ACAlison Chisholm

Alison Chisholm

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Alison Chisholm has a total of 91 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Current postpartum management of hypertension: A survey of obstetricians, general practitioners, and midwives in the UK

    by Katherine Tucker, Holly Edmundson, Richard Stevens, Alison Chisholm, Layla Lavallee, Lucy Goddard, Cristian Roman, Christine McCourt, Cynthia Ochieng, Lucy Yardley, et al.


  • Open Access

    Optimising the monitoring and management of raised blood pressure including proteinuria testing during pregnancy: the BUMP research programme including 2 RCTs

    by Richard J McManus, Lucy C Chappell, Katherine L Tucker, Lisa Hinton, Oliver Rivero-Arias, Julie Allen, Rebecca Band, Helen E Campbell, Alison Chisholm, Marcus Green, et al.

    Background: Raised blood pressure affects 10% of pregnancies worldwide, of which around half develop pre-eclampsia including proteinuria, causing maternal and perinatal morbidity and mortality. Objectives: To develop and test interventions for self-monitoring of blood pressure designed to improve the detection and management of hypertension in pregnancy. Additionally, to test the accuracy of self-testing of urine for protein, a key marker of pre-eclampsia. Design and methods: Development phase, a pilot trial, two large randomised controlled trials of self-monitoring of blood pressure interventions with integrated economic evaluations, linked qualitative work, a large survey and a diagnostic accuracy study of self-testing for proteinuria, and finally economic modelling. Setting and participants: Antenatal clinics in 16 English hospitals. Participants were pregnant women and antenatal healthcare professionals. Patient and public involvement: Comprehensive involvement from initial development through to dissemination, with collaboration from both individuals and relevant charities and organisations. Interventions: Self-monitoring of blood pressure supported by app to improve the detection (BUMP1) and management (BUMP2) of raised blood pressure in pregnancy (WS3.2.1 and 2). Proteinuria self-testing by pregnant hypertensive women (UDIP, WS4). Main outcome measures: Qualitative data informed the development of the BUMP App and trial (WS1). Feasibility of self-monitoring of blood pressure in hypertensive pregnancy (recruitment, retention, adherence and intervention persistence) (WS2). Prevalence of self-monitoring of blood pressure during pregnancy (WS3.1). Time to diagnosis of hypertension defined in routinely recorded clinical data (BUMP1, WS3.2.1) and difference in mean systolic blood pressure recorded by healthcare professionals between randomisation and birth (BUMP2, WS3.2.2). WS3.3 and 4.2 evaluated experiences with the trial and UDIP respectively using inductive and deductive thematic analysis. Within-trial cost–consequence analysis and long-term cost-effectiveness modelling (WS3.4 and WS5). Proteinuria testing accuracy (WS4.1). Results: WS1 : Areas important to staff included providing clear patient information and supporting them in decision-making in the context of discrepant readings. The intervention was optimised iteratively with pregnant women. WS2 : A feasibility trial showed that the self-monitoring of blood pressure intervention was feasible and acceptable. WS3.1 : Data from a survey of 5181 women showed that 19% of pregnant women were currently self-monitoring blood pressure but only 482/983 (49%) shared this information with healthcare professionals. WS3.2.1 : Self-monitoring of blood pressure in addition to usual care did not lead to an earlier diagnosis of clinic hypertension in routinely recorded clinical data with no evidence of differences in maternal or perinatal outcomes or serious adverse events (BUMP1). WS3.2.2: Self-monitoring of blood pressure in pregnancy hypertension did not improve clinic blood pressure control, with no difference in maternal or perinatal outcomes or serious adverse events (BUMP2). WS3.3: Self-monitoring was generally accepted by women and professionals with differences in views of which blood pressure data to give precedence. Women found self-monitoring empowering, provided health professionals considered home readings in their management. On occasion self-monitoring proved unsettling due to uncertainty. WS3.4: Within trial economic analyses revealed no significant difference in overall total costs between trial arms in either BUMP1 or BUMP2. Women’s health-related quality of life (EQ-5D-5L) was similar between groups in both trials. WS4 : Self-testing for proteinuria had a sensitivity of 0.71 (95% confidence interval 0.62 to 0.79) and a specificity of 0.89 (95% confidence interval 0.84 to 0.92) compared to laboratory protein–creatinine ratio testing and this was not clinically or statistically different when compared to healthcare professionals or a colorimetric monitor (UDIP, WS4.1). Self-testing was generally acceptable (WS4.2). WS5 : Model frameworks capable of facilitating exploration of the long-term cost-effectiveness of combining self-monitoring of blood pressure with blood pressure treatment and management policies were developed for use in future research projects in the area. Implementation : Self-monitoring was rapidly and widely implemented during the pandemic but has yet to become fully embedded in clinical pathways. Limitations: Self-monitoring of blood pressure by women in the control groups; difficulties in testing self-monitoring of blood pressure in clinical pathways in the absence of evidence or accepted treatment thresholds; process evaluation suggested women and professionals privileged different information. Conclusions: Self-monitoring of blood pressure during higher risk or hypertensive pregnancy was feasible, acceptable, safe, and no more expensive, but did not improve the detection of hypertension or blood pressure control in those with hypertension when used alongside usual care. During the programme, self-monitoring of blood pressure entered common practice in pregnancy, a process accelerated by the pandemic. Pregnant women can read a dipstick for urinary protein with similar accuracy to healthcare professionals or colorimetric testing, and find this acceptable, suggesting that self-testing could be included in clinical pathways. Future work: Future trials of interventions including self-monitoring of blood pressure should test strategies in the context of novel clinical pathways. Study registration: This study is registered as Current Controlled Trials ISRCTN16018898. Funding: This award was funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Programme Grants for Applied Research programme (NIHR award ref.: RP-PG-0614-20005) and is published in full in Programme Grants for Applied Research ; Vol. 14, No. 3. See the NIHR Funding and Awards website for further award information.

