John Pitlick
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
John Pitlick has a total of 37 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Catalina Segura
Department of Forest Engineering, Resources, and Management Oregon State University Corvallis Oregon USA
2 shared publications - Erich R. Mueller
Department of Geosciences Southern Utah University Cedar City UT USA
2 shared publications Peter Wilcock
United States Department of Agriculture Forest Service Rocky Mountain Research Station
2 shared publications- Simone Bizzi
Department of Geosciences University of Padova Padova Italy
2 shared publications University of Colorado
2 shared publications- Yantao Cui
Stillwater Sciences Berkeley California USA
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 16 October 2023
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Water Resources Research
- Vol. 59 (10)
The Influence of Knickpoint Development and Channel Incision on Riparian Vegetation in Semi‐Arid River Corridors
Hydrogeomorphic processes strongly influence riparian vegetation, but few studies have determined the influence of knickpoint development on these processes. We investigate the influence of knickpoint development and channel incision on flood inundation, channel morphology, and riparian vegetation on the Fremont River in Utah. We conducted topographic surveys (n = 30 transects) and plot‐based vegetation surveys (n = 336) in three 1 km‐long reaches with varying proximities to a human‐created knickpoint. We also developed 1D hydraulic models to assess flood inundation patterns. Our data indicate that knickpoint development affects riparian vegetation composition and abundance through its influence on geomorphic and hydrologic processes. The study reach located just upstream of the knickpoint (R2) had a deeper channel, flooded less frequently, and required higher flows to inundate the floodplain compared to the study reach located 5 km upstream of the knickpoint (R1). Overall mean vegetation abundance (percent cover) was higher in R1 (55.7%) than in R2 (30.1%), and R1 had more occurrences of wet‐adapted (facultative wetland and obligate) species than R2 (198 and 79, respectively). Vegetation in the human‐created abandoned meander reach near the knickpoint (R4) was predominantly dry‐adapted (upland) species. Cross‐reach comparisons and more than 3 m of incision in the knickzone since knickpoint creation indicate that knickpoint development has resulted in channel incision in R2, shifting its vegetation toward more dry‐adapted species reminiscent of the surrounding uplands. This work informs natural resource management practices for habitat in riparian ecosystems and can be applied to rivers in drier regions.
- 16 October 2023
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Water Resources Research
- Vol. 59 (10)
Open AccessThe Influence of Knickpoint Development and Channel Incision on Riparian Vegetation in Semi‐Arid River Corridors
Hydrogeomorphic processes strongly influence riparian vegetation, but few studies have determined the influence of knickpoint development on these processes. We investigate the influence of knickpoint development and channel incision on flood inundation, channel morphology, and riparian vegetation on the Fremont River in Utah. We conducted topographic surveys (n = 30 transects) and plot‐based vegetation surveys (n = 336) in three 1 km‐long reaches with varying proximities to a human‐created knickpoint. We also developed 1D hydraulic models to assess flood inundation patterns. Our data indicate that knickpoint development affects riparian vegetation composition and abundance through its influence on geomorphic and hydrologic processes. The study reach located just upstream of the knickpoint (R2) had a deeper channel, flooded less frequently, and required higher flows to inundate the floodplain compared to the study reach located 5 km upstream of the knickpoint (R1). Overall mean vegetation abundance (percent cover) was higher in R1 (55.7%) than in R2 (30.1%), and R1 had more occurrences of wet‐adapted (facultative wetland and obligate) species than R2 (198 and 79, respectively). Vegetation in the human‐created abandoned meander reach near the knickpoint (R4) was predominantly dry‐adapted (upland) species. Cross‐reach comparisons and more than 3 m of incision in the knickzone since knickpoint creation indicate that knickpoint development has resulted in channel incision in R2, shifting its vegetation toward more dry‐adapted species reminiscent of the surrounding uplands. This work informs natural resource management practices for habitat in riparian ecosystems and can be applied to rivers in drier regions.
