Gabrielle Burns
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Gabrielle Burns has a total of 5 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Clare Stephens
Hawkesbury Institute for the Environment, Western Sydney University, Richmond, NSW, Australia
7 shared publications - Keirnan Fowler
Department of Infrastructure Engineering, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, 3010, Victoria, Australia
7 shared publications - Murray Cameron Peel
Department of Infrastructure Engineering University of Melbourne Parkville VIC Australia
7 shared publications - Andrew John
Department of Infrastructure Engineering University of Melbourne Parkville VIC Australia
1 shared publication - Rory Nathan
Department of Infrastructure Engineering University of Melbourne Parkville VIC Australia
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 17 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Hydrology and Earth System Sciences
- Vol. 30 (14) , 4509-4528
A systematic evaluation of 15 actual evapotranspiration formulations within conceptual hydrological models
Actual evapotranspiration (AET) is a major component of the water balance, yet it is rarely assessed for accuracy in conceptual rainfall-runoff models that are often calibrated to match streamflow only. Inaccurate representation of underlying AET processes may cause models to incorrectly simulate long-term changes in partitioning between AET and streamflow, even if this partitioning was relatively accurate during calibration. To investigate AET representation within conceptual hydrological models, we systematically tested 15 evapotranspiration (ET) equations that convert potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture to AET. The 15 equations represent common practice, having been sourced from a published comprehensive review of conceptual hydrological models. Each of these 15 formulations were trialled within three conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd and Vic). Following multi-objective calibration, we evaluated performance across both streamflow and flux tower AET measurements at seven catchments from a range of Australian climates. A small number of AET equations outperformed the rest, with one equation standing out, which uses a non-linear relationship with soil moisture storage and can scale down AET such that it cannot equal PET even under high soil moisture conditions. This equation achieved a higher objective function value for both AET and streamflow and accurately captured evapotranspiration signatures. However, even this equation showed limitations in reproducing observed AET, suggesting persistent issues across commonly used formulations. These shortcomings may reflect missing vegetation-related dynamics and other simplifications. Our findings highlight the importance of ET equation selection in modelling AET and streamflow, and we recommend the identified equation as a promising option for future Australian studies. Further work is needed to test equations for consistency with known processes to improve the physical realism of conceptual hydrological models.
- 17 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Hydrology and Earth System Sciences
- Vol. 30 (14) , 4509-4528
Open AccessA systematic evaluation of 15 actual evapotranspiration formulations within conceptual hydrological models
Actual evapotranspiration (AET) is a major component of the water balance, yet it is rarely assessed for accuracy in conceptual rainfall-runoff models that are often calibrated to match streamflow only. Inaccurate representation of underlying AET processes may cause models to incorrectly simulate long-term changes in partitioning between AET and streamflow, even if this partitioning was relatively accurate during calibration. To investigate AET representation within conceptual hydrological models, we systematically tested 15 evapotranspiration (ET) equations that convert potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture to AET. The 15 equations represent common practice, having been sourced from a published comprehensive review of conceptual hydrological models. Each of these 15 formulations were trialled within three conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd and Vic). Following multi-objective calibration, we evaluated performance across both streamflow and flux tower AET measurements at seven catchments from a range of Australian climates. A small number of AET equations outperformed the rest, with one equation standing out, which uses a non-linear relationship with soil moisture storage and can scale down AET such that it cannot equal PET even under high soil moisture conditions. This equation achieved a higher objective function value for both AET and streamflow and accurately captured evapotranspiration signatures. However, even this equation showed limitations in reproducing observed AET, suggesting persistent issues across commonly used formulations. These shortcomings may reflect missing vegetation-related dynamics and other simplifications. Our findings highlight the importance of ET equation selection in modelling AET and streamflow, and we recommend the identified equation as a promising option for future Australian studies. Further work is needed to test equations for consistency with known processes to improve the physical realism of conceptual hydrological models.
