Stefania Profeti
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Stefania Profeti has a total of 34 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Giulio Citroni
University of Calabria
5 shared publications Andrea Lippi
University of Florence
4 shared publications- Federico Toth
Department of Political and Social Sciences University of Bologna Bologna Italy
4 shared publications - Alessandro Natalini
LUMSA University of Rome Rome Italy
2 shared publications - Fabrizio Di Mascio
University of Turin Turin Italy
2 shared publications - Giliberto Capano
University of Bologna
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Policy and Society
- Vol. 45 (1) , 33-45
Not one crisis, but many. The “crisis cube” and the politics of governing crises
This article examines the relationship between different types of crises and the political strategies employed to govern them. Drawing on crisis management literature, it introduces a novel heuristic typology—the “crisis cube”—grounded in three analytical dimensions: time, space, and intentionality. Although often treated as objective characteristics, these dimensions are politically constructed and strategically interpreted by crisis leaders. Through a structured analysis of empirical cases drawn from the literature, the article explores how varying framings of similar crisis scenarios can produce distinct modes of politically governing crises. It attempts to highlight that the interaction between the intrinsic features of a crisis and their political interpretation significantly shapes crisis governance trajectories. In doing so, the article contributes to bridging the gap between analytical classifications of crises and the politics of crisis response.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Policy and Society
- Vol. 45 (1) , 33-45
Open AccessNot one crisis, but many. The “crisis cube” and the politics of governing crises
This article examines the relationship between different types of crises and the political strategies employed to govern them. Drawing on crisis management literature, it introduces a novel heuristic typology—the “crisis cube”—grounded in three analytical dimensions: time, space, and intentionality. Although often treated as objective characteristics, these dimensions are politically constructed and strategically interpreted by crisis leaders. Through a structured analysis of empirical cases drawn from the literature, the article explores how varying framings of similar crisis scenarios can produce distinct modes of politically governing crises. It attempts to highlight that the interaction between the intrinsic features of a crisis and their political interpretation significantly shapes crisis governance trajectories. In doing so, the article contributes to bridging the gap between analytical classifications of crises and the politics of crisis response.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Policy and Society
- Vol. 45 (1) , 14-32
Unpacking the multidimensional relationship between crisis and policy change: a systematic review
This article presents a systematic review of how the relationship between crisis and policy change is conceptualized, operationalized, and analyzed in public policy literature. We analyze five dimensions: crisis definitions, the causal mechanisms linking crises to change, the types and intensities of change, the political and ideological effects, and the modes of governing crises. The review reveals persistent conceptual ambiguity, limited attention to political dynamics, and a dominant focus on ideational mechanisms. Furthermore, by adopting a typology of the politics of governing crises as an analytical tool, the study also identifies recurring patterns across mechanisms, political strategies, and outputs. This theory-informed review offers a foundation for systematic, comparative research on crisis-driven policy change.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Policy and Society
- Vol. 45 (1) , 14-32
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessUnpacking the multidimensional relationship between crisis and policy change: a systematic review
This article presents a systematic review of how the relationship between crisis and policy change is conceptualized, operationalized, and analyzed in public policy literature. We analyze five dimensions: crisis definitions, the causal mechanisms linking crises to change, the types and intensities of change, the political and ideological effects, and the modes of governing crises. The review reveals persistent conceptual ambiguity, limited attention to political dynamics, and a dominant focus on ideational mechanisms. Furthermore, by adopting a typology of the politics of governing crises as an analytical tool, the study also identifies recurring patterns across mechanisms, political strategies, and outputs. This theory-informed review offers a foundation for systematic, comparative research on crisis-driven policy change.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Policy and Society
- Vol. 45 (1) , 1-13
The politics of governing crises: three types of policymaking under uncertainty, urgency, and threat
