Jonathan D. Nelson
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Jonathan D. Nelson has a total of 95 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Björn Meder
Institute for Mind, Brain and Behavior, Department of Psychology, Health and Medical University, Potsdam, Germany
10 shared publications - Charley M. Wu
Human and Machine Cognition Lab, University of Tübingen, Tübingen, Germany
5 shared publications - David R. Mandel
Intelligence, Influence, and Collaboration Section Defence Research and Development Canada Toronto Ontario Canada
4 shared publications - Eric Schulz
Max Planck Institute for Biological Cybernetics, Tübingen, Germany
4 shared publications - Flavia Filimon
School of Psychology, University of Surrey, GU2 7XH Guildford, United Kingdom
4 shared publications - Craig R. M. McKenzie
Department of Psychology, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, California 92093-0109, USA
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 27 June 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 445-461
Applying Information Theory to Validate Commanders' Critical Information Requirements
Intelligence organizations must routinely assess information value. North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) intelligence professionals inform complex, high-consequence, operational decisions every day. In order to prioritize organizational resourcing, NATO Commanders issue a series of critical information requirements to subordinate units that subsequently drive intelligence collection efforts. Alarmingly, these information requirements are often derived through subjective group (or individual) brainstorming sessions. Thus, the primary aim of this chapter is to introduce a novel approach to strengthen contemporary intelligence community practices for establishing information value, ultimately proposing the integration of quantitative measures of information utility to optimize intelligence collection planning. Enhancing the precision through which command information requirements are established can improve consequent intelligence priorities and associated processes. To illustrate this point, this chapter describes a hypothetical operational dilemma inspired by NATO's recent decision to deploy combat forces into Eastern Europe following Russia's annexation of Crimea in 2014. Through this lens, the outputs of an information utility function are compared to those produced by a contemporary structured analytic technique for intelligence analysis designed for the purpose of information evaluation. We show how fundamental elements associated with information-theoretic measures can overcome many limitations of contemporary information evaluation practice, and can be applied to modern NATO operational practice immediately.
- 27 June 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 445-461
Applying Information Theory to Validate Commanders' Critical Information Requirements
Intelligence organizations must routinely assess information value. North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) intelligence professionals inform complex, high-consequence, operational decisions every day. In order to prioritize organizational resourcing, NATO Commanders issue a series of critical information requirements to subordinate units that subsequently drive intelligence collection efforts. Alarmingly, these information requirements are often derived through subjective group (or individual) brainstorming sessions. Thus, the primary aim of this chapter is to introduce a novel approach to strengthen contemporary intelligence community practices for establishing information value, ultimately proposing the integration of quantitative measures of information utility to optimize intelligence collection planning. Enhancing the precision through which command information requirements are established can improve consequent intelligence priorities and associated processes. To illustrate this point, this chapter describes a hypothetical operational dilemma inspired by NATO's recent decision to deploy combat forces into Eastern Europe following Russia's annexation of Crimea in 2014. Through this lens, the outputs of an information utility function are compared to those produced by a contemporary structured analytic technique for intelligence analysis designed for the purpose of information evaluation. We show how fundamental elements associated with information-theoretic measures can overcome many limitations of contemporary information evaluation practice, and can be applied to modern NATO operational practice immediately.
- Top Cited Papers
- 21 June 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Human Behaviour
- Vol. 8 (6) , 1035-1043
Using games to understand the mind
Board, card or video games have been played by virtually every individual in the world. Games are popular because they are intuitive and fun. These distinctive qualities of games also make them ideal for studying the mind. By being intuitive, games provide a unique vantage point for understanding the inductive biases that support behaviour in more complex, ecological settings than traditional laboratory experiments. By being fun, games allow researchers to study new questions in cognition such as the meaning of ‘play’ and intrinsic motivation, while also supporting more extensive and diverse data collection by attracting many more participants. We describe the advantages and drawbacks of using games relative to standard laboratory-based experiments and lay out a set of recommendations on how to gain the most from using games to study cognition. We hope this Perspective will lead to a wider use of games as experimental paradigms, elevating the ecological validity, scale and robustness of research on the mind.
