Anna Louise Merrifield
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Anna Louise Merrifield has a total of 58 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Reto Knutti
ETH Zurich
26 shared publications - Ruth Lorenz
Institute for Atmospheric and Climate Science, ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
19 shared publications - Lukas Brunner
Research Unit Sustainability and Climate Risk, Earth and Society Research Hub (ESRAH), University of Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany
17 shared publications - Vincent Humphrey
Federal Office of Meteorology and Climatology MeteoSwiss, Zurich, CH-8058, Switzerland
11 shared publications - Sebastian Sippel
Leipzig Institute for Meteorology, Leipzig University, Leipzig, Germany
6 shared publications Flavio Lehner
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 2 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-22
Comment on egusphere-2026-3242
Fog and low clouds (FLCs) are essential moisture sources for Namib desert ecosystems. However, their response to climate change remains uncertain because fog processes are not resolved in climate models. Here, we apply a cloud-controlling factor framework in which FLC anomalies are expressed as a linear function of large-scale meteorological drivers, including estimated inversion strength (EIS), relative humidity at 700 hPa (R700), sea surface temperature (SST), and the eastward and northward components of 10 m wind (U10, V10). Sensitivities of FLCs to these drivers are quantified using a statistical model. By applying these sensitivities to projections of the corresponding predictors from CMIP6, we produce the first observationally constrained projections of Namib FLC occurrence. Projected trends remain uncertain and scenario-dependent; however, a robust physical signal emerges. Changes in FLCs are governed by competing influences: SST increase over the southeast Atlantic region reduces FLCs, while increased lower-tropospheric stability as well as circulation changes enhance them. Overall, these results suggest that Namib FLCs may be more resilient to climate change than previously assumed, raising the question of whether similar compensating mechanisms operate in other eastern-ocean boundary-layer upwelling systems, such as those of the Atacama Desert and California.
- 2 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-22
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-3242
Fog and low clouds (FLCs) are essential moisture sources for Namib desert ecosystems. However, their response to climate change remains uncertain because fog processes are not resolved in climate models. Here, we apply a cloud-controlling factor framework in which FLC anomalies are expressed as a linear function of large-scale meteorological drivers, including estimated inversion strength (EIS), relative humidity at 700 hPa (R700), sea surface temperature (SST), and the eastward and northward components of 10 m wind (U10, V10). Sensitivities of FLCs to these drivers are quantified using a statistical model. By applying these sensitivities to projections of the corresponding predictors from CMIP6, we produce the first observationally constrained projections of Namib FLC occurrence. Projected trends remain uncertain and scenario-dependent; however, a robust physical signal emerges. Changes in FLCs are governed by competing influences: SST increase over the southeast Atlantic region reduces FLCs, while increased lower-tropospheric stability as well as circulation changes enhance them. Overall, these results suggest that Namib FLCs may be more resilient to climate change than previously assumed, raising the question of whether similar compensating mechanisms operate in other eastern-ocean boundary-layer upwelling systems, such as those of the Atacama Desert and California.
- Open Access
- 25 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-22
Comment on egusphere-2026-3242
Fog and low clouds (FLCs) are essential moisture sources for Namib desert ecosystems. However, their response to climate change remains uncertain because fog processes are not resolved in climate models. Here, we apply a cloud-controlling factor framework in which FLC anomalies are expressed as a linear function of large-scale meteorological drivers, including estimated inversion strength (EIS), relative humidity at 700 hPa (R700), sea surface temperature (SST), and the eastward and northward components of 10 m wind (U10, V10). Sensitivities of FLCs to these drivers are quantified using a statistical model. By applying these sensitivities to projections of the corresponding predictors from CMIP6, we produce the first observationally constrained projections of Namib FLC occurrence. Projected trends remain uncertain and scenario-dependent; however, a robust physical signal emerges. Changes in FLCs are governed by competing influences: SST increase over the southeast Atlantic region reduces FLCs, while increased lower-tropospheric stability as well as circulation changes enhance them. Overall, these results suggest that Namib FLCs may be more resilient to climate change than previously assumed, raising the question of whether similar compensating mechanisms operate in other eastern-ocean boundary-layer upwelling systems, such as those of the Atacama Desert and California.
