Bernard Dost
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Bernard Dost has a total of 108 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Elmer Ruigrok
Department of Earth Sciences, Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands
6 shared publications - Julian J. Bommer
Department of civil and environmental engineering Imperial College London London UK
5 shared publications - Benjamin Edwards
School of Environmental Sciences, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, United Kingdom
4 shared publications Jesper Spetzler
4 shared publicationsTorild van Eck
4 shared publications- Pauline P. Kruiver
Deltares
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 8 January 2025
- Published by Amsterdam University Press
GotNL_Chapter22_GIS.zip
GIS files belonging to the figures of Chapter 22 - Natural and induced seismicity, in Geology of the Netherlands (second edition).
- 8 January 2025
- Published by Amsterdam University Press
Open AccessGotNL_Chapter22_GIS.zip
GIS files belonging to the figures of Chapter 22 - Natural and induced seismicity, in Geology of the Netherlands (second edition).
- Open Access
- 8 January 2025
- Published by Amsterdam University Press
GotNL_Chapter22_GIS.zip
GIS files belonging to the figures of Chapter 22 - Natural and induced seismicity, in Geology of the Netherlands (second edition).
- 8 January 2025
- Published by Amsterdam University Press
Open AccessGotNL_Chapter22_GIS.zip
GIS files belonging to the figures of Chapter 22 - Natural and induced seismicity, in Geology of the Netherlands (second edition).
- Open Access
- 7 November 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Seismology
- Vol. 26 (6) , 1157-1184
Ground-motion prediction models for induced earthquakes in the Groningen gas field, the Netherlands
Small-magnitude earthquakes induced by gas production in the Groningen field in the Netherlands have prompted the development of seismic risk models that serve both to estimate the impact of these events and to explore the efficacy of different risk mitigation strategies. A core element of the risk modelling is ground-motion prediction models (GMPM) derived from an extensive database of recordings obtained from a dense network of accelerographs installed in the field. For the verification of damage claims, an empirical GMPM for peak ground velocity (PGV) has been developed, which predicts horizontal PGV as a function of local magnitude,ML; hypocentral distance,Rhyp; and the time-averaged shear-wave velocity over the upper 30 m,VS30. For modelling the risk due to potential induced and triggered earthquakes of larger magnitude, a GMPM for response spectral accelerations has been developed from regressions on the outputs from finite-rupture simulations of motions at a deeply buried rock horizon. The GMPM for rock motions is coupled with a zonation map defining frequency-dependent non-linear amplification factors to obtain estimates of surface motions in the region of thick deposits of soft soils. The GMPM for spectral accelerations is formulated within a logic-tree framework to capture the epistemic uncertainty associated with extrapolation from recordings of events ofML ≤ 3.6 to much larger magnitudes.
- 7 November 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Seismology
- Vol. 26 (6) , 1157-1184
Open AccessGround-motion prediction models for induced earthquakes in the Groningen gas field, the Netherlands
Small-magnitude earthquakes induced by gas production in the Groningen field in the Netherlands have prompted the development of seismic risk models that serve both to estimate the impact of these events and to explore the efficacy of different risk mitigation strategies. A core element of the risk modelling is ground-motion prediction models (GMPM) derived from an extensive database of recordings obtained from a dense network of accelerographs installed in the field. For the verification of damage claims, an empirical GMPM for peak ground velocity (PGV) has been developed, which predicts horizontal PGV as a function of local magnitude,ML; hypocentral distance,Rhyp; and the time-averaged shear-wave velocity over the upper 30 m,VS30. For modelling the risk due to potential induced and triggered earthquakes of larger magnitude, a GMPM for response spectral accelerations has been developed from regressions on the outputs from finite-rupture simulations of motions at a deeply buried rock horizon. The GMPM for rock motions is coupled with a zonation map defining frequency-dependent non-linear amplification factors to obtain estimates of surface motions in the region of thick deposits of soft soils. The GMPM for spectral accelerations is formulated within a logic-tree framework to capture the epistemic uncertainty associated with extrapolation from recordings of events ofML ≤ 3.6 to much larger magnitudes.