- Open Access
- 30 November 2021
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Water Resources Research
- Vol. 57 (12)
Sediment Production in French Alpine Rivers
Global compilations of river sediment loads show that mountainous areas produce a high proportion of the sediment transported to the oceans. However, because of the effort involved in measuring sediment fluxes in mountain river systems, the loads of these rivers are generally unknown. Here, we present estimates of contemporary sediment loads of 16 gravel bed rivers draining the Ecrins‐Pelvoux Massif in southeast France. Sediment production in this part of the Alps is relatively high and many river segments are either wandering or braided. We model sediment fluxes and annual sediment yields by coupling hydraulic‐based relations for sediment transport with hydrologic‐based relations for flow frequency. Bed load fluxes are modeled for a range of discharges using a function that relates transport rates to excess shear stress. Fluxes are then weighted by the frequency of individual discharges and summed to get the annual bed load for each site. The suspended load is estimated empirically as a fraction of the bed load. Results suggest that bed load fluxes at channel‐forming flows scale almost linearly with downstream increases in discharge. In addition, it appears that annual sediment loads (bed load + suspended load) scale linearly with drainage area. A complementary relation for specific sediment yield suggests that the load per unit drainage area is constant across the range of basins studied. The modeled sediment yields are comparable to previous field‐based estimates of modern sediment yields, and generally lower than estimates developed from analyses of cosmogenic radionuclides.
- 30 November 2021
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Water Resources Research
- Vol. 57 (12)
Open AccessSediment Production in French Alpine Rivers
Global compilations of river sediment loads show that mountainous areas produce a high proportion of the sediment transported to the oceans. However, because of the effort involved in measuring sediment fluxes in mountain river systems, the loads of these rivers are generally unknown. Here, we present estimates of contemporary sediment loads of 16 gravel bed rivers draining the Ecrins‐Pelvoux Massif in southeast France. Sediment production in this part of the Alps is relatively high and many river segments are either wandering or braided. We model sediment fluxes and annual sediment yields by coupling hydraulic‐based relations for sediment transport with hydrologic‐based relations for flow frequency. Bed load fluxes are modeled for a range of discharges using a function that relates transport rates to excess shear stress. Fluxes are then weighted by the frequency of individual discharges and summed to get the annual bed load for each site. The suspended load is estimated empirically as a fraction of the bed load. Results suggest that bed load fluxes at channel‐forming flows scale almost linearly with downstream increases in discharge. In addition, it appears that annual sediment loads (bed load + suspended load) scale linearly with drainage area. A complementary relation for specific sediment yield suggests that the load per unit drainage area is constant across the range of basins studied. The modeled sediment yields are comparable to previous field‐based estimates of modern sediment yields, and generally lower than estimates developed from analyses of cosmogenic radionuclides.
- Open Access
- 25 August 2021
- Published by Wiley in Earth Surface Processes and Landforms
- Vol. 46 (14) , 2946-2962
Sediment transport at the network scale and its link to channel morphology in the braided Vjosa River system
In this article we apply the CASCADE network‐scale sediment connectivity model to the Vjosa River in Albania. The Vjosa is one of the last unimpaired braided rivers in Europe and, at the same time, a data scarce environment, which limits our ability to model how this pristine river might respond to future human disturbance. To initialize the model, we use remotely sensed data and modeled hydrology from a regional model. We perform a reach‐by‐reach optimization of surface grain size distribution (GSD) and bedload transport capacity to ensure equilibrium conditions throughout the network. In order to account for the various sources of uncertainty in the calculation of transport capacity, we performed a global sensitivity analysis. The modeled GSD distributions generated by the sensitivity analysis generally match the six GSDs measured at different locations within the network. The modeled bedload sediment fluxes increase systematically downstream, and annual fluxes at the outlet of the Vjosa are well within an order of magnitude of fluxes derived from previous estimates of the annual suspended sediment load.We then use the modeled sediment fluxes as input to a set of theoretically derived functions that successfully discriminate between multi‐thread and single‐thread channel patterns. This finding provides additional validation of the model results by showing a clear connection between modeled sediment concentrations and observed river morphology. Finally, we observe that a reduction in sediment flux of about 50% (e.g., due to dams) would likely cause existing braided reaches to shift toward single thread morphology. The proposed method is widely applicable and opens a new avenue for application of network‐scale sediment models that aid in the exploration of river stability to changes in water and sediment fluxes.
