Jaime Tierney
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Jaime Tierney has a total of 27 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Brett Byram
Department of Biomedical Engineering, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN, USA
12 shared publications Matthew Berger
Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN, USA
4 shared publicationsJennifer Baker
Department of Radiology, Vanderbilt University Medical Center, Nashville, USA
3 shared publications- Adam C. Luchies
Department of Biomedical Engineering, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN, USA
2 shared publications Adam Luchies
Vanderbilt University
2 shared publicationsBrett Byram
Vanderbilt University
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 30 December 2021
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging
- Vol. 41 (1) , 158-171
Training Deep Network Ultrasound Beamformers With Unlabeled In Vivo Data
Conventional delay-and-sum (DAS) beamforming is highly efficient but also suffers from various sources of image degradation. Several adaptive beamformers have been proposed to address this problem, including more recently proposed deep learning methods. With deep learning, adaptive beamforming is typically framed as a regression problem, where clean ground-truth physical information is used for training. Because it is difficult to know ground truth information in vivo , training data are usually simulated. However, deep networks trained on simulations can produce suboptimal in vivo image quality because of a domain shift between simulated and in vivo data. In this work, we propose a novel domain adaptation (DA) scheme to correct for domain shift by incorporating unlabeled in vivo data during training. Unlike classification tasks for which both input domains map to the same target domain, a challenge in our regression-based beamforming scenario is that domain shift exists in both the input and target data. To solve this problem, we leverage cycle-consistent generative adversarial networks to map between simulated and in vivo data in both the input and ground truth target domains. Additionally, to account for separate as well as shared features between simulations and in vivo data, we use augmented feature mapping to train domain-specific beamformers. Using various types of training data, we explore the limitations and underlying functionality of the proposed DA approach. Additionally, we compare our proposed approach to several other adaptive beamformers. Using the DA DNN beamformer, consistent in vivo image quality improvements are achieved compared to established techniques.
- 30 December 2021
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging
- Vol. 41 (1) , 158-171
Training Deep Network Ultrasound Beamformers With Unlabeled In Vivo Data
Conventional delay-and-sum (DAS) beamforming is highly efficient but also suffers from various sources of image degradation. Several adaptive beamformers have been proposed to address this problem, including more recently proposed deep learning methods. With deep learning, adaptive beamforming is typically framed as a regression problem, where clean ground-truth physical information is used for training. Because it is difficult to know ground truth information in vivo , training data are usually simulated. However, deep networks trained on simulations can produce suboptimal in vivo image quality because of a domain shift between simulated and in vivo data. In this work, we propose a novel domain adaptation (DA) scheme to correct for domain shift by incorporating unlabeled in vivo data during training. Unlike classification tasks for which both input domains map to the same target domain, a challenge in our regression-based beamforming scenario is that domain shift exists in both the input and target data. To solve this problem, we leverage cycle-consistent generative adversarial networks to map between simulated and in vivo data in both the input and ground truth target domains. Additionally, to account for separate as well as shared features between simulations and in vivo data, we use augmented feature mapping to train domain-specific beamformers. Using various types of training data, we explore the limitations and underlying functionality of the proposed DA approach. Additionally, we compare our proposed approach to several other adaptive beamformers. Using the DA DNN beamformer, consistent in vivo image quality improvements are achieved compared to established techniques.
- 29 June 2021
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics, and Frequency Control
- Vol. 68 (7) , 2370-2385
Evaluating Input Domain and Model Selection for Deep Network Ultrasound Beamforming
Improving ultrasound B-mode image quality remains an important area of research. Recently, there has been increased interest in using deep neural networks (DNNs) to perform beamforming to improve image quality more efficiently. Several approaches have been proposed that use different representations of channel data for network processing, including a frequency-domain approach that we previously developed. We previously assumed that the frequency domain would be more robust to varying pulse shapes. However, frequency- and time-domain implementations have not been directly compared. In addition, because our approach operates on aperture domain data as an intermediate beamforming step, a discrepancy often exists between network performance and image quality on fully reconstructed images, making model selection challenging. Here, we perform a systematic comparison of frequency- and time-domain implementations. In addition, we propose a contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR)-based regularization to address previous challenges with model selection. Training channel data were generated from simulated anechoic cysts. Test channel data were generated from simulated anechoic cysts with and without varied pulse shapes, in addition to physical phantom and in vivo data. We demonstrate that simplified time-domain implementations are more robust than we previously assumed, especially when using phase preserving data representations. Specifically, 0.39- and 0.36-dB median improvements in in vivo CNR compared to DAS were achieved with frequency- and time-domain implementations, respectively. We also demonstrate that CNR regularization improves the correlation between training validation loss and simulated CNR by 0.83 and between simulated and in vivo CNR by 0.35 compared to DNNs trained without CNR regularization.
