ACAlan Cusack

Alan Cusack

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Alan Cusack has a total of 12 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Exploring readiness for implementation of an intermediary scheme in the Irish context: Findings from a mixed-data survey

    by Laura Zelenika, Camille Ryan, Aoife Gallagher, Alan Cusack, Aine Kearns

    Intermediaries are professionals who facilitate communication for vulnerable individuals in legal proceedings. Recently, Ireland has advanced the intermediary role by launching an accredited training programme and establishing a court intermediary register. This study examines the perceived readiness of the first two cohorts of newly qualified intermediaries for the implementation of a national scheme in Ireland. A descriptive cross-sectional study used quantitative and qualitative data from a purposive sample of newly qualified intermediaries via an online Qualtrics survey. Quantitative data were analysed descriptively, and qualitative data were analysed via content analysis. Participants felt confident in assessing communication and explaining their role but less prepared for court interventions or defending their position; they valued simulated learning over acquisition-based methods. Key practitioner challenges included role ambiguity, limited sustainability and lack of supervision, while system-level barriers centred on stakeholder resistance. Strengthening the intermediary role and access to justice may involve increasing stakeholder awareness and professional development.

  • Open Access

    Criminological Others: An Inquiry into the Construction and Legal Standing of Suspects with Intellectual Disabilities in Ireland

    by Alan Cusack

    Irish policymakers have evinced a distinct willingness in recent years to reconstruct pre-trial and trial practices in order to demonstrate an increased sensitivity for the needs and concerns of victims of crime with intellectual disabilities. However, the same cannot be said for suspects with intellectual disabilities who remain subject to an unrevised custodial framework that is almost four decades old. In an effort to appraise this framework through the lens of Nils Christie’s ‘not-so-ideal offender’ abstraction, this article surveys a number of discrete sites within Ireland’s pre-trial landscape where a tension is arguably apparent between mainstream criminal procedure, on the one hand, and the ontological realities of intellectual impairment, on the other. Through this analysis the article highlights the need to reconstruct suspect identities at a policy and procedural level and, in doing so, makes the case for greater legislative activism with regard to the procedural treatment of suspects with intellectual disabilities.

  • Open Access

    Establishing stakeholder priorities for advancing the role of the intermediary in the justice system: Findings from a consensus study

    by Aoife Lily Gallagher, Alan Cusack, Áine Kearns, Brendan M. O’mAhony, John Taggart

    At the forefront of efforts to enhance effective communication between vulnerable persons and stakeholders within the legal system has been the introduction of the intermediary. Embedding the role of the intermediary has presented complex challenges across jurisdictions. We report on phase one of a study involving a purposive sample ( n  = 60) of diverse stakeholders across the Island of Ireland in which priorities for policy, research and practice were generated using a modified nominal group technique. We identified six priority areas: (i) formalising the role; (ii) building awareness and understanding; (iii) establishing mechanisms of professional development and support; (iv) undertaking service evaluation and research; (v) supporting cross-sectoral working; and (vi) ensuring equality of access to intermediaries. In the next phase of the study, priorities of individuals who have experience of using intermediary accommodations will be identified. Findings from both studies will be integrated to provide robust recommendations for policy makers to further advance the role of the intermediary in the justice system.


  • Open Access

    Navigating the right to a fair trial for vulnerable suspects pretrial: a legal and psychological critique of the Strasbourg jurisprudence

    by Alan Cusack, Roxanna Dehaghani

    Pretrial criminal processes can prove challenging for suspects with intellectual and psychosocial disabilities. In recognition of this, the European Court of Human Rights has emphasized the importance of individualized assessments of vulnerability under Article 6. Yet, recent Strasbourg jurisprudence reveals a juridical willingness to define vulnerability narrowly with significant implications. This article analyses this jurisprudence to excavate the framing of vulnerability vis-à-vis fair trial rights during pretrial processes. Drawing upon a corpus of psychology and law literature, as well as the dissenting judgment in Hasáliková, it critiques the narrow formulation of vulnerability that has taken hold in Strasbourg and interrogates the Court’s ostensible faith in the safeguarding capacity of lawyers. By using Ireland’s weak pretrial procedural framework as a heuristic lens through which the shortcomings of this approach can be understood, it calls for a more generous conceptualization of vulnerability that is sensitive to the ontological and structural dimensions at play.


