Charles E. Kessel
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Charles E. Kessel has a total of 246 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
A.C.C. Sips
3 shared publications- Francesca Maria Poli
Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory, Princeton, NJ, United States of America
3 shared publications - Peter Titus
Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory
3 shared publications S.H. Kim
3 shared publications- Anna A Teplukhina
Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory, Princeton, NJ 08543, United States of America
2 shared publications - Cody S. Wiggins
Oak Ridge National Laboratory
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 24 June 2024
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science
- Vol. 52 (9) , 3785-3790
Simulation of Helium Flow Visualization Apparatus for Studies of Blanket Cooling in Fusion Reactors
Flow visualization is essential to understanding helium cooling performance. This article investigates helium flow visualization in an apparatus to support the design of the blanket first wall for a fusion reactor. Helium’s safety advantages make it an attractive coolant, but effective cooling and flow visualization remain challenging. Sophisticated simulations are conducted in different test sections to address three key areas in the design of a test apparatus and cooling channel enhancements: the influence of viewing glass windows on flow patterns, the impact of increased heating, and the effectiveness of cooling structures like baffles. Viewing glass windows introduce flow recirculation region bifurcation and flow asymmetry, affecting flow patterns and necessitating careful analysis in future experiments. Increased heating results in helium flow detachment from the heated surface, leading to hot spots. Cooling structures, particularly baffles, prove effective in maintaining consistent attachment to the heated surface, improving the heat transfer performance. This study also examines a tunable parameter in the turbulence model, highlighting the importance of accurate model tuning for future fusion reactor cooling designs. With an imminent helium flow visualization facility, these simulations will be used to optimize cooling structures on the heated wall to improve flow attachment and heat transfer efficiency. This work serves as a first investigation of the helium flow visualization apparatus for blanket cooling enhancement in fusion reactor design.
- 24 June 2024
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science
- Vol. 52 (9) , 3785-3790
Simulation of Helium Flow Visualization Apparatus for Studies of Blanket Cooling in Fusion Reactors
Flow visualization is essential to understanding helium cooling performance. This article investigates helium flow visualization in an apparatus to support the design of the blanket first wall for a fusion reactor. Helium’s safety advantages make it an attractive coolant, but effective cooling and flow visualization remain challenging. Sophisticated simulations are conducted in different test sections to address three key areas in the design of a test apparatus and cooling channel enhancements: the influence of viewing glass windows on flow patterns, the impact of increased heating, and the effectiveness of cooling structures like baffles. Viewing glass windows introduce flow recirculation region bifurcation and flow asymmetry, affecting flow patterns and necessitating careful analysis in future experiments. Increased heating results in helium flow detachment from the heated surface, leading to hot spots. Cooling structures, particularly baffles, prove effective in maintaining consistent attachment to the heated surface, improving the heat transfer performance. This study also examines a tunable parameter in the turbulence model, highlighting the importance of accurate model tuning for future fusion reactor cooling designs. With an imminent helium flow visualization facility, these simulations will be used to optimize cooling structures on the heated wall to improve flow attachment and heat transfer efficiency. This work serves as a first investigation of the helium flow visualization apparatus for blanket cooling enhancement in fusion reactor design.
- 26 April 2024
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science
- Vol. 52 (9) , 3644-3650
Preliminary Assessment of Additively Manufactured Cooling Channel Performance for Helium-Cooled Blanket Concepts
Sufficient cooling of the blanket first wall remains a critical challenge for the design and deployment of fusion power plants. Helium has been targeted as a potential blanket coolant due to its inertness and low neutron interactivity, among other advantages. However, the low thermal mass of helium creates a need for heat transfer enhancements in coolant channels to provide adequate cooling to the blanket’s first wall. Toward this end, a series of ribbed flow channels of various rib cross sections and configurations has been produced via additive manufacturing (AM) to study the efficacy of AM for first wall heat transfer enhancement and the optimization of heat transfer geometries. Helium cooling performance is studied in AM test articles at 4 MPa operating pressure, Reynolds numbers up to 197 000, and outer surface heat fluxes up to 42 kW/m $^{2}$ in the recently commissioned helium flow loop experiment (HFLE). Preliminary results of this study are presented herein. Heat transfer performance of nominally smooth (i.e., featureless) AM channels is quantified via measured Nusselt numbers and friction factors and compared to off-the-shelf smooth pipe experiments. Results are compared to existing correlations and used to discuss the effects of the AM processes on thermal-hydraulic performance. It is seen that the inherent roughness of the AM channels leads to an increase in both heat transfer coefficient and pressure drop when compared to the conventional pipe. Recommendations are made for future studies based on these findings and additional considerations for the deployment of AM blanket cooling components.
