CMCatherine M. Montgomery

Catherine M. Montgomery

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Catherine M. Montgomery has a total of 89 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Otherwising or Attaching? Play, Care, and Critique in Interdisciplinary Public Engagement

    by Catherine M. Montgomery, Santini Basra, Corrienne McCulloch, Annemarie B. Docherty

    This article builds on the affective turn in Science and Technology Studies (STS) analyses of public engagement with science to explore the tension between epistemological interrogation and social and political transformation. The empirical basis for this exploration is a year-long interdisciplinary public engagement project about routine data use in critical care. Partly conceived as a form of “otherwising” in relation both to determinist tropes of health data and reductionist forms of patient and public involvement in health research, the project sought to open up dialogue and debate using design-led methods, namely cultural probes. Widely regarded as a success, the project was, however, less subversive than originally envisaged, in spite of its commitment to playful and speculative processes. In order to explain this, we draw on feminist STS literature on the inseparability of knowledge and care, where care is conceived as a form of mutually transformative relating between beings—or attaching. Interdisciplinary collaboration, we suggest, was an effect of attaching, enabled by our methodological orientation to play. We show how playfulness as a mode of otherwising goes beyond the hollow critique of critical constructivism and fosters caring relations, both toward the objects of science and between scientists, clinicians, sociologists, and designers.

  • Open Access

    Remaking critical care: Place, body work and the materialities of care in the COVID intensive care unit

    by Catherine M. Montgomery, Annemarie B. Docherty, Sally Humphreys, Corrienne McCulloch, Natalie Pattison, Steve Sturdy

    In this article, we take forward sociological ways of knowing care‐in‐practice, in particular work in critical care. To do so, we analyse the experiences of staff working in critical care during the first wave of the COVID‐19 pandemic in the UK. This moment of exception throws into sharp relief the ways in which work and place were reconfigured during conditions of pandemic surge, and shows how critical care depends at all times on the co‐constitution of place, practices and relations. Our analysis draws on sociological and anthropological work on the material culture of health care and its sensory instantiations. Pursuing this through a study of the experiences of 40 staff across four intensive care units (ICUs) in 2020, we provide an empirical and theoretical elaboration of how place, body work and care are mutually co‐constitutive. We argue that the ICU does not exist independently of the constant embodied work of care and place‐making which iteratively constitute critical care as a total system of relations.


  • Open Access

    Domesticating models: On the contingency of Covid-19 modelling in UK media and policy

    by Lukas Engelmann, Catherine M Montgomery, Steve Sturdy, Cristina Moreno Lozano

    Our article traces the representation of pandemic modelling in UK print media from the emergence of Covid-19 to the early stages of implementing the first UK-wide lockdown in late March 2020. Covid modelling, it is widely assumed, has shaped policy decisions and public responses to the pandemic in unprecedented ways. We analyse how the UK print media has configured modelling as a significant evidence tool in the representation of the pandemic. Interrogating assumptions about infectious disease modelling, we ask why models became the trusted tool of choice for knowing and responding to the Covid pandemic in the UK. Our analysis has yielded four different periods in the evolution of intersecting policy and media frames. Initially, modellers, policymakers and media alike emphasized uncertainty about available data, and hence the speculative character of modelled projections, thus justifying a ‘wait and see’ approach to government intervention. With growing public pressure for government action, policy and media frames were adjusted to emphasize the importance of timing interventions for best effect, with modelling evidence mobilized to justify inaction. This gave way to a period of crisis, as the press increasingly questioned the reliability of the existing models and policies, leading modellers and policy makers to dramatically revise their projections. Finally, with the imposition of the first UK lockdown, policy and media frames were brought back into alignment with one another, in a process of domestication through which the language of modelling became a basic resource for the discussion of the epidemic. Our epistemological microhistory thus challenges general accounts of the impacts of pandemic modelling and instead emphasizes contingency and interpretative flexibility.


  • Open Access

    Turning the gaze: Digital patient feedback and the silent pathology of the NHS

    by Catherine M. Montgomery, John Powell, Kamal Mahtani, Anne‐Marie Boylan

    Online review and rating sites, where patients can leave feedback on their experience of the health‐care encounter, are becoming an increasing feature of primary care in the NHS. Previous research has analysed how digital surveillance is re‐shaping the clinical gaze, as health‐care professionals are subject to increased public monitoring. Here, we draw on an empirical study of 41 GP practice staff to show how the gaze is turning, not simply from the patient to the health‐care provider, but additionally to the body politic of the NHS. Drawing on focus group and interview data conducted in five UK practices, we show how discourses of online reviews and ratings are producing new professional subjectivities among health‐care professionals and the extent to which the gaze extends not only to individual health‐care interactions but to the health‐care service writ large. We identify three counter‐discourses characterising the evolving ways in which online reviews and ratings are creating new subjects in primary care practices: victimhood, prosumption versus traditional values and taking control. We show how the ways in which staff speak about online feedback are patterned by the social environment in which they work and the constraints of the NHS they encounter on a day‐to‐day basis.


