Rosemary Oram
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Rosemary Oram has a total of 26 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Alys Young
University of Manchester
11 shared publications - Jemina Napier
School of Social Sciences, Languages and Intercultural Studies, Heriot-Watt University , Edinburgh EH14 4AS
4 shared publications - Claire Dodds
University of Manchester
3 shared publications - Patricia Cartney
University of Manchester UK
3 shared publications Catherine Nassimi-Green
Division of Nursing, Midwifery and Social Work, Faculty of Biological, Medical and Health Sciences, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK
2 shared publicationsLinda Davies
Division of Population Health, Health Services Research and Primary Care, Faculty of Biological, Medical and Health Sciences, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 28 December 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in The British Journal of Social Work
- Vol. 55 (3) , 1436-1454
Standing at the crossroads: Child safeguarding and Deaf BSL parents (in England)—Issues and challenges in social work
Focussing on Deaf parents using British Sign Language (BSL) in England, this article shares perspectives of Child and Family social work practitioners (CFSWs) across a large urban area, through the lens of cultural competence. In an under-researched field, it explores linguistic and cultural aspects of working with Deaf parents, for whom English is not their first language, in the specific context of parenting assessments in child safeguarding procedures. Individual semi-structured online interviews were conducted by the researcher (in BSL) with seven CFSWs using English, involving a sign language interpreter. Participants were encouraged to reflect on the assessment process when it involves Deaf parents and/or other cultural-linguistic minority groups. Employing Braun and Clarke’s reflective thematic analysis method, the findings are grouped into three themes: CFSWs’ knowledge of working with Deaf people; cultural aspects relating to Deaf parents’ understanding of safeguarding/child protection proceedings; and meeting the communication and cultural needs of Deaf parents. The results identify several factors in current practice which impact CFSWs’ competence to carry out an assessment involving a Deaf BSL parent. Findings highlight the need for relevant training and resources developed specifically for this cultural minority group. Future research including the direct perspectives of Deaf parents is indicated.
- 28 December 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in The British Journal of Social Work
- Vol. 55 (3) , 1436-1454
Open AccessStanding at the crossroads: Child safeguarding and Deaf BSL parents (in England)—Issues and challenges in social work
Focussing on Deaf parents using British Sign Language (BSL) in England, this article shares perspectives of Child and Family social work practitioners (CFSWs) across a large urban area, through the lens of cultural competence. In an under-researched field, it explores linguistic and cultural aspects of working with Deaf parents, for whom English is not their first language, in the specific context of parenting assessments in child safeguarding procedures. Individual semi-structured online interviews were conducted by the researcher (in BSL) with seven CFSWs using English, involving a sign language interpreter. Participants were encouraged to reflect on the assessment process when it involves Deaf parents and/or other cultural-linguistic minority groups. Employing Braun and Clarke’s reflective thematic analysis method, the findings are grouped into three themes: CFSWs’ knowledge of working with Deaf people; cultural aspects relating to Deaf parents’ understanding of safeguarding/child protection proceedings; and meeting the communication and cultural needs of Deaf parents. The results identify several factors in current practice which impact CFSWs’ competence to carry out an assessment involving a Deaf BSL parent. Findings highlight the need for relevant training and resources developed specifically for this cultural minority group. Future research including the direct perspectives of Deaf parents is indicated.
- Open Access
- 12 December 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Qualitative Social Work
- Vol. 24 (4) , 504-523
Assessing deaf parents in safeguarding and child protection processes: Deaf experts’ experience of routine social work practice
This study concerns Deaf parents whose primary language is British Sign Language (BSL) and who are assessed as part of safeguarding and child protection processes. Seven Deaf-specialist professionals were interviewed in BSL about their experiences of usual practice with Child and Family Social workers who have little or no experience of child protection investigation and safeguarding assessments involving Deaf BSL users. The Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) informed data generation and the approach to analysis in BSL. Findings focus on: (i) getting early interactions right between mainstream social workers and Deaf parents (ii) the practice of relying on written English (iii) problems of cultural adaption between languages (iv) cultural norms in asking questions and (v) challenges arising from a poverty of background information. Recommendations are offered for improving cultural-linguistic practice when working with Deaf parents within safeguarding/child protection.
- 12 December 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Qualitative Social Work
- Vol. 24 (4) , 504-523
Open AccessAssessing deaf parents in safeguarding and child protection processes: Deaf experts’ experience of routine social work practice
This study concerns Deaf parents whose primary language is British Sign Language (BSL) and who are assessed as part of safeguarding and child protection processes. Seven Deaf-specialist professionals were interviewed in BSL about their experiences of usual practice with Child and Family Social workers who have little or no experience of child protection investigation and safeguarding assessments involving Deaf BSL users. The Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) informed data generation and the approach to analysis in BSL. Findings focus on: (i) getting early interactions right between mainstream social workers and Deaf parents (ii) the practice of relying on written English (iii) problems of cultural adaption between languages (iv) cultural norms in asking questions and (v) challenges arising from a poverty of background information. Recommendations are offered for improving cultural-linguistic practice when working with Deaf parents within safeguarding/child protection.