  • Open Access

    Exploring transformative social innovations for a wellbeing economy: insights from citizens’ juries in Vienna and Oxford

    by A. Krisch, J. Carpenter, A. Chisholm, J. Suitner

    The Wellbeing Economy has emerged as an alternative development approach that focuses on human and ecological wellbeing instead of material growth, but its implementation, particularly at the local level, remains underexplored. This paper argues that Democratic Innovations as specific forms of Transformative Social Innovations can help operationalise the Wellbeing Economy by fostering participatory, place-based interventions. Transformative Social Innovations can challenge, alter, or replace dominant institutions in specific socio-material contexts. However, their transformative impact and ability to change institutional configurations is hampered if their inherent ‘paradoxes’ are not adequately addressed. Using the cases of citizens’ juries in Vienna and Oxford, the paper examines how Democratic Innovations align normative visions, enable mechanisms of exchange, and operationalise transformative change to achieve more just governance outcomes. We highlight whether, and how, these deliberative democratic processes contribute to a Wellbeing Economy in place and how they dealt with their paradoxes and contradictions. Our findings indicate the relevance of socio-material, political-institutional, and cultural-discursive contexts for these types of innovations. We thus contribute to a more nuanced understanding of transformative impact for wellbeing in place and argue that Transformative Social Innovations can help bridge the gap between global and abstract notions of a Wellbeing Economy and local implementation if their paradoxes and contradictions are adequately considered.


  • Open Access

    Self-monitoring blood pressure in Pregnancy: Evaluation of health professional experiences of the BUMP trials

    by Alison Chisholm, Katherine L Tucker, Carole Crawford, Marcus Green, Sheila Greenfield, James Hodgkinson, Layla Lavallee, Paul Leeson, Lucy Mackillop, Christine McCourt, et al.


  • Open Access

    “You Probably Won’t Notice Any Symptoms”: Blood Pressure in Pregnancy—Discourses of Contested Expertise in an Era of Self-Care and Responsibilization

    by Lisa Hinton, Alison Chisholm, Beth Jakubowski, Sheila Greenfield, Katherine L Tucker, Richard J McManus, Louise Locock

    Pregnancy is not a disease or illness, but requires clinical surveillance as life-threatening complications can develop. Preeclampsia, one such potentially serious complication, puts both mother and baby at risk. Self-monitoring blood pressure in the general population is well established, and its potential in pregnancy is currently being explored. In the context of self-monitoring, the information and guidance given to women regarding hypertension, and the literature they themselves seek out during pregnancy, are vital to perceptions of disease risk and subsequent responses to, and management of, any symptoms. Drawing on online, offline, official, and unofficial sources of information, discourses are examined to provide analysis of how self-responsibilization is reflected in contemporary information, advice, and guidance drawn from multiple sources. A paradox emerges between the paternalistic and lay discourses that seek to challenge and regain control. Findings are discussed in the context of Foucault’s governmentality and medical power.


  • Open Access

    Wild data: how front‐line hospital staff make sense of patients’ experiences

    by Catherine M. Montgomery, Alison Chisholm, Stephen Parkin, Louise Locock

    Patient‐centred care has become the touchstone of healthcare policy in developed healthcare systems. The ensuing commodification of patients’ experiences has resulted in a mass of data but little sense of whether and how such data are used. We sought to understand how front‐line staff use patient experience data for quality improvement in the National Health Service (NHS). We conducted a 12‐month ethnographic case study evaluation of improvement projects in six NHS hospitals in England in 2016–2017. Drawing on the sociology of everyday life, we show how front‐line staff worked with a notion of data as interpersonal and embodied. In addition to consulting organisationally sanctioned forms of data, staff used their own embodied interactions with patients, carers, other staff and the ward environment to shape improvements. The data staff found useful involved face‐to‐face interaction and dialogue; were visual, emotive, and allowed for immediate action. We draw on de Certeau to re‐conceptualise this as ‘wild data’. We conclude that patient experience data are relational, and have material, social and affective dimensions, which have been elided in the literature to date. Practice‐based theories of the everyday help to envision ‘patient experience’ not as a disembodied tool of managerialism but as an embedded part of healthcare staff professionalism.


