Lukas Brunner
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Lukas Brunner has a total of 272 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Reto Knutti
ETH Zurich
27 shared publications - Jana Sillmann
Research Unit Sustainability and Climate Risk, Earth and Society Research Hub (ESRAH), University of Hamburg, Hamburg, 20144, Germany
26 shared publications - Benjamin Poschlod
Research Unit Sustainability and Climate Risk, Earth and Society Research Hub (ESRAH), University of Hamburg, Hamburg, 20144, Germany
24 shared publications - Ruth Lorenz
Institute for Atmospheric and Climate Science, ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
21 shared publications - Anna Louise Merrifield
Institute for Atmospheric and Climate Sciences, ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
17 shared publications Clara Deser
Climate and Global Dynamics Laboratory, National Center for Atmospheric Research, Boulder, CO, USA
15 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 5 November 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 17 (1) , 11456
Recent extreme heatwaves are no match for future events
In recent years, record-breaking heatwaves have occurred over many regions of the Earth causing serious impacts to human and natural systems. Here we show that recently observed exceptional heatwaves are no match to potential future 21 st century events based on multiple metrics. For several observed heatwaves, this holds even under low- and medium-emissions scenarios. In a high- to very high-emissions future, many regions are projected to experience heatwaves that generate several times more cumulative heat and are many times longer (up to several months) than the observed heatwaves. Should the Nationally Determined Contributions under the Paris Agreement not be implemented, in most regions a concerningly large proportion of projected heatwaves exceeds all analyzed heatwave characteristics at once. Our results underscore the crucial need for substantial emissions reduction and have important implications for adaptation measures, as a substantial proportion of projected heatwaves is well outside the recent lived experience.
- 5 November 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 17 (1) , 11456
Open AccessRecent extreme heatwaves are no match for future events
In recent years, record-breaking heatwaves have occurred over many regions of the Earth causing serious impacts to human and natural systems. Here we show that recently observed exceptional heatwaves are no match to potential future 21 st century events based on multiple metrics. For several observed heatwaves, this holds even under low- and medium-emissions scenarios. In a high- to very high-emissions future, many regions are projected to experience heatwaves that generate several times more cumulative heat and are many times longer (up to several months) than the observed heatwaves. Should the Nationally Determined Contributions under the Paris Agreement not be implemented, in most regions a concerningly large proportion of projected heatwaves exceeds all analyzed heatwave characteristics at once. Our results underscore the crucial need for substantial emissions reduction and have important implications for adaptation measures, as a substantial proportion of projected heatwaves is well outside the recent lived experience.
- 30 October 2026
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 12 (44)
Coarse climate model grids underestimate coastal humid-heat extremes
Humid-heat extremes reach intensities close to the limit of human survivability around the Arabian Peninsula. Here, we analyze fully coupled kilometer-scale Icosahedral Nonhydrostatic (ICON) and Integrated Forecasting System–FinitevolumE Sea ice-Ocean Model (IFS-FESOM) simulations from the nextGEMS project, with original resolutions of around 9 kilometers, and compare them with station observations, ERA5, and CMIP6 projections. IFS-FESOM reproduces well the observed upper-tail wet-bulb temperature (TW) and lies near the high end of the CMIP6 distribution over coastal regions, while ICON simulates weaker extremes. Spatial smoothing suppresses localized coastal maxima, reducing daily-maximum TW extremes by up to 8°C and lowering exceedance frequencies across multiple thresholds. Native resolution fields also show stronger mid-century increases in exposure under SSP3-7.0 than their coarse-gridded counterparts. These results suggest that conventional coarse resolution projections may underestimate localized coastal humid-heat risk, although the magnitude of this effect remains model dependent.