- 29 June 2021
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics, and Frequency Control
- Vol. 68 (7) , 2370-2385
Evaluating Input Domain and Model Selection for Deep Network Ultrasound Beamforming
Improving ultrasound B-mode image quality remains an important area of research. Recently, there has been increased interest in using deep neural networks (DNNs) to perform beamforming to improve image quality more efficiently. Several approaches have been proposed that use different representations of channel data for network processing, including a frequency-domain approach that we previously developed. We previously assumed that the frequency domain would be more robust to varying pulse shapes. However, frequency- and time-domain implementations have not been directly compared. In addition, because our approach operates on aperture domain data as an intermediate beamforming step, a discrepancy often exists between network performance and image quality on fully reconstructed images, making model selection challenging. Here, we perform a systematic comparison of frequency- and time-domain implementations. In addition, we propose a contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR)-based regularization to address previous challenges with model selection. Training channel data were generated from simulated anechoic cysts. Test channel data were generated from simulated anechoic cysts with and without varied pulse shapes, in addition to physical phantom and in vivo data. We demonstrate that simplified time-domain implementations are more robust than we previously assumed, especially when using phase preserving data representations. Specifically, 0.39- and 0.36-dB median improvements in in vivo CNR compared to DAS were achieved with frequency- and time-domain implementations, respectively. We also demonstrate that CNR regularization improves the correlation between training validation loss and simulated CNR by 0.83 and between simulated and in vivo CNR by 0.35 compared to DNNs trained without CNR regularization.
- Open Access
Domain Adaptation for Ultrasound Beamforming
Ultrasound B-Mode images are created from data obtained from each element in the transducer array in a process called beamforming. The beamforming goal is to enhance signals from specified spatial locations, while reducing signal from all other locations. On clinical systems, beamforming is accomplished with the delay-and-sum (DAS) algorithm. DAS is efficient but fails in patients with high noise levels, so various adaptive beamformers have been proposed. Recently, deep learning methods have been developed for this task. With deep learning methods, beamforming is typically framed as a regression problem, where clean, ground-truth data is known, and usually simulated. For in vivo data, however, it is extremely difficult to collect ground truth information, and deep networks trained on simulated data underperform when applied to in vivo data, due to domain shift between simulated and in vivo data. In this work, we show how to correct for domain shift by learning deep network beamformers that leverage both simulated data, and unlabeled in vivo data, via a novel domain adaption scheme. A challenge in our scenario is that domain shift exists both for noisy input, and clean output. We address this challenge by extending cycle-consistent generative adversarial networks, where we leverage maps between synthetic simulation and real in vivo domains to ensure that the learned beamformers capture the distribution of both noisy and clean in vivo data. We obtain consistent in vivo image quality improvements compared to existing beamforming techniques, when applying our approach to simulated anechoic cysts and in vivo liver data.
