Brecht Heyde
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Brecht Heyde has a total of 68 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jan D'Hooge
Department of Cardiovascular sciences, KU Leuven, Leuven, Belgium
17 shared publications - Piet Claus
Department of Cardiovascular Sciences KU Leuven Leuven Belgium
7 shared publications - Daniel Barbosa
Lab on Cardiovascular Imaging & Dynamics, Department of Cardiovascular Sciences, KU Leuven, Belgium
5 shared publications - Daniel Barbosa
Life and Health Sciences Research Institute (ICVS), Universidade do Minho, Braga, Portugal
5 shared publications - Bidisha Chakraborty
Cardiovascular Imaging and Dynamics, KU Leuven, Leuven, Belgium
3 shared publications - Martino Alessandrini
University of Bologna
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 2 April 2018
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics, and Frequency Control
- Vol. 65 (6) , 1037-1047
2-D Myocardial Deformation Imaging Based on RF-Based Nonrigid Image Registration
Myocardial deformation imaging is a well-established echocardiographic technique for the assessment of myocardial function. Although some solutions make use of speckle tracking of the reconstructed B-mode images, others apply block matching (BM) on the underlying radio frequency (RF) data in order to increase sensitivity to small interframe motion and deformation. However, for both approaches, lateral motion estimation remains a challenge due to the relatively poor lateral resolution of the ultrasound image in combination with the lack of phase information in this direction. Hereto, nonrigid image registration (NRIR) of B-mode images has previously been proposed as an attractive solution. However, hereby, the advantages of RF-based tracking were lost. The aim of this paper was, therefore, to develop an NRIR motion estimator adapted to RF data sets. The accuracy of this estimator was quantified using synthetic data and was contrasted against a state-of-the-art BM solution. The results show that RF-based NRIR outperforms BM in terms of tracking accuracy, particularly, as hypothesized, in the lateral direction. Finally, this RF-based NRIR algorithm was applied clinically, illustrating its ability to estimate both in-plane velocity components in vivo.
- 2 April 2018
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics, and Frequency Control
- Vol. 65 (6) , 1037-1047
2-D Myocardial Deformation Imaging Based on RF-Based Nonrigid Image Registration
Myocardial deformation imaging is a well-established echocardiographic technique for the assessment of myocardial function. Although some solutions make use of speckle tracking of the reconstructed B-mode images, others apply block matching (BM) on the underlying radio frequency (RF) data in order to increase sensitivity to small interframe motion and deformation. However, for both approaches, lateral motion estimation remains a challenge due to the relatively poor lateral resolution of the ultrasound image in combination with the lack of phase information in this direction. Hereto, nonrigid image registration (NRIR) of B-mode images has previously been proposed as an attractive solution. However, hereby, the advantages of RF-based tracking were lost. The aim of this paper was, therefore, to develop an NRIR motion estimator adapted to RF data sets. The accuracy of this estimator was quantified using synthetic data and was contrasted against a state-of-the-art BM solution. The results show that RF-based NRIR outperforms BM in terms of tracking accuracy, particularly, as hypothesized, in the lateral direction. Finally, this RF-based NRIR algorithm was applied clinically, illustrating its ability to estimate both in-plane velocity components in vivo.