- 26 April 2024
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science
- Vol. 52 (9) , 3644-3650
Preliminary Assessment of Additively Manufactured Cooling Channel Performance for Helium-Cooled Blanket Concepts
Sufficient cooling of the blanket first wall remains a critical challenge for the design and deployment of fusion power plants. Helium has been targeted as a potential blanket coolant due to its inertness and low neutron interactivity, among other advantages. However, the low thermal mass of helium creates a need for heat transfer enhancements in coolant channels to provide adequate cooling to the blanket’s first wall. Toward this end, a series of ribbed flow channels of various rib cross sections and configurations has been produced via additive manufacturing (AM) to study the efficacy of AM for first wall heat transfer enhancement and the optimization of heat transfer geometries. Helium cooling performance is studied in AM test articles at 4 MPa operating pressure, Reynolds numbers up to 197 000, and outer surface heat fluxes up to 42 kW/m $^{2}$ in the recently commissioned helium flow loop experiment (HFLE). Preliminary results of this study are presented herein. Heat transfer performance of nominally smooth (i.e., featureless) AM channels is quantified via measured Nusselt numbers and friction factors and compared to off-the-shelf smooth pipe experiments. Results are compared to existing correlations and used to discuss the effects of the AM processes on thermal-hydraulic performance. It is seen that the inherent roughness of the AM channels leads to an increase in both heat transfer coefficient and pressure drop when compared to the conventional pipe. Recommendations are made for future studies based on these findings and additional considerations for the deployment of AM blanket cooling components.
- 21 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Fusion Science and Technology
- Vol. 79 (3) , 222-250
Large Component Simulation of an Inboard Sector of a Dual-Coolant Lead-Lithium Blanket
Advances in high-performance computing now enable the engineering evaluation of large blanket components from a systems perspective at the beginning of a normal design cycle. As an example, we discuss the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) involved in characterizing the thermal performance of an entire 22.5 toroidal sector of a dual-coolant lead-lithium blanket with particular attention to the integrated manifolding and flow distributions. The inboard sector is roughly 7 m tall, has 321 first-wall helium-cooled channels, and five parallel PbLi breeder channels complete with insulating SiC flow channel inserts. A finite volume model was developed with various degrees of mesh refinement from 36 to 187 million cells to perform the flow calculations on disparate fluids with conjugate heat transfer in the solid. Steady-state CFD calculations were performed using a realizable k-ε turbulence model. Simplifications include a uniform applied surface heat flux and a one-dimensional radial volumetric neutron heating profile. Constant material properties were used for the F82H reduced-activation ferritic martensitic (RAFM) steel walls, SiC flow channel inserts, and the PbLi breeder. Ideal gas behavior was assumed for the helium, which includes compressibility. Helium mass flows of 54 kg/s at 8 MPa and PbLi flows of 3 kg/s at 101 kPa supply the sector, both at an inlet temperature of 350°C. This early model is not optimized; however, it reveals important features not obvious in a conglomeration of smaller independent models. For example, all the manifolding was included to evaluate flow distributions throughout the full component. Submodels were only used to obtain the convective heat transfer coefficients (HTCs) inside the helium first-wall channels equipped with enhancement vanes that allow the first wall to handle 0.8 MW/m2 of plasma heat flux with the aim of keeping bulk RAFM steel temperatures near the creep-fatigue limit of 550°C. Average HTCs obtained from these detailed submodels were then used in the large model to predict thermal performance without incurring the meshing overhead from the thousands of internal vanes. Although much progress was made, initial results indicate that more must be done to further reduce hot spots on the first wall, minimize pressure drops, and provide optimal flow distributions.
