eastern EU countries being particularly understudied. The synthesised evidence provides key implications for policymaking, thoroughly mapping the implementation of diverse social care policies as reported in the international literature.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Policy and Society
- Vol. 45 (1) , 33-45
Not one crisis, but many. The “crisis cube” and the politics of governing crises
This article examines the relationship between different types of crises and the political strategies employed to govern them. Drawing on crisis management literature, it introduces a novel heuristic typology—the “crisis cube”—grounded in three analytical dimensions: time, space, and intentionality. Although often treated as objective characteristics, these dimensions are politically constructed and strategically interpreted by crisis leaders. Through a structured analysis of empirical cases drawn from the literature, the article explores how varying framings of similar crisis scenarios can produce distinct modes of politically governing crises. It attempts to highlight that the interaction between the intrinsic features of a crisis and their political interpretation significantly shapes crisis governance trajectories. In doing so, the article contributes to bridging the gap between analytical classifications of crises and the politics of crisis response.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Policy and Society
- Vol. 45 (1) , 33-45
Open AccessNot one crisis, but many. The “crisis cube” and the politics of governing crises
This article examines the relationship between different types of crises and the political strategies employed to govern them. Drawing on crisis management literature, it introduces a novel heuristic typology—the “crisis cube”—grounded in three analytical dimensions: time, space, and intentionality. Although often treated as objective characteristics, these dimensions are politically constructed and strategically interpreted by crisis leaders. Through a structured analysis of empirical cases drawn from the literature, the article explores how varying framings of similar crisis scenarios can produce distinct modes of politically governing crises. It attempts to highlight that the interaction between the intrinsic features of a crisis and their political interpretation significantly shapes crisis governance trajectories. In doing so, the article contributes to bridging the gap between analytical classifications of crises and the politics of crisis response.
- Open Access
- 9 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in Public Administration Review
- Vol. 86 (1) , 87-96
Hamas's October 7 Attack: Analysis of an “Antagonistic” Crisis
The aim of the article is to interpret the Hamas attack of October 7, 2023 in light of crisis management theories, seeking to draw from this event some general lessons about the nature of crises, their determinants, and how they are managed. More specifically, the article addresses three questions: (1) Why did Israel underestimate the warning signs and fail to prevent the attack? (2) What decision‐making logic did the Israeli government adopt in responding to the attack? (3) What kind of crisis is the one being analyzed? In the article, it is proposed to adopt the category of “antagonistic crises,” that is of crises that are caused by human beings, who act intentionally with the stated goal of getting the other party into trouble. The logic of appropriateness is used to interpret the response to the attack by the Netanyahu government.
- 9 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in Public Administration Review
- Vol. 86 (1) , 87-96
Open AccessHamas's October 7 Attack: Analysis of an “Antagonistic” Crisis
The aim of the article is to interpret the Hamas attack of October 7, 2023 in light of crisis management theories, seeking to draw from this event some general lessons about the nature of crises, their determinants, and how they are managed. More specifically, the article addresses three questions: (1) Why did Israel underestimate the warning signs and fail to prevent the attack? (2) What decision‐making logic did the Israeli government adopt in responding to the attack? (3) What kind of crisis is the one being analyzed? In the article, it is proposed to adopt the category of “antagonistic crises,” that is of crises that are caused by human beings, who act intentionally with the stated goal of getting the other party into trouble. The logic of appropriateness is used to interpret the response to the attack by the Netanyahu government.
- Open Access
- 17 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Policy Design and Practice
- p. 1-15
Leading targets to comply. Uncertainty issues in the design of “intrinsic motivation-driven policies”
- 17 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Policy Design and Practice
- p. 1-15
Open AccessLeading targets to comply. Uncertainty issues in the design of “intrinsic motivation-driven policies”
- Open Access
- 1 January 2025
- Published by OpenEdition in International Review of Public Policy
- Vol. 7 (1) , 124-138
Why policies succeed or fail: the importance of 'policy consonance'
This article takes stock of the literature on policy success and policy failure. The huge amount of studies on the subject does not provide a clear and agreed answer to the question: what determines the success or failure of a policy?The paper attempts to answer this question by introducing the analytical scheme of the 'policy pentagram'. The proposed framework conceives of public policies as consisting of five basic components: 1) policy goals; 2) policy instruments; 3) the organizational structure in charge of implementation; 4) the recipients of the policy; 5) policy communication.For a policy to be successful, there must be 'consonance' between its five components. Consonance does not indicate generic compatibility or the absence of contradictory elements: it indicates synergy and a high degree of complementarity between policy components, which thus end up mutually reinforcing each other. To show the practical usefulness of the policy pentagram framework, a concrete example is given: the experience of the Bologna breast milk bank.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by OpenEdition in International Review of Public Policy
- Vol. 7 (1) , 124-138
Open AccessWhy policies succeed or fail: the importance of 'policy consonance'
This article takes stock of the literature on policy success and policy failure. The huge amount of studies on the subject does not provide a clear and agreed answer to the question: what determines the success or failure of a policy?The paper attempts to answer this question by introducing the analytical scheme of the 'policy pentagram'. The proposed framework conceives of public policies as consisting of five basic components: 1) policy goals; 2) policy instruments; 3) the organizational structure in charge of implementation; 4) the recipients of the policy; 5) policy communication.For a policy to be successful, there must be 'consonance' between its five components. Consonance does not indicate generic compatibility or the absence of contradictory elements: it indicates synergy and a high degree of complementarity between policy components, which thus end up mutually reinforcing each other. To show the practical usefulness of the policy pentagram framework, a concrete example is given: the experience of the Bologna breast milk bank.
