Clare Stephens
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Clare Stephens has a total of 60 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Lucy Marshall
Faculty of Engineering The University of Sydney Sydney NSW Australia
9 shared publications - Fiona Johnson
Water Research Centre, School of Civil and Environmental Engineering, UNSW Sydney, Australia
8 shared publications - Gabrielle Burns
Department of Infrastructure Engineering, The University of Melbourne, Parkville, VIC Australia
7 shared publications - Keirnan Fowler
Department of Infrastructure Engineering, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, 3010, Victoria, Australia
7 shared publications - Murray Cameron Peel
Department of Infrastructure Engineering University of Melbourne Parkville VIC Australia
7 shared publications - Belinda E. Medlyn
Hawkesbury Institute for the Environment Western Sydney University Richmond New South Wales Australia
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 17 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Hydrology and Earth System Sciences
- Vol. 30 (14) , 4509-4528
A systematic evaluation of 15 actual evapotranspiration formulations within conceptual hydrological models
Actual evapotranspiration (AET) is a major component of the water balance, yet it is rarely assessed for accuracy in conceptual rainfall-runoff models that are often calibrated to match streamflow only. Inaccurate representation of underlying AET processes may cause models to incorrectly simulate long-term changes in partitioning between AET and streamflow, even if this partitioning was relatively accurate during calibration. To investigate AET representation within conceptual hydrological models, we systematically tested 15 evapotranspiration (ET) equations that convert potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture to AET. The 15 equations represent common practice, having been sourced from a published comprehensive review of conceptual hydrological models. Each of these 15 formulations were trialled within three conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd and Vic). Following multi-objective calibration, we evaluated performance across both streamflow and flux tower AET measurements at seven catchments from a range of Australian climates. A small number of AET equations outperformed the rest, with one equation standing out, which uses a non-linear relationship with soil moisture storage and can scale down AET such that it cannot equal PET even under high soil moisture conditions. This equation achieved a higher objective function value for both AET and streamflow and accurately captured evapotranspiration signatures. However, even this equation showed limitations in reproducing observed AET, suggesting persistent issues across commonly used formulations. These shortcomings may reflect missing vegetation-related dynamics and other simplifications. Our findings highlight the importance of ET equation selection in modelling AET and streamflow, and we recommend the identified equation as a promising option for future Australian studies. Further work is needed to test equations for consistency with known processes to improve the physical realism of conceptual hydrological models.
- 17 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Hydrology and Earth System Sciences
- Vol. 30 (14) , 4509-4528
Open AccessA systematic evaluation of 15 actual evapotranspiration formulations within conceptual hydrological models
Actual evapotranspiration (AET) is a major component of the water balance, yet it is rarely assessed for accuracy in conceptual rainfall-runoff models that are often calibrated to match streamflow only. Inaccurate representation of underlying AET processes may cause models to incorrectly simulate long-term changes in partitioning between AET and streamflow, even if this partitioning was relatively accurate during calibration. To investigate AET representation within conceptual hydrological models, we systematically tested 15 evapotranspiration (ET) equations that convert potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture to AET. The 15 equations represent common practice, having been sourced from a published comprehensive review of conceptual hydrological models. Each of these 15 formulations were trialled within three conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd and Vic). Following multi-objective calibration, we evaluated performance across both streamflow and flux tower AET measurements at seven catchments from a range of Australian climates. A small number of AET equations outperformed the rest, with one equation standing out, which uses a non-linear relationship with soil moisture storage and can scale down AET such that it cannot equal PET even under high soil moisture conditions. This equation achieved a higher objective function value for both AET and streamflow and accurately captured evapotranspiration signatures. However, even this equation showed limitations in reproducing observed AET, suggesting persistent issues across commonly used formulations. These shortcomings may reflect missing vegetation-related dynamics and other simplifications. Our findings highlight the importance of ET equation selection in modelling AET and streamflow, and we recommend the identified equation as a promising option for future Australian studies. Further work is needed to test equations for consistency with known processes to improve the physical realism of conceptual hydrological models.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Estimating the stomatal slope (g1) parameter from the Medlyn model across Australian vegetation using multiple observational datasets