- 30 October 2026
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 12 (44)
Coarse climate model grids underestimate coastal humid-heat extremes
Humid-heat extremes reach intensities close to the limit of human survivability around the Arabian Peninsula. Here, we analyze fully coupled kilometer-scale Icosahedral Nonhydrostatic (ICON) and Integrated Forecasting System–FinitevolumE Sea ice-Ocean Model (IFS-FESOM) simulations from the nextGEMS project, with original resolutions of around 9 kilometers, and compare them with station observations, ERA5, and CMIP6 projections. IFS-FESOM reproduces well the observed upper-tail wet-bulb temperature (TW) and lies near the high end of the CMIP6 distribution over coastal regions, while ICON simulates weaker extremes. Spatial smoothing suppresses localized coastal maxima, reducing daily-maximum TW extremes by up to 8°C and lowering exceedance frequencies across multiple thresholds. Native resolution fields also show stronger mid-century increases in exposure under SSP3-7.0 than their coarse-gridded counterparts. These results suggest that conventional coarse resolution projections may underestimate localized coastal humid-heat risk, although the magnitude of this effect remains model dependent.
- Open Access
- 30 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Weather and Climate Dynamics
- Vol. 7 (4) , 2107-2132
Large-scale drivers of compounding hot and dry events in three breadbasket regions
Compound hot and dry events cause damage to ecosystems and society. While these events have been widely studied individually, their co-ocurrence and the associated large-scale atmospheric drivers remain less understood. Here, we use reanalysis products and observational data to identify compound hot and dry events in the historical period from 1960–2020. We analyze the large-scale circulation patterns associated with compound occurrence of hot and dry events when they affect large portions of three breadbasket regions in the Northern Hemisphere, namely North America, Europe and the Mediterranean and eastern Asia. We find that compound hot and dry events recur throughout the historical period and are consistently linked to Rossby wave patterns and mid-tropospheric anticyclonic ridging, which trigger land–atmosphere feedbacks resulting in the reinforcement of the events. Our study highlights that the spatial coverage of compound hot and dry events across the selected regions provides a useful metric for assessing regional impacts.
- 30 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Weather and Climate Dynamics
- Vol. 7 (4) , 2107-2132
Open AccessLarge-scale drivers of compounding hot and dry events in three breadbasket regions
Compound hot and dry events cause damage to ecosystems and society. While these events have been widely studied individually, their co-ocurrence and the associated large-scale atmospheric drivers remain less understood. Here, we use reanalysis products and observational data to identify compound hot and dry events in the historical period from 1960–2020. We analyze the large-scale circulation patterns associated with compound occurrence of hot and dry events when they affect large portions of three breadbasket regions in the Northern Hemisphere, namely North America, Europe and the Mediterranean and eastern Asia. We find that compound hot and dry events recur throughout the historical period and are consistently linked to Rossby wave patterns and mid-tropospheric anticyclonic ridging, which trigger land–atmosphere feedbacks resulting in the reinforcement of the events. Our study highlights that the spatial coverage of compound hot and dry events across the selected regions provides a useful metric for assessing regional impacts.
- Open Access
- 13 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-12
Reply on RC3
The number of consecutive dry days (CDD) is a widely used metric for assessing meteorological drought. This study investigates spatial CDD patterns over Germany during the drought year of 2018, comparing a convection-permitting model (CPM) at 3 km resolution with ERA5 reanalysis at 31 km, gauge-based interpolated observations at 1 km, and radar measurements at 1 km. The analysis reveals a surprise: high-resolution CPM and radar data produce strikingly heterogeneous, “brushstroke-like” spatial structures that differ fundamentally from the smooth fields of reanalysis and gridded observations. Our report confirms that these sharp spatial discontinuities are not computational artifacts but a physical consequence of the sensitivity to the fixed daily dryness threshold of the CDD metric. We find that the CPM can well reproduce these fine-scale patterns that are also detected by radar measurements, which is quantified by a spatial autocorrelogram and the radially averaged power spectral density. While averaging CDD over multiple years smooths out the brushstroke patterns, such temporal averaging does not resolve the underlying shortcoming: multi-year CDD is built upon individual annual CDD values that are, as shown here, highly variable and strongly dataset-dependent. A statistic whose single-year realizations are dominated by threshold-crossing noise provides an unstable foundation for climatological analysis regardless of the aggregation period applied. As a lesson learnt, we recommend caution when applying CDD in any context — including drought monitoring, impact assessment, and climate model evaluation. This study reports on the surprising fine-scale spatial patterns and resulting shortcomings of the CDD metric and is therefore submitted as a LESSONS report, a paper category dedicated to documenting Limitations, Errors, Surprises, Shortcomings, and Opportunities for New Science.