  • Open Access

    Critical care work during COVID-19: a qualitative study of staff experiences in the UK

    by Catherine M Montgomery, Sally Humphreys, Corrienne McCulloch, Annemarie B Docherty, Steve Sturdy, Natalie Pattison

    Objective To understand National Health Service (NHS) staff experiences of working in critical care during the first wave of the COVID-19 pandemic in the UK. Design Qualitative study using semistructured telephone interviews and rapid analysis, interpreted using Baehr’s sociological lens of ‘communities of fate’. Participants Forty NHS staff working in critical care, including 21 nurses, 10 doctors and advanced critical care practitioners, 4 allied health professionals, 3 operating department practitioners and 2 ward clerks. Participants were interviewed between August and October 2020; we purposefully sought the experiences of trained and experienced critical care staff and those who were redeployed. Setting Four hospitals in the UK. Results COVID-19 presented staff with a situation of extreme stress, duress and social emergency, leading to a shared set of experiences which we have characterised as a community of fate. This involved not only fear and dread of working in critical care, but also a collective sense of duty and vocation. Caring for patients and families involved changes to usual ways of working, revolving around: reorganisation of space and personnel, personal protective equipment, lack of evidence for treating COVID-19, inability for families to be physically present, and the trauma of witnessing extreme patient acuity and death on a large scale. The stress and isolation of working in critical care during COVID-19 was mitigated by strong teamwork, camaraderie, pride and fulfilment. Conclusion COVID-19 has changed working practices in critical care and profoundly affected staff physically, mentally and emotionally. Attention needs to be paid to the social and organisational conditions in which individuals work, addressing both practical resourcing and the interpersonal dynamics of critical care provision.


  • Open Access

    Wild data: how front‐line hospital staff make sense of patients’ experiences

    by Catherine M. Montgomery, Alison Chisholm, Stephen Parkin, Louise Locock

    Patient‐centred care has become the touchstone of healthcare policy in developed healthcare systems. The ensuing commodification of patients’ experiences has resulted in a mass of data but little sense of whether and how such data are used. We sought to understand how front‐line staff use patient experience data for quality improvement in the National Health Service (NHS). We conducted a 12‐month ethnographic case study evaluation of improvement projects in six NHS hospitals in England in 2016–2017. Drawing on the sociology of everyday life, we show how front‐line staff worked with a notion of data as interpersonal and embodied. In addition to consulting organisationally sanctioned forms of data, staff used their own embodied interactions with patients, carers, other staff and the ward environment to shape improvements. The data staff found useful involved face‐to‐face interaction and dialogue; were visual, emotive, and allowed for immediate action. We draw on de Certeau to re‐conceptualise this as ‘wild data’. We conclude that patient experience data are relational, and have material, social and affective dimensions, which have been elided in the literature to date. Practice‐based theories of the everyday help to envision ‘patient experience’ not as a disembodied tool of managerialism but as an embedded part of healthcare staff professionalism.


  • Open Access

    'Team capital’ in quality improvement teams: findings from an ethnographic study of front-line quality improvement in the NHS

    by Catherine Montgomery, Stephen Parkin, Alison Chisholm, Louise Locock

    Background Teamwork is important in the design and delivery of initiatives in complex healthcare systems but the specifics of quality improvement (QI) teams are not well studied. Objective To explain the functioning of front-line healthcare teams working on patient-centred QI using Bourdieu’s sociological construct of capital. Methods One medical ward from each of six NHS Trusts in England participated in the study, purposively selected for a range of performance levels on patient experience metrics. Three ethnographers conducted focused ethnography for 1 year, using interviews and observations to explore the organisation, management and delivery of patient-centred QI projects by the six front-line teams. Data were analysed using Bourdieu’s typology of the four forms of capital: economic, social, symbolic and cultural. Results While all teams implemented some QI activities to improve patient experience, progress was greater where teams included staff from a broad range of disciplines and levels of seniority. Teams containing both clinical and non-clinical staff, including staff on lower grades such as healthcare assistants and clerks, engaged more confidently with patient experience data than unidisciplinary teams, and implemented a more ambitious set of projects. We explain these findings in terms of ‘team capital’. Conclusion Teams that chose to restrict membership to particular disciplines appeared to limit their capital, whereas more varied teams were able to draw on multiple resources, skills, networks and alliances to overcome challenges. Staff of varying levels of seniority also shared and valued a broader range of insights into patient experience, including informal knowledge from daily practice. The construct of ‘team capital’ has the potential to enrich understanding of the mechanism of teamwork in QI work.


  • Open Access

    How do frontline staff use patient experience data for service improvement? Findings from an ethnographic case study evaluation

    by Louise Locock, Catherine Montgomery, Stephen Parkin, Alison Chisholm, Jennifer Bostock, Sue Dopson, Melanie Gager, Elizabeth Gibbons, Chris Graham, Jenny King, et al.