The article aims to present a conceptual framework for analyzing the politics of governing crises. This is achieved through the identification of three ideal types: “governing during the crisis,” “governing the crisis,” and “governing by the crisis.” The core of the article’s argument is that the function of political actors in determining the definition of a crisis is paramount. It is demonstrated that crises are not objective phenomena; rather, they are constructed through processes of interpretation, framing, and strategic narration. The different politics of governing crises reflect different actors’ assumptions about threat, urgency, and uncertainty, and lead to different policy trajectories and types of change. These paths range from reversion (a return to a previous state, thus no change) to normalization (marginal change, adaptation—i.e., intermediate changes) and acceleration (major transformation). These governing logics reveal how crises are used to justify political inaction, technocratic management, or sweeping reform. The article’s integration of insights from public policy and crisis management is a significant contribution to ongoing debates on crisis meaning-making, legitimacy, and institutional change. It also introduces the special issue with an analytical lens that offers a comprehensive understanding of how crises reshape policy and politics.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Policy and Society
- Vol. 45 (1) , 1-13
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessThe politics of governing crises: three types of policymaking under uncertainty, urgency, and threat
The article aims to present a conceptual framework for analyzing the politics of governing crises. This is achieved through the identification of three ideal types: “governing during the crisis,” “governing the crisis,” and “governing by the crisis.” The core of the article’s argument is that the function of political actors in determining the definition of a crisis is paramount. It is demonstrated that crises are not objective phenomena; rather, they are constructed through processes of interpretation, framing, and strategic narration. The different politics of governing crises reflect different actors’ assumptions about threat, urgency, and uncertainty, and lead to different policy trajectories and types of change. These paths range from reversion (a return to a previous state, thus no change) to normalization (marginal change, adaptation—i.e., intermediate changes) and acceleration (major transformation). These governing logics reveal how crises are used to justify political inaction, technocratic management, or sweeping reform. The article’s integration of insights from public policy and crisis management is a significant contribution to ongoing debates on crisis meaning-making, legitimacy, and institutional change. It also introduces the special issue with an analytical lens that offers a comprehensive understanding of how crises reshape policy and politics.
- Open Access
- 17 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Policy Design and Practice
- p. 1-15
Leading targets to comply. Uncertainty issues in the design of “intrinsic motivation-driven policies”
- 17 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Policy Design and Practice
- p. 1-15
Open AccessLeading targets to comply. Uncertainty issues in the design of “intrinsic motivation-driven policies”
- Open Access
- 10 January 2025
- Published by Wiley in Policy Studies Journal
- Vol. 53 (4) , 994-1013
How to talk about crises? Leaders' narrative strategies during the COVID ‐19 vaccination campaign in Italy and France
Defined by threat, urgency, and uncertainty, crises produce opportunities for government leaders to exploit and create meaning around their policy decisions in such unstable circumstances. In narrating their preferred policy solutions, one of the tools governments can use is relying on evidence‐based information. However, some studies have also stressed the importance of recovering emotional inputs when directing the public toward policy compliance. Based upon this premise, we first propose an original typology intersecting evidence/emotions with loss/gain‐framed narrative dimensions, enriching the analytical tools available to the Narrative Policy Framework (NPF), especially when it is applied to studying and interpreting the formulation of policy narratives in times of crisis. We then propose a set of expectations that are empirically tested against the narrative strategies concerning the vaccination campaign during the COVID‐19 crisis in two European countries, Italy and France. By taking into account the official public statements of the executive leaders and health ministers, they have been analyzed through the Discourse Network Analyzer (DNA) software, incorporating our typology into the NPF coding scheme. The analysis shows that tracing leaders' policy narratives back to the evidence/emotion and gain/loss dimensions allows more nuanced differences to emerge that are not immediately observable by resorting to the NPF standard categories. Indeed, although the stories of vaccination against COVID‐19 told in the two countries are broadly similar in terms of the characters and the moral of the story, and emotion‐based narrative strategies prevail in both contexts, we observe a greater overall use of admonitions and scaring tactics in France than in Italy. Moreover, when looking at the evolution of strategies over time, the stability of gain‐framed narratives in the Italian case seems less consistent with the progressively more intrusive nature of the policy solutions adopted by the government.
