Todd R. Zenger
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Todd R. Zenger has a total of 71 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Teppo Felin
University of Utah
7 shared publications - Sergio Giovanetti Lazzarini
Insper Institute of Education and Research Sao Paulo Brazil
6 shared publications Teppo Felin
David Eccles School of Business University of Utah Salt Lake City Utah USA
5 shared publications- Daniel Walter Elfenbein
Washington University in St Louis, John M. Olin School of Business, St. Louis, Missouri, United States
4 shared publications - Jeffrey J. Reuer
Mitch Daniels School of Business Purdue University West Lafayette Indiana USA
4 shared publications - Alfonso Gambardella
Department of Management and Technology Bocconi University Milan Italy
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 30 October 2026
- Published by Wiley in Strategic Management Journal
Strategy as a theory of change
Research Summary: The theory‐based view argues that a strategist's task is to develop a theory to move the organization to an improved future state. Focusing on theorizing as a thought process of model creation, we propose a framework to specify hypothetical causal links and analyze their structure as a directed graph connecting inputs, activities, and indicators of problem resolution. We then propose a set of metrics operationalizing key theory attributes: complexity, equifinality, interdependence, and circularity. We discuss the strategic relevance of these attributes in terms of a theory's ability to promote comprehensive problem resolution as well as implement, evaluate, and replicate the proposed solution. Our work represents a step toward operationalizing model creation in the theory‐based view and informs the design of strategic theories of change. Managerial Summary: Strategists often theorize how to move their organizations toward an improved performance state. Yet most strategic analysis tools describe the organization's external environment or the internal components of its business model, without precisely specifying forward‐looking interventions that might cause the desired changes. In this paper, we represent strategic theories as a chain of causal interventions—inputs and activities that address relevant problems and lead to desirable outcomes. We propose a structured framework that helps managers develop theories and measure key attributes that influence comprehensive problem resolution and the ability to implement, evaluate, and replicate the proposed interventions. In this sense, our work helps managers mentally create their strategic theories and assess their usefulness as a roadmap to superior performance.
- 30 October 2026
- Published by Wiley in Strategic Management Journal
Open AccessStrategy as a theory of change
Research Summary: The theory‐based view argues that a strategist's task is to develop a theory to move the organization to an improved future state. Focusing on theorizing as a thought process of model creation, we propose a framework to specify hypothetical causal links and analyze their structure as a directed graph connecting inputs, activities, and indicators of problem resolution. We then propose a set of metrics operationalizing key theory attributes: complexity, equifinality, interdependence, and circularity. We discuss the strategic relevance of these attributes in terms of a theory's ability to promote comprehensive problem resolution as well as implement, evaluate, and replicate the proposed solution. Our work represents a step toward operationalizing model creation in the theory‐based view and informs the design of strategic theories of change. Managerial Summary: Strategists often theorize how to move their organizations toward an improved performance state. Yet most strategic analysis tools describe the organization's external environment or the internal components of its business model, without precisely specifying forward‐looking interventions that might cause the desired changes. In this paper, we represent strategic theories as a chain of causal interventions—inputs and activities that address relevant problems and lead to desirable outcomes. We propose a structured framework that helps managers develop theories and measure key attributes that influence comprehensive problem resolution and the ability to implement, evaluate, and replicate the proposed interventions. In this sense, our work helps managers mentally create their strategic theories and assess their usefulness as a roadmap to superior performance.
- 27 August 2026
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Strategy Science
Unique Strategies and Average Treatment Effects
What explains the increasing disconnect between empirical strategy research and real-world strategy? Although empirical methods have evolved, notably in the use of techniques that support causal identification, we argue that empirical strategy’s focus on estimating well-identified average treatment effects from a population-level model of performance is fundamentally misaligned with the strategist’s need for firm-specific insights about how to build firm-specific models that guide strategic decision making. This misalignment poses a critical problem because strategic decisions are typically one-shot, nondiversifiable, and deeply interconnected with other firm-specific choices. Thus, strategists require localized, firm-specific models and estimates rather than population-level average treatment effects. Through an extended empirical example, this paper demonstrates the limits of strategy’s current approach of ever-more-precise identification and offers guidance about methodological approaches that can help bridge the relevance gap.