- 25 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-22
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-3242
Fog and low clouds (FLCs) are essential moisture sources for Namib desert ecosystems. However, their response to climate change remains uncertain because fog processes are not resolved in climate models. Here, we apply a cloud-controlling factor framework in which FLC anomalies are expressed as a linear function of large-scale meteorological drivers, including estimated inversion strength (EIS), relative humidity at 700 hPa (R700), sea surface temperature (SST), and the eastward and northward components of 10 m wind (U10, V10). Sensitivities of FLCs to these drivers are quantified using a statistical model. By applying these sensitivities to projections of the corresponding predictors from CMIP6, we produce the first observationally constrained projections of Namib FLC occurrence. Projected trends remain uncertain and scenario-dependent; however, a robust physical signal emerges. Changes in FLCs are governed by competing influences: SST increase over the southeast Atlantic region reduces FLCs, while increased lower-tropospheric stability as well as circulation changes enhance them. Overall, these results suggest that Namib FLCs may be more resilient to climate change than previously assumed, raising the question of whether similar compensating mechanisms operate in other eastern-ocean boundary-layer upwelling systems, such as those of the Atacama Desert and California.
- Open Access
- 25 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
Fog and low clouds in the Namib Desert may be more resilient than previously thought
Fog and low clouds (FLCs) are essential moisture sources for Namib desert ecosystems. However, their response to climate change remains uncertain because fog processes are not resolved in climate models. Here, we apply a cloud-controlling factor framework in which FLC anomalies are expressed as a linear function of large-scale meteorological drivers, including estimated inversion strength (EIS), relative humidity at 700 hPa (R700), sea surface temperature (SST), and the eastward and northward components of 10 m wind (U10, V10). Sensitivities of FLCs to these drivers are quantified using a statistical model. By applying these sensitivities to projections of the corresponding predictors from CMIP6, we produce the first observationally constrained projections of Namib FLC occurrence. Projected trends remain uncertain and scenario-dependent; however, a robust physical signal emerges. Changes in FLCs are governed by competing influences: SST increase over the southeast Atlantic region reduces FLCs, while increased lower-tropospheric stability as well as circulation changes enhance them. Overall, these results suggest that Namib FLCs may be more resilient to climate change than previously assumed, raising the question of whether similar compensating mechanisms operate in other eastern-ocean boundary-layer upwelling systems, such as those of the Atacama Desert and California.
- 25 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
Open AccessFog and low clouds in the Namib Desert may be more resilient than previously thought
Fog and low clouds (FLCs) are essential moisture sources for Namib desert ecosystems. However, their response to climate change remains uncertain because fog processes are not resolved in climate models. Here, we apply a cloud-controlling factor framework in which FLC anomalies are expressed as a linear function of large-scale meteorological drivers, including estimated inversion strength (EIS), relative humidity at 700 hPa (R700), sea surface temperature (SST), and the eastward and northward components of 10 m wind (U10, V10). Sensitivities of FLCs to these drivers are quantified using a statistical model. By applying these sensitivities to projections of the corresponding predictors from CMIP6, we produce the first observationally constrained projections of Namib FLC occurrence. Projected trends remain uncertain and scenario-dependent; however, a robust physical signal emerges. Changes in FLCs are governed by competing influences: SST increase over the southeast Atlantic region reduces FLCs, while increased lower-tropospheric stability as well as circulation changes enhance them. Overall, these results suggest that Namib FLCs may be more resilient to climate change than previously assumed, raising the question of whether similar compensating mechanisms operate in other eastern-ocean boundary-layer upwelling systems, such as those of the Atacama Desert and California.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
The Swiss Climate CH2025 scenarios: Underlying methods and scientific challenges