- 21 June 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Human Behaviour
- Vol. 8 (6) , 1035-1043
Top Cited PapersUsing games to understand the mind
Board, card or video games have been played by virtually every individual in the world. Games are popular because they are intuitive and fun. These distinctive qualities of games also make them ideal for studying the mind. By being intuitive, games provide a unique vantage point for understanding the inductive biases that support behaviour in more complex, ecological settings than traditional laboratory experiments. By being fun, games allow researchers to study new questions in cognition such as the meaning of ‘play’ and intrinsic motivation, while also supporting more extensive and diverse data collection by attracting many more participants. We describe the advantages and drawbacks of using games relative to standard laboratory-based experiments and lay out a set of recommendations on how to gain the most from using games to study cognition. We hope this Perspective will lead to a wider use of games as experimental paradigms, elevating the ecological validity, scale and robustness of research on the mind.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Decision
- Vol. 11 (1) , 60-85
The wisdom of the coherent: Improving correspondence with coherence-weighted aggregation.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Decision
- Vol. 11 (1) , 60-85
The wisdom of the coherent: Improving correspondence with coherence-weighted aggregation.
- Open Access
- 1 July 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Applying Information Theory to Validate Commanders’ Critical Information Requirements
The primary aim of this chapter is to introduce a novel approach to strengthen contemporary intelligence community practices for establishing intelligence collection priorities based on expected information value. We propose the integration of quantitative measures of information utility that have been discussed in the literature on information theory (Lindley, 1956; Nelson, 2005; Crupi & Tentori, 2014) as a method for optimizing intelligence collection planning. We argue that enhancing the effectiveness through which command information requirements are established can improve consequent intelligence collection priorities. We contrast this approach with the structured analytic technique (SAT) approach that is currently described as a method for prioritizing information requirements in intelligence collection. Specifically, we proceed with a review of the Indicators Validator (IV) SAT (Heuer & Pherson, 2008) for establishing information value, illustrating how it works, and where it falls short as an analytic method. Next, we introduce a quantitative information-theoretic measure of information utility called information gain (Lindley, 1956). We illustrate the contrast between these approaches using a practical example featuring a hypothetical North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) dilemma. This analysis shows how information gain overcomes many limitations of the IV technique, along with how it might be applied to modern NATO operational practice.
- 1 July 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessApplying Information Theory to Validate Commanders’ Critical Information Requirements
The primary aim of this chapter is to introduce a novel approach to strengthen contemporary intelligence community practices for establishing intelligence collection priorities based on expected information value. We propose the integration of quantitative measures of information utility that have been discussed in the literature on information theory (Lindley, 1956; Nelson, 2005; Crupi & Tentori, 2014) as a method for optimizing intelligence collection planning. We argue that enhancing the effectiveness through which command information requirements are established can improve consequent intelligence collection priorities. We contrast this approach with the structured analytic technique (SAT) approach that is currently described as a method for prioritizing information requirements in intelligence collection. Specifically, we proceed with a review of the Indicators Validator (IV) SAT (Heuer & Pherson, 2008) for establishing information value, illustrating how it works, and where it falls short as an analytic method. Next, we introduce a quantitative information-theoretic measure of information utility called information gain (Lindley, 1956). We illustrate the contrast between these approaches using a practical example featuring a hypothetical North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) dilemma. This analysis shows how information gain overcomes many limitations of the IV technique, along with how it might be applied to modern NATO operational practice.
