Enrico Rubiola
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Enrico Rubiola has a total of 76 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Francois Vernotte
Obs. Besançon, Univ. Metz, CNRS-Univ. Besançon
7 shared publications - Vincent Giordano
FEMTO-ST Institute UMR 6174 CNRS ENSMM 26 Chemin de l' Épitaphe 25000 Besançon -FRANCE and 2 FEMTO Engineering 32 avenue de l'Observatoire 25000 Besançon UFC UTBM FRANCE
7 shared publications - Claudio Eligio Calosso
Istituto Nazionale di Ricerca Metrologica INRIM Torino Italy
5 shared publications - Jean-Michel Friedt
FEMTO-ST Institute, Besanon, France
5 shared publications Vincent Giordano
Department of Time and Frequency, FEMTO-ST, Observatory THETA, UMR 6174 CNRS, Université Bourgogne Franche-Comté, Besançon, France
4 shared publications- Benoît Dubois
FEMTO Engineering, 32 Avenue de l'Observatoire 25000 Besançon, France
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 1 October 2026
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques
- Vol. 74 (10) , 9311-9313
Correction to "The Companion of Enrico's Chart for Phase Noise and Two-Sample Variances"
- 1 October 2026
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques
- Vol. 74 (10) , 9311-9313
Correction to "The Companion of Enrico's Chart for Phase Noise and Two-Sample Variances"
- 31 October 2025
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in Journal of Lightwave Technology
- Vol. 44 (1) , 222-228
Phase Noise Measurement of Optical Amplifiers
We introduce a novel measurement method for the phase noise measurement of optical amplifiers, topologically similar to the Heterodyne Mach-Zehnder Interferometer but governed by different principles, and we report on the measurement of a fibered semiconductor amplifier at 1.55 $\mu$m wavelength operated below saturation. The amplifier under test (DUT) is inserted in one arm of a symmetrical Mach-Zehnder interferometer, with an AOM in the other arm. We measure the phase noise of the RF beat detected at the Mach-Zehnder output. The phase noise floor of the amplifier decreases proportionally to the reciprocal of the laser power at the amplifier input, down to $-126$ $\mathrm{dBrad^{2}/Hz}$ at $f=100$ $\mathrm{kHz}$. The DUT flicker noise cannot be measured because it is lower than the background of the setup. This sets an upper bound of the amplifier noise at $-32$ $\mathrm{dBrad^{2}/Hz}$ at $f=1$ Hz, which corresponds to a frequency stability of $5.2{\times }10^{-17}/\tau$ (Allan deviation), where $\tau$ is the integration time. Such noise level is lower than that of most Fabry-Pérot cavity-stabilized lasers. These results are of interest in a wide range of applications including metrology, instrumentation, optical communications, or fiber links.
- 31 October 2025
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in Journal of Lightwave Technology
- Vol. 44 (1) , 222-228
Phase Noise Measurement of Optical Amplifiers
We introduce a novel measurement method for the phase noise measurement of optical amplifiers, topologically similar to the Heterodyne Mach-Zehnder Interferometer but governed by different principles, and we report on the measurement of a fibered semiconductor amplifier at 1.55 $\mu$m wavelength operated below saturation. The amplifier under test (DUT) is inserted in one arm of a symmetrical Mach-Zehnder interferometer, with an AOM in the other arm. We measure the phase noise of the RF beat detected at the Mach-Zehnder output. The phase noise floor of the amplifier decreases proportionally to the reciprocal of the laser power at the amplifier input, down to $-126$ $\mathrm{dBrad^{2}/Hz}$ at $f=100$ $\mathrm{kHz}$. The DUT flicker noise cannot be measured because it is lower than the background of the setup. This sets an upper bound of the amplifier noise at $-32$ $\mathrm{dBrad^{2}/Hz}$ at $f=1$ Hz, which corresponds to a frequency stability of $5.2{\times }10^{-17}/\tau$ (Allan deviation), where $\tau$ is the integration time. Such noise level is lower than that of most Fabry-Pérot cavity-stabilized lasers. These results are of interest in a wide range of applications including metrology, instrumentation, optical communications, or fiber links.