- 21 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Fusion Science and Technology
- Vol. 79 (3) , 222-250
Large Component Simulation of an Inboard Sector of a Dual-Coolant Lead-Lithium Blanket
Advances in high-performance computing now enable the engineering evaluation of large blanket components from a systems perspective at the beginning of a normal design cycle. As an example, we discuss the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) involved in characterizing the thermal performance of an entire 22.5 toroidal sector of a dual-coolant lead-lithium blanket with particular attention to the integrated manifolding and flow distributions. The inboard sector is roughly 7 m tall, has 321 first-wall helium-cooled channels, and five parallel PbLi breeder channels complete with insulating SiC flow channel inserts. A finite volume model was developed with various degrees of mesh refinement from 36 to 187 million cells to perform the flow calculations on disparate fluids with conjugate heat transfer in the solid. Steady-state CFD calculations were performed using a realizable k-ε turbulence model. Simplifications include a uniform applied surface heat flux and a one-dimensional radial volumetric neutron heating profile. Constant material properties were used for the F82H reduced-activation ferritic martensitic (RAFM) steel walls, SiC flow channel inserts, and the PbLi breeder. Ideal gas behavior was assumed for the helium, which includes compressibility. Helium mass flows of 54 kg/s at 8 MPa and PbLi flows of 3 kg/s at 101 kPa supply the sector, both at an inlet temperature of 350°C. This early model is not optimized; however, it reveals important features not obvious in a conglomeration of smaller independent models. For example, all the manifolding was included to evaluate flow distributions throughout the full component. Submodels were only used to obtain the convective heat transfer coefficients (HTCs) inside the helium first-wall channels equipped with enhancement vanes that allow the first wall to handle 0.8 MW/m2 of plasma heat flux with the aim of keeping bulk RAFM steel temperatures near the creep-fatigue limit of 550°C. Average HTCs obtained from these detailed submodels were then used in the large model to predict thermal performance without incurring the meshing overhead from the thousands of internal vanes. Although much progress was made, initial results indicate that more must be done to further reduce hot spots on the first wall, minimize pressure drops, and provide optimal flow distributions.
- 17 November 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Fusion Science and Technology
- Vol. 77 (7-8) , IX-XI
Foreword
The present environment for fusion energy development is one with increasing momentum. As ITER prepares for first plasma and ultimately burning plasma operations, demonstration power plants and nex...
- 17 November 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Fusion Science and Technology
- Vol. 77 (7-8) , IX-XI
Foreword
The present environment for fusion energy development is one with increasing momentum. As ITER prepares for first plasma and ultimately burning plasma operations, demonstration power plants and nex...
- 30 September 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Fusion Science and Technology
- Vol. 77 (7-8) , 519-531
The Compactness and Inboard Radial Build of Fusion Nuclear Devices
Restraining the size of fusion power plants is considered an important avenue to make them a competitive energy source among other forms of energy production. The most critical contributor to the size of a tokamak is the inboard radial build, composed of multiple components with various functions. This build is the ultimate limit to size reduction. The Fusion Nuclear Science Facility is reviewed and each element of the inboard build is described, showing that the build, including breeding blanket, structural ring, vacuum vessel, low-temperature shield, and toroidal field and central solenoid (CS) coils, contributes 2.9 m of build, with 0.6 m of bore hole inside the CS coil, or 3.5 m to reach the plasma scrape-off layer. This implies that it would be challenging to make a significantly smaller build and simultaneously meet all the engineering requirements.
- 30 September 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Fusion Science and Technology
- Vol. 77 (7-8) , 519-531
The Compactness and Inboard Radial Build of Fusion Nuclear Devices
Restraining the size of fusion power plants is considered an important avenue to make them a competitive energy source among other forms of energy production. The most critical contributor to the size of a tokamak is the inboard radial build, composed of multiple components with various functions. This build is the ultimate limit to size reduction. The Fusion Nuclear Science Facility is reviewed and each element of the inboard build is described, showing that the build, including breeding blanket, structural ring, vacuum vessel, low-temperature shield, and toroidal field and central solenoid (CS) coils, contributes 2.9 m of build, with 0.6 m of bore hole inside the CS coil, or 3.5 m to reach the plasma scrape-off layer. This implies that it would be challenging to make a significantly smaller build and simultaneously meet all the engineering requirements.