- Open Access
- 22 January 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025
Reply on RC2
Actual evapotranspiration (AET) is a major component of the water balance, yet it is rarely assessed for accuracy in conceptual rainfall-runoff models that are often calibrated to match streamflow only. Inaccurate representation of underlying AET processes may cause models to incorrectly simulate long-term changes in partitioning between AET and streamflow, even if this partitioning was relatively accurate during calibration. To investigate AET representation within conceptual hydrological models, we systematically tested 15 evapotranspiration (ET) equations that convert potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture to AET. The 15 equations represent common practice, having been sourced from a published comprehensive review of conceptual hydrological models. Each of these 15 formulations were trialled within three conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd and Vic). Following multi-objective calibration, we evaluated performance across both streamflow and flux tower AET measurements at seven catchments from a range of Australian climates. A small number of AET equations outperformed the rest, with one equation standing out, which uses a non-linear relationship with soil moisture storage and can scale down AET such that it cannot equal PET. This equation achieved a higher objective function value for both AET and streamflow and accurately captured evapotranspiration signatures. However, even this equation showed limitations in reproducing observed AET, suggesting persistent issues across commonly used formulations. These shortcomings may reflect missing vegetation-related dynamics and other simplifications. Our findings highlight the importance of ET equation selection in modelling AET and streamflow, and we recommend the identified equation as a promising option for future Australian studies. Further work is needed to test equations for consistency with known processes to improve the physical realism of conceptual hydrological models.
- 22 January 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025
Open AccessReply on RC2
Actual evapotranspiration (AET) is a major component of the water balance, yet it is rarely assessed for accuracy in conceptual rainfall-runoff models that are often calibrated to match streamflow only. Inaccurate representation of underlying AET processes may cause models to incorrectly simulate long-term changes in partitioning between AET and streamflow, even if this partitioning was relatively accurate during calibration. To investigate AET representation within conceptual hydrological models, we systematically tested 15 evapotranspiration (ET) equations that convert potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture to AET. The 15 equations represent common practice, having been sourced from a published comprehensive review of conceptual hydrological models. Each of these 15 formulations were trialled within three conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd and Vic). Following multi-objective calibration, we evaluated performance across both streamflow and flux tower AET measurements at seven catchments from a range of Australian climates. A small number of AET equations outperformed the rest, with one equation standing out, which uses a non-linear relationship with soil moisture storage and can scale down AET such that it cannot equal PET. This equation achieved a higher objective function value for both AET and streamflow and accurately captured evapotranspiration signatures. However, even this equation showed limitations in reproducing observed AET, suggesting persistent issues across commonly used formulations. These shortcomings may reflect missing vegetation-related dynamics and other simplifications. Our findings highlight the importance of ET equation selection in modelling AET and streamflow, and we recommend the identified equation as a promising option for future Australian studies. Further work is needed to test equations for consistency with known processes to improve the physical realism of conceptual hydrological models.
- Open Access
- 22 January 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025
Reply on RC1
Actual evapotranspiration (AET) is a major component of the water balance, yet it is rarely assessed for accuracy in conceptual rainfall-runoff models that are often calibrated to match streamflow only. Inaccurate representation of underlying AET processes may cause models to incorrectly simulate long-term changes in partitioning between AET and streamflow, even if this partitioning was relatively accurate during calibration. To investigate AET representation within conceptual hydrological models, we systematically tested 15 evapotranspiration (ET) equations that convert potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture to AET. The 15 equations represent common practice, having been sourced from a published comprehensive review of conceptual hydrological models. Each of these 15 formulations were trialled within three conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd and Vic). Following multi-objective calibration, we evaluated performance across both streamflow and flux tower AET measurements at seven catchments from a range of Australian climates. A small number of AET equations outperformed the rest, with one equation standing out, which uses a non-linear relationship with soil moisture storage and can scale down AET such that it cannot equal PET. This equation achieved a higher objective function value for both AET and streamflow and accurately captured evapotranspiration signatures. However, even this equation showed limitations in reproducing observed AET, suggesting persistent issues across commonly used formulations. These shortcomings may reflect missing vegetation-related dynamics and other simplifications. Our findings highlight the importance of ET equation selection in modelling AET and streamflow, and we recommend the identified equation as a promising option for future Australian studies. Further work is needed to test equations for consistency with known processes to improve the physical realism of conceptual hydrological models.