- Open Access
- 24 July 2023
- Published by AIP Publishing in Applied Physics Letters
- Vol. 123 (4)
A cryogenic sapphire resonator oscillator with 10−16 mid-term fractional frequency stability
We report in this Letter the outstanding frequency stability performance of an autonomous cryogenic sapphire oscillator (CSO) presenting a flicker frequency noise floor below 2×10−16 near 1000 s of integration time and a long-term Allan deviation limited by a random walk process of ∼1×10−18τ. The frequency stability qualification at this level called for the implementation of sophisticated instrumentation associated with ultra-stable frequency references. This result is technologically sound as it demonstrates the potentiality of the CSO technology. From the physical point of view, it sets an upper limit to the ultimate noise floor of the cryogenic microwave resonator that is competitive to that of the ultra-stable optical Fabry–Pérot cavities.
- 24 July 2023
- Published by AIP Publishing in Applied Physics Letters
- Vol. 123 (4)
Open AccessA cryogenic sapphire resonator oscillator with 10−16 mid-term fractional frequency stability
We report in this Letter the outstanding frequency stability performance of an autonomous cryogenic sapphire oscillator (CSO) presenting a flicker frequency noise floor below 2×10−16 near 1000 s of integration time and a long-term Allan deviation limited by a random walk process of ∼1×10−18τ. The frequency stability qualification at this level called for the implementation of sophisticated instrumentation associated with ultra-stable frequency references. This result is technologically sound as it demonstrates the potentiality of the CSO technology. From the physical point of view, it sets an upper limit to the ultimate noise floor of the cryogenic microwave resonator that is competitive to that of the ultra-stable optical Fabry–Pérot cavities.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 1 July 2023
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques
- Vol. 71 (7) , 2996-3025
The Companion of Enrico’s Chart for Phase Noise and Two-Sample Variances
Phase noise and frequency (in)stability both describe the fluctuation of stable periodic signals from somewhat different standpoints. Frequency is unique compared to other domains of metrology, in which its fluctuations of interest span at least 14 orders of magnitude, from $10^{-4}$ in a mechanical watch to $10^{-18}$ in atomic clocks. The frequency span of interest is some 12–15 orders of magnitude from $\mu$ Hz to GHz Fourier frequency for phase noise, while the time span over which the fluctuations occur ranges from sub-μ s to years integration time for variances. Because this domain is ubiquitous in science and technology, a common language and tools suitable to the variety mentioned are a challenge. This article is at once: 1) a tutorial; 2) a review covering the most important facts about phase noise, frequency noise, and two-sample (Allan and Allan-like) variances; and 3) a user guide to “Enrico’s Chart of Phase Noise and Two-Sample Variances.” In turn, the Chart is a reference card collecting the most useful concepts, formulas, and plots in a single A4/A-size sheet, intended to be a staple on the desk of whoever works with these topics. The Chart is available under Creative Commons 4.0 CC-BY-NC-ND license from Zenodo, DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.4399218. A wealth of auxiliary material is available for free on Enrico’s home page: http://rubiola.org.
- 1 July 2023
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques
- Vol. 71 (7) , 2996-3025
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessThe Companion of Enrico’s Chart for Phase Noise and Two-Sample Variances
Phase noise and frequency (in)stability both describe the fluctuation of stable periodic signals from somewhat different standpoints. Frequency is unique compared to other domains of metrology, in which its fluctuations of interest span at least 14 orders of magnitude, from $10^{-4}$ in a mechanical watch to $10^{-18}$ in atomic clocks. The frequency span of interest is some 12–15 orders of magnitude from $\mu$ Hz to GHz Fourier frequency for phase noise, while the time span over which the fluctuations occur ranges from sub-μ s to years integration time for variances. Because this domain is ubiquitous in science and technology, a common language and tools suitable to the variety mentioned are a challenge. This article is at once: 1) a tutorial; 2) a review covering the most important facts about phase noise, frequency noise, and two-sample (Allan and Allan-like) variances; and 3) a user guide to “Enrico’s Chart of Phase Noise and Two-Sample Variances.” In turn, the Chart is a reference card collecting the most useful concepts, formulas, and plots in a single A4/A-size sheet, intended to be a staple on the desk of whoever works with these topics. The Chart is available under Creative Commons 4.0 CC-BY-NC-ND license from Zenodo, DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.4399218. A wealth of auxiliary material is available for free on Enrico’s home page: http://rubiola.org.