- 22 December 2017
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics, and Frequency Control
- Vol. 65 (3) , 411-422
Realistic Vendor-Specific Synthetic Ultrasound Data for Quality Assurance of 2-D Speckle Tracking Echocardiography: Simulation Pipeline and Open Access Database
Two dimensional (2D) echocardiography is the modality of choice in the clinic for the diagnosis of cardiac disease. Hereto, speckle tracking (ST) packages complement visual assessment by the cardiologist by providing quantitative diagnostic markers of global and regional cardiac function (e.g. displacement, strain, strain-rate). Yet, the reported high vendordependency between the outputs of different ST packages raises clinical concern and hampers the widespread dissemination of the ST technology. In part, this is due to the lack of a solid commonly accepted quality assurance pipeline for ST packages. Recently, we have developed a framework to benchmark ST algorithms for three dimensional (3D) echocardiography by using realistic simulated volumetric echocardiographic recordings. Yet, 3D echocardiography remains an emerging technology while the compelling clinical concern is, so far, directed to the standardization of 2D ST only. By building upon our previous work, we present therefore in this paper a pipeline to generate realistic synthetic sequences for 2D ST algorithms. Hereto, the synthetic cardiac motion is obtained from a complex electro-mechanical heart model while realistic vendor-specific texture is obtained by sampling a real clinical ultrasound recording. By modifying the parameters in our pipeline, we generated an open access library of 105 synthetic sequences encompassing i) healthy and ischemic motion patterns, ii) most common apical probe orientations iii) vendor specific image quality from 7 different systems. Ground truth deformation is also provided to allow performance analysis. The application of the provided data-set is also demonstrated in the bench-marking of a recent academic ST algorithm.
- 22 December 2017
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics, and Frequency Control
- Vol. 65 (3) , 411-422
Realistic Vendor-Specific Synthetic Ultrasound Data for Quality Assurance of 2-D Speckle Tracking Echocardiography: Simulation Pipeline and Open Access Database
Two dimensional (2D) echocardiography is the modality of choice in the clinic for the diagnosis of cardiac disease. Hereto, speckle tracking (ST) packages complement visual assessment by the cardiologist by providing quantitative diagnostic markers of global and regional cardiac function (e.g. displacement, strain, strain-rate). Yet, the reported high vendordependency between the outputs of different ST packages raises clinical concern and hampers the widespread dissemination of the ST technology. In part, this is due to the lack of a solid commonly accepted quality assurance pipeline for ST packages. Recently, we have developed a framework to benchmark ST algorithms for three dimensional (3D) echocardiography by using realistic simulated volumetric echocardiographic recordings. Yet, 3D echocardiography remains an emerging technology while the compelling clinical concern is, so far, directed to the standardization of 2D ST only. By building upon our previous work, we present therefore in this paper a pipeline to generate realistic synthetic sequences for 2D ST algorithms. Hereto, the synthetic cardiac motion is obtained from a complex electro-mechanical heart model while realistic vendor-specific texture is obtained by sampling a real clinical ultrasound recording. By modifying the parameters in our pipeline, we generated an open access library of 105 synthetic sequences encompassing i) healthy and ischemic motion patterns, ii) most common apical probe orientations iii) vendor specific image quality from 7 different systems. Ground truth deformation is also provided to allow performance analysis. The application of the provided data-set is also demonstrated in the bench-marking of a recent academic ST algorithm.
- 1 September 2017
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- p. 1-4
A novel drift compensation algorithm for improved beat-to-beat repeatability of myocardial strain imaging: Preliminary in vivo results
Myocardial strain imaging has been shown to add significant prognostic and diagnostic value to echocardiography. While the reliability of ultrasound-based strain measurement techniques has improved considerably in terms of regional consistency and inter-reader, inter-vendor agreement; most state-of-the-art strain imaging packages constrain their analyses to individual cardiac cycles. This limitation is largely attributed to drift in displacement estimation over multiple consecutive cardiac cycles which results in unstable strain measurements. We present here a novel displacement-based drift compensation technique to correct for beat-to-beat drift and yield repeatable measures of regional myocardial strain over consecutive heart beats. A preliminary performance evaluation of this method in vivo demonstrated substantial improvements in maintaining temporal stability of displacement tracking across multiple heart beats and consistent measurements of end-systolic strain for prolonged acquisitions.