- 22 January 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025
Open AccessReply on RC1
Actual evapotranspiration (AET) is a major component of the water balance, yet it is rarely assessed for accuracy in conceptual rainfall-runoff models that are often calibrated to match streamflow only. Inaccurate representation of underlying AET processes may cause models to incorrectly simulate long-term changes in partitioning between AET and streamflow, even if this partitioning was relatively accurate during calibration. To investigate AET representation within conceptual hydrological models, we systematically tested 15 evapotranspiration (ET) equations that convert potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture to AET. The 15 equations represent common practice, having been sourced from a published comprehensive review of conceptual hydrological models. Each of these 15 formulations were trialled within three conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd and Vic). Following multi-objective calibration, we evaluated performance across both streamflow and flux tower AET measurements at seven catchments from a range of Australian climates. A small number of AET equations outperformed the rest, with one equation standing out, which uses a non-linear relationship with soil moisture storage and can scale down AET such that it cannot equal PET. This equation achieved a higher objective function value for both AET and streamflow and accurately captured evapotranspiration signatures. However, even this equation showed limitations in reproducing observed AET, suggesting persistent issues across commonly used formulations. These shortcomings may reflect missing vegetation-related dynamics and other simplifications. Our findings highlight the importance of ET equation selection in modelling AET and streamflow, and we recommend the identified equation as a promising option for future Australian studies. Further work is needed to test equations for consistency with known processes to improve the physical realism of conceptual hydrological models.
- Open Access
- 24 November 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-30
Comment on egusphere-2025-3122
Actual evapotranspiration (AET) is a major component of the water balance, yet it is rarely assessed for accuracy in conceptual rainfall-runoff models that are often calibrated to match streamflow only. Inaccurate representation of underlying AET processes may cause models to incorrectly simulate long-term changes in partitioning between AET and streamflow, even if this partitioning was relatively accurate during calibration. To investigate AET representation within conceptual hydrological models, we systematically tested 15 evapotranspiration (ET) equations that convert potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture to AET. The 15 equations represent common practice, having been sourced from a published comprehensive review of conceptual hydrological models. Each of these 15 formulations were trialled within three conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd and Vic). Following multi-objective calibration, we evaluated performance across both streamflow and flux tower AET measurements at seven catchments from a range of Australian climates. A small number of AET equations outperformed the rest, with one equation standing out, which uses a non-linear relationship with soil moisture storage and can scale down AET such that it cannot equal PET. This equation achieved a higher objective function value for both AET and streamflow and accurately captured evapotranspiration signatures. However, even this equation showed limitations in reproducing observed AET, suggesting persistent issues across commonly used formulations. These shortcomings may reflect missing vegetation-related dynamics and other simplifications. Our findings highlight the importance of ET equation selection in modelling AET and streamflow, and we recommend the identified equation as a promising option for future Australian studies. Further work is needed to test equations for consistency with known processes to improve the physical realism of conceptual hydrological models.
- 24 November 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-30
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2025-3122
Actual evapotranspiration (AET) is a major component of the water balance, yet it is rarely assessed for accuracy in conceptual rainfall-runoff models that are often calibrated to match streamflow only. Inaccurate representation of underlying AET processes may cause models to incorrectly simulate long-term changes in partitioning between AET and streamflow, even if this partitioning was relatively accurate during calibration. To investigate AET representation within conceptual hydrological models, we systematically tested 15 evapotranspiration (ET) equations that convert potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture to AET. The 15 equations represent common practice, having been sourced from a published comprehensive review of conceptual hydrological models. Each of these 15 formulations were trialled within three conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd and Vic). Following multi-objective calibration, we evaluated performance across both streamflow and flux tower AET measurements at seven catchments from a range of Australian climates. A small number of AET equations outperformed the rest, with one equation standing out, which uses a non-linear relationship with soil moisture storage and can scale down AET such that it cannot equal PET. This equation achieved a higher objective function value for both AET and streamflow and accurately captured evapotranspiration signatures. However, even this equation showed limitations in reproducing observed AET, suggesting persistent issues across commonly used formulations. These shortcomings may reflect missing vegetation-related dynamics and other simplifications. Our findings highlight the importance of ET equation selection in modelling AET and streamflow, and we recommend the identified equation as a promising option for future Australian studies. Further work is needed to test equations for consistency with known processes to improve the physical realism of conceptual hydrological models.