- 13 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-12
Open AccessReply on RC3
The number of consecutive dry days (CDD) is a widely used metric for assessing meteorological drought. This study investigates spatial CDD patterns over Germany during the drought year of 2018, comparing a convection-permitting model (CPM) at 3 km resolution with ERA5 reanalysis at 31 km, gauge-based interpolated observations at 1 km, and radar measurements at 1 km. The analysis reveals a surprise: high-resolution CPM and radar data produce strikingly heterogeneous, “brushstroke-like” spatial structures that differ fundamentally from the smooth fields of reanalysis and gridded observations. Our report confirms that these sharp spatial discontinuities are not computational artifacts but a physical consequence of the sensitivity to the fixed daily dryness threshold of the CDD metric. We find that the CPM can well reproduce these fine-scale patterns that are also detected by radar measurements, which is quantified by a spatial autocorrelogram and the radially averaged power spectral density. While averaging CDD over multiple years smooths out the brushstroke patterns, such temporal averaging does not resolve the underlying shortcoming: multi-year CDD is built upon individual annual CDD values that are, as shown here, highly variable and strongly dataset-dependent. A statistic whose single-year realizations are dominated by threshold-crossing noise provides an unstable foundation for climatological analysis regardless of the aggregation period applied. As a lesson learnt, we recommend caution when applying CDD in any context — including drought monitoring, impact assessment, and climate model evaluation. This study reports on the surprising fine-scale spatial patterns and resulting shortcomings of the CDD metric and is therefore submitted as a LESSONS report, a paper category dedicated to documenting Limitations, Errors, Surprises, Shortcomings, and Opportunities for New Science.
- Open Access
- 13 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-12
Reply on RC2
The number of consecutive dry days (CDD) is a widely used metric for assessing meteorological drought. This study investigates spatial CDD patterns over Germany during the drought year of 2018, comparing a convection-permitting model (CPM) at 3 km resolution with ERA5 reanalysis at 31 km, gauge-based interpolated observations at 1 km, and radar measurements at 1 km. The analysis reveals a surprise: high-resolution CPM and radar data produce strikingly heterogeneous, “brushstroke-like” spatial structures that differ fundamentally from the smooth fields of reanalysis and gridded observations. Our report confirms that these sharp spatial discontinuities are not computational artifacts but a physical consequence of the sensitivity to the fixed daily dryness threshold of the CDD metric. We find that the CPM can well reproduce these fine-scale patterns that are also detected by radar measurements, which is quantified by a spatial autocorrelogram and the radially averaged power spectral density. While averaging CDD over multiple years smooths out the brushstroke patterns, such temporal averaging does not resolve the underlying shortcoming: multi-year CDD is built upon individual annual CDD values that are, as shown here, highly variable and strongly dataset-dependent. A statistic whose single-year realizations are dominated by threshold-crossing noise provides an unstable foundation for climatological analysis regardless of the aggregation period applied. As a lesson learnt, we recommend caution when applying CDD in any context — including drought monitoring, impact assessment, and climate model evaluation. This study reports on the surprising fine-scale spatial patterns and resulting shortcomings of the CDD metric and is therefore submitted as a LESSONS report, a paper category dedicated to documenting Limitations, Errors, Surprises, Shortcomings, and Opportunities for New Science.