- 1 September 2017
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- p. 1-4
A novel drift compensation algorithm for improved beat-to-beat repeatability of myocardial strain imaging: Preliminary in vivo results
Myocardial strain imaging has been shown to add significant prognostic and diagnostic value to echocardiography. While the reliability of ultrasound-based strain measurement techniques has improved considerably in terms of regional consistency and inter-reader, inter-vendor agreement; most state-of-the-art strain imaging packages constrain their analyses to individual cardiac cycles. This limitation is largely attributed to drift in displacement estimation over multiple consecutive cardiac cycles which results in unstable strain measurements. We present here a novel displacement-based drift compensation technique to correct for beat-to-beat drift and yield repeatable measures of regional myocardial strain over consecutive heart beats. A preliminary performance evaluation of this method in vivo demonstrated substantial improvements in maintaining temporal stability of displacement tracking across multiple heart beats and consistent measurements of end-systolic strain for prolonged acquisitions.
- 1 September 2017
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- p. 1
Notice of Removal: RF-NRIR for motion estimation in fast cardiac anatomical imaging
Removed.
- 1 September 2017
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- p. 1
Notice of Removal: RF-NRIR for motion estimation in fast cardiac anatomical imaging
Removed.
- Open Access
- 24 July 2017
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 7 (7) , 752
Automatic Definition of an Anatomic Field of View for Volumetric Cardiac Motion Estimation at High Temporal Resolution
Fast volumetric cardiac imaging requires reducing the number of transmit events within a single volume. One way of achieving this is by limiting the field of view (FOV) of the recording to the myocardium when investigating cardiac mechanics. Although fully automatic solutions towards myocardial segmentation exist, translating that information in a fast ultrasound scan sequence is not trivial. In particular, multi-line transmit (MLT) scan sequences were investigated given their proven capability to increase frame rate (FR) while preserving image quality. The aim of this study was therefore to develop a methodology to automatically identify the anatomically relevant conically shaped FOV, and to translate this to the best associated MLT sequence. This approach was tested on 27 datasets leading to a conical scan with a mean opening angle of 19.7° ± 8.5°, while the mean “thickness” of the cone was 19° ± 3.4°, resulting in a frame rate gain of about 2. Then, to subsequently scan this conical volume, several MLT setups were tested in silico. The method of choice was a 10MLT sequence as it resulted in the highest frame rate gain while maintaining an acceptable cross-talk level. When combining this MLT scan sequence with at least four parallel receive beams, a total frame rate gain with a factor of approximately 80 could be obtained. As such, anatomical scan sequences can increase frame rate significantly while maintaining information of the relevant structures for functional myocardial imaging.
- 24 July 2017
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 7 (7) , 752
Open AccessAutomatic Definition of an Anatomic Field of View for Volumetric Cardiac Motion Estimation at High Temporal Resolution
Fast volumetric cardiac imaging requires reducing the number of transmit events within a single volume. One way of achieving this is by limiting the field of view (FOV) of the recording to the myocardium when investigating cardiac mechanics. Although fully automatic solutions towards myocardial segmentation exist, translating that information in a fast ultrasound scan sequence is not trivial. In particular, multi-line transmit (MLT) scan sequences were investigated given their proven capability to increase frame rate (FR) while preserving image quality. The aim of this study was therefore to develop a methodology to automatically identify the anatomically relevant conically shaped FOV, and to translate this to the best associated MLT sequence. This approach was tested on 27 datasets leading to a conical scan with a mean opening angle of 19.7° ± 8.5°, while the mean “thickness” of the cone was 19° ± 3.4°, resulting in a frame rate gain of about 2. Then, to subsequently scan this conical volume, several MLT setups were tested in silico. The method of choice was a 10MLT sequence as it resulted in the highest frame rate gain while maintaining an acceptable cross-talk level. When combining this MLT scan sequence with at least four parallel receive beams, a total frame rate gain with a factor of approximately 80 could be obtained. As such, anatomical scan sequences can increase frame rate significantly while maintaining information of the relevant structures for functional myocardial imaging.