- Open Access
- 18 February 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Geophysical Journal International
- Vol. 230 (2) , 776-795
Derivation of a near-surface damping model for the Groningen gas field
SUMMARY: Seismic damping of near-surface deposits is an important input to site-response analysis for seismic hazard assessment. In Groningen, the Netherlands, gas production from a reservoir at 3 km depth causes seismicity. Above the gas field, an 800 m thick layer of unconsolidated sediments exist, which consists of a mixture of sand, gravel, clay and peat strata. Shear waves induced at 3 km depth experience most of their anelastic attenuation in these loose sediments. A good estimate of damping is therefore crucial for modelling realistic ground-motion levels. In Groningen, we take advantage of a large network of 200 m deep vertical arrays to estimate damping from recordings of the induced events. As a first step, we apply seismic interferometry by deconvolution to estimate local transfer functions over these vertical arrays. Subsequently, two different methods are employed. The first is the ‘upgoing’ method, where the amplitude decay of the retrieved upgoing wave is used. The second is the ‘up-down’ method, where the amplitude difference between retrieved up- and downgoing waves is utilized. For the upgoing method, the amplitude of the upgoing direct wave is affected by both elastic and anelastic effects. In order to estimate the anelastic attenuation, it is necessary to remove the elastic amplification first. Despite the fact that elastic compensation could be determined quite accurately, non-physical damping values were estimated for a number of boreholes. Likely, the underlying cause was small differences in effective response functions of geophones at different depths. It was found that the up-down method is more robust. With this method, elastic propagation corrections are not needed. In addition, small differences in in situ geophone response are irrelevant because the up- and downgoing waves retrieved at the same geophone are used. For the 1-D case, we showed that for estimating the local transfer function, the complex reverberations need to be included in the interferometric process. Only when this is done, the transfer function does not contain elastic transmission loss and Q estimation can be made without knowing the soil profile in detail. Uncertainty in the estimated damping was found from the signal-to-noise ratio of the estimated transfer function. The Q profiles estimated with the up-down method were used to derive a damping model for the top 200 m of the entire Groningen field. A scaling relation was derived by comparing estimated Q profiles with low-strain damping profiles that were constructed using published models for low-strain damping linked to soil properties. This scaling relation, together with the soil-property-based damping model, allowed up-scaling of the model to each grid-cell in the Groningen field. For depths below 200 m, damping was derived from the attenuation of the microseism over Groningen. The mean damping model, over a frequency band between 2 and 20 Hz, was estimated to be 2.0 per cent (0–50 m depth), 1.3 per cent (50–100 m), 0.66 per cent (100–150 m), 0.57 per cent (150–200 m) and 0.5 per cent (200–580 m).