- 27 August 2026
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Strategy Science
Unique Strategies and Average Treatment Effects
What explains the increasing disconnect between empirical strategy research and real-world strategy? Although empirical methods have evolved, notably in the use of techniques that support causal identification, we argue that empirical strategy’s focus on estimating well-identified average treatment effects from a population-level model of performance is fundamentally misaligned with the strategist’s need for firm-specific insights about how to build firm-specific models that guide strategic decision making. This misalignment poses a critical problem because strategic decisions are typically one-shot, nondiversifiable, and deeply interconnected with other firm-specific choices. Thus, strategists require localized, firm-specific models and estimates rather than population-level average treatment effects. Through an extended empirical example, this paper demonstrates the limits of strategy’s current approach of ever-more-precise identification and offers guidance about methodological approaches that can help bridge the relevance gap.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Strategy Science
- Vol. 11 (1) , 16-30
Can AI Do Strategy? A Dialogue and Debate
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Strategy Science
- Vol. 11 (1) , 16-30
Can AI Do Strategy? A Dialogue and Debate
- Top Cited Papers
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Strategy Science
- Vol. 11 (1) , 1-15
Can AI Do Strategy?
Can artificial intelligence (AI) do strategy? This question is both urgent and foundational: urgent because AI is already reshaping strategic practice and foundational because answering it forces us to articulate what strategy actually is. In this introductory essay to the Strategy Science Special Issue on AI and Strategy, we propose a dual-ladder framework: a causal ladder that maps the cognitive hierarchy of strategic tasks and a delegation ladder that specifies when organizations will grant AI autonomy over those tasks. A core insight emerges: AI will not enter strategy where required reasoning is deepest but where its performance is most measurable. We organize the Special Issue contributions around what AI can do today, could do as capabilities develop, and should do given the imperatives of accountability and human judgment. We close with a challenge and an invitation: if strategy scholars do not define good strategizing precisely enough to be encoded, tested, and refined, other disciplines will, embedding thinner conceptions of strategy into the tools managers use. Teaching machines to strategize and support strategizing is ultimately a method for rediscovering what strategy is. History: Accepted for the Special Issue: Can AI Do Strategy?
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Strategy Science
- Vol. 11 (1) , 1-15
Top Cited PapersCan AI Do Strategy?
Can artificial intelligence (AI) do strategy? This question is both urgent and foundational: urgent because AI is already reshaping strategic practice and foundational because answering it forces us to articulate what strategy actually is. In this introductory essay to the Strategy Science Special Issue on AI and Strategy, we propose a dual-ladder framework: a causal ladder that maps the cognitive hierarchy of strategic tasks and a delegation ladder that specifies when organizations will grant AI autonomy over those tasks. A core insight emerges: AI will not enter strategy where required reasoning is deepest but where its performance is most measurable. We organize the Special Issue contributions around what AI can do today, could do as capabilities develop, and should do given the imperatives of accountability and human judgment. We close with a challenge and an invitation: if strategy scholars do not define good strategizing precisely enough to be encoded, tested, and refined, other disciplines will, embedding thinner conceptions of strategy into the tools managers use. Teaching machines to strategize and support strategizing is ultimately a method for rediscovering what strategy is. History: Accepted for the Special Issue: Can AI Do Strategy?