Open AccessDomain Adaptation for Ultrasound Beamforming
Ultrasound B-Mode images are created from data obtained from each element in the transducer array in a process called beamforming. The beamforming goal is to enhance signals from specified spatial locations, while reducing signal from all other locations. On clinical systems, beamforming is accomplished with the delay-and-sum (DAS) algorithm. DAS is efficient but fails in patients with high noise levels, so various adaptive beamformers have been proposed. Recently, deep learning methods have been developed for this task. With deep learning methods, beamforming is typically framed as a regression problem, where clean, ground-truth data is known, and usually simulated. For in vivo data, however, it is extremely difficult to collect ground truth information, and deep networks trained on simulated data underperform when applied to in vivo data, due to domain shift between simulated and in vivo data. In this work, we show how to correct for domain shift by learning deep network beamformers that leverage both simulated data, and unlabeled in vivo data, via a novel domain adaption scheme. A challenge in our scenario is that domain shift exists both for noisy input, and clean output. We address this challenge by extending cycle-consistent generative adversarial networks, where we leverage maps between synthetic simulation and real in vivo domains to ensure that the learned beamformers capture the distribution of both noisy and clean in vivo data. We obtain consistent in vivo image quality improvements compared to existing beamforming techniques, when applying our approach to simulated anechoic cysts and in vivo liver data.
- 3 May 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in Ultrasonic Imaging
- Vol. 42 (3) , 159-176
On the Effects of Constitutive Properties and Roughness of a Hard Inclusion in Soft Tissue on B-mode Images
We perform finite element modeling of pulse-echo ultrasound of a hard inclusion in a soft tissue to gain a better understanding of B-mode image brightness characteristics. We simulate a pressure wave emitted by an ultrasound transducer through the inclusion-tissue medium by prescribing suitable boundary conditions, and collect the scattered wave response to simulate the behavior of the transducer array used for pulse-echo ultrasound. We form B-mode images from simulated channel data using standard delay and sum beamforming. We establish the accuracy of the finite element model by comparing the point spread function with that obtained from Field II ultrasound simulation program. We also demonstrate qualitative validation by comparing the brightness characteristics of rough and smooth surfaced circular inclusions with experimental images of a cylindrical metal tool immersed in a water tank. We next conduct simulation studies to evaluate changes in B-mode image brightness intensity and contrast related to different constitutive properties, namely, compressibility of the inclusion, impedance contrast between the host and inclusion, and surface roughness of the inclusion. We find that the intensity observed behind a hard inclusion in the axial direction is strongly affected by the compressibility and roughness of the inclusion. Also, the perceived width of the stone based on the intensity is greater for rougher stones. Our study indicates that imaging of compressible inclusions may benefit from targeted B-mode image forming algorithms. Our modeling framework can potentially be useful in differentiating hard inclusions from surrounding parenchyma, and for classifying kidney stones or gallstones.
- 3 May 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in Ultrasonic Imaging
- Vol. 42 (3) , 159-176
On the Effects of Constitutive Properties and Roughness of a Hard Inclusion in Soft Tissue on B-mode Images
We perform finite element modeling of pulse-echo ultrasound of a hard inclusion in a soft tissue to gain a better understanding of B-mode image brightness characteristics. We simulate a pressure wave emitted by an ultrasound transducer through the inclusion-tissue medium by prescribing suitable boundary conditions, and collect the scattered wave response to simulate the behavior of the transducer array used for pulse-echo ultrasound. We form B-mode images from simulated channel data using standard delay and sum beamforming. We establish the accuracy of the finite element model by comparing the point spread function with that obtained from Field II ultrasound simulation program. We also demonstrate qualitative validation by comparing the brightness characteristics of rough and smooth surfaced circular inclusions with experimental images of a cylindrical metal tool immersed in a water tank. We next conduct simulation studies to evaluate changes in B-mode image brightness intensity and contrast related to different constitutive properties, namely, compressibility of the inclusion, impedance contrast between the host and inclusion, and surface roughness of the inclusion. We find that the intensity observed behind a hard inclusion in the axial direction is strongly affected by the compressibility and roughness of the inclusion. Also, the perceived width of the stone based on the intensity is greater for rougher stones. Our study indicates that imaging of compressible inclusions may benefit from targeted B-mode image forming algorithms. Our modeling framework can potentially be useful in differentiating hard inclusions from surrounding parenchyma, and for classifying kidney stones or gallstones.