- 12 December 2016
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics, and Frequency Control
- Vol. 64 (3) , 525-536
Left Ventricular Myocardial Segmentation in 3-D Ultrasound Recordings: Effect of Different Endocardial and Epicardial Coupling Strategies
Cardiac volume/function assessment remains a critical step in daily cardiology, and 3-D ultrasound plays an increasingly important role. Though development of automatic endocardial segmentation methods has received much attention, the same cannot be said about epicardial segmentation, in spite of the importance of full myocardial segmentation. In this paper, different ways of coupling the endocardial and epicardial segmentations are contrasted and compared with uncoupled segmentation. For this purpose, the B-spline explicit active surfaces framework was used; 27 3-D echocardiographic images were used to validate the different coupling strategies, which were compared with manual contouring of the endocardial and epicardial borders performed by an expert. It is shown that an independent segmentation of the endocardium followed by an epicardial segmentation coupled to the endocardium is the most advantageous. In this way, a framework for fully automatic 3-D myocardial segmentation is proposed using a novel coupling strategy.
- 12 December 2016
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics, and Frequency Control
- Vol. 64 (3) , 525-536
Left Ventricular Myocardial Segmentation in 3-D Ultrasound Recordings: Effect of Different Endocardial and Epicardial Coupling Strategies
Cardiac volume/function assessment remains a critical step in daily cardiology, and 3-D ultrasound plays an increasingly important role. Though development of automatic endocardial segmentation methods has received much attention, the same cannot be said about epicardial segmentation, in spite of the importance of full myocardial segmentation. In this paper, different ways of coupling the endocardial and epicardial segmentations are contrasted and compared with uncoupled segmentation. For this purpose, the B-spline explicit active surfaces framework was used; 27 3-D echocardiographic images were used to validate the different coupling strategies, which were compared with manual contouring of the endocardial and epicardial borders performed by an expert. It is shown that an independent segmentation of the endocardium followed by an epicardial segmentation coupled to the endocardium is the most advantageous. In this way, a framework for fully automatic 3-D myocardial segmentation is proposed using a novel coupling strategy.
- 28 October 2016
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics, and Frequency Control
- Vol. 64 (2) , 320-334
Evaluation of the Transverse Oscillation Technique for Cardiac Phased Array Imaging: A Theoretical Study
The transverse oscillation (TO) technique can improve the estimation of tissue motion perpendicular to the ultrasound beam direction. TOs can be introduced using plane wave (PW) insonification and bilobed Gaussian apodization (BA) on receive (abbreviated as PWTO). Furthermore, the TO frequency of PWTO can be doubled after a heterodyning demodulation process is performed (abbreviated as PWTO*). This paper is concerned with identifying the limitations of the PWTO technique in the specific context of myocardial deformation imaging with phased arrays and investigating the conditions in which it remains advantageous over traditional focused (FOC) beamforming. For this purpose, several tissue phantoms were simulated using Field II, undergoing a wide range of displacement magnitudes and modes (lateral, axial, and rotational motions). The Cramer-Rao lower bound was used to optimize TO beamforming parameters and theoretically predict the fundamental tracking performance limits associated with the FOC, PWTO, and PWTO* beamforming scenarios. This framework was extended to also predict the performance for BA functions that are windowed by the physical aperture of the transducer, leading to higher lateral oscillations. It was found that windowed BA functions resulted in lower jitter errors compared with traditional BA functions. PWTO* outperformed FOC at all investigated signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) levels but only up to a certain displacement, with the advantage rapidly decreasing when the SNR increased. These results suggest that PWTO* improves lateral tracking performance, but only when interframe displacements remain relatively low. This paper concludes by translating these findings into a clinical environment by suggesting optimal scanner settings.