Climate CH2025 documents and explains past, present, and future climate change in Switzerland using the latest climate model data, providing the scientific basis for updating the National Adaptation Strategy after 2025. The Climate CH2025 scenarios use climate models from the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP), integrating CMIP5-era Regional Climate Models (hereafter called RCMs) and CMIP6 General Circulation Models (GCMs) through both established and newly developed approaches based on Global Warming Levels (GWLs). Observations show that climate response in Switzerland has been particularly pronounced in comparison to other global land regions with mean near-surface air temperatures in 2024 exceeding the preindustrial reference period by 2.9 °C. This is a warming rate about two times faster than on global average. Most models simulate a substantially lower warming trend over this period. The recent warming was likely substantially enhanced by internal variability and by a decline of atmospheric aerosol loads since the 1980s. Regardless, a mismatch identified between RCMs and GCMs, where western Europe and Switzerland warm consistently more in GCMs than RCMs, in particular in spring and summer, limits confidence in the RCMs. This warming mismatch presents the main methodological challenge for Climate CH2025.Several methodological choices were made in Climate CH2025 to reduce the influence of the RCM-GCM warming mismatch on Swiss climate change projections. The first was to set the “present day” base period to 1991-2020, consistent with the current norm period of the World Meteorological Organization. The observed global warming from the preindustrial period to the present day was used to calculate when each GCM reaches a given GWL, defined as a 30-year mean relative to preindustrial conditions. CMIP6 GCMs were brought in to incorporate the latest regional warming estimates, which were used in a regional time adjustment step that ensured RCMs and GCMs warmed the same amount regionally at each GWL. Once regional warming was aligned, local climate responses at 1.5 °C, 2 °C, and 3 °C of global warming could be reported. This method we call the “Block-Time-Shift" (BTS) approach. An advantage of using GWLs is that they relate warming on the global scale to Swiss warming, without relying on specific details in socioeconomic emissions scenarios. A disadvantage is that BTS cannot provide fully transient timeseries. Here we show how the BTS approach shaped results in Climate CH2025, particularly in comparison to earlier Swiss climate scenarios. We report on user feedback on GWLs from communication and technical standpoints and provide guidance for updating workflows from change at fixed time points to change at fixed points in global temperature.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessThe Swiss Climate CH2025 scenarios: Underlying methods and scientific challenges
Climate CH2025 documents and explains past, present, and future climate change in Switzerland using the latest climate model data, providing the scientific basis for updating the National Adaptation Strategy after 2025. The Climate CH2025 scenarios use climate models from the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP), integrating CMIP5-era Regional Climate Models (hereafter called RCMs) and CMIP6 General Circulation Models (GCMs) through both established and newly developed approaches based on Global Warming Levels (GWLs). Observations show that climate response in Switzerland has been particularly pronounced in comparison to other global land regions with mean near-surface air temperatures in 2024 exceeding the preindustrial reference period by 2.9 °C. This is a warming rate about two times faster than on global average. Most models simulate a substantially lower warming trend over this period. The recent warming was likely substantially enhanced by internal variability and by a decline of atmospheric aerosol loads since the 1980s. Regardless, a mismatch identified between RCMs and GCMs, where western Europe and Switzerland warm consistently more in GCMs than RCMs, in particular in spring and summer, limits confidence in the RCMs. This warming mismatch presents the main methodological challenge for Climate CH2025.Several methodological choices were made in Climate CH2025 to reduce the influence of the RCM-GCM warming mismatch on Swiss climate change projections. The first was to set the “present day” base period to 1991-2020, consistent with the current norm period of the World Meteorological Organization. The observed global warming from the preindustrial period to the present day was used to calculate when each GCM reaches a given GWL, defined as a 30-year mean relative to preindustrial conditions. CMIP6 GCMs were brought in to incorporate the latest regional warming estimates, which were used in a regional time adjustment step that ensured RCMs and GCMs warmed the same amount regionally at each GWL. Once regional warming was aligned, local climate responses at 1.5 °C, 2 °C, and 3 °C of global warming could be reported. This method we call the “Block-Time-Shift" (BTS) approach. An advantage of using GWLs is that they relate warming on the global scale to Swiss warming, without relying on specific details in socioeconomic emissions scenarios. A disadvantage is that BTS cannot provide fully transient timeseries. Here we show how the BTS approach shaped results in Climate CH2025, particularly in comparison to earlier Swiss climate scenarios. We report on user feedback on GWLs from communication and technical standpoints and provide guidance for updating workflows from change at fixed time points to change at fixed points in global temperature.