Stomatal conductance plays a key role in the exchange of carbon and water between vegetation and the atmosphere, by controlling photosynthesis and transpiration in plants. However, its representation in land surface models (LSMs) is still considered a major source of uncertainty. The Medlyn model is widely used in LSMs to describe how strongly stomata and the model parameter g1 respond to carbon uptake and atmospheric dryness. This parameter is often introduced as a fixed value in global LSMs for broad vegetation types despite evidence that stomatal behaviour varies with plant water availability, particularly in water limited ecosystems such as those found in large parts of Australia.We estimated g1 for Australian vegetation using observational data obtained from three intrinsic water use efficiency techniques: leaf gas exchange, stable carbon isotope discrimination, and eddy covariance. These approaches together can provide a comprehensive knowledge on the estimation of g1 across a range of spatial and temporal scales, from leaf to ecosystem and from short to long term responses. To account for water stress, we relate g1 to soil moisture for both leaf-scale gas exchange and eddy covariance datasets, where direct plant water status measurements are rarely available. For the stable isotope dataset, water stress is represented using an aridity index that reflects longer-term water limitation experienced by plants over the period of carbon assimilation.We compared g1 estimates from these datasets along with soil moisture data to observe the shifts in the sensitivity of stomata under dry conditions and to determine consistency between scales. We found that g1 varied systematically across Australian plant functional types (PFTs), with lower values in xeric shrubs and C4 grasses and higher values in savanna and rainforest trees. Relative differences among PFTs were consistent across methods, but isotope-derived g1 values were generally higher than leaf gas exchange estimates. Eddy covariance data from Australian flux-tower sites showed a clear increasing trend in g1 with increasing soil moisture, and isotope-derived g1 decreased with increasing aridity, indicating more conservative stomatal behaviour under dry conditions.These findings will be used to generate representative values of g1 for Australian PFTs that can be implemented in land surface models (e.g., The Joint UK Land Environment Simulator JULES) for evaluation at flux-tower sites and the continental scale.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessEstimating the stomatal slope (g1) parameter from the Medlyn model across Australian vegetation using multiple observational datasets
Stomatal conductance plays a key role in the exchange of carbon and water between vegetation and the atmosphere, by controlling photosynthesis and transpiration in plants. However, its representation in land surface models (LSMs) is still considered a major source of uncertainty. The Medlyn model is widely used in LSMs to describe how strongly stomata and the model parameter g1 respond to carbon uptake and atmospheric dryness. This parameter is often introduced as a fixed value in global LSMs for broad vegetation types despite evidence that stomatal behaviour varies with plant water availability, particularly in water limited ecosystems such as those found in large parts of Australia.We estimated g1 for Australian vegetation using observational data obtained from three intrinsic water use efficiency techniques: leaf gas exchange, stable carbon isotope discrimination, and eddy covariance. These approaches together can provide a comprehensive knowledge on the estimation of g1 across a range of spatial and temporal scales, from leaf to ecosystem and from short to long term responses. To account for water stress, we relate g1 to soil moisture for both leaf-scale gas exchange and eddy covariance datasets, where direct plant water status measurements are rarely available. For the stable isotope dataset, water stress is represented using an aridity index that reflects longer-term water limitation experienced by plants over the period of carbon assimilation.We compared g1 estimates from these datasets along with soil moisture data to observe the shifts in the sensitivity of stomata under dry conditions and to determine consistency between scales. We found that g1 varied systematically across Australian plant functional types (PFTs), with lower values in xeric shrubs and C4 grasses and higher values in savanna and rainforest trees. Relative differences among PFTs were consistent across methods, but isotope-derived g1 values were generally higher than leaf gas exchange estimates. Eddy covariance data from Australian flux-tower sites showed a clear increasing trend in g1 with increasing soil moisture, and isotope-derived g1 decreased with increasing aridity, indicating more conservative stomatal behaviour under dry conditions.These findings will be used to generate representative values of g1 for Australian PFTs that can be implemented in land surface models (e.g., The Joint UK Land Environment Simulator JULES) for evaluation at flux-tower sites and the continental scale.
