SKShane Kilcommins

Shane Kilcommins

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Shane Kilcommins has a total of 14 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Ireland

    by Ger Coffey, Shane Kilcommins

    The Elgar Encyclopedia of Crime and Criminal Justice stands apart as the most comprehensive global reference title in its field. New entries will be added every month and PDF downloads will be available once the Encyclopedia is complete.

  • People With Intellectual Disabilities as Accused Persons in the Irish Policing Interface

    by Alan Cusack, Gautam Gulati, Colum P. Dunne, Shane Kilcommins

    This chapter sets out the policy context for people with intellectual disabilities interfacing with police as accused persons in Ireland. Against a backdrop of relevant international obligations, it outlines recent research-based developments in this field. It further sets out to discuss domestic safeguards that shape the treatment of individuals at this interface. It discusses five key safeguards in this context: access to a solicitor, right to medical assistance, access to specialist interviewers, the responsible adult safeguard, and accessible information. Recommendations are made to offer policymakers a blueprint for legislative and procedural reform that promises to align Irish criminal procedure with the human rights exigencies mandated under international conventions.


  • Vulnerable Suspects, Access to a Lawyer and the Right to a Fair Trial in Ireland

    by Alan Cusack, Shane Kilcommins, Gautam Gulati, Colum Dunne

    It is well established internationally that children, as well as individuals with intellectual disabilities, face particular challenges in negotiating the forensic formalities adopted by police at the pre-trial stage of the criminal process. Owing to limitations in cognitive and linguistic development, the testimonial accuracy of police-elicited accounts yielded from these individuals has been found to attract a heightened risk of narrative bias which can vary depending upon the types of questions asked, the status of the person asking them and the formality of the arena in which the interrogation takes place. For persons suspected of crime, the distortive impact of these psychological vulnerabilities can result in serious punitive consequences. In recognition of the unique challenges facing vulnerable suspects in police custody across Europe, a distinct line of Strasbourg jurisprudence has emerged in recent years that emphasises the need for all states to facilitate meaningful access to a lawyer during a suspect’s period of detainment. Most recently, this line of inculpatory logic found expression in the Chambers of Strasbourg in Doyle v Ireland (51979/17), where – although refusing to overrule the decision of Ireland’s Supreme Court – the European Court of Human Rights was openly critical of the Supreme Court’s failure to recognise Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights as incorporating a suspect’s right to have a lawyer physically present during a police interview. Against the backdrop of such emergent juridical activism, this chapter calibrates the right to reasonable access to a lawyer in Ireland, with a particular emphasis on the position of vulnerable suspects of crime.

  • Towards inclusionary policing: a critical inquiry into the pre-trial treatment of suspects with intellectual disabilities in Ireland

    by Alan Cusack, Gautam Gulati, Colum P. Dunne, Shane Kilcommins

    Purpose: This paper aims to critically evaluate contemporary Irish police practice, with an emphasis on emergent procedural innovations, in light of the needs of suspects with intellectual disabilities.Design/methodology/approach: A review of published prevalence data in respect of people with intellectual disabilities in the Irish criminal justice system, of the Irish legal and policy landscape and the results of a recent empirical inquiry are used in critical evaluation.Findings: In line with extant international research, the article identifies three sites of concern with respect to the protocols that exist within An Garda Síochána for identifying and responding to intellectual disability, including: (1) barriers to communication; (2) a need to build awareness and skills for police and persons with intellectual disabilities; and (3) a need for institutional change to secure equal access to justice for people with intellectual disabilities. Progress is being made at a systems level towards a human rights approach in Irish policing.Originality/value: In representing the first international analysis of its kind, the article locates the barriers confronting suspects with intellectual disabilities in Ireland within a discourse that is sensitive to ongoing research-led, procedural reforms within An Garda Síochána (Ireland's national police service). Owing to the universalised nature of these barriers across policing systems internationally, the format of these reforms from this will be of relevance to many other policing states, in particular the 162 other signatories to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of People with Disabilities.


  • Conclusion

    by Shane Kilcommins, Susan Leahy, Kathleen Moore Walsh, Eimear Spain

    This conclusion presents an overview of the key concepts discussed in the preceding chapters of this book. The book examines the criminal justice system's interactions with victims of crime. It demonstrates the 'conditions of possibility' of the return of victims of crime by examining the factors that shaped this emergence and informed its assumptions. The book focuses on 'rupture', 'discontinuity' and the 'incidence of interruptions' in order to produce a proper understanding of this emergence. It considers service provision for victims of crime. The book charts the challenges which continue to face service users, providers and the wider criminal justice sector in the delivery of services which are responsive to the needs of victims and meet increased demands under the EU Directive on Victims' Rights.

