Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Ben Evans has a total of 51 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    From Metrics to Meaning: Time to Rethink Evaluation in Human–AI Collaborative Design

    by Sean P. Walton, Ben J. Evans, Alma A. M. Rahat, James Stovold, Jakub Vincalek

    As AI systems increasingly shape decision-making in creative design contexts, understanding how humans engage with these tools has become a critical challenge for interactive intelligent systems research. This article contributes a challenge to rethink how to evaluate human–AI collaborative systems, advocating for a more nuanced and multidimensional approach. Findings from one of the largest field studies to date ( n = 808) of a human–AI co-creative system, The Genetic Car Designer, complemented by a controlled lab study ( n = 12), are presented. The system is based on an interactive evolutionary algorithm where participants were tasked with designing a simple 2D representation of a car. Participants were exposed to galleries of design suggestions generated by an intelligent system, MAP–Elites, and a random control. Results indicate that exposure to galleries generated by MAP–Elites significantly enhanced both cognitive and behavioral engagement, leading to higher-quality design outcomes. Crucially for the wider community, the analysis reveals that conventional evaluation methods, which often focus on solely behavioral and design quality metrics, fail to capture the full spectrum of user engagement. By considering the human–AI design process as a changing emotional, behavioral, and cognitive state of the designer, we propose evaluating human–AI systems holistically and considering intelligent systems as a core part of the user experience—not simply a back-end tool.


  • Open Access

    A Novel Mesh Deformation Methodology for Computational Aerodynamic Shape Optimisation

    by Joelle Salamoun, Ben Smith, Ben Evans, Sean Walton, Martin Dodds, Neil Taylor


  • Open Access

    A Mesh-Based Approach for Computational Fluid Dynamics-Free Aerodynamic Optimisation of Complex Geometries Using Area Ruling

    by Ben James Evans, Ben Smith, Sean Peter Walton, Neil Taylor, Martin Dodds, Vladeta Zmijanovic

    In this paper, an optimisation procedure is introduced that uses a significantly cheaper, and CFD-free, objective function for aerodynamic optimisation than conventional CFD-driven approaches. Despite the reduced computational cost, we show that this approach can still drive the optimisation scheme towards a design with a similar reduction in drag coefficient for wave drag-dominated problems. The approach used is ‘CFD-free’, i.e., it does not require any computational aerodynamic analysis. It can be applied to geometries discretised using meshes more conventionally used for ‘standard’ CFD-based optimisation approaches. The approach outlined in this paper makes use of the transonic area rule and its supersonic extension, exploiting a mesh-based parameterisation and mesh morphing methodology. The paper addresses the following question: ‘To what extent can an optimiser perform (wave) drag minimisation if using ‘area ruling’ alone as the objective (fitness) function measurement?’. A summary of the wave drag approximation in transonic and supersonic regimes is outlined along with the methodology for exploiting this theory on a typical CFD surface mesh to construct an objective function evaluation for a given geometry. The implementation is presented including notes on the considerations required to ensure stability, and error minimisation, of the numerical scheme. The paper concludes with the results from a number of (simple and complex geometry) examples of a drag-minimisation optimisation study and the results are compared with an approach using full-fidelity CFD simulation. The overall conclusions from this study suggest that the approach presented is capable of driving a geometry towards a similar shape to when using full-fidelity CFD at a significantly lower computational cost. However, it cannot account for any constraints, driven by other aerodynamic factors, that might be present within the problem.


  • Open Access

    Evaluating the effect of a ducted winglet on the induced drag of wind turbine blade using CFD and Trefftz plane analysis

    by Jakub Vincalek, Sean Walton, Ben Evans

    A novel patented ducted winglet design is compared, using numerical simulations, to an unmodified wing tip and a standard winglet in the context of a wind turbine blade. The aim of the ducted winglet is to reduce the induced drag. This reduction of induced drag, at the wing tip, would be particularly beneficial to wind turbine performance. Throughout the comparison, we explore the aerodynamic phenomena described in the patent which claim to explain how the ducted winglet reduces induced drag. The simulations were run using a CFD solver, FLITE3D, that has been thoroughly validated on industrial scale aerodynamic problems. A mesh convergence study was carried out to ensure that the results have sufficient numerical accuracy for a consistent ranking with respect to the lift-to-drag ratio. A Trefftz plane analysis is conducted to measure the effect of the duct on induced drag. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time that such a ducted design is tested in this context and compared to a standard unmodified blade and winglet. We found that the ducted winglet has a higher lift-to-drag ratio than an unmodified wing tip, but lower than a non-ducted winglet. Despite this, there is clear evidence that the duct had a positive influence on the induced drag. Our results show that with future optimisation this ducted winglet may prove beneficial to wind turbine design.