- Open Access
- 24 November 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-30
Comment on egusphere-2025-3122
Actual evapotranspiration (AET) is a major component of the water balance, yet it is rarely assessed for accuracy in conceptual rainfall-runoff models that are often calibrated to match streamflow only. Inaccurate representation of underlying AET processes may cause models to incorrectly simulate long-term changes in partitioning between AET and streamflow, even if this partitioning was relatively accurate during calibration. To investigate AET representation within conceptual hydrological models, we systematically tested 15 evapotranspiration (ET) equations that convert potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture to AET. The 15 equations represent common practice, having been sourced from a published comprehensive review of conceptual hydrological models. Each of these 15 formulations were trialled within three conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd and Vic). Following multi-objective calibration, we evaluated performance across both streamflow and flux tower AET measurements at seven catchments from a range of Australian climates. A small number of AET equations outperformed the rest, with one equation standing out, which uses a non-linear relationship with soil moisture storage and can scale down AET such that it cannot equal PET. This equation achieved a higher objective function value for both AET and streamflow and accurately captured evapotranspiration signatures. However, even this equation showed limitations in reproducing observed AET, suggesting persistent issues across commonly used formulations. These shortcomings may reflect missing vegetation-related dynamics and other simplifications. Our findings highlight the importance of ET equation selection in modelling AET and streamflow, and we recommend the identified equation as a promising option for future Australian studies. Further work is needed to test equations for consistency with known processes to improve the physical realism of conceptual hydrological models.
- 24 November 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-30
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2025-3122
Actual evapotranspiration (AET) is a major component of the water balance, yet it is rarely assessed for accuracy in conceptual rainfall-runoff models that are often calibrated to match streamflow only. Inaccurate representation of underlying AET processes may cause models to incorrectly simulate long-term changes in partitioning between AET and streamflow, even if this partitioning was relatively accurate during calibration. To investigate AET representation within conceptual hydrological models, we systematically tested 15 evapotranspiration (ET) equations that convert potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture to AET. The 15 equations represent common practice, having been sourced from a published comprehensive review of conceptual hydrological models. Each of these 15 formulations were trialled within three conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd and Vic). Following multi-objective calibration, we evaluated performance across both streamflow and flux tower AET measurements at seven catchments from a range of Australian climates. A small number of AET equations outperformed the rest, with one equation standing out, which uses a non-linear relationship with soil moisture storage and can scale down AET such that it cannot equal PET. This equation achieved a higher objective function value for both AET and streamflow and accurately captured evapotranspiration signatures. However, even this equation showed limitations in reproducing observed AET, suggesting persistent issues across commonly used formulations. These shortcomings may reflect missing vegetation-related dynamics and other simplifications. Our findings highlight the importance of ET equation selection in modelling AET and streamflow, and we recommend the identified equation as a promising option for future Australian studies. Further work is needed to test equations for consistency with known processes to improve the physical realism of conceptual hydrological models.
- Open Access
- 22 September 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-30
Comment on egusphere-2025-3122
Actual evapotranspiration (AET) is a major component of the water balance, yet it is rarely assessed for accuracy in conceptual rainfall-runoff models that are often calibrated to match streamflow only. Inaccurate representation of underlying AET processes may cause models to incorrectly simulate long-term changes in partitioning between AET and streamflow, even if this partitioning was relatively accurate during calibration. To investigate AET representation within conceptual hydrological models, we systematically tested 15 evapotranspiration (ET) equations that convert potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture to AET. The 15 equations represent common practice, having been sourced from a published comprehensive review of conceptual hydrological models. Each of these 15 formulations were trialled within three conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd and Vic). Following multi-objective calibration, we evaluated performance across both streamflow and flux tower AET measurements at seven catchments from a range of Australian climates. A small number of AET equations outperformed the rest, with one equation standing out, which uses a non-linear relationship with soil moisture storage and can scale down AET such that it cannot equal PET. This equation achieved a higher objective function value for both AET and streamflow and accurately captured evapotranspiration signatures. However, even this equation showed limitations in reproducing observed AET, suggesting persistent issues across commonly used formulations. These shortcomings may reflect missing vegetation-related dynamics and other simplifications. Our findings highlight the importance of ET equation selection in modelling AET and streamflow, and we recommend the identified equation as a promising option for future Australian studies. Further work is needed to test equations for consistency with known processes to improve the physical realism of conceptual hydrological models.