- 25 August 2021
- Published by Wiley in Earth Surface Processes and Landforms
- Vol. 46 (14) , 2946-2962
Open AccessSediment transport at the network scale and its link to channel morphology in the braided Vjosa River system
In this article we apply the CASCADE network‐scale sediment connectivity model to the Vjosa River in Albania. The Vjosa is one of the last unimpaired braided rivers in Europe and, at the same time, a data scarce environment, which limits our ability to model how this pristine river might respond to future human disturbance. To initialize the model, we use remotely sensed data and modeled hydrology from a regional model. We perform a reach‐by‐reach optimization of surface grain size distribution (GSD) and bedload transport capacity to ensure equilibrium conditions throughout the network. In order to account for the various sources of uncertainty in the calculation of transport capacity, we performed a global sensitivity analysis. The modeled GSD distributions generated by the sensitivity analysis generally match the six GSDs measured at different locations within the network. The modeled bedload sediment fluxes increase systematically downstream, and annual fluxes at the outlet of the Vjosa are well within an order of magnitude of fluxes derived from previous estimates of the annual suspended sediment load.We then use the modeled sediment fluxes as input to a set of theoretically derived functions that successfully discriminate between multi‐thread and single‐thread channel patterns. This finding provides additional validation of the model results by showing a clear connection between modeled sediment concentrations and observed river morphology. Finally, we observe that a reduction in sediment flux of about 50% (e.g., due to dams) would likely cause existing braided reaches to shift toward single thread morphology. The proposed method is widely applicable and opens a new avenue for application of network‐scale sediment models that aid in the exploration of river stability to changes in water and sediment fluxes.
- Open Access
- 2 July 2017
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Water Resources Research
- Vol. 53 (7) , 5276-5297
Concentration‐discharge relationships during an extreme event: Contrasting behavior of solutes and changes to chemical quality of dissolved organic material in the Boulder Creek Watershed during the September 2013 flood
During the week of 9–15 September 2013, about 44 cm of rain fell across Boulder County, Colorado, USA, representing a very rare precipitation event. The resultant streamflows corresponded to an extreme event not seen since the historical flood of 1894. For the Boulder Creek Critical Zone Observatory (BcCZO), this event provided an opportunity to study the effect of extreme rainfall on solute concentration‐discharge relationships and biogeochemical processes. We measured weathering‐derived lithologic solutes (Ca, Mg, Na, K, and Si) and dissolved organic carbon (DOC) concentrations at two sites on Boulder Creek during the recession of peak flow. We also isolated four distinct fractions of dissolved organic matter (DOM) for chemical characterization. At the upper and lower sites, all solutes had their highest concentration at peak flow. At the upper site, which represented a mostly forested catchment, the concentrations of lithologic solutes decreased slightly during flood recession. In contrast, DOC and K concentrations decreased by a factor of three. At the lower site within the urban corridor, concentration of lithologic solutes decreased substantially for a few days before rebounding, whereas the DOC and K concentrations continued to decrease. Additionally, we found spatiotemporal trends in the chemical quality of DOM that were consistent with a limited reservoir of soluble organic matter in surficial soils becoming depleted and deeper layers of the Critical Zone contributing DOM during the flood recession. Overall, these results suggest that despite the extreme flood event, concentration‐discharge relationships were similar to typical snowmelt periods in this Rocky Mountain region.