- 14 November 2019
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging
- Vol. 39 (5) , 1558-1570
A Spatial Coherence Beamformer Design for Power Doppler Imaging
Acoustic clutter is a primary source of image degradation in ultrasound imaging. In the context of flow imaging, tissue and acoustic clutter signals are often much larger in magnitude than the blood signal, which limits the sensitivity of conventional power Doppler in SNR-limited environments. This has motivated the development of coherence-based beamformers, including Coherent Flow Power Doppler (CFPD), which have demonstrated efficacy in mitigating sources of diffuse clutter. However, CFPD uses a measure of normalized coherence, which incurs a non-linear relationship between image intensity and the magnitude of the blood echo. As a result, CFPD is not a robust approach to study gradation of blood signal energy, which depicts the fractional moving blood volume. We propose the application of mutual intensity, rather than normalized coherence, to retain the clutter suppression capability inherent in coherence beamforming, while preserving the underlying signal energy. Feasibility of this approach was shown via Field II simulations, phantoms, and in vivo human liver data. In addition, we derive an adaptive statistical threshold for the suppression of residual noise signals. Overall, this beamformer design shows promise as an alternative technique to depict flow volume gradation in cluttered imaging environments.
- 14 November 2019
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging
- Vol. 39 (5) , 1558-1570
A Spatial Coherence Beamformer Design for Power Doppler Imaging
Acoustic clutter is a primary source of image degradation in ultrasound imaging. In the context of flow imaging, tissue and acoustic clutter signals are often much larger in magnitude than the blood signal, which limits the sensitivity of conventional power Doppler in SNR-limited environments. This has motivated the development of coherence-based beamformers, including Coherent Flow Power Doppler (CFPD), which have demonstrated efficacy in mitigating sources of diffuse clutter. However, CFPD uses a measure of normalized coherence, which incurs a non-linear relationship between image intensity and the magnitude of the blood echo. As a result, CFPD is not a robust approach to study gradation of blood signal energy, which depicts the fractional moving blood volume. We propose the application of mutual intensity, rather than normalized coherence, to retain the clutter suppression capability inherent in coherence beamforming, while preserving the underlying signal energy. Feasibility of this approach was shown via Field II simulations, phantoms, and in vivo human liver data. In addition, we derive an adaptive statistical threshold for the suppression of residual noise signals. Overall, this beamformer design shows promise as an alternative technique to depict flow volume gradation in cluttered imaging environments.
- 4 November 2019
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging
- Vol. 39 (5) , 1472-1482
Independent Component-Based Spatiotemporal Clutter Filtering for Slow Flow Ultrasound
Effective tissue clutter filtering is critical for non-contrast ultrasound imaging of slow blood flow in small vessels. Independent component analysis (ICA) has been considered by other groups for ultrasound clutter filtering in the past and was shown to be superior to principal component analysis (PCA)-based methods. However, it has not been considered specifically for slow flow applications or revisited since the onset of other slow flow-focused advancements in beamforming and tissue filtering, namely angled plane wave beamforming and full spatiotemporal singular value decomposition (SVD) (i.e., PCA-based) tissue filtering. In this work, we aim to develop a full spatiotemporal ICA-based tissue filtering technique facilitated by plane wave applications and compare it to SVD filtering. We compare ICA and SVD filtering in terms of optimal image quality in simulations and phantoms as well as in terms of optimal correlation to ground truth blood signal in simulations. Additionally, we propose an adaptive blood independent component sorting and selection method. We show that optimal and adaptive ICA can consistently separate blood from tissue better than principal component analysis (PCA)-based methods using simulations and phantoms. Additionally we demonstrate initial in vivo feasibility in ultrasound data of a liver tumor.