- 28 October 2016
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics, and Frequency Control
- Vol. 64 (2) , 320-334
Evaluation of the Transverse Oscillation Technique for Cardiac Phased Array Imaging: A Theoretical Study
The transverse oscillation (TO) technique can improve the estimation of tissue motion perpendicular to the ultrasound beam direction. TOs can be introduced using plane wave (PW) insonification and bilobed Gaussian apodization (BA) on receive (abbreviated as PWTO). Furthermore, the TO frequency of PWTO can be doubled after a heterodyning demodulation process is performed (abbreviated as PWTO*). This paper is concerned with identifying the limitations of the PWTO technique in the specific context of myocardial deformation imaging with phased arrays and investigating the conditions in which it remains advantageous over traditional focused (FOC) beamforming. For this purpose, several tissue phantoms were simulated using Field II, undergoing a wide range of displacement magnitudes and modes (lateral, axial, and rotational motions). The Cramer-Rao lower bound was used to optimize TO beamforming parameters and theoretically predict the fundamental tracking performance limits associated with the FOC, PWTO, and PWTO* beamforming scenarios. This framework was extended to also predict the performance for BA functions that are windowed by the physical aperture of the transducer, leading to higher lateral oscillations. It was found that windowed BA functions resulted in lower jitter errors compared with traditional BA functions. PWTO* outperformed FOC at all investigated signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) levels but only up to a certain displacement, with the advantage rapidly decreasing when the SNR increased. These results suggest that PWTO* improves lateral tracking performance, but only when interframe displacements remain relatively low. This paper concludes by translating these findings into a clinical environment by suggesting optimal scanner settings.
- 29 September 2016
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics, and Frequency Control
- Vol. 63 (12) , 2082-2091
A Comparison of the Performance of Different Multiline Transmit Setups for Fast Volumetric Cardiac Ultrasound
It was previously demonstrated in 2-D echocardiography that a proper multiline transmit (MLT) implementation can be used to increase frame rate while preserving image quality. Initial findings for extending MLT to 3-D showed that it might address the low spatiotemporal resolution of current volumetric ultrasound systems. However, to date, it remains unclear how much transmit/receive parallelization would be possible using a 3-D MLT system. Therefore, the aim of this paper was to contrast different MLT setups for 3-D imaging by computer simulation in order to determine an optimal tradeoff between the amount of parallelization of an MLT system and the corresponding signal-to-noise ratio of the resulting images. Hereto, the image quality of several MLT setups was estimated by quantifying their crosstalk energy level. The results showed that for the tested setups, 4MLT broad beams and 9MLT narrow beams with Tukey ( $\alpha = 0.5$ ) apodization in transmit and receive give the highest frame rate gain while maintaining an acceptable interbeam interference level. Moreover, although 16MLT narrow beams with Tukey/Tukey ( $\alpha = 0.5$ ) apodization did show more pronounced interbeam interference, its gain in frame rate might outweigh its predicted loss in image quality. As such both 9MLT and 16MLT narrow beams were tested experimentally. For both systems, four receive lines were reconstructed from each transmit beam. The contrast-to-noise ratio of these imaging strategies was quantified and compared with the image quality obtained with line-by-line scanning. Despite some expected loss in image quality, the resulting images of the parallelized systems were very competitive to the benchmark, while speeding up the acquisition process by a factor of 36 and 64, respectively.
- 29 September 2016
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics, and Frequency Control
- Vol. 63 (12) , 2082-2091
A Comparison of the Performance of Different Multiline Transmit Setups for Fast Volumetric Cardiac Ultrasound
It was previously demonstrated in 2-D echocardiography that a proper multiline transmit (MLT) implementation can be used to increase frame rate while preserving image quality. Initial findings for extending MLT to 3-D showed that it might address the low spatiotemporal resolution of current volumetric ultrasound systems. However, to date, it remains unclear how much transmit/receive parallelization would be possible using a 3-D MLT system. Therefore, the aim of this paper was to contrast different MLT setups for 3-D imaging by computer simulation in order to determine an optimal tradeoff between the amount of parallelization of an MLT system and the corresponding signal-to-noise ratio of the resulting images. Hereto, the image quality of several MLT setups was estimated by quantifying their crosstalk energy level. The results showed that for the tested setups, 4MLT broad beams and 9MLT narrow beams with Tukey ( $\alpha = 0.5$ ) apodization in transmit and receive give the highest frame rate gain while maintaining an acceptable interbeam interference level. Moreover, although 16MLT narrow beams with Tukey/Tukey ( $\alpha = 0.5$ ) apodization did show more pronounced interbeam interference, its gain in frame rate might outweigh its predicted loss in image quality. As such both 9MLT and 16MLT narrow beams were tested experimentally. For both systems, four receive lines were reconstructed from each transmit beam. The contrast-to-noise ratio of these imaging strategies was quantified and compared with the image quality obtained with line-by-line scanning. Despite some expected loss in image quality, the resulting images of the parallelized systems were very competitive to the benchmark, while speeding up the acquisition process by a factor of 36 and 64, respectively.