- 18 August 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Fusion Science and Technology
- Vol. 77 (7-8) , 745-760
Status and Progress of Liquid Metal Thermofluids Modeling for the U.S. Fusion Nuclear Science Facility
At present, the U.S. Fusion Engineering Systems Study (FESS) considers several cooling/breeding concepts that utilize flowing liquid metals (LMs), Li, or eutectic PbLi alloy as working fluids for implementation of these concepts in the Fusion Nuclear Science Facility (FNSF). In this paper, we review recent modeling activities aimed at the investigation of LM flows and heat transfer relevant to the FESS-FNSF program. In particular, considerations are given to (1) development and validation & verification of computational magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) codes, (2) characterization of critical coupled MHD/heat transfer phenomena, and (3) design and analysis for selected LM applications in the FNSF. Under these three research thrusts, the reviewed topics including the MHD code HyPerComp Incompressible MHD solver for Arbitrary Geometries (HIMAG), MHD mixed-convection flows, MHD pressure drop in the blanket inlet/outlet manifolds, PbLi flows in a thermal convection loop, MHD PbLi flows in a dual-coolant lead-lithium blanket prototype, and a design window for a flowing Li divertor with He-cooled substrate.
- 18 August 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Fusion Science and Technology
- Vol. 77 (7-8) , 745-760
Status and Progress of Liquid Metal Thermofluids Modeling for the U.S. Fusion Nuclear Science Facility
At present, the U.S. Fusion Engineering Systems Study (FESS) considers several cooling/breeding concepts that utilize flowing liquid metals (LMs), Li, or eutectic PbLi alloy as working fluids for implementation of these concepts in the Fusion Nuclear Science Facility (FNSF). In this paper, we review recent modeling activities aimed at the investigation of LM flows and heat transfer relevant to the FESS-FNSF program. In particular, considerations are given to (1) development and validation & verification of computational magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) codes, (2) characterization of critical coupled MHD/heat transfer phenomena, and (3) design and analysis for selected LM applications in the FNSF. Under these three research thrusts, the reviewed topics including the MHD code HyPerComp Incompressible MHD solver for Arbitrary Geometries (HIMAG), MHD mixed-convection flows, MHD pressure drop in the blanket inlet/outlet manifolds, PbLi flows in a thermal convection loop, MHD PbLi flows in a dual-coolant lead-lithium blanket prototype, and a design window for a flowing Li divertor with He-cooled substrate.
- 4 August 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Fusion Science and Technology
- Vol. 77 (7-8) , 557-567
FNSF Structural Sizing Studies
New superconductor types and performance levels are being developed and have enabled consideration of higher-field, smaller-size devices. In this paper, sizing options for the next Fusion Energy System Study (FESS) design study are explored. The 2016/2017 baseline Fusion Nuclear Science Facility (FNSF) used a bucked and wedged solution with a large external case mainly to support out-of-plane loads and allow radial servicing. Use of a larger case to provide inner leg compression may be needed for the higher-field, smaller devices. These structural concepts have been employed in FIRE, IGNITOR, and C-Mod. Each of these concepts will be investigated as candidates for a next machine study. Recommendations will be made as to how these concepts can be incorporated into systems codes. The iterative design of the poloidal field coil system and the iterative choice of scenario currents are needed to go along with toroidal field (TF) coil support concepts. Concepts that employ a bucked solution require assessment of cancellation of the central solenoid radially outward and the TF radially inward load, and thus affect the sizing of both. Ideally better but simple structural models of the poloidal coils can be built into the scenario development codes to address advanced TF support schemes. Simplified spreadsheet assessments of structural concepts are presented, and these are benchmarked against finite element analyses. Possible options for the FNSF and next machine studies are assessed in terms of achievable fields and space allocation.