- Open Access
- 25 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in Strategic Management Journal
- Vol. 46 (8) , 1831-1860
Pay transparency and productivity
Research Summary: This article investigates the productivity consequences of pay transparency. Tracking the research output of 20,000 US academics and leveraging staggered shocks to transparency, we show that productivity responses vary predictably based on what pay transparency reveals. We reject a hypothesis that pay transparency leads to a decline in productivity. Rather, we find that those who transparency reveals to be inequitably overcompensated subsequently increase their effort, while those inequitably undercompensated subsequently weakly decrease their effort. Controlling for such pay inequity, the simple level of pay has little effect on productivity. Our study provides one of the first field‐based empirical investigations of the productivity consequences of wage transparency and points to the importance of clearly delineating the effects driven by equity as opposed to equality of rewards allocations. Managerial Summary: While evidence suggests that pay transparency consistently reduces discrimination, many organizations have resisted implementation over concerns about its impact on productivity. To date, there has been very little evidence to either confirm or reject this concern. This study of 20,000 US academics directly addresses the effect of pay transparency on productivity. We find that when salaries become public, average productivity does not decline. However, there is a varied individual productivity response that depends on what transparency reveals to individual employees about their pay and its fairness relative to peers. Employees who found they were paid more than their performance warranted increased their productivity, likely to justify their elevated compensation. Conversely, unfairly underpaid individuals decreased their productivity, particularly when they had job security. Notably, individuals seem to care more about pay fairness than pay equality. Our results also highlight another benefit of pay transparency: employees who became aware of the potential for substantial salary raises through promotion enhanced their productivity.
- 25 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in Strategic Management Journal
- Vol. 46 (8) , 1831-1860
Open AccessPay transparency and productivity
Research Summary: This article investigates the productivity consequences of pay transparency. Tracking the research output of 20,000 US academics and leveraging staggered shocks to transparency, we show that productivity responses vary predictably based on what pay transparency reveals. We reject a hypothesis that pay transparency leads to a decline in productivity. Rather, we find that those who transparency reveals to be inequitably overcompensated subsequently increase their effort, while those inequitably undercompensated subsequently weakly decrease their effort. Controlling for such pay inequity, the simple level of pay has little effect on productivity. Our study provides one of the first field‐based empirical investigations of the productivity consequences of wage transparency and points to the importance of clearly delineating the effects driven by equity as opposed to equality of rewards allocations. Managerial Summary: While evidence suggests that pay transparency consistently reduces discrimination, many organizations have resisted implementation over concerns about its impact on productivity. To date, there has been very little evidence to either confirm or reject this concern. This study of 20,000 US academics directly addresses the effect of pay transparency on productivity. We find that when salaries become public, average productivity does not decline. However, there is a varied individual productivity response that depends on what transparency reveals to individual employees about their pay and its fairness relative to peers. Employees who found they were paid more than their performance warranted increased their productivity, likely to justify their elevated compensation. Conversely, unfairly underpaid individuals decreased their productivity, particularly when they had job security. Notably, individuals seem to care more about pay fairness than pay equality. Our results also highlight another benefit of pay transparency: employees who became aware of the potential for substantial salary raises through promotion enhanced their productivity.
- 1 December 2024
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Strategy Science
- Vol. 9 (4) , 297-310
Theory-Based Decisions: Foundations and Introduction
Theories are foundational for decision making. We point to a normative agenda that emphasizes the need for decision makers—including managers, firms, entrepreneurs, and startups—to develop their own theories. Our argument is that decision makers should be like scientists and use the scientific method—theories, causal reasoning, and experimentation—to problem solve and generate new data and value. In this paper and special issue introduction, we discuss the foundations of the theory-based view (TBV), particularly as it relates to forward-looking reasoning and decision making under uncertainty. Rather than handing prescriptive theories to others, the goal of the TBV is to provide the scaffolding for economic actors themselves to develop their own, idiosyncratic theories. Theories are built on heterogeneous beliefs and causal reasoning that enable the generation of unique paths to value. We discuss the implications of this argument for key theories within strategy and economics, along with highlighting research opportunities at the nexus of the TBV and topics such as learning, entrepreneurship, finance, ownership and leadership. We also introduce the special issue papers and discuss their contributions to the TBV. Funding: We appreciate ION Management Science Laboratory at Bocconi for funding the special issue conference and related activities. A. Gambardella also acknowledges support from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Programme [Grant 101021061].