- 18 February 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Geophysical Journal International
- Vol. 230 (2) , 776-795
Open AccessDerivation of a near-surface damping model for the Groningen gas field
SUMMARY: Seismic damping of near-surface deposits is an important input to site-response analysis for seismic hazard assessment. In Groningen, the Netherlands, gas production from a reservoir at 3 km depth causes seismicity. Above the gas field, an 800 m thick layer of unconsolidated sediments exist, which consists of a mixture of sand, gravel, clay and peat strata. Shear waves induced at 3 km depth experience most of their anelastic attenuation in these loose sediments. A good estimate of damping is therefore crucial for modelling realistic ground-motion levels. In Groningen, we take advantage of a large network of 200 m deep vertical arrays to estimate damping from recordings of the induced events. As a first step, we apply seismic interferometry by deconvolution to estimate local transfer functions over these vertical arrays. Subsequently, two different methods are employed. The first is the ‘upgoing’ method, where the amplitude decay of the retrieved upgoing wave is used. The second is the ‘up-down’ method, where the amplitude difference between retrieved up- and downgoing waves is utilized. For the upgoing method, the amplitude of the upgoing direct wave is affected by both elastic and anelastic effects. In order to estimate the anelastic attenuation, it is necessary to remove the elastic amplification first. Despite the fact that elastic compensation could be determined quite accurately, non-physical damping values were estimated for a number of boreholes. Likely, the underlying cause was small differences in effective response functions of geophones at different depths. It was found that the up-down method is more robust. With this method, elastic propagation corrections are not needed. In addition, small differences in in situ geophone response are irrelevant because the up- and downgoing waves retrieved at the same geophone are used. For the 1-D case, we showed that for estimating the local transfer function, the complex reverberations need to be included in the interferometric process. Only when this is done, the transfer function does not contain elastic transmission loss and Q estimation can be made without knowing the soil profile in detail. Uncertainty in the estimated damping was found from the signal-to-noise ratio of the estimated transfer function. The Q profiles estimated with the up-down method were used to derive a damping model for the top 200 m of the entire Groningen field. A scaling relation was derived by comparing estimated Q profiles with low-strain damping profiles that were constructed using published models for low-strain damping linked to soil properties. This scaling relation, together with the soil-property-based damping model, allowed up-scaling of the model to each grid-cell in the Groningen field. For depths below 200 m, damping was derived from the attenuation of the microseism over Groningen. The mean damping model, over a frequency band between 2 and 20 Hz, was estimated to be 2.0 per cent (0–50 m depth), 1.3 per cent (50–100 m), 0.66 per cent (100–150 m), 0.57 per cent (150–200 m) and 0.5 per cent (200–580 m).
- 11 August 2020
- Published by Seismological Society of America (SSA) in Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America
- Vol. 110 (5) , 2112-2123
Probabilistic Moment Tensor Inversion for Hydrocarbon-Induced Seismicity in the Groningen Gas Field, the Netherlands, Part 2: Application
Recent developments in the densification of the seismic network covering the Groningen gas field allow a more detailed study of the connection between induced seismicity and reactivated faults around the gas reservoir at 3 km depth. With the reduction of the average station distance from 20 km to 4–5 km, a probabilistic full‐waveform moment tensor inversion procedure could be applied, resulting in both improved hypocenter location accuracy and full moment tensor solutions for events of recorded in the period 2016–2019. Hypocenter locations as output from the moment tensor inversion are compared to locations from the application of other methods and are found similar within 250 m distance. Moment tensor results show that the double‐couple (DC) solutions are in accordance with the known structure, namely normal faulting along 50°–70° dipping faults. Comparison with reprocessed 3D seismic sections, extended to a depth of 6–7 km, demonstrate that (a) most events occur along faults with a small throw and (b) reactivated faults in the reservoir often continue downward in the Carboniferous underburden. From non‐DC contributions, the isotropic (ISO) component is dominant and shows consistent negative values, which is expected in a compacting medium. There is some indication that events connected to faults with a large throw ( ) exhibit the largest ISO component (40%–50%).- 11 August 2020
- Published by Seismological Society of America (SSA) in Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America
- Vol. 110 (5) , 2112-2123
Probabilistic Moment Tensor Inversion for Hydrocarbon-Induced Seismicity in the Groningen Gas Field, the Netherlands, Part 2: Application