- 10 January 2025
- Published by Wiley in Policy Studies Journal
- Vol. 53 (4) , 994-1013
Open AccessHow to talk about crises? Leaders' narrative strategies during the COVID ‐19 vaccination campaign in Italy and France
Defined by threat, urgency, and uncertainty, crises produce opportunities for government leaders to exploit and create meaning around their policy decisions in such unstable circumstances. In narrating their preferred policy solutions, one of the tools governments can use is relying on evidence‐based information. However, some studies have also stressed the importance of recovering emotional inputs when directing the public toward policy compliance. Based upon this premise, we first propose an original typology intersecting evidence/emotions with loss/gain‐framed narrative dimensions, enriching the analytical tools available to the Narrative Policy Framework (NPF), especially when it is applied to studying and interpreting the formulation of policy narratives in times of crisis. We then propose a set of expectations that are empirically tested against the narrative strategies concerning the vaccination campaign during the COVID‐19 crisis in two European countries, Italy and France. By taking into account the official public statements of the executive leaders and health ministers, they have been analyzed through the Discourse Network Analyzer (DNA) software, incorporating our typology into the NPF coding scheme. The analysis shows that tracing leaders' policy narratives back to the evidence/emotion and gain/loss dimensions allows more nuanced differences to emerge that are not immediately observable by resorting to the NPF standard categories. Indeed, although the stories of vaccination against COVID‐19 told in the two countries are broadly similar in terms of the characters and the moral of the story, and emotion‐based narrative strategies prevail in both contexts, we observe a greater overall use of admonitions and scaring tactics in France than in Italy. Moreover, when looking at the evolution of strategies over time, the stability of gain‐framed narratives in the Italian case seems less consistent with the progressively more intrusive nature of the policy solutions adopted by the government.
- Open Access
- 2 January 2024
- Published by Wiley in Review of Policy Research
- Vol. 42 (2) , 212-233
Upstream and downstream implementation arrangements in two‐level games. A focus on administrative simplification in the Italian National Recovery and Resilience Plan
The onset of the European NGEU program represented for European member states a formidable opportunity for post‐pandemic recovery and yet a significant challenge at the same time: to receive and retain EU funds, each state had to promptly draw up a National Recovery and Resilience Plan—NRRP) and commit to a pressing timetable for its implementation. Regarding this challenge, the Italian government's response is a case in point: first, Italy is by far the largest beneficiary of NGEU funds; second, it has long had a reputation for being laggard in both the implementation of European directives and the spending of cohesion policy structural funds; and the formulation of the NRRP, the design of the governance in charge of its implementation, and implementation itself, occurred at a particular moment in the country's political life. Based on these premises, the article examines the upstream process by which the Italian government designed the implementation arrangements for the adoption of simplification policies under the NRRP and their downstream recalibration in the first two years, taking the implementation arrangements as the dependent variable. Analytically, the focus is on the interplay between the pressures of EU timetables and internal political dynamics, be they the legacy or strategic political considerations on the part of national policymakers, in determining the design and eventual re‐design of implementation arrangements as the plan unfolds.
- 2 January 2024
- Published by Wiley in Review of Policy Research
- Vol. 42 (2) , 212-233
Open AccessUpstream and downstream implementation arrangements in two‐level games. A focus on administrative simplification in the Italian National Recovery and Resilience Plan
The onset of the European NGEU program represented for European member states a formidable opportunity for post‐pandemic recovery and yet a significant challenge at the same time: to receive and retain EU funds, each state had to promptly draw up a National Recovery and Resilience Plan—NRRP) and commit to a pressing timetable for its implementation. Regarding this challenge, the Italian government's response is a case in point: first, Italy is by far the largest beneficiary of NGEU funds; second, it has long had a reputation for being laggard in both the implementation of European directives and the spending of cohesion policy structural funds; and the formulation of the NRRP, the design of the governance in charge of its implementation, and implementation itself, occurred at a particular moment in the country's political life. Based on these premises, the article examines the upstream process by which the Italian government designed the implementation arrangements for the adoption of simplification policies under the NRRP and their downstream recalibration in the first two years, taking the implementation arrangements as the dependent variable. Analytically, the focus is on the interplay between the pressures of EU timetables and internal political dynamics, be they the legacy or strategic political considerations on the part of national policymakers, in determining the design and eventual re‐design of implementation arrangements as the plan unfolds.