- Open Access
- 19 June 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Policy and Society
- Vol. 42 (3) , 392-405
The politics of COVID-19 experts: comparing winners and losers in Italy and the UK
This article analyzes the “politics of experts”—or the struggle between scientific advisers to gain visibility and influence—in the early months of the COVID-19 pandemic in Italy and the UK. Modifying classic studies of policy communities of interest groups and civil servants, we classify relevant policy experts in the two countries into the following categories: “core insiders,” “specialist insiders,” “peripheral insiders,” and “outsiders.” Within these categories, we distinguish between “high-profile” and “low-profile” experts, depending on media exposure. The comparison between the UK and Italian cases helps to identify how actors interpret and follow formal and informal “rules of the game.” We identify a contest between experts to influence policy with reference to two competing “rules of the game.” The first set of rules comes from government, while the second comes from science advice principles. These rules collide, such as when governments require secrecy and nonconfrontation and scientists expect transparency and independent criticism. Therefore, experts face dilemmas regarding which rules to favor: some accept the limits to their behavior to ensure insider access; others are free to criticize the policies that they struggle to influence.
- 19 June 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Policy and Society
- Vol. 42 (3) , 392-405
Open AccessThe politics of COVID-19 experts: comparing winners and losers in Italy and the UK
This article analyzes the “politics of experts”—or the struggle between scientific advisers to gain visibility and influence—in the early months of the COVID-19 pandemic in Italy and the UK. Modifying classic studies of policy communities of interest groups and civil servants, we classify relevant policy experts in the two countries into the following categories: “core insiders,” “specialist insiders,” “peripheral insiders,” and “outsiders.” Within these categories, we distinguish between “high-profile” and “low-profile” experts, depending on media exposure. The comparison between the UK and Italian cases helps to identify how actors interpret and follow formal and informal “rules of the game.” We identify a contest between experts to influence policy with reference to two competing “rules of the game.” The first set of rules comes from government, while the second comes from science advice principles. These rules collide, such as when governments require secrecy and nonconfrontation and scientists expect transparency and independent criticism. Therefore, experts face dilemmas regarding which rules to favor: some accept the limits to their behavior to ensure insider access; others are free to criticize the policies that they struggle to influence.
- Open Access
- 14 May 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Policy Sciences
- Vol. 56 (4) , 709-731
Climbing the 'ladder of intrusiveness': the Italian government's strategy to push the Covid-19 vaccination coverage further
In all Western countries, the vaccination campaign against COVID-19 encountered some resistance. To overcome vaccine inertia and hesitancy, governments have used a variety of strategies and policy instruments. These instruments can be placed on a 'ladder of intrusiveness', starting from voluntary tools based on simple information and persuasion, through material incentives and disincentives of varying nature and magnitude, to highly coercive tools, such as lockdown for the unvaccinated and the introduction of the vaccination mandate. Italy's experience during the vaccination campaign against Covid provides an ideal observational point for starting to investigate this issue: not only was Italy among the top countries with the highest percentage of people vaccinated at the beginning of 2022, but—at least compared to other European countries—it was also one of the countries that had gradually introduced the most intrusive measures to increase vaccination compliance. In the article the different steps of the ‘intrusiveness ladder’ are presented, providing examples from various countries, and then tested on the Italian Covid-19 vaccination campaign between 2021 and the first months of 2022. For each phase of the campaign, the instrument mixes adopted by the Italian government are described, as well as the contextual conditions that led to their adoption. In the final section, an assessment of the composition and evolution of the Italian vaccination strategy is provided, based on the following criteria: legitimacy, feasibility, effectiveness, internal consistency and strategic coherence. Conclusions highlight the pragmatic approach adopted by the Italian government and underline the effects—both positive and negative—of scaling up the intrusiveness ladder.
- 14 May 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Policy Sciences
- Vol. 56 (4) , 709-731
Open AccessClimbing the 'ladder of intrusiveness': the Italian government's strategy to push the Covid-19 vaccination coverage further
In all Western countries, the vaccination campaign against COVID-19 encountered some resistance. To overcome vaccine inertia and hesitancy, governments have used a variety of strategies and policy instruments. These instruments can be placed on a 'ladder of intrusiveness', starting from voluntary tools based on simple information and persuasion, through material incentives and disincentives of varying nature and magnitude, to highly coercive tools, such as lockdown for the unvaccinated and the introduction of the vaccination mandate. Italy's experience during the vaccination campaign against Covid provides an ideal observational point for starting to investigate this issue: not only was Italy among the top countries with the highest percentage of people vaccinated at the beginning of 2022, but—at least compared to other European countries—it was also one of the countries that had gradually introduced the most intrusive measures to increase vaccination compliance. In the article the different steps of the ‘intrusiveness ladder’ are presented, providing examples from various countries, and then tested on the Italian Covid-19 vaccination campaign between 2021 and the first months of 2022. For each phase of the campaign, the instrument mixes adopted by the Italian government are described, as well as the contextual conditions that led to their adoption. In the final section, an assessment of the composition and evolution of the Italian vaccination strategy is provided, based on the following criteria: legitimacy, feasibility, effectiveness, internal consistency and strategic coherence. Conclusions highlight the pragmatic approach adopted by the Italian government and underline the effects—both positive and negative—of scaling up the intrusiveness ladder.