- 1 December 2024
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Strategy Science
- Vol. 9 (4) , 297-310
Theory-Based Decisions: Foundations and Introduction
Theories are foundational for decision making. We point to a normative agenda that emphasizes the need for decision makers—including managers, firms, entrepreneurs, and startups—to develop their own theories. Our argument is that decision makers should be like scientists and use the scientific method—theories, causal reasoning, and experimentation—to problem solve and generate new data and value. In this paper and special issue introduction, we discuss the foundations of the theory-based view (TBV), particularly as it relates to forward-looking reasoning and decision making under uncertainty. Rather than handing prescriptive theories to others, the goal of the TBV is to provide the scaffolding for economic actors themselves to develop their own, idiosyncratic theories. Theories are built on heterogeneous beliefs and causal reasoning that enable the generation of unique paths to value. We discuss the implications of this argument for key theories within strategy and economics, along with highlighting research opportunities at the nexus of the TBV and topics such as learning, entrepreneurship, finance, ownership and leadership. We also introduce the special issue papers and discuss their contributions to the TBV. Funding: We appreciate ION Management Science Laboratory at Bocconi for funding the special issue conference and related activities. A. Gambardella also acknowledges support from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Programme [Grant 101021061].
- 1 December 2024
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Strategy Science
- Vol. 9 (4) , 416-432
Competing with Theories: Using Awareness and Confidence to Secure Resources and Rents
An assumption of factor market efficiency is often used to grant primacy to firms’ existing unique and valuable resources as the source of economic rents. But this assumption is difficult to reconcile with observed market outcomes. For instance, five of the six companies with the highest global market capitalization in 2022 were upstarts in their industries with few resources at their origins. More surprising, three of these entrants were assisted by incumbents with vastly superior resources in assembling the resources they required. In this paper we explore how entrants compete with theories to secure resources from incumbents and capture rents. We introduce a modeling approach in which theories with causal logic generate awareness of valuable potential future states and shape the beliefs about payoffs and probabilities associated with these states. We combine work in the theory-based view and value capture theory to distinguish among three distinct sources of economic rents that are potentially available to entrants: awareness rents, confidence rents, and resource rents. We explore the circumstances under which these three types of rents are available. By exploring the role of theories and awareness in value creation and capture, our paper seeks to deepen our understanding of how entrants both attract resources and secure rents. Funding: T. Zenger was supported by the ION Management Science Lab, Utah.
- 1 December 2024
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Strategy Science
- Vol. 9 (4) , 416-432
Competing with Theories: Using Awareness and Confidence to Secure Resources and Rents
An assumption of factor market efficiency is often used to grant primacy to firms’ existing unique and valuable resources as the source of economic rents. But this assumption is difficult to reconcile with observed market outcomes. For instance, five of the six companies with the highest global market capitalization in 2022 were upstarts in their industries with few resources at their origins. More surprising, three of these entrants were assisted by incumbents with vastly superior resources in assembling the resources they required. In this paper we explore how entrants compete with theories to secure resources from incumbents and capture rents. We introduce a modeling approach in which theories with causal logic generate awareness of valuable potential future states and shape the beliefs about payoffs and probabilities associated with these states. We combine work in the theory-based view and value capture theory to distinguish among three distinct sources of economic rents that are potentially available to entrants: awareness rents, confidence rents, and resource rents. We explore the circumstances under which these three types of rents are available. By exploring the role of theories and awareness in value creation and capture, our paper seeks to deepen our understanding of how entrants both attract resources and secure rents. Funding: T. Zenger was supported by the ION Management Science Lab, Utah.
- Open Access
- 29 February 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Management
- Vol. 50 (8) , 3080-3104
A Scientific Method for Startups
Recent scholarship has sought to develop a “scientific method” for startups. In this paper we contrast two approaches: lean startup and the theory-based view of startups. The lean startup movement has served an important function in calling for a normative and scientific approach to startups and venture creation. The theory-based view shares this agenda. But there are differences in the underlying theoretical mechanisms and practical prescriptions suggested by each approach. We highlight these differences and their implications for both research and practice. For example, we contrast lean startup’s emphasis on bounded rationality and entrepreneur–customer information asymmetry with the theory-based view’s emphasis on generative rationality and belief asymmetry. The theory-based view focuses on contrarian beliefs, associated problem formulation, and the development of a startup-specific causal logic for experimentation, resource acquisition, and problem solving. The right mix of entrepreneurial actions is contingent and startup-specific—guided by a startup’s unique theory. After pointing out differences between the lean and theory-based view of startups, we discuss opportunities for partial reconciliation, as well as opportunities for empirically comparing perspectives. Overall, we emphasize that a scientific method for startups needs to recognize the importance of contingent, discriminating alignment between entrepreneurial theories and the actions they prescribe (including different types of experimentation and validation, search, and forms of organization).