- Open Access
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Testing An Optimal Fingerprinting Method to Separate the Greenhouse Gas and Aerosol Forced Responses in Observations
A central challenge in climate science is the assessment and quantification of anthropogenic temperature and precipitation change patterns in space and time, as well as the individual contributions from anthropogenic greenhouse gas (GHG) and aerosol (AER) forcings. While single model initial condition large ensembles allow robust separation of forced responses from internal variability and single-forcing simulations allow for the direct interrogation of individual drivers of climate change, understanding the interplay between AER and GHG responses remains difficult in observations, where only one realization of the climate system, subject to all forcings, is available. Signal-to-Noise Maximizing Pattern Optimal Fingerprinting (SNMP-OF) offers a promising method to estimate the responses to AER and GHG forcing in a single climate realization. In a first step, Signal-to-Noise Maximizing Pattern (SNMP) analysis is used to characterize spatiotemporal anomaly patterns that are common across ensembles of single-forcing GHG or AER simulations and therefore likely represent an externally forced signal. Optimal Fingerprinting (OF) projects these patterns onto single ensemble members or observations to estimate the contribution of anthropogenic GHG and AER forcings to global temperature and precipitation changes. CNRM-CM6.1, CanESM5, HadGEM3, IPSL-CM6A, MIROC6 and CESM2 single- and all-forcings simulations of near-surface air temperature and total precipitation rate are used to test the method, by iteratively retrieving the forced response with SNMP from 5 of the 6 models and testing it with OF on single ensemble members of the remaining model. The skill in estimating the forced response in the left out model is compared to a benchmark method which is based on a simple scaling of the other 5 models. SNMP-OF is then used to estimate the AER and GHG forced responses in temperature and precipitation within observations. Since GHG and AER exert partly opposing effects on the climate system, their separate quantification is essential for a physically consistent understanding of anthropogenic climate change and may provide more causal insight into observed climate trends.
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessTesting An Optimal Fingerprinting Method to Separate the Greenhouse Gas and Aerosol Forced Responses in Observations
A central challenge in climate science is the assessment and quantification of anthropogenic temperature and precipitation change patterns in space and time, as well as the individual contributions from anthropogenic greenhouse gas (GHG) and aerosol (AER) forcings. While single model initial condition large ensembles allow robust separation of forced responses from internal variability and single-forcing simulations allow for the direct interrogation of individual drivers of climate change, understanding the interplay between AER and GHG responses remains difficult in observations, where only one realization of the climate system, subject to all forcings, is available. Signal-to-Noise Maximizing Pattern Optimal Fingerprinting (SNMP-OF) offers a promising method to estimate the responses to AER and GHG forcing in a single climate realization. In a first step, Signal-to-Noise Maximizing Pattern (SNMP) analysis is used to characterize spatiotemporal anomaly patterns that are common across ensembles of single-forcing GHG or AER simulations and therefore likely represent an externally forced signal. Optimal Fingerprinting (OF) projects these patterns onto single ensemble members or observations to estimate the contribution of anthropogenic GHG and AER forcings to global temperature and precipitation changes. CNRM-CM6.1, CanESM5, HadGEM3, IPSL-CM6A, MIROC6 and CESM2 single- and all-forcings simulations of near-surface air temperature and total precipitation rate are used to test the method, by iteratively retrieving the forced response with SNMP from 5 of the 6 models and testing it with OF on single ensemble members of the remaining model. The skill in estimating the forced response in the left out model is compared to a benchmark method which is based on a simple scaling of the other 5 models. SNMP-OF is then used to estimate the AER and GHG forced responses in temperature and precipitation within observations. Since GHG and AER exert partly opposing effects on the climate system, their separate quantification is essential for a physically consistent understanding of anthropogenic climate change and may provide more causal insight into observed climate trends.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 15 January 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Weather and Climate Dynamics
- Vol. 7 (1) , 89-108
Considerable yet contrasting regional imprint of circulation change on summer temperature trends across the Northern hemisphere mid-latitudes
Rising summer temperatures and more frequent heat extremes are well-documented outcomes of anthropogenic climate change. However, the extent to which atmospheric circulation changes contribute to these trends remains contested. Regional differences across the northern mid-latitudes suggest that circulation plays a role, yet robustly quantifying its contribution over multiple decades is very challenging. We address this by systematically testing statistical and machine learning methods that decompose temperature signals into a thermodynamic and a dynamic contribution against climate model simulations. Specifically, we use unforced simulations with circulation nudged to match a forced simulation that includes anthropogenic emissions and land-use change. We apply decomposition methods to the forced simulations and compare their estimates of circulation-induced trends with those found in nudged circulation simulations. Our analysis reveals that most methods accurately identify the sign of circulation-induced changes in temperature, although they consistently underestimate their magnitude. Despite this limitation, the results demonstrate that circulation changes have made a substantial contribution to summer temperature trends across the northern mid-latitudes. In Europe, a hotspot region, we estimate that up to half of the observed summer warming between 1979 and 2023 can be attributed to circulation trends. Furthermore, circulation trends have contributed to warmer summer temperatures over Western North America, Central Siberia, Mongolia, Central China, and northeastern Canada. Yet, circulation changes have cooled summer temperatures over Eastern and Central North America, Eastern China, and Central Asia. Overall, our results, based on multiple methods, confirm a circumglobal mid-latitude pattern of considerable, yet contrasting, contributions of circulation changes to summer temperature trends.