- Open Access
- 4 July 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Qualitative Social Work
- Vol. 23 (1) , 91-107
Now you see them, now you don’t: Professional recognition of specialist professionals working with Deaf British Sign Language parents in child safeguarding
This paper concerns parenting assessments which are integral to child-safeguarding professional processes in England, and which involve Deaf parents whose primary language is British Sign Language (BSL). In an under-researched area of social work, the research aim was to contribute to the existing literature by eliciting the practice wisdom of specialist professionals. Specifically, it draws upon their linguistic and cultural knowledge of the Deaf community when they are involved in parenting assessments with Deaf parents who are subject to safeguarding concerns. Data about these professionals’ actual experiences of navigating Deaf cultural-competency in contemporary child protection practices were collected through seven video-recorded, semi-structured interviews conducted in BSL. Using interpretive phenomenological analysis, data were analysed in their source language (BSL). This article focusses on one key theme, termed ‘Professional Recognition’, which incorporates a) the identification of specialist roles and b) the impact of referral processes and protocols on assessment outcomes. The findings highlight participants’ perspectives on the benefits and disadvantages of their specialist role in this context. Although their brokerage skills, cultural competence, linguistic fluency and specialist knowledge of the Deaf community are highly regarded and valued by some colleagues, there is insufficient recognition of their existence by the majority. Secondly, participants are concerned by the inefficiency and inconsistency of the referral processes and protocols which they consider have adverse effects on assessment outcomes, and consequently the parents involved. The BSL translation of this article is available in the supplementary material .
- 4 July 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Qualitative Social Work
- Vol. 23 (1) , 91-107
Open AccessNow you see them, now you don’t: Professional recognition of specialist professionals working with Deaf British Sign Language parents in child safeguarding
This paper concerns parenting assessments which are integral to child-safeguarding professional processes in England, and which involve Deaf parents whose primary language is British Sign Language (BSL). In an under-researched area of social work, the research aim was to contribute to the existing literature by eliciting the practice wisdom of specialist professionals. Specifically, it draws upon their linguistic and cultural knowledge of the Deaf community when they are involved in parenting assessments with Deaf parents who are subject to safeguarding concerns. Data about these professionals’ actual experiences of navigating Deaf cultural-competency in contemporary child protection practices were collected through seven video-recorded, semi-structured interviews conducted in BSL. Using interpretive phenomenological analysis, data were analysed in their source language (BSL). This article focusses on one key theme, termed ‘Professional Recognition’, which incorporates a) the identification of specialist roles and b) the impact of referral processes and protocols on assessment outcomes. The findings highlight participants’ perspectives on the benefits and disadvantages of their specialist role in this context. Although their brokerage skills, cultural competence, linguistic fluency and specialist knowledge of the Deaf community are highly regarded and valued by some colleagues, there is insufficient recognition of their existence by the majority. Secondly, participants are concerned by the inefficiency and inconsistency of the referral processes and protocols which they consider have adverse effects on assessment outcomes, and consequently the parents involved. The BSL translation of this article is available in the supplementary material .
- Open Access
- 6 July 2022
- Published by John Benjamins Publishing Company in Translation and Translanguaging in Multilingual Contexts
- Vol. 5 (2) , 95-120
“When I speak people look at me”
Deaf people’s lives are predicated to some extent on working with sign language interpreters. The self is translated on a regular basis and is a long-term state of being. Identity becomes known and performed through the translated self in many interactions, especially at work. (Hearing) others’ experience of deaf people, largely formed indirectly through the use of sign language interpreters, is rarely understood as intercultural or from a sociocultural linguistic perspective. This study positions itself at the cross-roads of translation studies, sociolinguistics and deaf studies, to specifically discuss findings from a scoping study that sought, for the first time, to explore whether the experience of being ‘known’ through translation is a pertinent issue for deaf signers. Through interviews with three deaf signers, we examine how they draw upon their linguistic repertoires and adopt bimodal translanguaging strategies in their work to assert or maintain their professional identity, including bypassing their representation through interpreters. This group we refer to as ‘Deaf Contextual Speakers’ (DCS). The DCS revealed the tensions they experienced as deaf signers in reinforcing, contravening or perpetuating language ideologies, with respect to assumptions that hearing people make about them as deaf people, their language use in differing contexts; the status of sign language; as well as the perceptions of other deaf signers about their translanguaging choices. This preliminary discussion of DCS’ engagement with translation, translanguaging and professional identity(ies) will contribute to theoretical discussions of translanguaging through the examination of how this group of deaf people draw upon their multilingual and multimodal repertoires, contingent and situational influences on these choices, and extend our understanding of the relationship between language use, power, identity, translation and representation.