- Open Access
- 22 September 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-30
Comment on egusphere-2025-3122
Actual evapotranspiration (AET) is a major component of the water balance, yet it is rarely assessed for accuracy in conceptual rainfall-runoff models that are often calibrated to match streamflow only. Inaccurate representation of underlying AET processes may cause models to incorrectly simulate long-term changes in partitioning between AET and streamflow, even if this partitioning was relatively accurate during calibration. To investigate AET representation within conceptual hydrological models, we systematically tested 15 evapotranspiration (ET) equations that convert potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture to AET. The 15 equations represent common practice, having been sourced from a published comprehensive review of conceptual hydrological models. Each of these 15 formulations were trialled within three conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd and Vic). Following multi-objective calibration, we evaluated performance across both streamflow and flux tower AET measurements at seven catchments from a range of Australian climates. A small number of AET equations outperformed the rest, with one equation standing out, which uses a non-linear relationship with soil moisture storage and can scale down AET such that it cannot equal PET. This equation achieved a higher objective function value for both AET and streamflow and accurately captured evapotranspiration signatures. However, even this equation showed limitations in reproducing observed AET, suggesting persistent issues across commonly used formulations. These shortcomings may reflect missing vegetation-related dynamics and other simplifications. Our findings highlight the importance of ET equation selection in modelling AET and streamflow, and we recommend the identified equation as a promising option for future Australian studies. Further work is needed to test equations for consistency with known processes to improve the physical realism of conceptual hydrological models.
- 22 September 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-30
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2025-3122
Actual evapotranspiration (AET) is a major component of the water balance, yet it is rarely assessed for accuracy in conceptual rainfall-runoff models that are often calibrated to match streamflow only. Inaccurate representation of underlying AET processes may cause models to incorrectly simulate long-term changes in partitioning between AET and streamflow, even if this partitioning was relatively accurate during calibration. To investigate AET representation within conceptual hydrological models, we systematically tested 15 evapotranspiration (ET) equations that convert potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture to AET. The 15 equations represent common practice, having been sourced from a published comprehensive review of conceptual hydrological models. Each of these 15 formulations were trialled within three conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd and Vic). Following multi-objective calibration, we evaluated performance across both streamflow and flux tower AET measurements at seven catchments from a range of Australian climates. A small number of AET equations outperformed the rest, with one equation standing out, which uses a non-linear relationship with soil moisture storage and can scale down AET such that it cannot equal PET. This equation achieved a higher objective function value for both AET and streamflow and accurately captured evapotranspiration signatures. However, even this equation showed limitations in reproducing observed AET, suggesting persistent issues across commonly used formulations. These shortcomings may reflect missing vegetation-related dynamics and other simplifications. Our findings highlight the importance of ET equation selection in modelling AET and streamflow, and we recommend the identified equation as a promising option for future Australian studies. Further work is needed to test equations for consistency with known processes to improve the physical realism of conceptual hydrological models.
- Open Access
- 12 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Supplementary material to "A systematic evaluation of 15 actual evapotranspiration formulations within conceptual hydrological models"
- 12 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessSupplementary material to "A systematic evaluation of 15 actual evapotranspiration formulations within conceptual hydrological models"
- Open Access
- 12 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-30
A systematic evaluation of 15 actual evapotranspiration formulations within conceptual hydrological models
Actual evapotranspiration (AET) is a major component of the water balance, yet it is rarely assessed for accuracy in conceptual rainfall-runoff models that are often calibrated to match streamflow only. Inaccurate representation of underlying AET processes may cause models to incorrectly simulate long-term changes in partitioning between AET and streamflow, even if this partitioning was relatively accurate during calibration. To investigate AET representation within conceptual hydrological models, we systematically tested 15 evapotranspiration (ET) equations that convert potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture to AET. The 15 equations represent common practice, having been sourced from a published comprehensive review of conceptual hydrological models. Each of these 15 formulations were trialled within three conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd and Vic). Following multi-objective calibration, we evaluated performance across both streamflow and flux tower AET measurements at seven catchments from a range of Australian climates. A small number of AET equations outperformed the rest, with one equation standing out, which uses a non-linear relationship with soil moisture storage and can scale down AET such that it cannot equal PET. This equation achieved a higher objective function value for both AET and streamflow and accurately captured evapotranspiration signatures. However, even this equation showed limitations in reproducing observed AET, suggesting persistent issues across commonly used formulations. These shortcomings may reflect missing vegetation-related dynamics and other simplifications. Our findings highlight the importance of ET equation selection in modelling AET and streamflow, and we recommend the identified equation as a promising option for future Australian studies. Further work is needed to test equations for consistency with known processes to improve the physical realism of conceptual hydrological models.