- 5 June 2023
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement
- Vol. 72 (00189456) , 1-8
Reliability and Reproducibility of the Cryogenic Sapphire Oscillator Technology
The cryogenic sapphire oscillator (CSO) is a highly specialized machine, which delivers a microwave reference signal exhibiting the lowest frequency fluctuations (Allan deviation σy(τ)) for the integration time τ between 1 s and 104 s, indeed 4 decades. In such interval, good units feature σy(τ) < 10-15, with < 10-14 drift in one day. The oscillator is based on a sapphire monocrystal resonating at 10 GHz in a whisperinggallery mode, cooled at ≈ 6 K for zero thermal coefficient and optimal quality factor Q.We report on the progress accomplished implementing eleven CSOs in about 10 years since the first sample delivered to the Malargüe station of the European Space Agency (ESA) in Argentina. Short-term stability is improved by a factor of 3.10, depending on τ, and the refrigerator’s electric power is reduced to 3 kW single-phase line. Frequency stability and overall performances are reproducible, with unattended operation between scheduled maintenance every two years. The CSO is now a semicommercial product suitable to scientific applications requiring extreme frequency stability with reliable unattended long-term operation, like the flywheel for primary frequency standards, the ground segment of Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS), astrometry, Very Long Baseline Interferometry, and radio astronomy stations.
- 5 June 2023
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement
- Vol. 72 (00189456) , 1-8
Reliability and Reproducibility of the Cryogenic Sapphire Oscillator Technology
The cryogenic sapphire oscillator (CSO) is a highly specialized machine, which delivers a microwave reference signal exhibiting the lowest frequency fluctuations (Allan deviation σy(τ)) for the integration time τ between 1 s and 104 s, indeed 4 decades. In such interval, good units feature σy(τ) < 10-15, with < 10-14 drift in one day. The oscillator is based on a sapphire monocrystal resonating at 10 GHz in a whisperinggallery mode, cooled at ≈ 6 K for zero thermal coefficient and optimal quality factor Q.We report on the progress accomplished implementing eleven CSOs in about 10 years since the first sample delivered to the Malargüe station of the European Space Agency (ESA) in Argentina. Short-term stability is improved by a factor of 3.10, depending on τ, and the refrigerator’s electric power is reduced to 3 kW single-phase line. Frequency stability and overall performances are reproducible, with unattended operation between scheduled maintenance every two years. The CSO is now a semicommercial product suitable to scientific applications requiring extreme frequency stability with reliable unattended long-term operation, like the flywheel for primary frequency standards, the ground segment of Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS), astrometry, Very Long Baseline Interferometry, and radio astronomy stations.
- 22 June 2022
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics, and Frequency Control
- Vol. 69 (8) , 2585-2594
The Statistics of the Cross-Spectrum and the Spectrum Average: Generalization to Multiple Instruments
This article addresses the measurement of the power spectrum of red noise processes at the lowest frequencies, where the minimum acquisition time is so long that it is impossible to average on a sequence of data record. Therefore, averaging is possible only on simultaneous observation of multiple instruments. This is the case of radio astronomy, which we take as the paradigm, but examples may be found in other fields such as climatology and geodesy. We compare the Bayesian confidence interval of the red noise parameter using two estimators, the spectrum average and the cross-spectrum. While the spectrum average is widely used, the cross-spectrum using multiple instruments is rather uncommon. With two instruments, the cross-spectrum estimator leads to the Variance-Gamma distribution. A generalization to q devices based on the Fourier transform of characteristic functions is provided, with the example of the observation of millisecond pulsars with 5 radio telescopes. The simulations show that the spectrum average is by a small amount more efficient than the cross-spectrum, chiefly when the background exceeds the signal. However some notable differences between their upper limit indicate that it should be wiser to compute both estimators.
- 22 June 2022
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics, and Frequency Control
- Vol. 69 (8) , 2585-2594
The Statistics of the Cross-Spectrum and the Spectrum Average: Generalization to Multiple Instruments
This article addresses the measurement of the power spectrum of red noise processes at the lowest frequencies, where the minimum acquisition time is so long that it is impossible to average on a sequence of data record. Therefore, averaging is possible only on simultaneous observation of multiple instruments. This is the case of radio astronomy, which we take as the paradigm, but examples may be found in other fields such as climatology and geodesy. We compare the Bayesian confidence interval of the red noise parameter using two estimators, the spectrum average and the cross-spectrum. While the spectrum average is widely used, the cross-spectrum using multiple instruments is rather uncommon. With two instruments, the cross-spectrum estimator leads to the Variance-Gamma distribution. A generalization to q devices based on the Fourier transform of characteristic functions is provided, with the example of the observation of millisecond pulsars with 5 radio telescopes. The simulations show that the spectrum average is by a small amount more efficient than the cross-spectrum, chiefly when the background exceeds the signal. However some notable differences between their upper limit indicate that it should be wiser to compute both estimators.