- 17 August 2016
- Published by Springer Nature in The International Journal of Cardiovascular Imaging
- Vol. 32 (12) , 1707-1714
In-vivo validation of a new clinical tool to quantify three-dimensional myocardial strain using ultrasound
Three-dimensional (3D) strain analysis based on real-time 3-D echocardiography (RT3DE) has emerged as a novel technique to quantify regional myocardial function. The goal of this study was to evaluate accuracy of a novel model-based 3D tracking tool (eSie Volume Mechanics, Siemens Ultrasound, Mountain View, CA, USA) using sonomicrometry as an independent measure of cardiac deformation. Thirteen sheep were instrumented with microcrystals sutured to the epi- and endocardium of the inferolateral left ventricular wall to trace myocardial deformation along its three directional axes of motion. Paired acquisitions of RT3DE and sonomicrometry were made at baseline, during inotropic modulation and during myocardial ischemia. Accuracy of 3D strain measurements was quantified and expressed as level of agreement with sonomicrometry using linear regression and Bland–Altman analysis. Correlations between 3D strain analysis and sonomicrometry were good for longitudinal and circumferential strain components (r = 0.78 and r = 0.71) but poor for radial strain (r = 0.30). Accordingly, agreement (bias ± 2SD) was −5 ± 6 % for longitudinal, −5 ± 7 % for circumferential, and 15 ± 19 % for radial strain. Intra-observer variability was low for all components (intra-class correlation coefficients (ICC) of respectively 0.89, 0.88 and 0.95) while inter-observer variability was higher, in particular for radial strain (ICC = 0.41). The present study shows that 3D strain analysis provided good estimates of circumferential and longitudinal strain, while estimates of radial strain were less accurate between observers.
- 17 August 2016
- Published by Springer Nature in The International Journal of Cardiovascular Imaging
- Vol. 32 (12) , 1707-1714
In-vivo validation of a new clinical tool to quantify three-dimensional myocardial strain using ultrasound
Three-dimensional (3D) strain analysis based on real-time 3-D echocardiography (RT3DE) has emerged as a novel technique to quantify regional myocardial function. The goal of this study was to evaluate accuracy of a novel model-based 3D tracking tool (eSie Volume Mechanics, Siemens Ultrasound, Mountain View, CA, USA) using sonomicrometry as an independent measure of cardiac deformation. Thirteen sheep were instrumented with microcrystals sutured to the epi- and endocardium of the inferolateral left ventricular wall to trace myocardial deformation along its three directional axes of motion. Paired acquisitions of RT3DE and sonomicrometry were made at baseline, during inotropic modulation and during myocardial ischemia. Accuracy of 3D strain measurements was quantified and expressed as level of agreement with sonomicrometry using linear regression and Bland–Altman analysis. Correlations between 3D strain analysis and sonomicrometry were good for longitudinal and circumferential strain components (r = 0.78 and r = 0.71) but poor for radial strain (r = 0.30). Accordingly, agreement (bias ± 2SD) was −5 ± 6 % for longitudinal, −5 ± 7 % for circumferential, and 15 ± 19 % for radial strain. Intra-observer variability was low for all components (intra-class correlation coefficients (ICC) of respectively 0.89, 0.88 and 0.95) while inter-observer variability was higher, in particular for radial strain (ICC = 0.41). The present study shows that 3D strain analysis provided good estimates of circumferential and longitudinal strain, while estimates of radial strain were less accurate between observers.