- 13 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-12
Open AccessReply on RC2
The number of consecutive dry days (CDD) is a widely used metric for assessing meteorological drought. This study investigates spatial CDD patterns over Germany during the drought year of 2018, comparing a convection-permitting model (CPM) at 3 km resolution with ERA5 reanalysis at 31 km, gauge-based interpolated observations at 1 km, and radar measurements at 1 km. The analysis reveals a surprise: high-resolution CPM and radar data produce strikingly heterogeneous, “brushstroke-like” spatial structures that differ fundamentally from the smooth fields of reanalysis and gridded observations. Our report confirms that these sharp spatial discontinuities are not computational artifacts but a physical consequence of the sensitivity to the fixed daily dryness threshold of the CDD metric. We find that the CPM can well reproduce these fine-scale patterns that are also detected by radar measurements, which is quantified by a spatial autocorrelogram and the radially averaged power spectral density. While averaging CDD over multiple years smooths out the brushstroke patterns, such temporal averaging does not resolve the underlying shortcoming: multi-year CDD is built upon individual annual CDD values that are, as shown here, highly variable and strongly dataset-dependent. A statistic whose single-year realizations are dominated by threshold-crossing noise provides an unstable foundation for climatological analysis regardless of the aggregation period applied. As a lesson learnt, we recommend caution when applying CDD in any context — including drought monitoring, impact assessment, and climate model evaluation. This study reports on the surprising fine-scale spatial patterns and resulting shortcomings of the CDD metric and is therefore submitted as a LESSONS report, a paper category dedicated to documenting Limitations, Errors, Surprises, Shortcomings, and Opportunities for New Science.
- Open Access
- 13 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-12
Reply on RC1
The number of consecutive dry days (CDD) is a widely used metric for assessing meteorological drought. This study investigates spatial CDD patterns over Germany during the drought year of 2018, comparing a convection-permitting model (CPM) at 3 km resolution with ERA5 reanalysis at 31 km, gauge-based interpolated observations at 1 km, and radar measurements at 1 km. The analysis reveals a surprise: high-resolution CPM and radar data produce strikingly heterogeneous, “brushstroke-like” spatial structures that differ fundamentally from the smooth fields of reanalysis and gridded observations. Our report confirms that these sharp spatial discontinuities are not computational artifacts but a physical consequence of the sensitivity to the fixed daily dryness threshold of the CDD metric. We find that the CPM can well reproduce these fine-scale patterns that are also detected by radar measurements, which is quantified by a spatial autocorrelogram and the radially averaged power spectral density. While averaging CDD over multiple years smooths out the brushstroke patterns, such temporal averaging does not resolve the underlying shortcoming: multi-year CDD is built upon individual annual CDD values that are, as shown here, highly variable and strongly dataset-dependent. A statistic whose single-year realizations are dominated by threshold-crossing noise provides an unstable foundation for climatological analysis regardless of the aggregation period applied. As a lesson learnt, we recommend caution when applying CDD in any context — including drought monitoring, impact assessment, and climate model evaluation. This study reports on the surprising fine-scale spatial patterns and resulting shortcomings of the CDD metric and is therefore submitted as a LESSONS report, a paper category dedicated to documenting Limitations, Errors, Surprises, Shortcomings, and Opportunities for New Science.
- 13 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-12
Open AccessReply on RC1
The number of consecutive dry days (CDD) is a widely used metric for assessing meteorological drought. This study investigates spatial CDD patterns over Germany during the drought year of 2018, comparing a convection-permitting model (CPM) at 3 km resolution with ERA5 reanalysis at 31 km, gauge-based interpolated observations at 1 km, and radar measurements at 1 km. The analysis reveals a surprise: high-resolution CPM and radar data produce strikingly heterogeneous, “brushstroke-like” spatial structures that differ fundamentally from the smooth fields of reanalysis and gridded observations. Our report confirms that these sharp spatial discontinuities are not computational artifacts but a physical consequence of the sensitivity to the fixed daily dryness threshold of the CDD metric. We find that the CPM can well reproduce these fine-scale patterns that are also detected by radar measurements, which is quantified by a spatial autocorrelogram and the radially averaged power spectral density. While averaging CDD over multiple years smooths out the brushstroke patterns, such temporal averaging does not resolve the underlying shortcoming: multi-year CDD is built upon individual annual CDD values that are, as shown here, highly variable and strongly dataset-dependent. A statistic whose single-year realizations are dominated by threshold-crossing noise provides an unstable foundation for climatological analysis regardless of the aggregation period applied. As a lesson learnt, we recommend caution when applying CDD in any context — including drought monitoring, impact assessment, and climate model evaluation. This study reports on the surprising fine-scale spatial patterns and resulting shortcomings of the CDD metric and is therefore submitted as a LESSONS report, a paper category dedicated to documenting Limitations, Errors, Surprises, Shortcomings, and Opportunities for New Science.