- Open Access
- 1 February 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Using Games to Understand the Mind
Board, card, or video games have been played by virtually every individual in the world population, with both children and adults participating. Games are popular because they are intuitive and fun. These distinctive qualities of games also make them ideal as a platform for studying the mind. By being intuitive, games provide a unique vantage point for understanding the inductive biases that support behavior in more complex, ecological settings than traditional lab experiments. By being fun, games allow researchers to study new questions in cognition such as the meaning of "play'' and intrinsic motivation, while also supporting more extensive and diverse data collection by attracting many more participants. We describe both the advantages and drawbacks of using games relative to standard lab-based experiments and lay out a set of recommendations on how to gain the most from using games to study cognition. We hope this article will lead to a wider use of games as experimental paradigms, elevating the ecological validity, scale, and robustness of research on the mind.
- 1 February 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessUsing Games to Understand the Mind
Board, card, or video games have been played by virtually every individual in the world population, with both children and adults participating. Games are popular because they are intuitive and fun. These distinctive qualities of games also make them ideal as a platform for studying the mind. By being intuitive, games provide a unique vantage point for understanding the inductive biases that support behavior in more complex, ecological settings than traditional lab experiments. By being fun, games allow researchers to study new questions in cognition such as the meaning of "play'' and intrinsic motivation, while also supporting more extensive and diverse data collection by attracting many more participants. We describe both the advantages and drawbacks of using games relative to standard lab-based experiments and lay out a set of recommendations on how to gain the most from using games to study cognition. We hope this article will lead to a wider use of games as experimental paradigms, elevating the ecological validity, scale, and robustness of research on the mind.
- 1 July 2022
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Decision
- Vol. 9 (3) , 285-319
The likelihood difference heuristic and binary test selection given situation-specific utilities.
- 1 July 2022
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Decision
- Vol. 9 (3) , 285-319
The likelihood difference heuristic and binary test selection given situation-specific utilities.
- Open Access
- 10 November 2021
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Subjective probability is modulated by emotions
Information about risks and probabilities is ubiquitous in our environment, forming the basis for decisions in an uncertain world. Emotions are known to modulate subjective probability assessments when probabilistic information is emotionally valenced. Yet little is known about the role of emotions in subjective probability assessment of affectively neutral events. We investigated this in one correlational study (Study 1, N = 162) and one experimental study (Study 2, N = 119). As predicted, we found that emotional dominance modulated the degree of conservatism in respondents’ neutral probability estimates. Remarkably, this pattern also transferred to realistic risk assessments. Furthermore, respondents’ tendency to use the representativeness heuristic as a proxy for probability was increased in high dominance individuals. Our findings highlight the importance of considering emotions, particularly the little-understood emotion dimension dominance, in research on probabilistic cognition.
- 10 November 2021
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessSubjective probability is modulated by emotions
Information about risks and probabilities is ubiquitous in our environment, forming the basis for decisions in an uncertain world. Emotions are known to modulate subjective probability assessments when probabilistic information is emotionally valenced. Yet little is known about the role of emotions in subjective probability assessment of affectively neutral events. We investigated this in one correlational study (Study 1, N = 162) and one experimental study (Study 2, N = 119). As predicted, we found that emotional dominance modulated the degree of conservatism in respondents’ neutral probability estimates. Remarkably, this pattern also transferred to realistic risk assessments. Furthermore, respondents’ tendency to use the representativeness heuristic as a proxy for probability was increased in high dominance individuals. Our findings highlight the importance of considering emotions, particularly the little-understood emotion dimension dominance, in research on probabilistic cognition.