- 4 August 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Fusion Science and Technology
- Vol. 77 (7-8) , 557-567
FNSF Structural Sizing Studies
New superconductor types and performance levels are being developed and have enabled consideration of higher-field, smaller-size devices. In this paper, sizing options for the next Fusion Energy System Study (FESS) design study are explored. The 2016/2017 baseline Fusion Nuclear Science Facility (FNSF) used a bucked and wedged solution with a large external case mainly to support out-of-plane loads and allow radial servicing. Use of a larger case to provide inner leg compression may be needed for the higher-field, smaller devices. These structural concepts have been employed in FIRE, IGNITOR, and C-Mod. Each of these concepts will be investigated as candidates for a next machine study. Recommendations will be made as to how these concepts can be incorporated into systems codes. The iterative design of the poloidal field coil system and the iterative choice of scenario currents are needed to go along with toroidal field (TF) coil support concepts. Concepts that employ a bucked solution require assessment of cancellation of the central solenoid radially outward and the TF radially inward load, and thus affect the sizing of both. Ideally better but simple structural models of the poloidal coils can be built into the scenario development codes to address advanced TF support schemes. Simplified spreadsheet assessments of structural concepts are presented, and these are benchmarked against finite element analyses. Possible options for the FNSF and next machine studies are assessed in terms of achievable fields and space allocation.
- 10 May 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Fusion Science and Technology
- Vol. 77 (7-8) , 883-893
CFD Simulation of Helium Flow Loop Test Section
A helium flow loop is being assembled at Oak Ridge National Laboratory to analyze heat transfer enhancement for systems such as blanket and divertor components. To efficiently identify optimum geometries for heat transfer enhancement in these applications, simulation work is performed to optimize test section designs that are built and tested in the helium flow loop that operates at 4 MPa and a mass flow rate of 100 g/s. Different ribbed geometries that examine rib shape, rib height, rib orientation, rib spacing, and three-dimensional orientation are modeled and simulated in STAR-CCM+ to compare their ability to remove heat and mitigate pressure drop. Following the simulations, models are selected and manufactured for the helium flow loop tests. Simulations initially focus on a hydrodynamic study to determine the appropriate mesh and physics models and then add a heat flux to analyze the heat transfer abilities of the models. The simulations are run in steady state and use a Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes k-ε turbulence model. The helium is modeled as an ideal gas. The simulation explores models of geometries that enhance the heat transfer and decrease pressure drop with an overall goal of increasing fluid collision with the wall. Enhanced geometries are simulated to select appropriate designs for manufacturing, and preliminary experimental results are used to validate the simulations. The factors that are being analyzed in the comparison between the experimental and the simulated results include matching thermocouple temperatures, pressure drop, roughness, and fluid velocity.
- 10 May 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Fusion Science and Technology
- Vol. 77 (7-8) , 883-893
CFD Simulation of Helium Flow Loop Test Section
A helium flow loop is being assembled at Oak Ridge National Laboratory to analyze heat transfer enhancement for systems such as blanket and divertor components. To efficiently identify optimum geometries for heat transfer enhancement in these applications, simulation work is performed to optimize test section designs that are built and tested in the helium flow loop that operates at 4 MPa and a mass flow rate of 100 g/s. Different ribbed geometries that examine rib shape, rib height, rib orientation, rib spacing, and three-dimensional orientation are modeled and simulated in STAR-CCM+ to compare their ability to remove heat and mitigate pressure drop. Following the simulations, models are selected and manufactured for the helium flow loop tests. Simulations initially focus on a hydrodynamic study to determine the appropriate mesh and physics models and then add a heat flux to analyze the heat transfer abilities of the models. The simulations are run in steady state and use a Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes k-ε turbulence model. The helium is modeled as an ideal gas. The simulation explores models of geometries that enhance the heat transfer and decrease pressure drop with an overall goal of increasing fluid collision with the wall. Enhanced geometries are simulated to select appropriate designs for manufacturing, and preliminary experimental results are used to validate the simulations. The factors that are being analyzed in the comparison between the experimental and the simulated results include matching thermocouple temperatures, pressure drop, roughness, and fluid velocity.