- 15 January 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Weather and Climate Dynamics
- Vol. 7 (1) , 89-108
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessConsiderable yet contrasting regional imprint of circulation change on summer temperature trends across the Northern hemisphere mid-latitudes
Rising summer temperatures and more frequent heat extremes are well-documented outcomes of anthropogenic climate change. However, the extent to which atmospheric circulation changes contribute to these trends remains contested. Regional differences across the northern mid-latitudes suggest that circulation plays a role, yet robustly quantifying its contribution over multiple decades is very challenging. We address this by systematically testing statistical and machine learning methods that decompose temperature signals into a thermodynamic and a dynamic contribution against climate model simulations. Specifically, we use unforced simulations with circulation nudged to match a forced simulation that includes anthropogenic emissions and land-use change. We apply decomposition methods to the forced simulations and compare their estimates of circulation-induced trends with those found in nudged circulation simulations. Our analysis reveals that most methods accurately identify the sign of circulation-induced changes in temperature, although they consistently underestimate their magnitude. Despite this limitation, the results demonstrate that circulation changes have made a substantial contribution to summer temperature trends across the northern mid-latitudes. In Europe, a hotspot region, we estimate that up to half of the observed summer warming between 1979 and 2023 can be attributed to circulation trends. Furthermore, circulation trends have contributed to warmer summer temperatures over Western North America, Central Siberia, Mongolia, Central China, and northeastern Canada. Yet, circulation changes have cooled summer temperatures over Eastern and Central North America, Eastern China, and Central Asia. Overall, our results, based on multiple methods, confirm a circumglobal mid-latitude pattern of considerable, yet contrasting, contributions of circulation changes to summer temperature trends.
- Open Access
- 7 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-28
Comment on egusphere-2025-2397
The increase in summer temperature and heat extremes is well documented and attributed to anthropogenic climate change. There is, however, still a vivid debate about the influence of atmospheric circulation changes on summer temperatures and heat extremes. Over the northern hemispheric mid-latitudes, considerable regional differences in summer temperatures have been observed. These differences have been linked to atmospheric circulation changes using statistical methods, but it remains challenging to evaluate such methods on multi-decadal time scales. Here, we evaluate different decomposition methods and systematically investigate circulation-induced summer temperature trends. For the evaluation of statistical and machine learning decomposition methods we use climate model simulations without external forcing but with atmospheric circulation nudged towards the circulation of a freely running simulation forced by anthropogenic emissions and land use changes. We train the decomposition methods on the free-running forced simulation and compare its circulation-induced trends to the trends simulated in the nudged circulation simulation. Most decomposition methods show skill in estimating the sign of circulation-induced trends but all methods underestimate the magnitude of these trends. The application of tested decomposition methods confirms that circulation changes have contributed substantially to an increase in summer heat over several mid-latitude regions, including Europe. In this hotspot region, we estimate that up to half of the warming over the period 1979–2023 is due to circulation changes.
- 7 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-28
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2025-2397
The increase in summer temperature and heat extremes is well documented and attributed to anthropogenic climate change. There is, however, still a vivid debate about the influence of atmospheric circulation changes on summer temperatures and heat extremes. Over the northern hemispheric mid-latitudes, considerable regional differences in summer temperatures have been observed. These differences have been linked to atmospheric circulation changes using statistical methods, but it remains challenging to evaluate such methods on multi-decadal time scales. Here, we evaluate different decomposition methods and systematically investigate circulation-induced summer temperature trends. For the evaluation of statistical and machine learning decomposition methods we use climate model simulations without external forcing but with atmospheric circulation nudged towards the circulation of a freely running simulation forced by anthropogenic emissions and land use changes. We train the decomposition methods on the free-running forced simulation and compare its circulation-induced trends to the trends simulated in the nudged circulation simulation. Most decomposition methods show skill in estimating the sign of circulation-induced trends but all methods underestimate the magnitude of these trends. The application of tested decomposition methods confirms that circulation changes have contributed substantially to an increase in summer heat over several mid-latitude regions, including Europe. In this hotspot region, we estimate that up to half of the warming over the period 1979–2023 is due to circulation changes.