- 5 September 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Economic Policy Reform
- Vol. 27 (2) , 162-184
Not a black or white issue: choosing alternative organizational models for delivering early childhood services
- 5 September 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Economic Policy Reform
- Vol. 27 (2) , 162-184
Not a black or white issue: choosing alternative organizational models for delivering early childhood services
- Open Access
- 14 May 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Policy Sciences
- Vol. 56 (4) , 709-731
Climbing the 'ladder of intrusiveness': the Italian government's strategy to push the Covid-19 vaccination coverage further
In all Western countries, the vaccination campaign against COVID-19 encountered some resistance. To overcome vaccine inertia and hesitancy, governments have used a variety of strategies and policy instruments. These instruments can be placed on a 'ladder of intrusiveness', starting from voluntary tools based on simple information and persuasion, through material incentives and disincentives of varying nature and magnitude, to highly coercive tools, such as lockdown for the unvaccinated and the introduction of the vaccination mandate. Italy's experience during the vaccination campaign against Covid provides an ideal observational point for starting to investigate this issue: not only was Italy among the top countries with the highest percentage of people vaccinated at the beginning of 2022, but—at least compared to other European countries—it was also one of the countries that had gradually introduced the most intrusive measures to increase vaccination compliance. In the article the different steps of the ‘intrusiveness ladder’ are presented, providing examples from various countries, and then tested on the Italian Covid-19 vaccination campaign between 2021 and the first months of 2022. For each phase of the campaign, the instrument mixes adopted by the Italian government are described, as well as the contextual conditions that led to their adoption. In the final section, an assessment of the composition and evolution of the Italian vaccination strategy is provided, based on the following criteria: legitimacy, feasibility, effectiveness, internal consistency and strategic coherence. Conclusions highlight the pragmatic approach adopted by the Italian government and underline the effects—both positive and negative—of scaling up the intrusiveness ladder.
- 14 May 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Policy Sciences
- Vol. 56 (4) , 709-731
Open AccessClimbing the 'ladder of intrusiveness': the Italian government's strategy to push the Covid-19 vaccination coverage further
In all Western countries, the vaccination campaign against COVID-19 encountered some resistance. To overcome vaccine inertia and hesitancy, governments have used a variety of strategies and policy instruments. These instruments can be placed on a 'ladder of intrusiveness', starting from voluntary tools based on simple information and persuasion, through material incentives and disincentives of varying nature and magnitude, to highly coercive tools, such as lockdown for the unvaccinated and the introduction of the vaccination mandate. Italy's experience during the vaccination campaign against Covid provides an ideal observational point for starting to investigate this issue: not only was Italy among the top countries with the highest percentage of people vaccinated at the beginning of 2022, but—at least compared to other European countries—it was also one of the countries that had gradually introduced the most intrusive measures to increase vaccination compliance. In the article the different steps of the ‘intrusiveness ladder’ are presented, providing examples from various countries, and then tested on the Italian Covid-19 vaccination campaign between 2021 and the first months of 2022. For each phase of the campaign, the instrument mixes adopted by the Italian government are described, as well as the contextual conditions that led to their adoption. In the final section, an assessment of the composition and evolution of the Italian vaccination strategy is provided, based on the following criteria: legitimacy, feasibility, effectiveness, internal consistency and strategic coherence. Conclusions highlight the pragmatic approach adopted by the Italian government and underline the effects—both positive and negative—of scaling up the intrusiveness ladder.
- Open Access
COVID-19 Vaccine Refusal and Delay among Adults in Italy: Evidence from the OBVIOUS Project, a National Survey in Italy
Background: Vaccine hesitancy was defined by the World Health Organization (WHO) in 2019 as a major threat to global health. In Italy, reluctance to receive vaccines is a widespread phenomenon that was amplified during the COVID-19 pandemic by fear and mistrust in government. This study aims to depict different profiles and characteristics of people reluctant to vaccinate, focusing on the drivers of those who are in favor of and those who are opposed to receiving the COVID-19 vaccine. Methods: A sample of 10,000 Italian residents was collected. A survey on COVID-19 vaccination behavior and possible determinants of vaccine uptake, delay, and refusal was administered to participants through a computer-assisted web interviewing method. Results: In our sample, 83.2% stated that they were vaccinated as soon as possible (“vaccinators”), 8.0% delayed vaccination (“delayers”), and 6.7% refused to be vaccinated (“no-vaccinators”). In general, the results show that being female, aged between 25 and 64, with an education level less than a high school diploma or above a master’s degree, and coming from a rural area were characteristics significantly associated with delaying or refusing COVID-19 vaccination. In addition, it was found that having minimal trust in science and/or government (i.e., 1 or 2 points on a scale from 1 to 10), using alternative medicine as the main source of treatment, and intention to vote for certain parties were characteristics associated with profiles of “delayers” or “no-vaccinators”. Finally, the main reported motivation for delaying or not accepting vaccination was fear of vaccine side effects (55.0% among delayers, 55.6% among no-vaccinators). Conclusion: In this study, three main profiles of those who chose to be vaccinated are described. Since those who are in favor of vaccines and those who are not usually cluster in similar sociodemographic categories, we argue that findings from this study might be useful to policy makers when shaping vaccine strategies and choosing policy instruments.