- 12 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-30
Open AccessA systematic evaluation of 15 actual evapotranspiration formulations within conceptual hydrological models
Actual evapotranspiration (AET) is a major component of the water balance, yet it is rarely assessed for accuracy in conceptual rainfall-runoff models that are often calibrated to match streamflow only. Inaccurate representation of underlying AET processes may cause models to incorrectly simulate long-term changes in partitioning between AET and streamflow, even if this partitioning was relatively accurate during calibration. To investigate AET representation within conceptual hydrological models, we systematically tested 15 evapotranspiration (ET) equations that convert potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture to AET. The 15 equations represent common practice, having been sourced from a published comprehensive review of conceptual hydrological models. Each of these 15 formulations were trialled within three conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd and Vic). Following multi-objective calibration, we evaluated performance across both streamflow and flux tower AET measurements at seven catchments from a range of Australian climates. A small number of AET equations outperformed the rest, with one equation standing out, which uses a non-linear relationship with soil moisture storage and can scale down AET such that it cannot equal PET. This equation achieved a higher objective function value for both AET and streamflow and accurately captured evapotranspiration signatures. However, even this equation showed limitations in reproducing observed AET, suggesting persistent issues across commonly used formulations. These shortcomings may reflect missing vegetation-related dynamics and other simplifications. Our findings highlight the importance of ET equation selection in modelling AET and streamflow, and we recommend the identified equation as a promising option for future Australian studies. Further work is needed to test equations for consistency with known processes to improve the physical realism of conceptual hydrological models.
- Open Access
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Regional scale projections of future change in wetland hydrologic regimes in Australia
Wetlands provide key habitat for many species but are threatened by climate change. However, quantitatively projecting climate change impacts on wetland hydrologic regimes is difficult due to the often remote nature of wetlands, leading to a scarcity of data on wetland inundation. In these contexts, remote sensing offers a large scale tool for periodic observations of wetland water extent. In addition, wetlands can display a diverse range of inundation regimes, driven by the different hydrological processes that contribute to inflows. For example, perennial wetlands might have ongoing groundwater contributions or high rainfall that keep water levels elevated throughout the year. But more variable systems such as floodplain wetlands might rely on overbank river flows, such that they might only be inundated every few years. This large range in hydrologic variability can make modelling wetland inundation a difficult task.We used a timeseries dataset of wetland inundation extents, extracted from Landsat-derived water observations over 1988-2022, to classify the hydrologic regime of 34,890 wetlands in the state of Victoria, Australia. Wetlands were classified as permanent, seasonal, intermittent or episodic systems, which represent increasing variability in inundation. We then calibrated a series of conceptual hydrologic and Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) neural network models to simulate wetland inundation, driven by climate inputs. Conceptual hydrologic models were able to reasonably simulate wetland inundation for permanent, seasonal and intermittent systems, but struggled in representing the more variable episodic wetlands. For episodic wetlands, LSTM models performed better than conceptual hydrologic models, but many that calibrated well over the historic period showed unrealistic sensitivity to changes in climate inputs.We then applied a range of climate projections to wetlands models, to understand potential future shifts in wetland hydrologic regimes, based on a subset of 8,334 of the best performing models. Climate change projections substantially reduced the proportion of permanent and seasonal wetlands and increase the proportion of episodic wetlands in Victoria. Our results suggest the biggest risk is to permanent wetlands, where even under a moderate emissions scenario nearly two thirds of permanent wetlands could transition to seasonal or intermittent systems by 2065. “Rare” wetlands (with an average inundation frequency of less than once every 10 years) are predicted to increase eight-fold under a high emissions scenario by 2065. These results demonstrate the significant vulnerability of wetland hydrology to climate change, with potential major implications for wetland habitat for freshwater ecosystems.