Recent developments in the densification of the seismic network covering the Groningen gas field allow a more detailed study of the connection between induced seismicity and reactivated faults around the gas reservoir at 3 km depth. With the reduction of the average station distance from 20 km to 4–5 km, a probabilistic full‐waveform moment tensor inversion procedure could be applied, resulting in both improved hypocenter location accuracy and full moment tensor solutions for events of recorded in the period 2016–2019. Hypocenter locations as output from the moment tensor inversion are compared to locations from the application of other methods and are found similar within 250 m distance. Moment tensor results show that the double‐couple (DC) solutions are in accordance with the known structure, namely normal faulting along 50°–70° dipping faults. Comparison with reprocessed 3D seismic sections, extended to a depth of 6–7 km, demonstrate that (a) most events occur along faults with a small throw and (b) reactivated faults in the reservoir often continue downward in the Carboniferous underburden. From non‐DC contributions, the isotropic (ISO) component is dominant and shows consistent negative values, which is expected in a compacting medium. There is some indication that events connected to faults with a large throw ( ) exhibit the largest ISO component (40%–50%).- Open Access
- 28 October 2019
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Seismology
- Vol. 23 (6) , 1233-1253
Ground-motion networks in the Groningen field: usability and consistency of surface recordings
Several strong-motion networks have been installed in the Groningen gas field in the Netherlands to record ground motions associated with induced earthquakes. There are now more than 450 permanent surface accelerographs plus a mobile array of 450 instruments, which, in addition to many instrumented boreholes, yield a wealth of data. The database of recordings has been of fundamental importance to the development of ground-motion models that form a key element of the seismic hazard and risk estimations for the field. In order to maximise the benefit that can be derived from these recordings, this study evaluates the usability of the recordings from the different networks, in general terms and specifically with regards to the frequency ranges with acceptable signal-to-noise ratios. The study also explores the consistency among the recordings from the different networks, highlighting in particular how a configuration error was identified and resolved. The largest accelerograph network consists of instruments housed in buildings around the field, frequently installed on the lower parts of walls rather than on the floor. A series of experiments were conducted, using additional instruments installed adjacent to these buildings and replicating the installation configuration in full-scale shake table tests, to identify the degree to which structural response contaminated the recordings. The general finding of these efforts was that for PGV and oscillator periods above 0.1 s, the response spectral ordinates from these recordings can be used with confidence.
- 28 October 2019
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Seismology
- Vol. 23 (6) , 1233-1253
Open AccessGround-motion networks in the Groningen field: usability and consistency of surface recordings
Several strong-motion networks have been installed in the Groningen gas field in the Netherlands to record ground motions associated with induced earthquakes. There are now more than 450 permanent surface accelerographs plus a mobile array of 450 instruments, which, in addition to many instrumented boreholes, yield a wealth of data. The database of recordings has been of fundamental importance to the development of ground-motion models that form a key element of the seismic hazard and risk estimations for the field. In order to maximise the benefit that can be derived from these recordings, this study evaluates the usability of the recordings from the different networks, in general terms and specifically with regards to the frequency ranges with acceptable signal-to-noise ratios. The study also explores the consistency among the recordings from the different networks, highlighting in particular how a configuration error was identified and resolved. The largest accelerograph network consists of instruments housed in buildings around the field, frequently installed on the lower parts of walls rather than on the floor. A series of experiments were conducted, using additional instruments installed adjacent to these buildings and replicating the installation configuration in full-scale shake table tests, to identify the degree to which structural response contaminated the recordings. The general finding of these efforts was that for PGV and oscillator periods above 0.1 s, the response spectral ordinates from these recordings can be used with confidence.
- 24 April 2019
- Published by Seismological Society of America (SSA) in Seismological Research Letters
- Vol. 90 (4) , 1660-1662
Erratum The Relationship between M and ML: A Review and Application to Induced Seismicity in the Groningen Gas Field, The Netherlands
In response to induced earthquakes associated with conventional gas production in the Groningen gas field in the Netherlands, several networks of seismic monitoring instruments have been installed in the region (Dost et al., 2017). The recordings recovered from these networks have been of fundamental importance to the development of ground‐motion prediction models that underpin hazard and risk modeling to inform decision making regarding mitigation measures (van Elk et al., 2019). In late 2018, it was discovered that the surface accelerographs of the G‐network had been installed with a calibration error such that the majority...