  • Open Access

    'Team capital’ in quality improvement teams: findings from an ethnographic study of front-line quality improvement in the NHS

    by Catherine Montgomery, Stephen Parkin, Alison Chisholm, Louise Locock

    Background Teamwork is important in the design and delivery of initiatives in complex healthcare systems but the specifics of quality improvement (QI) teams are not well studied. Objective To explain the functioning of front-line healthcare teams working on patient-centred QI using Bourdieu’s sociological construct of capital. Methods One medical ward from each of six NHS Trusts in England participated in the study, purposively selected for a range of performance levels on patient experience metrics. Three ethnographers conducted focused ethnography for 1 year, using interviews and observations to explore the organisation, management and delivery of patient-centred QI projects by the six front-line teams. Data were analysed using Bourdieu’s typology of the four forms of capital: economic, social, symbolic and cultural. Results While all teams implemented some QI activities to improve patient experience, progress was greater where teams included staff from a broad range of disciplines and levels of seniority. Teams containing both clinical and non-clinical staff, including staff on lower grades such as healthcare assistants and clerks, engaged more confidently with patient experience data than unidisciplinary teams, and implemented a more ambitious set of projects. We explain these findings in terms of ‘team capital’. Conclusion Teams that chose to restrict membership to particular disciplines appeared to limit their capital, whereas more varied teams were able to draw on multiple resources, skills, networks and alliances to overcome challenges. Staff of varying levels of seniority also shared and valued a broader range of insights into patient experience, including informal knowledge from daily practice. The construct of ‘team capital’ has the potential to enrich understanding of the mechanism of teamwork in QI work.


  • Open Access

    Understanding how front-line staff use patient experience data for service improvement: an exploratory case study evaluation

    by Louise Locock, Chris Graham, Jenny King, Stephen Parkin, Alison Chisholm, Catherine Montgomery, Elizabeth Gibbons, Esther Ainley, Jennifer Bostock, Melanie Gager, et al.

    Background and aim: The NHS collects a large number of data on patient experience, but there are concerns that it does not use this information to improve care. This study explored whether or not and how front-line staff use patient experience data for service improvement. Methods: Phase 1 – secondary analysis of existing national survey data, and a new survey of NHS trust patient experience leads. Phase 2 – case studies in six medical wards using ethnographic observations and interviews. A baseline and a follow-up patient experience survey were conducted on each ward, supplemented by in-depth interviews. Following an initial learning community to discuss approaches to learning from and improving patient experience, teams developed and implemented their own interventions. Emerging findings from the ethnographic research were shared formatively. Phase 3 – dissemination, including an online guide for NHS staff. Key findings: Phase 1 – an analysis of staff and inpatient survey results for all 153 acute trusts in England was undertaken, and 57 completed surveys were obtained from patient experience leads. The most commonly cited barrier to using patient experience data was a lack of staff time to examine the data (75%), followed by cost (35%), lack of staff interest/support (21%) and too many data (21%). Trusts were grouped in a matrix of high, medium and low performance across several indices to inform case study selection. Phase 2 – in every site, staff undertook quality improvement projects using a range of data sources. The number and scale of these varied, as did the extent to which they drew directly on patient experience data, and the extent of involvement of patients. Before-and-after surveys of patient experience showed little statistically significant change. Making sense of patient experience ‘data’ Staff were engaged in a process of sense-making from a range of formal and informal sources of intelligence. Survey data remain the most commonly recognised and used form of data. ‘Soft’ intelligence, such as patient stories, informal comments and daily ward experiences of staff, patients and family, also fed into staff’s improvement plans, but they and the wider organisation may not recognise these as ‘data’. Staff may lack confidence in using them for improvement. Staff could not always point to a specific source of patient experience ‘data’ that led to a particular project, and sometimes reported acting on what they felt they already knew needed changing. Staff experience as a route to improving patient experience Some sites focused on staff motivation and experience on the assumption that this would improve patient experience through indirect cultural and attitudinal change, and by making staff feel empowered and supported. Staff participants identified several potential interlinked mechanisms: (1) motivated staff provide better care, (2) staff who feel taken seriously are more likely to be motivated, (3) involvement in quality improvement is itself motivating and (4) improving patient experience can directly improve staff experience. ‘Team-based capital’ in NHS settings We propose ‘team-based capital’ in NHS settings as a key mechanism between the contexts in our case studies and observed outcomes. ‘Capital’ is the extent to which staff command varied practical, organisational and social resources that enable them to set agendas, drive process and implement change. These include not just material or economic resources, but also status, time, space, relational networks and influence. Teams involving a range of clinical and non-clinical staff from multiple disciplines and levels of seniority could assemble a greater range of capital; progress was generally greater when the team included individuals from the patient experience office. Phase 3 – an online guide for NHS staff was produced in collaboration with The Point of Care Foundation. Limitations: This was an ethnographic study of how and why NHS front-line staff do or do not use patient experience data for quality improvement. It was not designed to demonstrate whether particular types of patient experience data or quality improvement approaches are more effective than others. Future research: Developing and testing interventions focused specifically on staff but with patient experience as the outcome, with a health economics component. Studies focusing on the effect of team composition and diversity on the impact and scope of patient-centred quality improvement. Research into using unstructured feedback and soft intelligence. Funding: The National Institute for Health Research Health Services and Delivery Research programme.