- 4 November 2019
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging
- Vol. 39 (5) , 1472-1482
Independent Component-Based Spatiotemporal Clutter Filtering for Slow Flow Ultrasound
Effective tissue clutter filtering is critical for non-contrast ultrasound imaging of slow blood flow in small vessels. Independent component analysis (ICA) has been considered by other groups for ultrasound clutter filtering in the past and was shown to be superior to principal component analysis (PCA)-based methods. However, it has not been considered specifically for slow flow applications or revisited since the onset of other slow flow-focused advancements in beamforming and tissue filtering, namely angled plane wave beamforming and full spatiotemporal singular value decomposition (SVD) (i.e., PCA-based) tissue filtering. In this work, we aim to develop a full spatiotemporal ICA-based tissue filtering technique facilitated by plane wave applications and compare it to SVD filtering. We compare ICA and SVD filtering in terms of optimal image quality in simulations and phantoms as well as in terms of optimal correlation to ground truth blood signal in simulations. Additionally, we propose an adaptive blood independent component sorting and selection method. We show that optimal and adaptive ICA can consistently separate blood from tissue better than principal component analysis (PCA)-based methods using simulations and phantoms. Additionally we demonstrate initial in vivo feasibility in ultrasound data of a liver tumor.
- Open Access
- 10 September 2019
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientific Reports
- Vol. 9 (1) , 1-12
Non-contrast power Doppler ultrasound imaging for early assessment of trans-arterial chemoembolization of liver tumors
Trans-arterial chemoembolization (TACE) is an important yet variably effective treatment for management of hepatic malignancies. Lack of response can be in part due to inability to assess treatment adequacy in real-time. Gold-standard contrast enhanced computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging, although effective, suffer from treatment-induced artifacts that prevent early treatment evaluation. Non-contrast ultrasound is a potential solution but has historically been ineffective at detecting treatment response. Here, we propose non-contrast ultrasound with recent perfusion-focused advancements as a tool for immediate evaluation of TACE. We demonstrate initial feasibility in an 11-subject pilot study. Treatment-induced changes in tumor perfusion are detected best when combining adaptive demodulation (AD) and singular value decomposition (SVD) techniques. Using a 0.5 s (300-sample) ensemble size, AD + SVD resulted in a 7.42 dB median decrease in tumor power after TACE compared to only a 0.06 dB median decrease with conventional methods.
- 10 September 2019
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientific Reports
- Vol. 9 (1) , 1-12
Open AccessNon-contrast power Doppler ultrasound imaging for early assessment of trans-arterial chemoembolization of liver tumors
Trans-arterial chemoembolization (TACE) is an important yet variably effective treatment for management of hepatic malignancies. Lack of response can be in part due to inability to assess treatment adequacy in real-time. Gold-standard contrast enhanced computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging, although effective, suffer from treatment-induced artifacts that prevent early treatment evaluation. Non-contrast ultrasound is a potential solution but has historically been ineffective at detecting treatment response. Here, we propose non-contrast ultrasound with recent perfusion-focused advancements as a tool for immediate evaluation of TACE. We demonstrate initial feasibility in an 11-subject pilot study. Treatment-induced changes in tumor perfusion are detected best when combining adaptive demodulation (AD) and singular value decomposition (SVD) techniques. Using a 0.5 s (300-sample) ensemble size, AD + SVD resulted in a 7.42 dB median decrease in tumor power after TACE compared to only a 0.06 dB median decrease with conventional methods.
- 7 February 2019
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics, and Frequency Control
- Vol. 66 (5) , 834-848
Combining Slow Flow Techniques With Adaptive Demodulation for Improved Perfusion Ultrasound Imaging Without Contrast
Non-contrast perfusion ultrasound imaging remains challenging due to spectral broadening of the tissue clutter signal caused by patient and sonographer hand motion. To address this problem, we previously introduced an adaptive demodulation scheme to suppress the bandwidth of tissue prior to high-pass filtering. Our initial implementation used single plane wave power Doppler imaging and a conventional tissue filter. Recent advancements in beamforming and tissue filtering have been proposed for improved slow-flow imaging, including coherent flow power Doppler (CFPD) imaging and singular value decomposition (SVD) filtering. Here, we aim to evaluate adaptive demodulation in conjunction with improvements in beamforming and filtering using simulations, single vessel phantoms, and an in vivo liver tumor embolization study. We show that simulated blood-to-background contrast-to-noise ratios are highest when using adaptive demodulation with CFPD and a 100ms ensemble, which resulted in a 13.6dB average increase in contrast-to-noise ratio compared to basic IIR filtering alone. We also show that combining adaptive demodulation with SVD and with CFPD+SVD results in 9.3dB and 19dB increases in contrast-to-noise ratios compared to IIR filtering alone at 700ms and 500ms ensembles for phantom data with 1mm/s and 5mm/s average flows, respectively. In general, combining techniques resulted in higher signal-to-noise, contrast-to-noise, and generalized contrast-to-noise ratios in both simulations and phantoms. Finally, adaptive demodulation with SVD resulted in the largest qualitative and quantitative change in tumor-tobackground contrast post-embolization.