- 24 January 2022
- Published by AIP Publishing in Applied Physics Letters
- Vol. 120 (4) , 044101
All-optical microwave feedback oscillator with atomic cell resonator
We report the demonstration of an all-optical self-sustained cell-based microwave feedback oscillator. In this scheme, a microwave resonance, optically induced in a buffer-gas filled vapor cell resonator through coherent population trapping (CPT), is detected by a fast photodiode, amplified, and used to drive back, through a frequency divider, a Mach–Zehnder electro-optic modulator in a sustaining loop configuration. The total gain and phase of the system was measured in an open-loop configuration with a network analyzer. In good agreement with values predicted by the Leeson effect, the CPT feedback oscillator demonstrates an absolute phase noise of −24 dB rad2/Hz at 1 Hz offset frequency, compatible with a fractional frequency stability of 8 × 10−12 at 1 s, and a phase noise floor of −112 dB rad2/Hz, limited by the low microwave power available at the photodiode output. The amplitude noise of the oscillator shows a comparable noise floor and, for offset frequencies lower than 200 Hz, a 1/f dependence, due to the presence of the frequency divider in the loop.
- 24 January 2022
- Published by AIP Publishing in Applied Physics Letters
- Vol. 120 (4) , 044101
All-optical microwave feedback oscillator with atomic cell resonator
We report the demonstration of an all-optical self-sustained cell-based microwave feedback oscillator. In this scheme, a microwave resonance, optically induced in a buffer-gas filled vapor cell resonator through coherent population trapping (CPT), is detected by a fast photodiode, amplified, and used to drive back, through a frequency divider, a Mach–Zehnder electro-optic modulator in a sustaining loop configuration. The total gain and phase of the system was measured in an open-loop configuration with a network analyzer. In good agreement with values predicted by the Leeson effect, the CPT feedback oscillator demonstrates an absolute phase noise of −24 dB rad2/Hz at 1 Hz offset frequency, compatible with a fractional frequency stability of 8 × 10−12 at 1 s, and a phase noise floor of −112 dB rad2/Hz, limited by the low microwave power available at the photodiode output. The amplitude noise of the oscillator shows a comparable noise floor and, for offset frequencies lower than 200 Hz, a 1/f dependence, due to the presence of the frequency divider in the loop.
- 26 April 2021
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement
- Vol. 70 (00189456) , 1-6
Response and Uncertainty of the Parabolic Variance PVAR to Noninteger Exponents of Power Law
The oscillator fluctuations are described as the phase or frequency-noise spectrum or in terms of a wavelet variance as a function of the measurement time. The spectrum is generally approximated with the “power law,” i.e., a Laurent polynomial with integer exponents of the frequency. This article provides: 1) the analytical expression of the response of the wavelet variance parabolic variance (PVAR) to the frequency-noise spectrum in the general case of noninteger exponents of the frequency and 2) a useful approximate expression of the statistical uncertainty. In turn, PVAR is relevant in that it replaces the widely used modified Allan variance (MVAR), featuring the identification of noise processes with fewer data.
- 26 April 2021
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement
- Vol. 70 (00189456) , 1-6
Response and Uncertainty of the Parabolic Variance PVAR to Noninteger Exponents of Power Law
The oscillator fluctuations are described as the phase or frequency-noise spectrum or in terms of a wavelet variance as a function of the measurement time. The spectrum is generally approximated with the “power law,” i.e., a Laurent polynomial with integer exponents of the frequency. This article provides: 1) the analytical expression of the response of the wavelet variance parabolic variance (PVAR) to the frequency-noise spectrum in the general case of noninteger exponents of the frequency and 2) a useful approximate expression of the statistical uncertainty. In turn, PVAR is relevant in that it replaces the widely used modified Allan variance (MVAR), featuring the identification of noise processes with fewer data.
- Open Access
- 19 August 2020
- Published by IOP Publishing in Metrologia
- Vol. 57 (5) , 055010
Artifacts and errors in cross-spectrum phase noise measurements
This article deals with the erratic and inconsistent phase-noise spectra often seen in low-noise oscillators, whose floor is of the order of −180 dBc/Hz or less. Such oscillators are generally measured with two-channel instruments based on averaging two simultaneous and statistically independent measures. Our new method consists of inserting a dissipative attenuator between the oscillator under test and the phase-noise analyzer. The thermal noise of the attenuator introduces a controlled amount of phase noise. We compare the phase noise floor to the theoretical expectation with different values of the attenuation in small steps. The analysis reveals a negative bias (underestimation of phase noise) due to the thermal energy of the internal power splitter at the instrument input, and an uncertainty due to crosstalk between the two channels. In not-so-rare unfortunate cases, the bias results in a negative phase-noise spectrum, which is an obvious nonsense. Similar results are observed separately in three labs with instruments from the two major brands. We provide experimental evidence, full theory and suggestions to mitigate the problem, and a first attempt to assess the uncertainty. Our multiple-attenuators method provides quantitative information about the correlation phenomena inside the instrument.