- Open Access
- 4 June 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-28
The contribution of circulation changes to summer temperature trends in the northern hemisphere mid-latitudes: A multi-method quantification
The increase in summer temperature and heat extremes is well documented and attributed to anthropogenic climate change. There is, however, still a vivid debate about the influence of atmospheric circulation changes on summer temperatures and heat extremes. Over the northern hemispheric mid-latitudes, considerable regional differences in summer temperatures have been observed. These differences have been linked to atmospheric circulation changes using statistical methods, but it remains challenging to evaluate such methods on multi-decadal time scales. Here, we evaluate different decomposition methods and systematically investigate circulation-induced summer temperature trends. For the evaluation of statistical and machine learning decomposition methods we use climate model simulations without external forcing but with atmospheric circulation nudged towards the circulation of a freely running simulation forced by anthropogenic emissions and land use changes. We train the decomposition methods on the free-running forced simulation and compare its circulation-induced trends to the trends simulated in the nudged circulation simulation. Most decomposition methods show skill in estimating the sign of circulation-induced trends but all methods underestimate the magnitude of these trends. The application of tested decomposition methods confirms that circulation changes have contributed substantially to an increase in summer heat over several mid-latitude regions, including Europe. In this hotspot region, we estimate that up to half of the warming over the period 1979–2023 is due to circulation changes.
- 4 June 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-28
Open AccessThe contribution of circulation changes to summer temperature trends in the northern hemisphere mid-latitudes: A multi-method quantification
The increase in summer temperature and heat extremes is well documented and attributed to anthropogenic climate change. There is, however, still a vivid debate about the influence of atmospheric circulation changes on summer temperatures and heat extremes. Over the northern hemispheric mid-latitudes, considerable regional differences in summer temperatures have been observed. These differences have been linked to atmospheric circulation changes using statistical methods, but it remains challenging to evaluate such methods on multi-decadal time scales. Here, we evaluate different decomposition methods and systematically investigate circulation-induced summer temperature trends. For the evaluation of statistical and machine learning decomposition methods we use climate model simulations without external forcing but with atmospheric circulation nudged towards the circulation of a freely running simulation forced by anthropogenic emissions and land use changes. We train the decomposition methods on the free-running forced simulation and compare its circulation-induced trends to the trends simulated in the nudged circulation simulation. Most decomposition methods show skill in estimating the sign of circulation-induced trends but all methods underestimate the magnitude of these trends. The application of tested decomposition methods confirms that circulation changes have contributed substantially to an increase in summer heat over several mid-latitude regions, including Europe. In this hotspot region, we estimate that up to half of the warming over the period 1979–2023 is due to circulation changes.
- Open Access
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Forced Component Estimation Statistical Methods Intercomparison Project (ForceSMIP)
Anthropogenic climate change is unfolding rapidly, yet its regional manifestation is often obscured by atmosphere-ocean internal variability. A primary goal of climate science is to identify the forced response, i.e., spatiotemporal changes in climate in response to greenhouse gases, anthropogenic aerosols, and other external forcing, amongst the noise of internal climate variability. Separating the forced response from internal variability can be addressed in climate models by using a large ensemble to average over different possible realizations of internal variability. However, with only one realization of the real world, it is a major challenge to isolate the forced response in observations, as is needed for attribution of historical climate changes, for characterizing and understanding observed internal variability, and for climate model evaluation.In the Forced Component Estimation Intercomparison Project (ForceSMIP), contributors used existing and newly developed statistical and machine learning methods to estimate the forced response during the historical period within individual ensemble members and observations, across eight key climate variables (SST, surface air temperature, precipitation, SLP, zonal-mean atmospheric temperature, monthly max. and min. temperature, and monthly max. precipitation). Participants could use five CMIP6 large ensembles to train their methods, but they then had to apply their methods to individual evaluation members, the identity of which was hidden. Participants used methods including regression methods, convolutional neural networks, linear inverse models, fingerprinting methods, and low-frequency component analysis. Here we show how the different methods performed on climate models and what they determined to the be the forced response in observations. Our results show that many different types of methods are skillful for estimating the forced response and that the most skillful method depends highly on which variable and metric is evaluated. Furthermore, methods that show comparable skill can give very different estimates of the forced response in observations, illustrating the epistemic uncertainty in estimating the forced climate response from observations. ForceSMIP gives new insights into the forced response in observations across multiple key variables, but also the remaining uncertainty in its estimation.