- 2 July 2017
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Water Resources Research
- Vol. 53 (7) , 5276-5297
Open AccessConcentration‐discharge relationships during an extreme event: Contrasting behavior of solutes and changes to chemical quality of dissolved organic material in the Boulder Creek Watershed during the September 2013 flood
During the week of 9–15 September 2013, about 44 cm of rain fell across Boulder County, Colorado, USA, representing a very rare precipitation event. The resultant streamflows corresponded to an extreme event not seen since the historical flood of 1894. For the Boulder Creek Critical Zone Observatory (BcCZO), this event provided an opportunity to study the effect of extreme rainfall on solute concentration‐discharge relationships and biogeochemical processes. We measured weathering‐derived lithologic solutes (Ca, Mg, Na, K, and Si) and dissolved organic carbon (DOC) concentrations at two sites on Boulder Creek during the recession of peak flow. We also isolated four distinct fractions of dissolved organic matter (DOM) for chemical characterization. At the upper and lower sites, all solutes had their highest concentration at peak flow. At the upper site, which represented a mostly forested catchment, the concentrations of lithologic solutes decreased slightly during flood recession. In contrast, DOC and K concentrations decreased by a factor of three. At the lower site within the urban corridor, concentration of lithologic solutes decreased substantially for a few days before rebounding, whereas the DOC and K concentrations continued to decrease. Additionally, we found spatiotemporal trends in the chemical quality of DOM that were consistent with a limited reservoir of soluble organic matter in surficial soils becoming depleted and deeper layers of the Critical Zone contributing DOM during the flood recession. Overall, these results suggest that despite the extreme flood event, concentration‐discharge relationships were similar to typical snowmelt periods in this Rocky Mountain region.
- Open Access
- 8 February 2017
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Earth Surface
- Vol. 122 (2) , 546-572
Characterizing the transient geomorphic response to base‐level fall in the northeastern Tibetan Plateau
Analysis of hillslope gradient, landscape relief, and channel steepness in the Daxia River basin provides evidence of a transient geomorphic response to base‐level fall on the northeastern Tibetan Plateau. Low‐gradient channels and gentle hillslopes of the upper watershed are separated from a steeper, high‐relief landscape by a series of convex knickzones along channel longitudinal profiles. Downstream projection of the “relict” portions of the profiles implies ~800–850 m of incision, consistent with geologic and geomorphic records of post ~1.7 Ma incision in the lower watershed. We combine optically stimulated luminescence dating of fluvial terrace deposits to constrain incision rates downstream of knickpoints with catchment‐averaged 10Be concentrations in modern sediment to estimate erosion rates in tributary basins both above and below knickpoints. Both sources of data imply landscape lowering rates of ~300 m Ma−1 below the knickpoint and ~50–100 m Ma−1 above. Field measurements of channel width (n = 48) and calculations of bankfull discharge (n = 9) allow determination of scaling relations among channel hydraulic geometry, discharge, and contributing area that we employ to estimate the patterns of basal shear stress, unit stream power, and bed load transport rate throughout the channel network. Our results imply a clear downstream increase of incision potential; this result would appear to be consistent with a detachment‐limited response to imposed base‐level fall, in which steepening of channels drives an increase in erosion rates. In contrast, however, we do not observe apparent narrowing of channels across the transition from slowly eroding to rapidly eroding portions of the watershed. Rather, the present‐day channel morphology as well as its scaling of hydraulic geometry imply that the river is primarily adjusted to transport its sediment load and suggest that channel morphology may not always reflect the presence of knickpoints and differences in landscape relief.
- 8 February 2017
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Earth Surface
- Vol. 122 (2) , 546-572
Open AccessCharacterizing the transient geomorphic response to base‐level fall in the northeastern Tibetan Plateau
Analysis of hillslope gradient, landscape relief, and channel steepness in the Daxia River basin provides evidence of a transient geomorphic response to base‐level fall on the northeastern Tibetan Plateau. Low‐gradient channels and gentle hillslopes of the upper watershed are separated from a steeper, high‐relief landscape by a series of convex knickzones along channel longitudinal profiles. Downstream projection of the “relict” portions of the profiles implies ~800–850 m of incision, consistent with geologic and geomorphic records of post ~1.7 Ma incision in the lower watershed. We combine optically stimulated luminescence dating of fluvial terrace deposits to constrain incision rates downstream of knickpoints with catchment‐averaged 10Be concentrations in modern sediment to estimate erosion rates in tributary basins both above and below knickpoints. Both sources of data imply landscape lowering rates of ~300 m Ma−1 below the knickpoint and ~50–100 m Ma−1 above. Field measurements of channel width (n = 48) and calculations of bankfull discharge (n = 9) allow determination of scaling relations among channel hydraulic geometry, discharge, and contributing area that we employ to estimate the patterns of basal shear stress, unit stream power, and bed load transport rate throughout the channel network. Our results imply a clear downstream increase of incision potential; this result would appear to be consistent with a detachment‐limited response to imposed base‐level fall, in which steepening of channels drives an increase in erosion rates. In contrast, however, we do not observe apparent narrowing of channels across the transition from slowly eroding to rapidly eroding portions of the watershed. Rather, the present‐day channel morphology as well as its scaling of hydraulic geometry imply that the river is primarily adjusted to transport its sediment load and suggest that channel morphology may not always reflect the presence of knickpoints and differences in landscape relief.