  • People With Intellectual Disabilities as Accused Persons in the Irish Policing Interface

    by Alan Cusack, Gautam Gulati, Colum P. Dunne, Shane Kilcommins

    This chapter sets out the policy context for people with intellectual disabilities interfacing with police as accused persons in Ireland. Against a backdrop of relevant international obligations, it outlines recent research-based developments in this field. It further sets out to discuss domestic safeguards that shape the treatment of individuals at this interface. It discusses five key safeguards in this context: access to a solicitor, right to medical assistance, access to specialist interviewers, the responsible adult safeguard, and accessible information. Recommendations are made to offer policymakers a blueprint for legislative and procedural reform that promises to align Irish criminal procedure with the human rights exigencies mandated under international conventions.


  • Vulnerable Suspects, Access to a Lawyer and the Right to a Fair Trial in Ireland

    by Alan Cusack, Shane Kilcommins, Gautam Gulati, Colum Dunne

    It is well established internationally that children, as well as individuals with intellectual disabilities, face particular challenges in negotiating the forensic formalities adopted by police at the pre-trial stage of the criminal process. Owing to limitations in cognitive and linguistic development, the testimonial accuracy of police-elicited accounts yielded from these individuals has been found to attract a heightened risk of narrative bias which can vary depending upon the types of questions asked, the status of the person asking them and the formality of the arena in which the interrogation takes place. For persons suspected of crime, the distortive impact of these psychological vulnerabilities can result in serious punitive consequences. In recognition of the unique challenges facing vulnerable suspects in police custody across Europe, a distinct line of Strasbourg jurisprudence has emerged in recent years that emphasises the need for all states to facilitate meaningful access to a lawyer during a suspect’s period of detainment. Most recently, this line of inculpatory logic found expression in the Chambers of Strasbourg in Doyle v Ireland (51979/17), where – although refusing to overrule the decision of Ireland’s Supreme Court – the European Court of Human Rights was openly critical of the Supreme Court’s failure to recognise Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights as incorporating a suspect’s right to have a lawyer physically present during a police interview. Against the backdrop of such emergent juridical activism, this chapter calibrates the right to reasonable access to a lawyer in Ireland, with a particular emphasis on the position of vulnerable suspects of crime.

  • Towards inclusionary policing: a critical inquiry into the pre-trial treatment of suspects with intellectual disabilities in Ireland

    by Alan Cusack, Gautam Gulati, Colum P. Dunne, Shane Kilcommins

    Purpose: This paper aims to critically evaluate contemporary Irish police practice, with an emphasis on emergent procedural innovations, in light of the needs of suspects with intellectual disabilities.Design/methodology/approach: A review of published prevalence data in respect of people with intellectual disabilities in the Irish criminal justice system, of the Irish legal and policy landscape and the results of a recent empirical inquiry are used in critical evaluation.Findings: In line with extant international research, the article identifies three sites of concern with respect to the protocols that exist within An Garda Síochána for identifying and responding to intellectual disability, including: (1) barriers to communication; (2) a need to build awareness and skills for police and persons with intellectual disabilities; and (3) a need for institutional change to secure equal access to justice for people with intellectual disabilities. Progress is being made at a systems level towards a human rights approach in Irish policing.Originality/value: In representing the first international analysis of its kind, the article locates the barriers confronting suspects with intellectual disabilities in Ireland within a discourse that is sensitive to ongoing research-led, procedural reforms within An Garda Síochána (Ireland's national police service). Owing to the universalised nature of these barriers across policing systems internationally, the format of these reforms from this will be of relevance to many other policing states, in particular the 162 other signatories to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of People with Disabilities.


  • Reforming Ireland’s Adversarial Trial for Victims of Crime with Intellectual Disabilities

    by Alan Cusack

    The people most impacted by criminal justice policies and practices are seldom included in the decision-making processes that affect their lives. Building on th...

  • Addressing vulnerability in Ireland’s criminal justice system: A survey of recent statutory developments

    by Alan Cusack

    For over a quarter of century Ireland’s statutory special measures framework, as originally enacted by the Criminal Evidence Act 1992, remained largely unchanged, falling beyond the reformative gaze of successive Irish governments. This period of political inertia, however, came to an abrupt end in 2017 when Irish policymakers, motivated by developments at a European Union level, introduced two landmark legislative instruments which promised to reimagine the availability and diversity of Ireland’s store of statutory testimonial accommodations, namely the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act 2017 and the Criminal Justice (Victims of Crime) Act 2017. By interrogating these newly-commenced instruments in light of the experience of crime victims with intellectual disabilities, this paper surveys the current procedural landscape governing the treatment of vulnerable crime victims in Ireland and is intended to go some way towards exposing the embedded evidential barriers which continue to prejudice efforts aimed at securing their best evidence in court.