- 29 February 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Management
- Vol. 50 (8) , 3080-3104
Open AccessA Scientific Method for Startups
Recent scholarship has sought to develop a “scientific method” for startups. In this paper we contrast two approaches: lean startup and the theory-based view of startups. The lean startup movement has served an important function in calling for a normative and scientific approach to startups and venture creation. The theory-based view shares this agenda. But there are differences in the underlying theoretical mechanisms and practical prescriptions suggested by each approach. We highlight these differences and their implications for both research and practice. For example, we contrast lean startup’s emphasis on bounded rationality and entrepreneur–customer information asymmetry with the theory-based view’s emphasis on generative rationality and belief asymmetry. The theory-based view focuses on contrarian beliefs, associated problem formulation, and the development of a startup-specific causal logic for experimentation, resource acquisition, and problem solving. The right mix of entrepreneurial actions is contingent and startup-specific—guided by a startup’s unique theory. After pointing out differences between the lean and theory-based view of startups, we discuss opportunities for partial reconciliation, as well as opportunities for empirically comparing perspectives. Overall, we emphasize that a scientific method for startups needs to recognize the importance of contingent, discriminating alignment between entrepreneurial theories and the actions they prescribe (including different types of experimentation and validation, search, and forms of organization).
- Top Cited Papers
- 1 September 2023
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Organization Science
- Vol. 34 (5) , 1965-1980
The Firm as a Subsociety: Purpose, Justice, and the Theory of the Firm
Research in the “theory of the firm” tradition has often characterized firms as subeconomies, in which economic exchange is shaped by a central authority. We propose an expanded view of firms as subsocieties, in which authority is also responsible for establishing principles that shape cooperation among members. We draw on insights from political theory, sociology, and, to a lesser degree, legal theory to discuss how employees become members of subsocieties by exchanging rights, such as formal control over their work, for the benefits of membership. With this rights exchange, subsociety members develop expectations that those in positions of authority will use their control to define and sustain principles of justice and common purpose consistent with members’ moral sentiments. This view suggests expanded roles for authority and firm boundaries from what are incorporated into standard theories of the firm. These expanded roles have implications both for internal governance and for the boundary itself: When considering boundary changes, leaders must weigh both the economic and the social consequences of their decision.Funding: C. Gartenberg recognizes financial support from the Wharton School at University of Pennsylvania. T. Zenger recognizes the financial support of the Eccles School at the University of Utah.
- 1 September 2023
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Organization Science
- Vol. 34 (5) , 1965-1980
Top Cited PapersThe Firm as a Subsociety: Purpose, Justice, and the Theory of the Firm
Research in the “theory of the firm” tradition has often characterized firms as subeconomies, in which economic exchange is shaped by a central authority. We propose an expanded view of firms as subsocieties, in which authority is also responsible for establishing principles that shape cooperation among members. We draw on insights from political theory, sociology, and, to a lesser degree, legal theory to discuss how employees become members of subsocieties by exchanging rights, such as formal control over their work, for the benefits of membership. With this rights exchange, subsociety members develop expectations that those in positions of authority will use their control to define and sustain principles of justice and common purpose consistent with members’ moral sentiments. This view suggests expanded roles for authority and firm boundaries from what are incorporated into standard theories of the firm. These expanded roles have implications both for internal governance and for the boundary itself: When considering boundary changes, leaders must weigh both the economic and the social consequences of their decision.Funding: C. Gartenberg recognizes financial support from the Wharton School at University of Pennsylvania. T. Zenger recognizes the financial support of the Eccles School at the University of Utah.
- 1 June 2023
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Strategy Science
- Vol. 8 (2) , 121-122
Editorial: Special Issue on Corporate Purpose
- 1 June 2023
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Strategy Science
- Vol. 8 (2) , 121-122
Editorial: Special Issue on Corporate Purpose