Kim Schildkamp
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Kim Schildkamp has a total of 84 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Cindy Louise Poortman
University of Twente
23 shared publications Johanna Ebbeler
University of Twente
14 shared publicationsMaaike Smit
Datateam Partners, Hengelo, The Netherlands
13 shared publicationsAdam Handelzalts
University of Twente
12 shared publicationsHanadie Leusink
University of Twente
12 shared publicationsMarije Meerdink
University of Twente
12 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 17 October 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Towards a Multidimensional Framework of AI Literacy in Education: An Umbrella Review of Conceptualizations, Components, and Multilevel Influences
Advancements in artificial intelligence (AI) have significant implications for education, making AI literacy increasingly important for teachers and students. Although research on AI literacy is expanding, its conceptualization in educational contexts remains fragmented. This study therefore synthesizes existing conceptualizations and develops a comprehensive framework for AI literacy in education through an umbrella review of 30 prior reviews. Our findings conceptualize AI literacy as a multidimensional construct comprising three interrelated components: (a) Knowledge of AI, (b) Skills with AI, and (c) AI Attitudes and Emotions, with (d) Ethical Awareness as a cross-cutting dimensiontogether shaping actors' AI-literate engagement with AI in education. In addition, we identify factors influencing the development and enactment of AI literacy at individual, organizational, and policy levels, highlighting that AI literacy cannot be understood solely as an individual accomplishment. The resulting framework integrates these dimensions and multilevel influences while identifying the team or collective level as an important gap in the existing literature. We discuss implications for educational practice and propose directions for validating and refining the framework across educational contexts as AI continues to evolve.
- 17 October 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessTowards a Multidimensional Framework of AI Literacy in Education: An Umbrella Review of Conceptualizations, Components, and Multilevel Influences
Advancements in artificial intelligence (AI) have significant implications for education, making AI literacy increasingly important for teachers and students. Although research on AI literacy is expanding, its conceptualization in educational contexts remains fragmented. This study therefore synthesizes existing conceptualizations and develops a comprehensive framework for AI literacy in education through an umbrella review of 30 prior reviews. Our findings conceptualize AI literacy as a multidimensional construct comprising three interrelated components: (a) Knowledge of AI, (b) Skills with AI, and (c) AI Attitudes and Emotions, with (d) Ethical Awareness as a cross-cutting dimensiontogether shaping actors' AI-literate engagement with AI in education. In addition, we identify factors influencing the development and enactment of AI literacy at individual, organizational, and policy levels, highlighting that AI literacy cannot be understood solely as an individual accomplishment. The resulting framework integrates these dimensions and multilevel influences while identifying the team or collective level as an important gap in the existing literature. We discuss implications for educational practice and propose directions for validating and refining the framework across educational contexts as AI continues to evolve.
- Open Access
- 25 June 2026
- Published by Vereniging voor Onderwijs Research in Pedagogische Studiën
- Vol. 103 (2)
How team innovative work behaviour unfolds under top-down, incremental change in education: a longitudinal case
Sustainable educational innovation requires teams that demonstrate Team Innovative Work Behaviour (TIWB). Although TIWB is often described as iterative and fluid, little is known about how it unfolds over time within teacher teams. This longitudinal qualitative case study examined TIWB in a team involved in a top-down, incremental curriculum redesign in higher education. Over eight months, 19 recorded team meetings were analysed using a codebook based on five TIWB dimensions, complemented by interpretive depth cues such as counter-argumentation and collective sensemaking. TIWB followed a predominantly linear pattern aligned with the project phases, with one nested design subcycle emerging around assessment development during implementation. Idea generation and idea realization occurred frequently, whereas opportunity exploration and idea sustainability, especially external dissemination, were rare. The structured, top-down context and incremental nature of the innovation plausibly contributed to these patterns. These findings offer a fine-grained view of how TIWB unfolds in practice and underscore the importance of stimulating sustainability-oriented behaviours from the start so that innovations are not only implemented but also sustained over time. The study provides practical guidance for strengthening sustainability within teams, including early agreement on design criteria, clearer dissemination roles, and reflective moments during meetings.