- 24 April 2019
- Published by Seismological Society of America (SSA) in Seismological Research Letters
- Vol. 90 (4) , 1660-1662
Erratum The Relationship between M and ML: A Review and Application to Induced Seismicity in the Groningen Gas Field, The Netherlands
In response to induced earthquakes associated with conventional gas production in the Groningen gas field in the Netherlands, several networks of seismic monitoring instruments have been installed in the region (Dost et al., 2017). The recordings recovered from these networks have been of fundamental importance to the development of ground‐motion prediction models that underpin hazard and risk modeling to inform decision making regarding mitigation measures (van Elk et al., 2019). In late 2018, it was discovered that the surface accelerographs of the G‐network had been installed with a calibration error such that the majority...
- 1 May 2018
- Published by Seismological Society of America (SSA) in Seismological Research Letters
- Vol. 89 (3) , 1062-1074
The Relationship between M and ML: A Review and Application to Induced Seismicity in the Groningen Gas Field, The Netherlands
The use of local magnitude (M-L) in seismic hazard analyses is a topic of recent debate. In regions of weak or moderate seismicity, small earthquakes (characterized by M-L) are commonly used to determine frequency-magnitude distributions (FMDs) for probabilistic seismic hazard calculations. However, empirical and theoretical studies on the relation between moment magnitude (M) and M-L for small earthquakes show a systematic difference between the two below a region-dependent magnitude threshold. This difference may introduce bias in the estimation of the frequency of larger events with given M, and consequently seismic hazard. For induced seismicity related to the Groningen gas field, this magnitude threshold is determined to be M similar to 2, with equality between M and M-L at higher magnitudes. A quadratic relation between M and M-L is derived for 0: 5 < M-L < 2, in correspondence to recent theoretical studies. Although the seismic hazard analysis for Groningen is internally consistent when expressed in terms of M-L (with the implicit assumption of equivalence between the two scales), a more physical interpretation of the seismicity model requires transformation of the earthquake catalog from local to moment magnitude, especially because the dataset currently used in estimating time-dependent hazard consists mainly of M-L < 2:5 events. We show that measured station effects, derived from M calculations, correspond to predicted model calculations used to determine a ground-motion model for the region.
- 1 May 2018
- Published by Seismological Society of America (SSA) in Seismological Research Letters
- Vol. 89 (3) , 1062-1074
The Relationship between M and ML: A Review and Application to Induced Seismicity in the Groningen Gas Field, The Netherlands
The use of local magnitude (M-L) in seismic hazard analyses is a topic of recent debate. In regions of weak or moderate seismicity, small earthquakes (characterized by M-L) are commonly used to determine frequency-magnitude distributions (FMDs) for probabilistic seismic hazard calculations. However, empirical and theoretical studies on the relation between moment magnitude (M) and M-L for small earthquakes show a systematic difference between the two below a region-dependent magnitude threshold. This difference may introduce bias in the estimation of the frequency of larger events with given M, and consequently seismic hazard. For induced seismicity related to the Groningen gas field, this magnitude threshold is determined to be M similar to 2, with equality between M and M-L at higher magnitudes. A quadratic relation between M and M-L is derived for 0: 5 < M-L < 2, in correspondence to recent theoretical studies. Although the seismic hazard analysis for Groningen is internally consistent when expressed in terms of M-L (with the implicit assumption of equivalence between the two scales), a more physical interpretation of the seismicity model requires transformation of the earthquake catalog from local to moment magnitude, especially because the dataset currently used in estimating time-dependent hazard consists mainly of M-L < 2:5 events. We show that measured station effects, derived from M calculations, correspond to predicted model calculations used to determine a ground-motion model for the region.
- Open Access
- 1 December 2017
- Published by Netherlands Journal of Geosciences Foundation in Netherlands Journal of Geosciences
- Vol. 96 (5) , s235-s245
Development of seismicity and probabilistic hazard assessment for the Groningen gas field
The increase in number and strength of shallow induced seismicity connected to the Groningen gas field since 2003 and the occurrence of aML3.6 event in 2012 started the development of a full probabilistic seismic hazard assessment (PSHA) for Groningen, required by the regulator. Densification of the monitoring network resulted in a decrease of the location threshold and magnitude of completeness down to ~ML=0.5. Combined with a detailed local velocity model, epicentre accuracy could be reduced from 0.5–1km to 0.1–0.3km and a vertical resolution ~0.3km. Time-dependent seismic activity is observed and taken into account into PSHA calculations. Development of the Ground Motion Model for Groningen resulted in a significant reduction of the hazard. Comparison of different implementations of the PSHA, using different source models, based on either a compaction model and production scenarios or on extrapolation of past seismicity, and methods of calculation, shows similar results.