- Open Access
- 14 October 2021
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
The Likelihood Difference Heuristic and Binary Test Selection Given Situation-Specific Utilities
Consider the task of selecting a medical test to determine whether a patient has a particular disease. Normatively, this requires taking into account (i) the prior probability of the disease, (ii) the likelihood---for each available test---of obtaining a positive result if the medical condition is present or absent, respectively, and (iii) the utilities for both correct and incorrect treatment decisions based upon each possible test result. But these quantities may not be precisely known. Are there strategies that could help identify the test with the highest utility given incomplete information? Here we consider the Likelihood Difference Heuristic (LDH), a simple heuristic that selects the test with the highest difference between the likelihood of obtaining a true positive and a false positive test result, ignoring all other information. We prove that the LDH is optimal when the probability of the disease equals the therapeutic threshold, the probability for which treating the patient and not treating the patient have the same expected utility. By contrast, prominent models of the value of information from the literature, such as information gain, probability gain, and Bayesian diagnosticity, are not optimal under these circumstances. Further results show how, depending on the relationship of the therapeutic threshold and prior probability of the disease, it is possible to determine which likelihoods are more important for assessing tests' expected utilities. Finally, to illustrate the potential relevance for real-life contexts, we show how the LDH might be applied to choosing tests for screening of latent tuberculosis infection.
- 14 October 2021
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessThe Likelihood Difference Heuristic and Binary Test Selection Given Situation-Specific Utilities
Consider the task of selecting a medical test to determine whether a patient has a particular disease. Normatively, this requires taking into account (i) the prior probability of the disease, (ii) the likelihood---for each available test---of obtaining a positive result if the medical condition is present or absent, respectively, and (iii) the utilities for both correct and incorrect treatment decisions based upon each possible test result. But these quantities may not be precisely known. Are there strategies that could help identify the test with the highest utility given incomplete information? Here we consider the Likelihood Difference Heuristic (LDH), a simple heuristic that selects the test with the highest difference between the likelihood of obtaining a true positive and a false positive test result, ignoring all other information. We prove that the LDH is optimal when the probability of the disease equals the therapeutic threshold, the probability for which treating the patient and not treating the patient have the same expected utility. By contrast, prominent models of the value of information from the literature, such as information gain, probability gain, and Bayesian diagnosticity, are not optimal under these circumstances. Further results show how, depending on the relationship of the therapeutic threshold and prior probability of the disease, it is possible to determine which likelihoods are more important for assessing tests' expected utilities. Finally, to illustrate the potential relevance for real-life contexts, we show how the LDH might be applied to choosing tests for screening of latent tuberculosis infection.
- Open Access
- 30 June 2021
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Education
- Vol. 6
Playing Entropy Mastermind can Foster Children’s Information-Theoretical Intuitions
Conceptual descriptions and measures of information and entropy were established in the twentieth century with the emergence of a science of communication and information. Today these concepts have come to pervade modern science and society, and are increasingly being recommended as topics for science and mathematics education. We introduce a set of playful activities aimed at fostering intuitions about entropy and describe a primary school intervention that was conducted according to this plan. Fourth grade schoolchildren (8–10 years) played a version of Entropy Mastermind with jars and colored marbles, in which a hidden code to be deciphered was generated at random from an urn with a known, visually presented probability distribution of marble colors. Children prepared urns according to specified recipes, drew marbles from the urns, generated codes and guessed codes. Despite not being formally instructed in probability or entropy, children were able to estimate and compare the difficulty of different probability distributions used for generating possible codes.
- 30 June 2021
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Education
- Vol. 6
Open AccessPlaying Entropy Mastermind can Foster Children’s Information-Theoretical Intuitions
Conceptual descriptions and measures of information and entropy were established in the twentieth century with the emergence of a science of communication and information. Today these concepts have come to pervade modern science and society, and are increasingly being recommended as topics for science and mathematics education. We introduce a set of playful activities aimed at fostering intuitions about entropy and describe a primary school intervention that was conducted according to this plan. Fourth grade schoolchildren (8–10 years) played a version of Entropy Mastermind with jars and colored marbles, in which a hidden code to be deciphered was generated at random from an urn with a known, visually presented probability distribution of marble colors. Children prepared urns according to specified recipes, drew marbles from the urns, generated codes and guessed codes. Despite not being formally instructed in probability or entropy, children were able to estimate and compare the difficulty of different probability distributions used for generating possible codes.