- 1 January 2017
- Published by Geological Society of America
OUT WITH THE TRUCKERS AND THE KICKERS AND THE COWBOY ANGELS
- 1 January 2017
- Published by Geological Society of America
OUT WITH THE TRUCKERS AND THE KICKERS AND THE COWBOY ANGELS
- 28 May 2013
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE)
- p. 426-432
Effects of Varying Stream Channel Conductance on Siting New Pumping Wells in an Aquifer
In regions of the world where growing population and changing climates are threatening water supplies, accurate modeling of potential human impacts on water resources is becoming more important. Stream depletion, the reduction of surface water flow due to the extraction of groundwater from a hydraulically connected aquifer, is a direct way that development can alter water availability. Thus, the accurate modeling of stream depletion is an important step in siting new groundwater wells. Proper estimation of stream depletion requires appropriate parameterization of aquifer and streambed hydraulic properties. Although many studies have conducted numerical investigations to determine stream depletion at specific sites, they typically do not use measured streambed hydraulic conductivity (K3), but rather assume a representative value. These assumptions are inaccurate for natural systems because Kr varies spatially along the stream channel. In this work, we investigate how stream depletion is affected by spatially-variable conductance, given by C = wKr/br, where C is conductance, w is the width of the stream, Kr is the streambed hydraulic conductivity, and br is the thickness of the streambed. The conductance of the model stream channel is varied along the flow axis with regions of relatively high conductance along the straight sections and regions of relatively low conductance along the bent sections. This was done to better represent the conductance patterns in a natural system. It was found that altering the value of conductance along the stream channel can affect stream depletion estimations to a significant degree. For example, if attempting to determine the optimal placement of a pumping well in an aquifer to minimize its effect on the stream, modeling stream depletion with conductance values that vary along the stream channel will alter favorable well locations. The numerical simulations show that in situations such as the one described, accounting for the natural variations of conductance will be necessary to develop an accurate model of a stream-aquifer system.
- 28 May 2013
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE)
- p. 426-432
Effects of Varying Stream Channel Conductance on Siting New Pumping Wells in an Aquifer
In regions of the world where growing population and changing climates are threatening water supplies, accurate modeling of potential human impacts on water resources is becoming more important. Stream depletion, the reduction of surface water flow due to the extraction of groundwater from a hydraulically connected aquifer, is a direct way that development can alter water availability. Thus, the accurate modeling of stream depletion is an important step in siting new groundwater wells. Proper estimation of stream depletion requires appropriate parameterization of aquifer and streambed hydraulic properties. Although many studies have conducted numerical investigations to determine stream depletion at specific sites, they typically do not use measured streambed hydraulic conductivity (K3), but rather assume a representative value. These assumptions are inaccurate for natural systems because Kr varies spatially along the stream channel. In this work, we investigate how stream depletion is affected by spatially-variable conductance, given by C = wKr/br, where C is conductance, w is the width of the stream, Kr is the streambed hydraulic conductivity, and br is the thickness of the streambed. The conductance of the model stream channel is varied along the flow axis with regions of relatively high conductance along the straight sections and regions of relatively low conductance along the bent sections. This was done to better represent the conductance patterns in a natural system. It was found that altering the value of conductance along the stream channel can affect stream depletion estimations to a significant degree. For example, if attempting to determine the optimal placement of a pumping well in an aquifer to minimize its effect on the stream, modeling stream depletion with conductance values that vary along the stream channel will alter favorable well locations. The numerical simulations show that in situations such as the one described, accounting for the natural variations of conductance will be necessary to develop an accurate model of a stream-aquifer system.