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessRegional scale projections of future change in wetland hydrologic regimes in Australia
Wetlands provide key habitat for many species but are threatened by climate change. However, quantitatively projecting climate change impacts on wetland hydrologic regimes is difficult due to the often remote nature of wetlands, leading to a scarcity of data on wetland inundation. In these contexts, remote sensing offers a large scale tool for periodic observations of wetland water extent. In addition, wetlands can display a diverse range of inundation regimes, driven by the different hydrological processes that contribute to inflows. For example, perennial wetlands might have ongoing groundwater contributions or high rainfall that keep water levels elevated throughout the year. But more variable systems such as floodplain wetlands might rely on overbank river flows, such that they might only be inundated every few years. This large range in hydrologic variability can make modelling wetland inundation a difficult task.We used a timeseries dataset of wetland inundation extents, extracted from Landsat-derived water observations over 1988-2022, to classify the hydrologic regime of 34,890 wetlands in the state of Victoria, Australia. Wetlands were classified as permanent, seasonal, intermittent or episodic systems, which represent increasing variability in inundation. We then calibrated a series of conceptual hydrologic and Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) neural network models to simulate wetland inundation, driven by climate inputs. Conceptual hydrologic models were able to reasonably simulate wetland inundation for permanent, seasonal and intermittent systems, but struggled in representing the more variable episodic wetlands. For episodic wetlands, LSTM models performed better than conceptual hydrologic models, but many that calibrated well over the historic period showed unrealistic sensitivity to changes in climate inputs.We then applied a range of climate projections to wetlands models, to understand potential future shifts in wetland hydrologic regimes, based on a subset of 8,334 of the best performing models. Climate change projections substantially reduced the proportion of permanent and seasonal wetlands and increase the proportion of episodic wetlands in Victoria. Our results suggest the biggest risk is to permanent wetlands, where even under a moderate emissions scenario nearly two thirds of permanent wetlands could transition to seasonal or intermittent systems by 2065. “Rare” wetlands (with an average inundation frequency of less than once every 10 years) are predicted to increase eight-fold under a high emissions scenario by 2065. These results demonstrate the significant vulnerability of wetland hydrology to climate change, with potential major implications for wetland habitat for freshwater ecosystems.
- Open Access
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Leveraging flux tower data to systematically evaluate evapotranspiration formulas in conceptual hydrological models
Accurately representing actual evapotranspiration (AET) is crucial for hydrological modelling, as it is a major component of the catchment water balance. However, AET is often neglected when calibrating conceptual rainfall-runoff models to reproduce observed streamflow. This oversight can lead to models with accurate streamflow predictions but flawed internal fluxes, which could become problematic under changing environmental conditions. To address this gap, we systematically evaluated 15 evapotranspiration equations by substituting them into three widely used conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd, and VIC). These equations represent diverse process assumptions found across common conceptual rainfall-runoff models by variously converting potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture into AET. The performance of each model-equation combination was assessed using a multi-objective calibration approach, accounting for simulated streamflow and flux tower-derived AET. We applied this method across seven Australian catchments spanning diverse climatic conditions.Our analysis reveals that the choice of evapotranspiration equation significantly influences both internal flux accuracy and streamflow predictions. The performance among the tested equations varied extensively. It was found some widely used evapotranspiration equations struggled to replicate observed AET, underscoring potential limitations in their assumptions. Conversely, the better performing equations captured observed evapotranspiration signatures and achieved higher objective function values for both AET and streamflow, suggesting they better represent underlying hydrological processes. One equation consistently performed best across model structures and catchments. This equation incorporated a non-linear relationship between soil moisture and AET, while limiting AET to below potential evapotranspiration (PET).Our findings underscore the need to improve the realism of evapotranspiration processes in conceptual hydrological models, particularly in relation to vegetation dynamics and their interactions with soil and atmosphere. By incorporating flux tower observations into model calibration and evaluation, our study bridges the gap between experimental data and catchment-scale modelling. We recommend that similar systematic reviews be undertaken on other continents to assess global patterns and differences. Enhancing the representation of these processes could improve model reliability across temporal and spatial scales, especially under changing climatic and environmental conditions.