  • On the subsonic and low transonic aerodynamic performance of the land speed record car, Bloodhound LSR

    by Ben Evans, Jack Townsend, Oubay Hassan, Kenneth Morgan, Ron Ayers, Mark Chapman, Andy Green

    The land speed record vehicle, Bloodhound, undertook testing at subsonic and low transonic speeds (up to Mach 0.8) at Hakskeen Pan, South Africa, during October and November of 2019. A decade of CFD-led aerodynamic design had been undertaken to produce a vehicle with the aim of minimised Mach number aerodynamic dependencies and minimised overall drag. This paper sets out and explains the measured pressure distributions with a focus on the highest speed run of Bloodhound up to a peak speed of 628 mile/h. It compares the measured aerodynamic performance with the various CFD model predictions used throughout the design process showing that, whilst localised discrepancies between CFD model and real behaviour exist, overall the Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS)-based CFD tools used to design the car did result in sufficiently accurate aerodynamic data to predict the overall vehicle performance to a high degree of accuracy. The work outlined in this paper, and the conclusions and recommendations drawn, form the basis for a future record attempt and the understanding of what will be required in principle to extend the World Land Speed Record to 1000 mile/h. It also provides guidance on how to effectively make use of RANS-based CFD modelling predictions for other complex, ground-interacting high-speed applications.


  • Open Access

    On an Exact Step Length in Gradient-Based Aerodynamic Shape Optimization—Part II: Viscous Flows

    by Farzad Mohebbi, Ben Evans, Mathieu Sellier

    This study presents an extension of a previous study (On an Exact Step Length in Gradient-Based Aerodynamic Shape Optimization) to viscous transonic flows. In this work, we showed that the same procedure to derive an explicit expression for an exact step length βexact in a gradient-based optimization method for inviscid transonic flows can be employed for viscous transonic flows. The extended numerical method was evaluated for the viscous flows over the transonic RAE 2822 airfoil at two common flow conditions in the transonic regime. To do so, the RAE 2822 airfoil was reconstructed by a Bezier curve of degree 16. The numerical solution of the transonic turbulent flow over the airfoil was performed using the solver ANSYS Fluent (using the Spalart–Allmaras turbulence model). Using the proposed step length, a gradient-based optimization method was employed to minimize the drag-to-lift ratio of the airfoil. The gradient of the objective function with respect to design variables was calculated by the finite-difference method. Efficiency and accuracy of the proposed method were investigated through two test cases.


  • Open Access

    A user-centered approach to evolutionary algorithms and their use in industry

    by Jakub Vincalek, Sean Walton, Ben Evans

    The key contribution of this article to the domain of engineering optimisation is establishing best practices with respect to the development of evolutionary algorithms in the context of design engineering. Despite their various uses, the uptake of evolutionary algorithms in industry remains limited. In order to understand why uptake is low a survey of engineers was undertaken, the results of which are presented here. A total of 23 participants (N = 23) took part in the 3-section mixed methods survey. Reflexive thematic analysis was conducted on the open-ended questions. A common thread throughout participants responses is that there is a question of trust towards evolutionary algorithms within industry. Perhaps surprising is that the key to gaining this trust is not producing good results, but creating algorithms which explain the process they take in reaching a result. Based on this, recommendations have been made to increase their use in industry.


  • Open Access

    On an Exact Step Length in Gradient-Based Aerodynamic Shape Optimization

    by Farzad Mohebbi, Ben Evans

    This study proposeda novel exact expression for step length (size) in gradient-based aerodynamic shape optimization for an airfoil in steady inviscid transonic flows. The airfoil surfaces were parameterized using Bezier curves. The Bezier curve control points were considered as design variables and the finite-difference method was used to compute the gradient of the objective function (drag-to-lift ratio) with respect to the design variables. An exact explicit expression was derived for the step length in gradient-based shape optimization problems. It was shown that the derived step length was independent of the method used for calculating the gradient (adjoint method, finite-difference method, etc.). The obtained results reveal the accuracy of the derived step length.