  • Open Access

    How do frontline staff use patient experience data for service improvement? Findings from an ethnographic case study evaluation

    by Louise Locock, Catherine Montgomery, Stephen Parkin, Alison Chisholm, Jennifer Bostock, Sue Dopson, Melanie Gager, Elizabeth Gibbons, Chris Graham, Jenny King, et al.

    Objectives: Improving patient experience is widely regarded as a key component of health care quality. However, while a considerable amount of data are collected about patient experience, there are concerns this information is not always used to improve care. This study explored whether and how frontline staff use patient experience data for service improvement. Methods: We conducted a year-long ethnographic case study evaluation, including 299 hours of observations and 95 interviews, of how frontline staff in six medical wards at different hospital sites in the United Kingdom used patient experience data for improvement. Results: In every site, staff undertook quality improvement projects using a range of data sources. Teams of health care practitioners and ancillary staff engaged collectively in a process of sense-making using formal and informal sources of patient experience data. While survey data were popular, ‘soft’ intelligence – such as patients’ stories, informal comments and observations – also informed staff’s improvement plans, without always being recognized as data. Teams with staff from different professional backgrounds and grades tended to make more progress than less diverse teams, being able to draw on a wider net of practical, organizational and social resources, support and skills, which we describe as team-based capital. Conclusions: Organizational recognition, or rejection, of specific forms of patient experience intelligence as ‘data’ affects whether staff feel the data are actionable. Teams combining a diverse range of staff generated higher levels of ‘team-based capital’ for quality improvement than those adopting a single disciplinary approach. This may be a key mechanism for achieving person-centred improvement in health care.


  • Open Access

    Blood pressure monitoring in high-risk pregnancy to improve the detection and monitoring of hypertension (the BUMP 1 and 2 trials): protocol for two linked randomised controlled trials

    by Greig Dougall, Marloes Franssen, Katherine Louise Tucker, Ly-Mee Yu, Lisa Hinton, Oliver Rivero-Arias, Lucy Abel, Julie Allen, Rebecca Jane Band, Alison Chisholm, et al.

    Introduction Self-monitoring of blood pressure (BP) in pregnancy could improve the detection and management of pregnancy hypertension, while also empowering and engaging women in their own care. Two linked trials aim to evaluate whether BP self-monitoring in pregnancy improves the detection of raised BP during higher risk pregnancies (BUMP 1) and whether self-monitoring reduces systolic BP during hypertensive pregnancy (BUMP 2). Methods and analyses Both are multicentre, non-masked, parallel group, randomised controlled trials. Participants will be randomised to self-monitoring with telemonitoring or usual care. BUMP 1 will recruit a minimum of 2262 pregnant women at higher risk of pregnancy hypertension and BUMP 2 will recruit a minimum of 512 pregnant women with either gestational or chronic hypertension. The BUMP 1 primary outcome is the time to the first recording of raised BP by a healthcare professional. The BUMP 2 primary outcome is mean systolic BP between baseline and delivery recorded by healthcare professionals. Other outcomes will include maternal and perinatal outcomes, quality of life and adverse events. An economic evaluation of BP self-monitoring in addition to usual care compared with usual care alone will be assessed across both study populations within trial and with modelling to estimate long-term cost-effectiveness. A linked process evaluation will combine quantitative and qualitative data to examine how BP self-monitoring in pregnancy is implemented and accepted in both daily life and routine clinical practice. Ethics and dissemination The trials have been approved by a Research Ethics Committee (17/WM/0241) and relevant research authorities. They will be published in peer-reviewed journals and presented at national and international conferences. If shown to be effective, BP self-monitoring would be applicable to a large population of pregnant women. Trial registration number NCT03334149