- 19 August 2020
- Published by IOP Publishing in Metrologia
- Vol. 57 (5) , 055010
Open AccessArtifacts and errors in cross-spectrum phase noise measurements
This article deals with the erratic and inconsistent phase-noise spectra often seen in low-noise oscillators, whose floor is of the order of −180 dBc/Hz or less. Such oscillators are generally measured with two-channel instruments based on averaging two simultaneous and statistically independent measures. Our new method consists of inserting a dissipative attenuator between the oscillator under test and the phase-noise analyzer. The thermal noise of the attenuator introduces a controlled amount of phase noise. We compare the phase noise floor to the theoretical expectation with different values of the attenuation in small steps. The analysis reveals a negative bias (underestimation of phase noise) due to the thermal energy of the internal power splitter at the instrument input, and an uncertainty due to crosstalk between the two channels. In not-so-rare unfortunate cases, the bias results in a negative phase-noise spectrum, which is an obvious nonsense. Similar results are observed separately in three labs with instruments from the two major brands. We provide experimental evidence, full theory and suggestions to mitigate the problem, and a first attempt to assess the uncertainty. Our multiple-attenuators method provides quantitative information about the correlation phenomena inside the instrument.
- 13 August 2020
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in Journal of Microelectromechanical Systems
- Vol. 29 (5) , 1347-1361
Fundamental Noise Limits and Sensitivity of Piezoelectrically Driven Magnetoelastic Cantilevers
Magnetoelastic sensors for the detection of low-frequency and low-amplitude magnetic fields are in the focus of research for more than 30 years. In order to minimize the limit of detection (LOD) of such sensor systems, it is of high importance to understand and to be able to quantify the relevant noise sources. In this contribution, cantilever-type electromechanical and magnetoelastic resonators, respectively, are comprehensively investigated and mathematically described not only with regard to their phase sensitivity but especially to the extent of the sensor-intrinsic phase noise. Both measurements and calculations reveal that the fundamental LOD is limited by additive phase noise due to thermal-mechanical noise of the resonator, i.e. by thermally induced random vibrations of the cantilever, and by thermal-electrical noise of the piezoelectric material. However, due to losses in the magnetic material parametric flicker phase noise arises, limiting the overall performance. In particular, it is shown that the LOD is virtually independent of the magnetic sensitivity but is solely determined by the magnetic losses. Instead of the sensitivity, the magnetic losses, represented by the material's effective complex permeability, should be considered as the most important parameter for the further improvement of such sensors in the future. This implication is not only valid for magnetoelastic cantilevers but also applies to any type of magnetoelastic resonator. [2020-0219]
- 13 August 2020
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in Journal of Microelectromechanical Systems
- Vol. 29 (5) , 1347-1361
Fundamental Noise Limits and Sensitivity of Piezoelectrically Driven Magnetoelastic Cantilevers
Magnetoelastic sensors for the detection of low-frequency and low-amplitude magnetic fields are in the focus of research for more than 30 years. In order to minimize the limit of detection (LOD) of such sensor systems, it is of high importance to understand and to be able to quantify the relevant noise sources. In this contribution, cantilever-type electromechanical and magnetoelastic resonators, respectively, are comprehensively investigated and mathematically described not only with regard to their phase sensitivity but especially to the extent of the sensor-intrinsic phase noise. Both measurements and calculations reveal that the fundamental LOD is limited by additive phase noise due to thermal-mechanical noise of the resonator, i.e. by thermally induced random vibrations of the cantilever, and by thermal-electrical noise of the piezoelectric material. However, due to losses in the magnetic material parametric flicker phase noise arises, limiting the overall performance. In particular, it is shown that the LOD is virtually independent of the magnetic sensitivity but is solely determined by the magnetic losses. Instead of the sensitivity, the magnetic losses, represented by the material's effective complex permeability, should be considered as the most important parameter for the further improvement of such sensors in the future. This implication is not only valid for magnetoelastic cantilevers but also applies to any type of magnetoelastic resonator. [2020-0219]