- 22 September 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-30
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2025-3122
Actual evapotranspiration (AET) is a major component of the water balance, yet it is rarely assessed for accuracy in conceptual rainfall-runoff models that are often calibrated to match streamflow only. Inaccurate representation of underlying AET processes may cause models to incorrectly simulate long-term changes in partitioning between AET and streamflow, even if this partitioning was relatively accurate during calibration. To investigate AET representation within conceptual hydrological models, we systematically tested 15 evapotranspiration (ET) equations that convert potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture to AET. The 15 equations represent common practice, having been sourced from a published comprehensive review of conceptual hydrological models. Each of these 15 formulations were trialled within three conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd and Vic). Following multi-objective calibration, we evaluated performance across both streamflow and flux tower AET measurements at seven catchments from a range of Australian climates. A small number of AET equations outperformed the rest, with one equation standing out, which uses a non-linear relationship with soil moisture storage and can scale down AET such that it cannot equal PET. This equation achieved a higher objective function value for both AET and streamflow and accurately captured evapotranspiration signatures. However, even this equation showed limitations in reproducing observed AET, suggesting persistent issues across commonly used formulations. These shortcomings may reflect missing vegetation-related dynamics and other simplifications. Our findings highlight the importance of ET equation selection in modelling AET and streamflow, and we recommend the identified equation as a promising option for future Australian studies. Further work is needed to test equations for consistency with known processes to improve the physical realism of conceptual hydrological models.
- Open Access
- 28 August 2025
- Published by Wiley in Plants, People, Planet
- Vol. 8 (2) , 461-485
Detecting and attributing climate change effects on vegetation: Australia as a test case
Societal Impact Statement: Climate change is contributing to vegetation changes that threaten life support systems. Yet, inherent climatic variability and past and present human actions—such as clearing, burning and grazing regimes—also alter vegetation and complicate understanding of vegetation change. Australian ecosystems exemplify such complexity. To predict future vegetation changes, proactively guide management and ensure persistent drivers do not disrupt intended outcomes, we need to untangle the effects of these various change drivers on vegetation. Such attribution of change, which is rarely done, requires historical context, long‐term datasets of vegetation and environmental drivers and integrating data with process‐based understanding. Summary: Climate change is expected to affect vegetation: associated rising atmospheric CO 2 , higher temperatures and more variable and extreme rainfall regimes can all cause major shifts in vegetation composition, structure and function. Such effects need to be detected to confirm understanding and to inform models that can predict future vegetation change and guide management efforts. However, many change drivers—some related to, and others distinct from, climate change—simultaneously affect vegetation. These drivers include altered land management practices and shifts in fire and grazing regimes. Untangling the signals of climate‐change‐induced vegetation change from these other drivers of variation poses significant challenges. These challenges are amplified in regions with high interdecadal climate variability and enduring legacies of shifting human activities. Here, we assess attempts to detect and attribute vegetation change across Australia, a continent that exemplifies such complexities. We develop a scheme to classify attribution efforts according to whether they consider (1) qualitative or quantitative evidence, (2) mechanistic explanations and (3) alternative plausible change drivers. While a significant body of evidence demonstrates vegetation change in Australia, we find that it is difficult to confidently attribute changes to recent climate shifts—noting that few studies have attempted to do so. Several recommendations emerge that may improve attribution worldwide, including explicitly considering attribution strength, committing to long‐term monitoring of vegetation and change drivers and recognising multiple drivers of change, especially past and present human influences. Finally, achieving the strongest level of attribution requires linking observations and mechanistic models.