- 7 February 2019
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics, and Frequency Control
- Vol. 66 (5) , 834-848
Combining Slow Flow Techniques With Adaptive Demodulation for Improved Perfusion Ultrasound Imaging Without Contrast
Non-contrast perfusion ultrasound imaging remains challenging due to spectral broadening of the tissue clutter signal caused by patient and sonographer hand motion. To address this problem, we previously introduced an adaptive demodulation scheme to suppress the bandwidth of tissue prior to high-pass filtering. Our initial implementation used single plane wave power Doppler imaging and a conventional tissue filter. Recent advancements in beamforming and tissue filtering have been proposed for improved slow-flow imaging, including coherent flow power Doppler (CFPD) imaging and singular value decomposition (SVD) filtering. Here, we aim to evaluate adaptive demodulation in conjunction with improvements in beamforming and filtering using simulations, single vessel phantoms, and an in vivo liver tumor embolization study. We show that simulated blood-to-background contrast-to-noise ratios are highest when using adaptive demodulation with CFPD and a 100ms ensemble, which resulted in a 13.6dB average increase in contrast-to-noise ratio compared to basic IIR filtering alone. We also show that combining adaptive demodulation with SVD and with CFPD+SVD results in 9.3dB and 19dB increases in contrast-to-noise ratios compared to IIR filtering alone at 700ms and 500ms ensembles for phantom data with 1mm/s and 5mm/s average flows, respectively. In general, combining techniques resulted in higher signal-to-noise, contrast-to-noise, and generalized contrast-to-noise ratios in both simulations and phantoms. Finally, adaptive demodulation with SVD resulted in the largest qualitative and quantitative change in tumor-tobackground contrast post-embolization.
- 1 October 2018
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- p. 1-3
Adaptive Independent Component Analysis-Based Clutter Filtering for Improved Non-Contrast Perfusion Ultrasound Imaging
Tissue motion makes perfusion ultrasound imaging without contrast difficult. We previously developed an adaptive demodulation (AD) method to correct for this motion prior to tissue filtering. Additionally, 2D space and time eigen-based clutter filtering has been shown to be superior to conventional frequency domain filtering performed only in the slow-time dimension, especially when long ensembles are used. We have shown that combining AD with singular value decomposition (SVD) filtering can improve slow blood flow detection. Here, we aim to develop and evaluate an adaptive independent component analysis (ICA) approach to clutter filtering and compare it to adaptive SVD filtering with and without AD using simulations and a single vessel phantom. We show that AD+ICA and ICA produce the highest blood-to-background signal-to-noise ratios in simulations and in the phantom, respectively.
- 1 October 2018
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- p. 1-3
Adaptive Independent Component Analysis-Based Clutter Filtering for Improved Non-Contrast Perfusion Ultrasound Imaging
Tissue motion makes perfusion ultrasound imaging without contrast difficult. We previously developed an adaptive demodulation (AD) method to correct for this motion prior to tissue filtering. Additionally, 2D space and time eigen-based clutter filtering has been shown to be superior to conventional frequency domain filtering performed only in the slow-time dimension, especially when long ensembles are used. We have shown that combining AD with singular value decomposition (SVD) filtering can improve slow blood flow detection. Here, we aim to develop and evaluate an adaptive independent component analysis (ICA) approach to clutter filtering and compare it to adaptive SVD filtering with and without AD using simulations and a single vessel phantom. We show that AD+ICA and ICA produce the highest blood-to-background signal-to-noise ratios in simulations and in the phantom, respectively.