- 1 December 2017
- Published by Netherlands Journal of Geosciences Foundation in Netherlands Journal of Geosciences
- Vol. 96 (5) , s235-s245
Open AccessDevelopment of seismicity and probabilistic hazard assessment for the Groningen gas field
The increase in number and strength of shallow induced seismicity connected to the Groningen gas field since 2003 and the occurrence of aML3.6 event in 2012 started the development of a full probabilistic seismic hazard assessment (PSHA) for Groningen, required by the regulator. Densification of the monitoring network resulted in a decrease of the location threshold and magnitude of completeness down to ~ML=0.5. Combined with a detailed local velocity model, epicentre accuracy could be reduced from 0.5–1km to 0.1–0.3km and a vertical resolution ~0.3km. Time-dependent seismic activity is observed and taken into account into PSHA calculations. Development of the Ground Motion Model for Groningen resulted in a significant reduction of the hazard. Comparison of different implementations of the PSHA, using different source models, based on either a compaction model and production scenarios or on extrapolation of past seismicity, and methods of calculation, shows similar results.
- 17 October 2017
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
- Vol. 122 (10) , 8035-8050
A Shallow Seismic Velocity Model for the Groningen Area in the Netherlands
The province of Groningen in the Netherlands holds one of the world's largest natural gas fields, and it has been an important source of energy for Western Europe for many decades. The seismicity in recent years called for a better understanding of the local subsurface, and therefore a dense network of 70 boreholes was installed in early 2015. Each borehole is equipped with four geophones and a surface accelerometer. In this study, data from this network are used to determine the shallow velocity structure that is important for the quantification of the seismic hazard and accurate source localizations. Compressional and shear wave velocity profiles with uncertainties are derived for each of the 200 m deep boreholes using passive seismic interferometry applied to local event data. The resulting seismic velocity distributions are presented as contour maps for 50 m depth intervals. The maps show strong lateral variations, where areas of low VP/VS ratio correspond to regions of sedimentary infill. The shear wave velocities were derived using the transverse component seismograms. Because the sensor orientations of the borehole geophones were unknown, they had to be determined first. This was done using a novel method based on cross correlations between the geophones and their colocated surface accelerometer. In addition, by extensive cross‐correlation analysis over the network, several installation inconsistencies were identified and resolved.
- 17 October 2017
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
- Vol. 122 (10) , 8035-8050
A Shallow Seismic Velocity Model for the Groningen Area in the Netherlands
The province of Groningen in the Netherlands holds one of the world's largest natural gas fields, and it has been an important source of energy for Western Europe for many decades. The seismicity in recent years called for a better understanding of the local subsurface, and therefore a dense network of 70 boreholes was installed in early 2015. Each borehole is equipped with four geophones and a surface accelerometer. In this study, data from this network are used to determine the shallow velocity structure that is important for the quantification of the seismic hazard and accurate source localizations. Compressional and shear wave velocity profiles with uncertainties are derived for each of the 200 m deep boreholes using passive seismic interferometry applied to local event data. The resulting seismic velocity distributions are presented as contour maps for 50 m depth intervals. The maps show strong lateral variations, where areas of low VP/VS ratio correspond to regions of sedimentary infill. The shear wave velocities were derived using the transverse component seismograms. Because the sensor orientations of the borehole geophones were unknown, they had to be determined first. This was done using a novel method based on cross correlations between the geophones and their colocated surface accelerometer. In addition, by extensive cross‐correlation analysis over the network, several installation inconsistencies were identified and resolved.