- 28 August 2025
- Published by Wiley in Plants, People, Planet
- Vol. 8 (2) , 461-485
Open AccessDetecting and attributing climate change effects on vegetation: Australia as a test case
Societal Impact Statement: Climate change is contributing to vegetation changes that threaten life support systems. Yet, inherent climatic variability and past and present human actions—such as clearing, burning and grazing regimes—also alter vegetation and complicate understanding of vegetation change. Australian ecosystems exemplify such complexity. To predict future vegetation changes, proactively guide management and ensure persistent drivers do not disrupt intended outcomes, we need to untangle the effects of these various change drivers on vegetation. Such attribution of change, which is rarely done, requires historical context, long‐term datasets of vegetation and environmental drivers and integrating data with process‐based understanding. Summary: Climate change is expected to affect vegetation: associated rising atmospheric CO 2 , higher temperatures and more variable and extreme rainfall regimes can all cause major shifts in vegetation composition, structure and function. Such effects need to be detected to confirm understanding and to inform models that can predict future vegetation change and guide management efforts. However, many change drivers—some related to, and others distinct from, climate change—simultaneously affect vegetation. These drivers include altered land management practices and shifts in fire and grazing regimes. Untangling the signals of climate‐change‐induced vegetation change from these other drivers of variation poses significant challenges. These challenges are amplified in regions with high interdecadal climate variability and enduring legacies of shifting human activities. Here, we assess attempts to detect and attribute vegetation change across Australia, a continent that exemplifies such complexities. We develop a scheme to classify attribution efforts according to whether they consider (1) qualitative or quantitative evidence, (2) mechanistic explanations and (3) alternative plausible change drivers. While a significant body of evidence demonstrates vegetation change in Australia, we find that it is difficult to confidently attribute changes to recent climate shifts—noting that few studies have attempted to do so. Several recommendations emerge that may improve attribution worldwide, including explicitly considering attribution strength, committing to long‐term monitoring of vegetation and change drivers and recognising multiple drivers of change, especially past and present human influences. Finally, achieving the strongest level of attribution requires linking observations and mechanistic models.
- Open Access
- 12 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Supplementary material to "A systematic evaluation of 15 actual evapotranspiration formulations within conceptual hydrological models"
- 12 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessSupplementary material to "A systematic evaluation of 15 actual evapotranspiration formulations within conceptual hydrological models"
- Open Access
- 12 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-30
A systematic evaluation of 15 actual evapotranspiration formulations within conceptual hydrological models
Actual evapotranspiration (AET) is a major component of the water balance, yet it is rarely assessed for accuracy in conceptual rainfall-runoff models that are often calibrated to match streamflow only. Inaccurate representation of underlying AET processes may cause models to incorrectly simulate long-term changes in partitioning between AET and streamflow, even if this partitioning was relatively accurate during calibration. To investigate AET representation within conceptual hydrological models, we systematically tested 15 evapotranspiration (ET) equations that convert potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture to AET. The 15 equations represent common practice, having been sourced from a published comprehensive review of conceptual hydrological models. Each of these 15 formulations were trialled within three conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd and Vic). Following multi-objective calibration, we evaluated performance across both streamflow and flux tower AET measurements at seven catchments from a range of Australian climates. A small number of AET equations outperformed the rest, with one equation standing out, which uses a non-linear relationship with soil moisture storage and can scale down AET such that it cannot equal PET. This equation achieved a higher objective function value for both AET and streamflow and accurately captured evapotranspiration signatures. However, even this equation showed limitations in reproducing observed AET, suggesting persistent issues across commonly used formulations. These shortcomings may reflect missing vegetation-related dynamics and other simplifications. Our findings highlight the importance of ET equation selection in modelling AET and streamflow, and we recommend the identified equation as a promising option for future Australian studies. Further work is needed to test equations for consistency with known processes to improve the physical realism of conceptual hydrological models.