- 25 June 2026
- Published by Vereniging voor Onderwijs Research in Pedagogische Studiën
- Vol. 103 (2)
Open AccessHow team innovative work behaviour unfolds under top-down, incremental change in education: a longitudinal case
Sustainable educational innovation requires teams that demonstrate Team Innovative Work Behaviour (TIWB). Although TIWB is often described as iterative and fluid, little is known about how it unfolds over time within teacher teams. This longitudinal qualitative case study examined TIWB in a team involved in a top-down, incremental curriculum redesign in higher education. Over eight months, 19 recorded team meetings were analysed using a codebook based on five TIWB dimensions, complemented by interpretive depth cues such as counter-argumentation and collective sensemaking. TIWB followed a predominantly linear pattern aligned with the project phases, with one nested design subcycle emerging around assessment development during implementation. Idea generation and idea realization occurred frequently, whereas opportunity exploration and idea sustainability, especially external dissemination, were rare. The structured, top-down context and incremental nature of the innovation plausibly contributed to these patterns. These findings offer a fine-grained view of how TIWB unfolds in practice and underscore the importance of stimulating sustainability-oriented behaviours from the start so that innovations are not only implemented but also sustained over time. The study provides practical guidance for strengthening sustainability within teams, including early agreement on design criteria, clearer dissemination roles, and reflective moments during meetings.
- Open Access
- 24 April 2026
- Published by Vereniging voor Onderwijs Research in Pedagogische Studiën
- Vol. 103 (1)
Student voice in Professional Learning Communities: The question of student agency
Actively involving students in improving education can positively impact its quality and student agency. This can be achieved when students voice their opinions, collaborate with adults, and/or take leadership roles (student voice), for example in Professional Learning Communities (PLCs). However, little is known about how students can be involved in school improvement through PLCs. We therefore qualitatively explored in what ways students were involved in the work of seven PLCs. In addition, we zoomed in on the case of one PLC in which students participated together with teachers as PLC members. Using social network analysis supplemented with qualitative data, we explored the positions and roles of these students. We concluded that students were only involved to a limited extent in most PLCs: mainly as passive data sources and sometimes as active respondents. Even when students were involved as PLC members, they initially seemed to have only limited agency. On the other hand, students can play an important key role in making connections between education professionals in the PLC and the student population outside.
- 24 April 2026
- Published by Vereniging voor Onderwijs Research in Pedagogische Studiën
- Vol. 103 (1)
Open AccessStudent voice in Professional Learning Communities: The question of student agency
Actively involving students in improving education can positively impact its quality and student agency. This can be achieved when students voice their opinions, collaborate with adults, and/or take leadership roles (student voice), for example in Professional Learning Communities (PLCs). However, little is known about how students can be involved in school improvement through PLCs. We therefore qualitatively explored in what ways students were involved in the work of seven PLCs. In addition, we zoomed in on the case of one PLC in which students participated together with teachers as PLC members. Using social network analysis supplemented with qualitative data, we explored the positions and roles of these students. We concluded that students were only involved to a limited extent in most PLCs: mainly as passive data sources and sometimes as active respondents. Even when students were involved as PLC members, they initially seemed to have only limited agency. On the other hand, students can play an important key role in making connections between education professionals in the PLC and the student population outside.
- 3 April 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in School Effectiveness and School Improvement
- Vol. 37 (2) , 222-240
Teachers’ Pedagogical Practices: Primary Predictors of Instructional Data Use in Chile.
- 3 April 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in School Effectiveness and School Improvement
- Vol. 37 (2) , 222-240
Teachers’ Pedagogical Practices: Primary Predictors of Instructional Data Use in Chile.
- 22 January 2026
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Professional Capital and Community
- Vol. 11 (1) , 5-11
Editorial: Making networks work: the central role of facilitators in PLNs
- 22 January 2026
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Professional Capital and Community
- Vol. 11 (1) , 5-11
Editorial: Making networks work: the central role of facilitators in PLNs
- Open Access
- 19 November 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Studies in Educational Evaluation
- Vol. 87
Improving teachers' beliefs about using student feedback: Can professional learning communities make a difference?
- 19 November 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Studies in Educational Evaluation
- Vol. 87
Open AccessImproving teachers' beliefs about using student feedback: Can professional learning communities make a difference?
- Open Access
- 14 November 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Studies in Educational Evaluation
- Vol. 87
The effect of teacher data use professional development interventions on student achievement: A meta-analysis and qualitative comparative analysis
- 14 November 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Studies in Educational Evaluation
- Vol. 87
Open AccessThe effect of teacher data use professional development interventions on student achievement: A meta-analysis and qualitative comparative analysis
- 13 August 2025
- Published by University Library/University of Twente
The utilisation of a self-evaluation instrument for primary education
- 13 August 2025
- Published by University Library/University of Twente
The utilisation of a self-evaluation instrument for primary education
- Open Access
- 29 April 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Education Sciences
- Vol. 15 (5) , 548
Leadership for Student Participation in Data-Use Professional Learning Communities
Student participation in educational decision making, for example, through data-informed decision making, can have a positive effect on student well-being, engagement, and performance. Teachers play a crucial role in student participation, and leadership is a main factor influencing teacher professional development, which can lead to improved experiences and outcomes for students. In this study, we aimed to combine the benefits associated with data-informed decision making with those associated with Professional Learning Communities. Moreover, we included students as PLC participants. This study therefore focuses on the question how school leaders can support teachers in connection with student participation in data-use PLCs. Based on previous research, we used leadership core functions needed for successful PLCs to describe school leaders’ roles in an approach to student participation that combines the pedagogical analysis model and Shier’s model for student participation. School leaders and teachers from five schools participating in the previous study were interviewed to describe school leaders’ roles. The findings show what concrete school leader activities can support teachers in connection with student participation in data-use PLCs and what implications this has for practice, policy, and further research.