    Objectives: Improving patient experience is widely regarded as a key component of health care quality. However, while a considerable amount of data are collected about patient experience, there are concerns this information is not always used to improve care. This study explored whether and how frontline staff use patient experience data for service improvement. Methods: We conducted a year-long ethnographic case study evaluation, including 299 hours of observations and 95 interviews, of how frontline staff in six medical wards at different hospital sites in the United Kingdom used patient experience data for improvement. Results: In every site, staff undertook quality improvement projects using a range of data sources. Teams of health care practitioners and ancillary staff engaged collectively in a process of sense-making using formal and informal sources of patient experience data. While survey data were popular, ‘soft’ intelligence – such as patients’ stories, informal comments and observations – also informed staff’s improvement plans, without always being recognized as data. Teams with staff from different professional backgrounds and grades tended to make more progress than less diverse teams, being able to draw on a wider net of practical, organizational and social resources, support and skills, which we describe as team-based capital. Conclusions: Organizational recognition, or rejection, of specific forms of patient experience intelligence as ‘data’ affects whether staff feel the data are actionable. Teams combining a diverse range of staff generated higher levels of ‘team-based capital’ for quality improvement than those adopting a single disciplinary approach. This may be a key mechanism for achieving person-centred improvement in health care.


  • Open Access

    Critical Care Work During COVID-19: A Sociological Analysis of Staff Experiences

    by Catherine M. Montgomery, Sally Humphreys, Corrienne McCulloch, Annemarie Docherty, Steve Sturdy, Natalie Pattison

    Background: The COVID-19 pandemic and ensuing healthcare crisis presented staff working in critical care with unprecedented demands. We sought to understand frontline staff’s experiences of working in critical care in the UK during the first wave of the outbreak. Methods: Between August and October 2020, we conducted qualitative, semi-structured telephone interviews with forty NHS staff who worked in critical care during the first wave of the pandemic in the UK. Staff were recruited from four hospitals and included doctors, nurses, allied health professionals and ward clerks. We purposefully sought the experiences of trained and experienced critical care staff and those who were redeployed. We analysed the data using Rapid Analysis and subsequently interpreted the findings using Baehr’s sociological lens of ‘communities of fate’. Findings: COVID-19 presented staff with a situation of extreme stress, duress and social emergency, leading to a shared set of experiences which we have characterised as a community of fate. This involved fear and dread of working in critical care, but also a collective sense of duty and vocation. Caring for patients and families involved changes to usual ways of working, revolving around: reorganisation of space and personnel, personal protective equipment, lack of evidence for treating COVID-19, inability for families to be physically present, and the trauma of witnessing extreme patient acuity and death on a large scale. The stress and isolation of working in critical care during COVID-19 was mitigated by strong teamwork, camaraderie, pride and fulfilment. Interpretation: COVID-19 has changed working practices in critical care and profoundly affected staff physically, mentally and emotionally. Attention needs to be paid to the social and organisational conditions in which individuals work, addressing both practical resourcing and the interpersonal dynamics of critical care provision. Funding: Medical Research Scotland, Wellcome Trust Declaration of Interests: CM reports a grant from Medical Research Scotland during the conduct of the study; SH reports a grant from Florence Nightingale Foundation, outside the submitted work; SS reports grants from Wellcome Trust, during the conduct of the study; CMC, AD and NP declare no competing interests. Ethics Approval Statement: Ethical approval was granted by the University of Edinburgh School of Social and Political Science Research Ethics Committee; HRA approval (20/HRA/3270) was also obtained.


  • Educating China on the move: A typology of contemporary Chinese higher education mobilities

    by Cora Lingling Xu, Catherine Montgomery

    The landscape of global higher education is changing rapidly in response to and alongside the geopolitical and geosocial global transformations, with China and East Asia becoming key players in higher education. As China's economic power and strategic reach grows against a context of global uncertainty, it has become increasingly important to develop a nuanced understanding of Chinese globalisation, not least for its significance to the balance of power relations within and beyond Asia. Higher education provides a powerful lens through which to see how China is globalising and how this might impact on the world. This is manifested in its many established and newer forms of education mobilities. Recognising the lack of research efforts to systematically understand the complexities of contemporary higher education mobilities across China, this paper proposes a typology through a thematic narrative review of more than 250 peer‐reviewed journal articles, government and media documents. This typology of Chinese higher education mobilities reveals three key insights, including (1) a critique on the ‘mobility imperative’ and the role of the Chinese state, (2) a call for more longitudinal and/or retrospective research to facilitate a relational understanding of the fluid nature of higher education mobilities in China, and (3) a note on the urgency of developing a comprehensive theoretical and conceptual tool kit. This article contributes to an updated understanding of the fluid, multiple and multi‐directional nature of contemporary higher education mobilities of China.