- 12 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-30
Open AccessA systematic evaluation of 15 actual evapotranspiration formulations within conceptual hydrological models
Actual evapotranspiration (AET) is a major component of the water balance, yet it is rarely assessed for accuracy in conceptual rainfall-runoff models that are often calibrated to match streamflow only. Inaccurate representation of underlying AET processes may cause models to incorrectly simulate long-term changes in partitioning between AET and streamflow, even if this partitioning was relatively accurate during calibration. To investigate AET representation within conceptual hydrological models, we systematically tested 15 evapotranspiration (ET) equations that convert potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture to AET. The 15 equations represent common practice, having been sourced from a published comprehensive review of conceptual hydrological models. Each of these 15 formulations were trialled within three conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd and Vic). Following multi-objective calibration, we evaluated performance across both streamflow and flux tower AET measurements at seven catchments from a range of Australian climates. A small number of AET equations outperformed the rest, with one equation standing out, which uses a non-linear relationship with soil moisture storage and can scale down AET such that it cannot equal PET. This equation achieved a higher objective function value for both AET and streamflow and accurately captured evapotranspiration signatures. However, even this equation showed limitations in reproducing observed AET, suggesting persistent issues across commonly used formulations. These shortcomings may reflect missing vegetation-related dynamics and other simplifications. Our findings highlight the importance of ET equation selection in modelling AET and streamflow, and we recommend the identified equation as a promising option for future Australian studies. Further work is needed to test equations for consistency with known processes to improve the physical realism of conceptual hydrological models.
- Open Access
- 25 July 2025
- Published by Wiley in Global Change Biology
- Vol. 31 (7) , e70361
The Response and Recovery of Carbon and Water Fluxes in Australian Ecosystems Exposed to Severe Drought
Climate change‐driven increases in drought risk pose a critical threat to global carbon and water cycles. However, ecosystem‐scale responses remain poorly quantified, particularly for severe, multiyear drought events. We addressed this gap by examining ecosystem‐scale carbon and water flux sensitivity to the extreme 2018–19 drought in Australia using data from 14 eddy covariance flux sites. The ecosystems span grasslands and semi‐arid woodlands to tropical and temperate forests. The driest sites (classed as “grass” and “very dry”) experienced drastic productivity impacts, with a 65% decrease in Gross Primary Productivity (GPP) over 2 years relative to the pre‐drought average. However, fluxes in “dry,” “seasonally wet” and “wet” ecosystems showed remarkable resistance, with no overall change in GPP. All sites recovered rapidly; carbon fluxes in the first post‐drought year matched (and generally exceeded) those of a climatically similar pre‐drought year. Drought responses were strongly mediated by ecosystem‐specific strategies. The driest ecosystems showed direct coupling of productivity to water availability, while intermediate ecosystems (dry and seasonally wet) leveraged stored soil water to maintain evapotranspiration and productivity under drought. At these sites, water was conserved over wet periods (evapotranspiration < demand, despite sufficient rainfall) and consumed over dry periods (evapotranspiration > rainfall). This mechanism mitigating periodic water stress under high rainfall variability likely contributed to the notable drought resistance of the dry and seasonally wet sites. The monthly water deficit index (MWDI) emerged as a robust predictor of productivity across space, highlighting that short‐term water availability deficits strongly influence overall ecosystem composition. Analysis of drought response mechanisms suggested rapid leaf loss under water stress, particularly at the driest sites. Our findings underscore the importance of accounting for sub‐surface water storage and diverse drought response strategies in vegetation models. We provide critical benchmarks for improving parameterization of plant‐water relations, aiding efforts to inform climate‐robust management strategies.