Open AccessCOVID-19 Vaccine Refusal and Delay among Adults in Italy: Evidence from the OBVIOUS Project, a National Survey in Italy
Background: Vaccine hesitancy was defined by the World Health Organization (WHO) in 2019 as a major threat to global health. In Italy, reluctance to receive vaccines is a widespread phenomenon that was amplified during the COVID-19 pandemic by fear and mistrust in government. This study aims to depict different profiles and characteristics of people reluctant to vaccinate, focusing on the drivers of those who are in favor of and those who are opposed to receiving the COVID-19 vaccine. Methods: A sample of 10,000 Italian residents was collected. A survey on COVID-19 vaccination behavior and possible determinants of vaccine uptake, delay, and refusal was administered to participants through a computer-assisted web interviewing method. Results: In our sample, 83.2% stated that they were vaccinated as soon as possible (“vaccinators”), 8.0% delayed vaccination (“delayers”), and 6.7% refused to be vaccinated (“no-vaccinators”). In general, the results show that being female, aged between 25 and 64, with an education level less than a high school diploma or above a master’s degree, and coming from a rural area were characteristics significantly associated with delaying or refusing COVID-19 vaccination. In addition, it was found that having minimal trust in science and/or government (i.e., 1 or 2 points on a scale from 1 to 10), using alternative medicine as the main source of treatment, and intention to vote for certain parties were characteristics associated with profiles of “delayers” or “no-vaccinators”. Finally, the main reported motivation for delaying or not accepting vaccination was fear of vaccine side effects (55.0% among delayers, 55.6% among no-vaccinators). Conclusion: In this study, three main profiles of those who chose to be vaccinated are described. Since those who are in favor of vaccines and those who are not usually cluster in similar sociodemographic categories, we argue that findings from this study might be useful to policy makers when shaping vaccine strategies and choosing policy instruments.
- 30 September 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Contemporary Italian Politics
- Vol. 14 (4) , 402-408
The Draghi Government put to the Test by the National Recovery and Resilience Plan
The political and institutional trajectory of Italy was clearly punctuated by the economic upheavals of the pandemic. The articles in the special issue aim to assess the character of the institutional change prompted by the economic response to the pandemic, and in particular by the National Recovery and Resilience Plan (NRRP), in different policy areas. Three contributions analyse the reform dynamics related to the strategic axis of the Italian NRRP, namely digitalization and innovation (Barbieri and Ottone), the ecological transition (Domorenok and Cotta), and social inclusion as concerns labour-market policies (Tassinari). Two contributions focus on two overarching priorities of the NRRP: gender equality (Donà) and development of southern Italy (Cersosimo and Raniolo). Finally, one contribution focuses on reform of the public administration, which has been identified as a key area, affecting horizontally all missions in the NRRP (Di Mascio, Natalini and Profeti). Overall, the articles in the special issue highlight that the pandemic has been followed by a process of institutional change that occurred both incrementally and unevenly, often disguising substantial continuity.
- 30 September 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Contemporary Italian Politics
- Vol. 14 (4) , 402-408
The Draghi Government put to the Test by the National Recovery and Resilience Plan
The political and institutional trajectory of Italy was clearly punctuated by the economic upheavals of the pandemic. The articles in the special issue aim to assess the character of the institutional change prompted by the economic response to the pandemic, and in particular by the National Recovery and Resilience Plan (NRRP), in different policy areas. Three contributions analyse the reform dynamics related to the strategic axis of the Italian NRRP, namely digitalization and innovation (Barbieri and Ottone), the ecological transition (Domorenok and Cotta), and social inclusion as concerns labour-market policies (Tassinari). Two contributions focus on two overarching priorities of the NRRP: gender equality (Donà) and development of southern Italy (Cersosimo and Raniolo). Finally, one contribution focuses on reform of the public administration, which has been identified as a key area, affecting horizontally all missions in the NRRP (Di Mascio, Natalini and Profeti). Overall, the articles in the special issue highlight that the pandemic has been followed by a process of institutional change that occurred both incrementally and unevenly, often disguising substantial continuity.