- 24 July 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Fusion Science and Technology
- Vol. 76 (1) , 53-61
Potential Impacts of Liquid-Metal Plasma-Facing Components on Heating and Current Drive Actuators for a Fusion Nuclear Science Facility
This paper addresses the potential impact of liquid metal (LM) plasma-facing components (PFCs) for the heating and current drive (H&CD) actuators on the Fusion Nuclear Science Facility (FNSF) fusion reactor. Fulfilling the high neutron fluence mission of the FSNF requires steady-state operation for extremely long pulses (months to years) between maintenance opportunities. The use of LM as a surface material is one strategy for extending the lifetime of the PFCs for long pulse operation in a high heat flux, high neutron flux environment like that of the FNSF. Liquid metal PFCs provide possible pathways forward on many difficult aspects of a fusion reactor; however, the LM PFCs also bring new challenges and unknowns with respect to the H&CD actuators needed to provide steady-state operation. The development of LM-compatible materials for radio-frequency (RF) antennas will be critical, as well as strategies for minimizing contamination of antenna surfaces and the core plasma. Successful deployment of LM PFCs on the FNSF will require operational experience with RF in a LM environment both on test stands and in an integrated toroidal environment.
- 24 July 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Fusion Science and Technology
- Vol. 76 (1) , 53-61
Potential Impacts of Liquid-Metal Plasma-Facing Components on Heating and Current Drive Actuators for a Fusion Nuclear Science Facility
This paper addresses the potential impact of liquid metal (LM) plasma-facing components (PFCs) for the heating and current drive (H&CD) actuators on the Fusion Nuclear Science Facility (FNSF) fusion reactor. Fulfilling the high neutron fluence mission of the FSNF requires steady-state operation for extremely long pulses (months to years) between maintenance opportunities. The use of LM as a surface material is one strategy for extending the lifetime of the PFCs for long pulse operation in a high heat flux, high neutron flux environment like that of the FNSF. Liquid metal PFCs provide possible pathways forward on many difficult aspects of a fusion reactor; however, the LM PFCs also bring new challenges and unknowns with respect to the H&CD actuators needed to provide steady-state operation. The development of LM-compatible materials for radio-frequency (RF) antennas will be critical, as well as strategies for minimizing contamination of antenna surfaces and the core plasma. Successful deployment of LM PFCs on the FNSF will require operational experience with RF in a LM environment both on test stands and in an integrated toroidal environment.
- 18 June 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Fusion Science and Technology
- Vol. 75 (8) , 886-917
Critical Exploration of Liquid Metal Plasma-Facing Components in a Fusion Nuclear Science Facility
Liquid metal (LM) plasma-facing components (PFCs) may provide a resolution to the challenging fusion environment, particularly the first wall and divertor surfaces. Transforming these concepts into viable technologies will require considerable research and development. With the fusion nuclear regime in mind, the Fusion Energy System Studies group examined LM PFCs in order to identify needed research thrusts that could accelerate their development and assess their viability. Liquid metal behavior, solid substrate aspects, and fusion facility integration aspects are examined, with concepts as the research focusing element. The concepts applied to a fusion nuclear device are the primary definer of the LM parameters, environmental conditions, and operational aspects. This forms the research strategy recommended for these complex systems.
- 18 June 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Fusion Science and Technology
- Vol. 75 (8) , 886-917
Critical Exploration of Liquid Metal Plasma-Facing Components in a Fusion Nuclear Science Facility
Liquid metal (LM) plasma-facing components (PFCs) may provide a resolution to the challenging fusion environment, particularly the first wall and divertor surfaces. Transforming these concepts into viable technologies will require considerable research and development. With the fusion nuclear regime in mind, the Fusion Energy System Studies group examined LM PFCs in order to identify needed research thrusts that could accelerate their development and assess their viability. Liquid metal behavior, solid substrate aspects, and fusion facility integration aspects are examined, with concepts as the research focusing element. The concepts applied to a fusion nuclear device are the primary definer of the LM parameters, environmental conditions, and operational aspects. This forms the research strategy recommended for these complex systems.