- 25 July 2025
- Published by Wiley in Global Change Biology
- Vol. 31 (7) , e70361
Open AccessThe Response and Recovery of Carbon and Water Fluxes in Australian Ecosystems Exposed to Severe Drought
Climate change‐driven increases in drought risk pose a critical threat to global carbon and water cycles. However, ecosystem‐scale responses remain poorly quantified, particularly for severe, multiyear drought events. We addressed this gap by examining ecosystem‐scale carbon and water flux sensitivity to the extreme 2018–19 drought in Australia using data from 14 eddy covariance flux sites. The ecosystems span grasslands and semi‐arid woodlands to tropical and temperate forests. The driest sites (classed as “grass” and “very dry”) experienced drastic productivity impacts, with a 65% decrease in Gross Primary Productivity (GPP) over 2 years relative to the pre‐drought average. However, fluxes in “dry,” “seasonally wet” and “wet” ecosystems showed remarkable resistance, with no overall change in GPP. All sites recovered rapidly; carbon fluxes in the first post‐drought year matched (and generally exceeded) those of a climatically similar pre‐drought year. Drought responses were strongly mediated by ecosystem‐specific strategies. The driest ecosystems showed direct coupling of productivity to water availability, while intermediate ecosystems (dry and seasonally wet) leveraged stored soil water to maintain evapotranspiration and productivity under drought. At these sites, water was conserved over wet periods (evapotranspiration < demand, despite sufficient rainfall) and consumed over dry periods (evapotranspiration > rainfall). This mechanism mitigating periodic water stress under high rainfall variability likely contributed to the notable drought resistance of the dry and seasonally wet sites. The monthly water deficit index (MWDI) emerged as a robust predictor of productivity across space, highlighting that short‐term water availability deficits strongly influence overall ecosystem composition. Analysis of drought response mechanisms suggested rapid leaf loss under water stress, particularly at the driest sites. Our findings underscore the importance of accounting for sub‐surface water storage and diverse drought response strategies in vegetation models. We provide critical benchmarks for improving parameterization of plant‐water relations, aiding efforts to inform climate‐robust management strategies.
- Open Access
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Leveraging flux tower data to systematically evaluate evapotranspiration formulas in conceptual hydrological models
Accurately representing actual evapotranspiration (AET) is crucial for hydrological modelling, as it is a major component of the catchment water balance. However, AET is often neglected when calibrating conceptual rainfall-runoff models to reproduce observed streamflow. This oversight can lead to models with accurate streamflow predictions but flawed internal fluxes, which could become problematic under changing environmental conditions. To address this gap, we systematically evaluated 15 evapotranspiration equations by substituting them into three widely used conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd, and VIC). These equations represent diverse process assumptions found across common conceptual rainfall-runoff models by variously converting potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture into AET. The performance of each model-equation combination was assessed using a multi-objective calibration approach, accounting for simulated streamflow and flux tower-derived AET. We applied this method across seven Australian catchments spanning diverse climatic conditions.Our analysis reveals that the choice of evapotranspiration equation significantly influences both internal flux accuracy and streamflow predictions. The performance among the tested equations varied extensively. It was found some widely used evapotranspiration equations struggled to replicate observed AET, underscoring potential limitations in their assumptions. Conversely, the better performing equations captured observed evapotranspiration signatures and achieved higher objective function values for both AET and streamflow, suggesting they better represent underlying hydrological processes. One equation consistently performed best across model structures and catchments. This equation incorporated a non-linear relationship between soil moisture and AET, while limiting AET to below potential evapotranspiration (PET).Our findings underscore the need to improve the realism of evapotranspiration processes in conceptual hydrological models, particularly in relation to vegetation dynamics and their interactions with soil and atmosphere. By incorporating flux tower observations into model calibration and evaluation, our study bridges the gap between experimental data and catchment-scale modelling. We recommend that similar systematic reviews be undertaken on other continents to assess global patterns and differences. Enhancing the representation of these processes could improve model reliability across temporal and spatial scales, especially under changing climatic and environmental conditions.