- 29 April 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Education Sciences
- Vol. 15 (5) , 548
Open AccessLeadership for Student Participation in Data-Use Professional Learning Communities
Student participation in educational decision making, for example, through data-informed decision making, can have a positive effect on student well-being, engagement, and performance. Teachers play a crucial role in student participation, and leadership is a main factor influencing teacher professional development, which can lead to improved experiences and outcomes for students. In this study, we aimed to combine the benefits associated with data-informed decision making with those associated with Professional Learning Communities. Moreover, we included students as PLC participants. This study therefore focuses on the question how school leaders can support teachers in connection with student participation in data-use PLCs. Based on previous research, we used leadership core functions needed for successful PLCs to describe school leaders’ roles in an approach to student participation that combines the pedagogical analysis model and Shier’s model for student participation. School leaders and teachers from five schools participating in the previous study were interviewed to describe school leaders’ roles. The findings show what concrete school leader activities can support teachers in connection with student participation in data-use PLCs and what implications this has for practice, policy, and further research.
- Open Access
- 26 February 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Quality & Quantity
- p. 1-45
The M-PerFeCt questionnaire: assessing higher education students’ motivation in a peer feedback context
In higher education, teacher feedback has increasingly been replaced or complemented with peer feedback. But, when students lack motivation, they may not participate in the peer feedback activity adequately, and, thus, the activity may not have the desired effect. Motivation is a complex, difficult-to-measure concept, and existing questionnaires for assessing students’ motivation in the context of a peer feedback intervention in higher education have each considered only a few aspects of motivation to learn or motivation to participate in the peer feedback activity. However, a questionnaire that concurrently assesses (almost) all aspects of higher education students’ motivation in a peer feedback context is needed for researchers and practitioners to obtain a complete picture of students’ motivation, so they can determine whether and how this motivation needs to be improved. Therefore, this study aimed to develop the Motivation in a Peer Feedback Context (M-PerFeCt) questionnaire. Methodological pluralism was used to capture this complex concept while ensuring more rigorous scientific results, including eliciting a student and expert appraisal of the questionnaire and collecting responses to the questionnaire from higher education students in The Netherlands and performing exploratory and confirmatory factor analyses. Pre-activity and post-activity forms of the questionnaire were developed and validated. The final questionnaire comprised 66 items in 19 scales. The questionnaire provides insight into the underlying structure of students’ motivation in a peer feedback context. Additionally, it enables teachers and researchers to assess students’ motivation in a peer feedback context.
- 26 February 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Quality & Quantity
- p. 1-45
Open AccessThe M-PerFeCt questionnaire: assessing higher education students’ motivation in a peer feedback context
In higher education, teacher feedback has increasingly been replaced or complemented with peer feedback. But, when students lack motivation, they may not participate in the peer feedback activity adequately, and, thus, the activity may not have the desired effect. Motivation is a complex, difficult-to-measure concept, and existing questionnaires for assessing students’ motivation in the context of a peer feedback intervention in higher education have each considered only a few aspects of motivation to learn or motivation to participate in the peer feedback activity. However, a questionnaire that concurrently assesses (almost) all aspects of higher education students’ motivation in a peer feedback context is needed for researchers and practitioners to obtain a complete picture of students’ motivation, so they can determine whether and how this motivation needs to be improved. Therefore, this study aimed to develop the Motivation in a Peer Feedback Context (M-PerFeCt) questionnaire. Methodological pluralism was used to capture this complex concept while ensuring more rigorous scientific results, including eliciting a student and expert appraisal of the questionnaire and collecting responses to the questionnaire from higher education students in The Netherlands and performing exploratory and confirmatory factor analyses. Pre-activity and post-activity forms of the questionnaire were developed and validated. The final questionnaire comprised 66 items in 19 scales. The questionnaire provides insight into the underlying structure of students’ motivation in a peer feedback context. Additionally, it enables teachers and researchers to assess students’ motivation in a peer feedback context.