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessForced Component Estimation Statistical Methods Intercomparison Project (ForceSMIP)
Anthropogenic climate change is unfolding rapidly, yet its regional manifestation is often obscured by atmosphere-ocean internal variability. A primary goal of climate science is to identify the forced response, i.e., spatiotemporal changes in climate in response to greenhouse gases, anthropogenic aerosols, and other external forcing, amongst the noise of internal climate variability. Separating the forced response from internal variability can be addressed in climate models by using a large ensemble to average over different possible realizations of internal variability. However, with only one realization of the real world, it is a major challenge to isolate the forced response in observations, as is needed for attribution of historical climate changes, for characterizing and understanding observed internal variability, and for climate model evaluation.In the Forced Component Estimation Intercomparison Project (ForceSMIP), contributors used existing and newly developed statistical and machine learning methods to estimate the forced response during the historical period within individual ensemble members and observations, across eight key climate variables (SST, surface air temperature, precipitation, SLP, zonal-mean atmospheric temperature, monthly max. and min. temperature, and monthly max. precipitation). Participants could use five CMIP6 large ensembles to train their methods, but they then had to apply their methods to individual evaluation members, the identity of which was hidden. Participants used methods including regression methods, convolutional neural networks, linear inverse models, fingerprinting methods, and low-frequency component analysis. Here we show how the different methods performed on climate models and what they determined to the be the forced response in observations. Our results show that many different types of methods are skillful for estimating the forced response and that the most skillful method depends highly on which variable and metric is evaluated. Furthermore, methods that show comparable skill can give very different estimates of the forced response in observations, illustrating the epistemic uncertainty in estimating the forced climate response from observations. ForceSMIP gives new insights into the forced response in observations across multiple key variables, but also the remaining uncertainty in its estimation.
- Open Access
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Multi-method quantification of the contribution of circulation changes to summer temperature trends in the northern hemispheric mid-latitudes
Observed summer temperature trends differ strongly around the northern hemispheric latitudes. Besides changes in aerosol emissions, changes in atmospheric circulation patterns - whether forced or not - are expected to contribute to considerable variation in summer temperature trends. Different statistical and machine learning methods have been developed and applied to quantify this contribution of circulation changes to summer temperatures. Here we test the accuracy of multiple methods by applying them to historical climate simulations and comparing the circulation contribution obtained by different methods to trends found in nudged circulation simulations with wind fields of the historical simulations but pre-industrial control forcing. After validating the methods we apply them to ERA5 and over the entire northern hemispheric mid-latitudes (over land). Our results consistently suggest that especially over Europe circulation changes have contributed to an increase in summer temperatures. In parts of central Asia and eastern North America, circulation changes have contributed to a cooling in summer temperatures.While providing a systematic overview of circulation contributions to local temperature trends in the northern hemispheric mid-latitudes we also show how nudging experiments can help to validate and consolidate methods. We argue that such method evaluation studies become increasingly important with the ongoing expansion of applications of statistical and machine learning analyses on the observational record.
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessMulti-method quantification of the contribution of circulation changes to summer temperature trends in the northern hemispheric mid-latitudes
Observed summer temperature trends differ strongly around the northern hemispheric latitudes. Besides changes in aerosol emissions, changes in atmospheric circulation patterns - whether forced or not - are expected to contribute to considerable variation in summer temperature trends. Different statistical and machine learning methods have been developed and applied to quantify this contribution of circulation changes to summer temperatures. Here we test the accuracy of multiple methods by applying them to historical climate simulations and comparing the circulation contribution obtained by different methods to trends found in nudged circulation simulations with wind fields of the historical simulations but pre-industrial control forcing. After validating the methods we apply them to ERA5 and over the entire northern hemispheric mid-latitudes (over land). Our results consistently suggest that especially over Europe circulation changes have contributed to an increase in summer temperatures. In parts of central Asia and eastern North America, circulation changes have contributed to a cooling in summer temperatures.While providing a systematic overview of circulation contributions to local temperature trends in the northern hemispheric mid-latitudes we also show how nudging experiments can help to validate and consolidate methods. We argue that such method evaluation studies become increasingly important with the ongoing expansion of applications of statistical and machine learning analyses on the observational record.