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessLeveraging flux tower data to systematically evaluate evapotranspiration formulas in conceptual hydrological models
Accurately representing actual evapotranspiration (AET) is crucial for hydrological modelling, as it is a major component of the catchment water balance. However, AET is often neglected when calibrating conceptual rainfall-runoff models to reproduce observed streamflow. This oversight can lead to models with accurate streamflow predictions but flawed internal fluxes, which could become problematic under changing environmental conditions. To address this gap, we systematically evaluated 15 evapotranspiration equations by substituting them into three widely used conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd, and VIC). These equations represent diverse process assumptions found across common conceptual rainfall-runoff models by variously converting potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture into AET. The performance of each model-equation combination was assessed using a multi-objective calibration approach, accounting for simulated streamflow and flux tower-derived AET. We applied this method across seven Australian catchments spanning diverse climatic conditions.Our analysis reveals that the choice of evapotranspiration equation significantly influences both internal flux accuracy and streamflow predictions. The performance among the tested equations varied extensively. It was found some widely used evapotranspiration equations struggled to replicate observed AET, underscoring potential limitations in their assumptions. Conversely, the better performing equations captured observed evapotranspiration signatures and achieved higher objective function values for both AET and streamflow, suggesting they better represent underlying hydrological processes. One equation consistently performed best across model structures and catchments. This equation incorporated a non-linear relationship between soil moisture and AET, while limiting AET to below potential evapotranspiration (PET).Our findings underscore the need to improve the realism of evapotranspiration processes in conceptual hydrological models, particularly in relation to vegetation dynamics and their interactions with soil and atmosphere. By incorporating flux tower observations into model calibration and evaluation, our study bridges the gap between experimental data and catchment-scale modelling. We recommend that similar systematic reviews be undertaken on other continents to assess global patterns and differences. Enhancing the representation of these processes could improve model reliability across temporal and spatial scales, especially under changing climatic and environmental conditions.
- Open Access
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Investigating evapotranspiration calculations within conceptual hydrological models: an intercomparison among models.
Hydrological models, ranging from conceptual frameworks to complex physical representations, play a pivotal role in diverse applications including climate change projections and characterising floods and droughts. One crucial aspect of these models is the incorporation of vegetation dynamics, often achieved through links to evapotranspiration and interception. Our study will delve into the critical role of evapotranspiration in the terrestrial water cycle, and how this intricate relationship is simplified across various hydrological models.Despite the versatility of hydrological models, a common limitation is the static representation of vegetation over time. This limitation becomes particularly significant under climate change, where the consequences of altered vegetation behaviour might not be accurately reflected in the model results. Our research will address this gap by exploring numerous evapotranspiration equations utilised by conceptual rainfall-runoff models, by employing a novel rainfall-runoff model comparison toolbox (MARRMoT), and integrating flux tower measurements into the calibration processes.By examining how different evapotranspiration equations are utilised across the models and integrating flux tower measurements into the hydrological modelling processes, we seek to improve the models' adaptability to changing environmental conditions. We will do this by interchanging the numerous evapotranspiration equations, whilst keeping all other aspects of the hydrological model constant to explore potential benefits and differences among methods. Further, we will include in-situ measurements by calibrating the model outputted actual-evapotranspiration to flux tower evapotranspiration data, as well as the traditionally calibrated streamflow data.This research contributes to advancing the accuracy of hydrological predictions and improving the reliability of models in forecasting catchment responses to future climatic shifts.
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessInvestigating evapotranspiration calculations within conceptual hydrological models: an intercomparison among models.
Hydrological models, ranging from conceptual frameworks to complex physical representations, play a pivotal role in diverse applications including climate change projections and characterising floods and droughts. One crucial aspect of these models is the incorporation of vegetation dynamics, often achieved through links to evapotranspiration and interception. Our study will delve into the critical role of evapotranspiration in the terrestrial water cycle, and how this intricate relationship is simplified across various hydrological models.Despite the versatility of hydrological models, a common limitation is the static representation of vegetation over time. This limitation becomes particularly significant under climate change, where the consequences of altered vegetation behaviour might not be accurately reflected in the model results. Our research will address this gap by exploring numerous evapotranspiration equations utilised by conceptual rainfall-runoff models, by employing a novel rainfall-runoff model comparison toolbox (MARRMoT), and integrating flux tower measurements into the calibration processes.By examining how different evapotranspiration equations are utilised across the models and integrating flux tower measurements into the hydrological modelling processes, we seek to improve the models' adaptability to changing environmental conditions. We will do this by interchanging the numerous evapotranspiration equations, whilst keeping all other aspects of the hydrological model constant to explore potential benefits and differences among methods. Further, we will include in-situ measurements by calibrating the model outputted actual-evapotranspiration to flux tower evapotranspiration data, as well as the traditionally calibrated streamflow data.This research contributes to advancing the accuracy of hydrological predictions and improving the reliability of models in forecasting catchment responses to future climatic shifts.