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessLeveraging flux tower data to systematically evaluate evapotranspiration formulas in conceptual hydrological models
Accurately representing actual evapotranspiration (AET) is crucial for hydrological modelling, as it is a major component of the catchment water balance. However, AET is often neglected when calibrating conceptual rainfall-runoff models to reproduce observed streamflow. This oversight can lead to models with accurate streamflow predictions but flawed internal fluxes, which could become problematic under changing environmental conditions. To address this gap, we systematically evaluated 15 evapotranspiration equations by substituting them into three widely used conceptual hydrological models (GR4J, Simhyd, and VIC). These equations represent diverse process assumptions found across common conceptual rainfall-runoff models by variously converting potential evapotranspiration (PET) and soil moisture into AET. The performance of each model-equation combination was assessed using a multi-objective calibration approach, accounting for simulated streamflow and flux tower-derived AET. We applied this method across seven Australian catchments spanning diverse climatic conditions.Our analysis reveals that the choice of evapotranspiration equation significantly influences both internal flux accuracy and streamflow predictions. The performance among the tested equations varied extensively. It was found some widely used evapotranspiration equations struggled to replicate observed AET, underscoring potential limitations in their assumptions. Conversely, the better performing equations captured observed evapotranspiration signatures and achieved higher objective function values for both AET and streamflow, suggesting they better represent underlying hydrological processes. One equation consistently performed best across model structures and catchments. This equation incorporated a non-linear relationship between soil moisture and AET, while limiting AET to below potential evapotranspiration (PET).Our findings underscore the need to improve the realism of evapotranspiration processes in conceptual hydrological models, particularly in relation to vegetation dynamics and their interactions with soil and atmosphere. By incorporating flux tower observations into model calibration and evaluation, our study bridges the gap between experimental data and catchment-scale modelling. We recommend that similar systematic reviews be undertaken on other continents to assess global patterns and differences. Enhancing the representation of these processes could improve model reliability across temporal and spatial scales, especially under changing climatic and environmental conditions.
- Open Access
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Investigating evapotranspiration calculations within conceptual hydrological models: an intercomparison among models.
Hydrological models, ranging from conceptual frameworks to complex physical representations, play a pivotal role in diverse applications including climate change projections and characterising floods and droughts. One crucial aspect of these models is the incorporation of vegetation dynamics, often achieved through links to evapotranspiration and interception. Our study will delve into the critical role of evapotranspiration in the terrestrial water cycle, and how this intricate relationship is simplified across various hydrological models.Despite the versatility of hydrological models, a common limitation is the static representation of vegetation over time. This limitation becomes particularly significant under climate change, where the consequences of altered vegetation behaviour might not be accurately reflected in the model results. Our research will address this gap by exploring numerous evapotranspiration equations utilised by conceptual rainfall-runoff models, by employing a novel rainfall-runoff model comparison toolbox (MARRMoT), and integrating flux tower measurements into the calibration processes.By examining how different evapotranspiration equations are utilised across the models and integrating flux tower measurements into the hydrological modelling processes, we seek to improve the models' adaptability to changing environmental conditions. We will do this by interchanging the numerous evapotranspiration equations, whilst keeping all other aspects of the hydrological model constant to explore potential benefits and differences among methods. Further, we will include in-situ measurements by calibrating the model outputted actual-evapotranspiration to flux tower evapotranspiration data, as well as the traditionally calibrated streamflow data.This research contributes to advancing the accuracy of hydrological predictions and improving the reliability of models in forecasting catchment responses to future climatic shifts.
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessInvestigating evapotranspiration calculations within conceptual hydrological models: an intercomparison among models.
Hydrological models, ranging from conceptual frameworks to complex physical representations, play a pivotal role in diverse applications including climate change projections and characterising floods and droughts. One crucial aspect of these models is the incorporation of vegetation dynamics, often achieved through links to evapotranspiration and interception. Our study will delve into the critical role of evapotranspiration in the terrestrial water cycle, and how this intricate relationship is simplified across various hydrological models.Despite the versatility of hydrological models, a common limitation is the static representation of vegetation over time. This limitation becomes particularly significant under climate change, where the consequences of altered vegetation behaviour might not be accurately reflected in the model results. Our research will address this gap by exploring numerous evapotranspiration equations utilised by conceptual rainfall-runoff models, by employing a novel rainfall-runoff model comparison toolbox (MARRMoT), and integrating flux tower measurements into the calibration processes.By examining how different evapotranspiration equations are utilised across the models and integrating flux tower measurements into the hydrological modelling processes, we seek to improve the models' adaptability to changing environmental conditions. We will do this by interchanging the numerous evapotranspiration equations, whilst keeping all other aspects of the hydrological model constant to explore potential benefits and differences among methods. Further, we will include in-situ measurements by calibrating the model outputted actual-evapotranspiration to flux tower evapotranspiration data, as well as the traditionally calibrated streamflow data.This research contributes to advancing the accuracy of hydrological predictions and improving the reliability of models in forecasting catchment responses to future climatic shifts.