  • Open Access

    The Victim in Law – The Emergence of a New Juridical Subject in the Crime Conflict

    by Shane Kilcommins

    There has been growing recognition of the interests and needs of victims in the law arena, where previous emphasis had been predominantly on the rights of the accused and the offender. The result, in Ireland and in other jurisdictions, has been a series of developments which seek to enhance their status in relation to the alleged wrongdoing. Via the deliberative capacity of domestic and EU legislatures drawing upon the (admittedly imperfect) opinion and will formation of its citizens, together with expansive judicial interpretation of constitutional and convention texts, we are slowly discovering that rights in the criminal process are not confined to an exclusive caste, anchored to a fixed date in history. All of this impetus is largely inclusionary. The ‘axis of individualisation’ in the criminal justice process − which for so long was directed only at offenders, the causes of their wrongdoing and their right to protection from the state − has now bifurcated to embrace the multi-faceted experiences of victimhood. This of course disturbs older, hegemonic ways of doing things (an accused/offender-organising logic that infused a police–public interest-prosecutions-prisons model of justice) and the reified, exclusive voices of certain actors that were central to that process (prosecution and defence lawyers, policing authorities, and judges). Its recent emergence must be seen much more as a response to a previous scandalous neglect, as a justified attempt to correct an imbalance in which the victim was constituted as a ‘silent abstraction, a background figure whose individuality hardly registered’. The purpose of this article is to demonstrate how victims of crime are again being recognised as a ‘community of identity’. This reshapes the construction and presentation of intersubjective criminal conflict, not least because pluralism of this kind generates competing interests, priorities and validity claims in the decision-making process. Momentum of this kind makes it more difficult to rely exclusively on tradition and previously settled conventions of practice. The criminal process is thus slowly moving from a monolithic culture of rights to cultures of rights that reflect ‘multiple identities’ which are deserving of concern and respect.

  • Open Access

    Defining Corporate, White – Collar and Regulatory Crime: Offences, Defences and Procedure

    by Shane Kilcommins

    New approaches adopted to tackle white-collar crime have unsettled traditional commitments and assumptions about the operation of the criminal process. More nuanced understandings of harm and ‘systems risks’, for example, are emerging, including a growing recognition of the harm done to ordinary citizens through misconduct in the financial and corporate sectors and through misconduct in the political arena. A new governmental approach has emerged in light of the changing nature and perception of security risks, employing a variety of mechanisms (civil, administrative and regulatory) in tandem with criminal law instruments. Technological changes and a recognition that the disequilibrium in power between the State and the accused is no longer as pronounced are also impacting on constructions of State-accused relations. New investigative and prosecutorial networks are also emerging that in part rely on information gathering and information transfer beyond the traditional reach of the police and prosecution agencies. These changes are occurring against the backdrop of a delegation of power to an extensive range of specialist agencies with wide investigative powers and supported by a wide range of criminal sanctions available summarily and on indictment. There is also evidence of an increasing willingness to imprison individuals convicted of serious corporate crime. In this chapter we begin by examining the concept of white-collar crime, including its scope, cause and consequences, before exploring some of the changes which are impacting upon traditional understandings of the criminal process and the changing nature of the power used by the State in its battle against white-collar crime.

  • Open Access

    The victim in the Irish criminal process: a journey from dispossession towards partial repossession

    by Shane Kilcommins

    This article has sought to examine the criminal justice system’s interactions with victims of crime. It is a relationship which has changed irrevocably over time. A significant discontinuity occurred in the nineteenth century when a new architecture of criminal and penal semiotics slowly emerged. An institutional way of knowing interpersonal conflict crystallised, one which reified system relations over personal experiences. It also emphasised new ideals and values such as proportionality, legalism, procedural rationality, equality and uniformity. New commitments, discourses and practices came to the fore in the criminal justice network. In modernity, the problem of criminal wrongdoing became a rationalised domain of action, a site which actively distrusted and excluded ‘non-objective’ truth claims. The state, the law, the accused and the public interest became the principal claims-makers within this institutional and normative arrangement, an arrangement which would dominate criminal and penal relations for the next 150 years. In the last 40 years, the victim has slowly re-emerged as a stakeholder in the criminal process.

  • The absence of regulatory crime from the criminal law curriculum

    by Shane Kilcommins, Susan Leahy, Eimear Spain

    The teaching of criminal law should be extended beyond a focus on a relatively narrow taxonomy of offences and contestable principles - such as subjective culpability - to incorporate regulatory criminal wrongdoing. It is hardly contentious that our criminal justice system is founded on the identification of public protection and security as 'essential goods' to enable us to flourish and go about our lives free from the threat of injury or harm. At a more technocratic level, many aspects of regulatory crime operate in opposition to the general trend of paradigmatic criminal law which permits general defences, demands both a conduct element and a fault element, and respects procedural standards such as a legal burden of proof beyond reasonable doubt. The number of administrative agencies that have entered the criminal justice arena, colonising the power to investigate regulatory crimes in specific areas and to prosecute summarily, has increased dramatically in Ireland in recent years.


  • “Deaths in Prison Custody” Capstone Course: Engaging Final-Year Law Students In Service Learning and Public Value

    by Shane Kilcommins, Eimear Spain

    Capstone service learning courses are designed to overcome the negative effects of fractioned knowledge by enabling students to consolidate and apply what they have learned over a program of study. They also promote a scholarship of engagement. This article documents the learning experiences of students on a Deaths in Prison Custody capstone service learning course. Though such a criminal justice course requires significant staff input and involves some loss of educational control, it has many benefits including enhanced learning, meaningful service, public value, and civic engagement. The focus on this article is on student learning experiences. It outlines how the pragmatic focus of such a course made knowledge and student learning relevant and actionable. It also describes how the deliberately unstructured design of the course, together with its emphasis on pubic value, encouraged autonomous and self-directed learning, prompting the students to take greater ownership of their learning.