- Open Access
- 13 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-12
Reply on CC1
The number of consecutive dry days (CDD) is a widely used metric for assessing meteorological drought. This study investigates spatial CDD patterns over Germany during the drought year of 2018, comparing a convection-permitting model (CPM) at 3 km resolution with ERA5 reanalysis at 31 km, gauge-based interpolated observations at 1 km, and radar measurements at 1 km. The analysis reveals a surprise: high-resolution CPM and radar data produce strikingly heterogeneous, “brushstroke-like” spatial structures that differ fundamentally from the smooth fields of reanalysis and gridded observations. Our report confirms that these sharp spatial discontinuities are not computational artifacts but a physical consequence of the sensitivity to the fixed daily dryness threshold of the CDD metric. We find that the CPM can well reproduce these fine-scale patterns that are also detected by radar measurements, which is quantified by a spatial autocorrelogram and the radially averaged power spectral density. While averaging CDD over multiple years smooths out the brushstroke patterns, such temporal averaging does not resolve the underlying shortcoming: multi-year CDD is built upon individual annual CDD values that are, as shown here, highly variable and strongly dataset-dependent. A statistic whose single-year realizations are dominated by threshold-crossing noise provides an unstable foundation for climatological analysis regardless of the aggregation period applied. As a lesson learnt, we recommend caution when applying CDD in any context — including drought monitoring, impact assessment, and climate model evaluation. This study reports on the surprising fine-scale spatial patterns and resulting shortcomings of the CDD metric and is therefore submitted as a LESSONS report, a paper category dedicated to documenting Limitations, Errors, Surprises, Shortcomings, and Opportunities for New Science.
- 13 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-12
Open AccessReply on CC1
The number of consecutive dry days (CDD) is a widely used metric for assessing meteorological drought. This study investigates spatial CDD patterns over Germany during the drought year of 2018, comparing a convection-permitting model (CPM) at 3 km resolution with ERA5 reanalysis at 31 km, gauge-based interpolated observations at 1 km, and radar measurements at 1 km. The analysis reveals a surprise: high-resolution CPM and radar data produce strikingly heterogeneous, “brushstroke-like” spatial structures that differ fundamentally from the smooth fields of reanalysis and gridded observations. Our report confirms that these sharp spatial discontinuities are not computational artifacts but a physical consequence of the sensitivity to the fixed daily dryness threshold of the CDD metric. We find that the CPM can well reproduce these fine-scale patterns that are also detected by radar measurements, which is quantified by a spatial autocorrelogram and the radially averaged power spectral density. While averaging CDD over multiple years smooths out the brushstroke patterns, such temporal averaging does not resolve the underlying shortcoming: multi-year CDD is built upon individual annual CDD values that are, as shown here, highly variable and strongly dataset-dependent. A statistic whose single-year realizations are dominated by threshold-crossing noise provides an unstable foundation for climatological analysis regardless of the aggregation period applied. As a lesson learnt, we recommend caution when applying CDD in any context — including drought monitoring, impact assessment, and climate model evaluation. This study reports on the surprising fine-scale spatial patterns and resulting shortcomings of the CDD metric and is therefore submitted as a LESSONS report, a paper category dedicated to documenting Limitations, Errors, Surprises, Shortcomings, and Opportunities for New Science.
- Open Access
- 22 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-12
Comment on egusphere-2026-4014
The number of consecutive dry days (CDD) is a widely used metric for assessing meteorological drought. This study investigates spatial CDD patterns over Germany during the drought year of 2018, comparing a convection-permitting model (CPM) at 3 km resolution with ERA5 reanalysis at 31 km, gauge-based interpolated observations at 1 km, and radar measurements at 1 km. The analysis reveals a surprise: high-resolution CPM and radar data produce strikingly heterogeneous, “brushstroke-like” spatial structures that differ fundamentally from the smooth fields of reanalysis and gridded observations. Our report confirms that these sharp spatial discontinuities are not computational artifacts but a physical consequence of the sensitivity to the fixed daily dryness threshold of the CDD metric. We find that the CPM can well reproduce these fine-scale patterns that are also detected by radar measurements, which is quantified by a spatial autocorrelogram and the radially averaged power spectral density. While averaging CDD over multiple years smooths out the brushstroke patterns, such temporal averaging does not resolve the underlying shortcoming: multi-year CDD is built upon individual annual CDD values that are, as shown here, highly variable and strongly dataset-dependent. A statistic whose single-year realizations are dominated by threshold-crossing noise provides an unstable foundation for climatological analysis regardless of the aggregation period applied. As a lesson learnt, we recommend caution when applying CDD in any context — including drought monitoring, impact assessment, and climate model evaluation. This study reports on the surprising fine-scale spatial patterns and resulting shortcomings of the CDD metric and is therefore submitted as a LESSONS report, a paper category dedicated to documenting Limitations, Errors, Surprises, Shortcomings, and Opportunities for New Science.