- Open Access
- 18 March 2013
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Earth Surface
- Vol. 118 (2) , 553-570
Width adjustment in experimental gravel‐bed channels in response to overbank flows
We conducted a series of flume experiments to investigate the response of self‐formed gravel‐bed channels to floods of varying magnitude and duration. Floods were generated by increasing the discharge into a channel created in sand‐ and gravel‐sized sediment with a median grain size of 2 mm. Flooding increased the Shields stress along the channel perimeter, causing bank erosion and rapid channel widening. The sediment introduced to the channel by bank erosion was not necessarily deposited on the channel bed, but was rather transported downstream, a process likely facilitated by transient fining of the bed surface. At the end of each experiment, bank sediments were no longer in motion, “partial bed load transport” characterized the flat‐bed portion of the channel, and the Shields stress approached a constant value of 0.056, about 1.2 times the critical Shields stress for incipient motion. Furthermore, the discharge was entirely accommodated by flow within the channel: the creation of a stable channel entirely eliminated overbank flows. We speculate that similar processes may occur in nature, but only where bank sediments are non‐cohesive and where channel‐narrowing processes cannot counteract bank erosion during overbank flows. We also demonstrate that a simple model of lateral bed load transport can reproduce observed channel widening rates, suggesting that simple methods may be appropriate for predicting width increases in channels with non‐cohesive, unvegetated banks, even during overbank flows. Last, we present a model for predicting the equilibrium width and depth of a stable gravel‐bed channel with a known channel‐forming Shields stress.
- 18 March 2013
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Earth Surface
- Vol. 118 (2) , 553-570
Open AccessWidth adjustment in experimental gravel‐bed channels in response to overbank flows
We conducted a series of flume experiments to investigate the response of self‐formed gravel‐bed channels to floods of varying magnitude and duration. Floods were generated by increasing the discharge into a channel created in sand‐ and gravel‐sized sediment with a median grain size of 2 mm. Flooding increased the Shields stress along the channel perimeter, causing bank erosion and rapid channel widening. The sediment introduced to the channel by bank erosion was not necessarily deposited on the channel bed, but was rather transported downstream, a process likely facilitated by transient fining of the bed surface. At the end of each experiment, bank sediments were no longer in motion, “partial bed load transport” characterized the flat‐bed portion of the channel, and the Shields stress approached a constant value of 0.056, about 1.2 times the critical Shields stress for incipient motion. Furthermore, the discharge was entirely accommodated by flow within the channel: the creation of a stable channel entirely eliminated overbank flows. We speculate that similar processes may occur in nature, but only where bank sediments are non‐cohesive and where channel‐narrowing processes cannot counteract bank erosion during overbank flows. We also demonstrate that a simple model of lateral bed load transport can reproduce observed channel widening rates, suggesting that simple methods may be appropriate for predicting width increases in channels with non‐cohesive, unvegetated banks, even during overbank flows. Last, we present a model for predicting the equilibrium width and depth of a stable gravel‐bed channel with a known channel‐forming Shields stress.
- 1 January 2013
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Hydraulic Engineering
- Vol. 139 (1) , 51-54
Shields versus Isbash
The Shields and the Isbash equations for predicting the stability of rocks exposed to a turbulent flow were both proposed in 1936, and since then, both equations have been used widely in the analysis of transport thresholds for coarse sediment. These two equations were obtained using two very different approaches, but as demonstrated in this paper, the equation developed by Isbash is consistent with the relation formulated by Shields for predicting the motion of sediments either in the flume or in the field. Comparison of the two equations suggests that standard approaches tend to oversize riprap in mountain streams.
- 1 January 2013
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Hydraulic Engineering
- Vol. 139 (1) , 51-54
Shields versus Isbash
The Shields and the Isbash equations for predicting the stability of rocks exposed to a turbulent flow were both proposed in 1936, and since then, both equations have been used widely in the analysis of transport thresholds for coarse sediment. These two equations were obtained using two very different approaches, but as demonstrated in this paper, the equation developed by Isbash is consistent with the relation formulated by Shields for predicting the motion of sediments either in the flume or in the field. Comparison of the two equations suggests that standard approaches tend to oversize riprap in mountain streams.