- 22 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-12
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-4014
The number of consecutive dry days (CDD) is a widely used metric for assessing meteorological drought. This study investigates spatial CDD patterns over Germany during the drought year of 2018, comparing a convection-permitting model (CPM) at 3 km resolution with ERA5 reanalysis at 31 km, gauge-based interpolated observations at 1 km, and radar measurements at 1 km. The analysis reveals a surprise: high-resolution CPM and radar data produce strikingly heterogeneous, “brushstroke-like” spatial structures that differ fundamentally from the smooth fields of reanalysis and gridded observations. Our report confirms that these sharp spatial discontinuities are not computational artifacts but a physical consequence of the sensitivity to the fixed daily dryness threshold of the CDD metric. We find that the CPM can well reproduce these fine-scale patterns that are also detected by radar measurements, which is quantified by a spatial autocorrelogram and the radially averaged power spectral density. While averaging CDD over multiple years smooths out the brushstroke patterns, such temporal averaging does not resolve the underlying shortcoming: multi-year CDD is built upon individual annual CDD values that are, as shown here, highly variable and strongly dataset-dependent. A statistic whose single-year realizations are dominated by threshold-crossing noise provides an unstable foundation for climatological analysis regardless of the aggregation period applied. As a lesson learnt, we recommend caution when applying CDD in any context — including drought monitoring, impact assessment, and climate model evaluation. This study reports on the surprising fine-scale spatial patterns and resulting shortcomings of the CDD metric and is therefore submitted as a LESSONS report, a paper category dedicated to documenting Limitations, Errors, Surprises, Shortcomings, and Opportunities for New Science.
- Open Access
- 22 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-12
Comment on egusphere-2026-4014
The number of consecutive dry days (CDD) is a widely used metric for assessing meteorological drought. This study investigates spatial CDD patterns over Germany during the drought year of 2018, comparing a convection-permitting model (CPM) at 3 km resolution with ERA5 reanalysis at 31 km, gauge-based interpolated observations at 1 km, and radar measurements at 1 km. The analysis reveals a surprise: high-resolution CPM and radar data produce strikingly heterogeneous, “brushstroke-like” spatial structures that differ fundamentally from the smooth fields of reanalysis and gridded observations. Our report confirms that these sharp spatial discontinuities are not computational artifacts but a physical consequence of the sensitivity to the fixed daily dryness threshold of the CDD metric. We find that the CPM can well reproduce these fine-scale patterns that are also detected by radar measurements, which is quantified by a spatial autocorrelogram and the radially averaged power spectral density. While averaging CDD over multiple years smooths out the brushstroke patterns, such temporal averaging does not resolve the underlying shortcoming: multi-year CDD is built upon individual annual CDD values that are, as shown here, highly variable and strongly dataset-dependent. A statistic whose single-year realizations are dominated by threshold-crossing noise provides an unstable foundation for climatological analysis regardless of the aggregation period applied. As a lesson learnt, we recommend caution when applying CDD in any context — including drought monitoring, impact assessment, and climate model evaluation. This study reports on the surprising fine-scale spatial patterns and resulting shortcomings of the CDD metric and is therefore submitted as a LESSONS report, a paper category dedicated to documenting Limitations, Errors, Surprises, Shortcomings, and Opportunities for New Science.
- 22 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-12
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-4014
The number of consecutive dry days (CDD) is a widely used metric for assessing meteorological drought. This study investigates spatial CDD patterns over Germany during the drought year of 2018, comparing a convection-permitting model (CPM) at 3 km resolution with ERA5 reanalysis at 31 km, gauge-based interpolated observations at 1 km, and radar measurements at 1 km. The analysis reveals a surprise: high-resolution CPM and radar data produce strikingly heterogeneous, “brushstroke-like” spatial structures that differ fundamentally from the smooth fields of reanalysis and gridded observations. Our report confirms that these sharp spatial discontinuities are not computational artifacts but a physical consequence of the sensitivity to the fixed daily dryness threshold of the CDD metric. We find that the CPM can well reproduce these fine-scale patterns that are also detected by radar measurements, which is quantified by a spatial autocorrelogram and the radially averaged power spectral density. While averaging CDD over multiple years smooths out the brushstroke patterns, such temporal averaging does not resolve the underlying shortcoming: multi-year CDD is built upon individual annual CDD values that are, as shown here, highly variable and strongly dataset-dependent. A statistic whose single-year realizations are dominated by threshold-crossing noise provides an unstable foundation for climatological analysis regardless of the aggregation period applied. As a lesson learnt, we recommend caution when applying CDD in any context — including drought monitoring, impact assessment, and climate model evaluation. This study reports on the surprising fine-scale spatial patterns and resulting shortcomings of the CDD metric and is therefore submitted as a LESSONS report, a paper category dedicated to documenting Limitations, Errors, Surprises, Shortcomings, and Opportunities for New Science.
- Open Access
- 18 September 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 21 (18) , 184022
The variability atlas: how internal climate variability affects the estimation of climate extreme indices
Robustly quantifying climate extremes is crucial for understanding their occurrence, reliable impact assessments, and efficient adaptation planning. To allow objective and comparable assessments of various climate extremes across regions, time periods, and datasets, standardized indices like those from the Expert Team on Climate Change Detection and Indices (ETCCDI) have been developed. These indices are routinely used for climate impact assessment. However, the occurrence of extremes depends not only on the climate state but also on the manifestation of internal climate variability, which is often not explicitly considered in such impact assessments. Here, we complement existing work on climate extremes by isolating the effect of internal climate variability on the estimation of extremes and raise awareness of potential implications for the community. We use a 50-member ensemble from the MPI-ESM global climate model to comprehensively map the effect of internal variability on various climate extremes as captured by the temperature- and precipitation-based ETCCDI indices in the period 1995–2014. We investigate the extent to which the assessment of extremes is affected by internal variability and discuss implications for users. These implications depend on many case-specific priorities, including the indices used, the region considered, and the focus on expected state versus worst-case scenario or single observed manifestation. To provide practical guidance, we introduce the Variability Atlas , an interactive online interface that allows for the investigation of the effect of internal variability for flexible user-defined cases and without coding experience.
- 18 September 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 21 (18) , 184022
Open AccessThe variability atlas: how internal climate variability affects the estimation of climate extreme indices
Robustly quantifying climate extremes is crucial for understanding their occurrence, reliable impact assessments, and efficient adaptation planning. To allow objective and comparable assessments of various climate extremes across regions, time periods, and datasets, standardized indices like those from the Expert Team on Climate Change Detection and Indices (ETCCDI) have been developed. These indices are routinely used for climate impact assessment. However, the occurrence of extremes depends not only on the climate state but also on the manifestation of internal climate variability, which is often not explicitly considered in such impact assessments. Here, we complement existing work on climate extremes by isolating the effect of internal climate variability on the estimation of extremes and raise awareness of potential implications for the community. We use a 50-member ensemble from the MPI-ESM global climate model to comprehensively map the effect of internal variability on various climate extremes as captured by the temperature- and precipitation-based ETCCDI indices in the period 1995–2014. We investigate the extent to which the assessment of extremes is affected by internal variability and discuss implications for users. These implications depend on many case-specific priorities, including the indices used, the region considered, and the focus on expected state versus worst-case scenario or single observed manifestation. To provide practical guidance, we introduce the Variability Atlas , an interactive online interface that allows for the investigation of the effect of internal variability for flexible user-defined cases and without coding experience.