- 6 July 2022
- Published by John Benjamins Publishing Company in Translation and Translanguaging in Multilingual Contexts
- Vol. 5 (2) , 95-120
Open Access“When I speak people look at me”
Deaf people’s lives are predicated to some extent on working with sign language interpreters. The self is translated on a regular basis and is a long-term state of being. Identity becomes known and performed through the translated self in many interactions, especially at work. (Hearing) others’ experience of deaf people, largely formed indirectly through the use of sign language interpreters, is rarely understood as intercultural or from a sociocultural linguistic perspective. This study positions itself at the cross-roads of translation studies, sociolinguistics and deaf studies, to specifically discuss findings from a scoping study that sought, for the first time, to explore whether the experience of being ‘known’ through translation is a pertinent issue for deaf signers. Through interviews with three deaf signers, we examine how they draw upon their linguistic repertoires and adopt bimodal translanguaging strategies in their work to assert or maintain their professional identity, including bypassing their representation through interpreters. This group we refer to as ‘Deaf Contextual Speakers’ (DCS). The DCS revealed the tensions they experienced as deaf signers in reinforcing, contravening or perpetuating language ideologies, with respect to assumptions that hearing people make about them as deaf people, their language use in differing contexts; the status of sign language; as well as the perceptions of other deaf signers about their translanguaging choices. This preliminary discussion of DCS’ engagement with translation, translanguaging and professional identity(ies) will contribute to theoretical discussions of translanguaging through the examination of how this group of deaf people draw upon their multilingual and multimodal repertoires, contingent and situational influences on these choices, and extend our understanding of the relationship between language use, power, identity, translation and representation.
- Open Access
- 2 October 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Translator
- Vol. 25 (4) , 349-368
The translated deaf self, ontological (in)security and deaf culture
In this article, we posit and explore the concept of ‘the translated deaf self’, tentatively defined as: ‘the socio-cultural impact for deaf sign language users of multiple, regular, lifelong experiences of being encountered by others and inter-subjectively known in a translated form, i.e. through sign language interpreters’. Regarding translation as both linguistic and non-linguistic, we explore the translated deaf self in terms of ontological (in)security in the context of phonocentrism, demonstrating how the recursive dynamics of structure-agency, within and through which the self is constituted, are impacted by the contingency of being interpreted. We show how such impacts on self, identity and agency are not equivalent to the hearing non-signing actors who also participate in relational encounters through sign language interpreters. The extent to which the shared experience of the translated deaf self may or may not be considered constitutive of (deaf) culture is examined with reference to strategies of linguistic resistances and personal empowerment evident in our data but not universally available or necessarily considered desirable from a collective perspective. Finally, we reflect on how to breakdown the exclusive and excluding nature of considerations such as these by breaking free of the written/signed signifier.
- 2 October 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Translator
- Vol. 25 (4) , 349-368
Open AccessThe translated deaf self, ontological (in)security and deaf culture
In this article, we posit and explore the concept of ‘the translated deaf self’, tentatively defined as: ‘the socio-cultural impact for deaf sign language users of multiple, regular, lifelong experiences of being encountered by others and inter-subjectively known in a translated form, i.e. through sign language interpreters’. Regarding translation as both linguistic and non-linguistic, we explore the translated deaf self in terms of ontological (in)security in the context of phonocentrism, demonstrating how the recursive dynamics of structure-agency, within and through which the self is constituted, are impacted by the contingency of being interpreted. We show how such impacts on self, identity and agency are not equivalent to the hearing non-signing actors who also participate in relational encounters through sign language interpreters. The extent to which the shared experience of the translated deaf self may or may not be considered constitutive of (deaf) culture is examined with reference to strategies of linguistic resistances and personal empowerment evident in our data but not universally available or necessarily considered desirable from a collective perspective. Finally, we reflect on how to breakdown the exclusive and excluding nature of considerations such as these by breaking free of the written/signed signifier.
- Open Access
- 2 January 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Applied Communication Research
- Vol. 47 (1) , 90-110
Hearing people perceiving deaf people through sign language interpreters at work: on the loss of self through interpreted communication
This article addresses the impact on occupational relations of mediated communication through a sign language interpreter from the perspective of hearing people who do not sign but who work alongside deaf signers in the workplace. Based on a phenomenological analysis of eight semi-structured interviews, findings address the influence of phonocentrism on working practice between deaf and hearing people. In particular, the implications of the inscription of identity and presence through an embodied language are discussed. The consequences of failure to acknowledge the interpreter as a contingent practice for all, not just the deaf person, are examined. The findings have implications for the recognition and promotion of deaf agency and talent in the ‘hearing’ work place and extend understandings of structural influences on workplace discriminations to include those of interpreted communication.
- 2 January 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Applied Communication Research
- Vol. 47 (1) , 90-110
Open AccessHearing people perceiving deaf people through sign language interpreters at work: on the loss of self through interpreted communication
This article addresses the impact on occupational relations of mediated communication through a sign language interpreter from the perspective of hearing people who do not sign but who work alongside deaf signers in the workplace. Based on a phenomenological analysis of eight semi-structured interviews, findings address the influence of phonocentrism on working practice between deaf and hearing people. In particular, the implications of the inscription of identity and presence through an embodied language are discussed. The consequences of failure to acknowledge the interpreter as a contingent practice for all, not just the deaf person, are examined. The findings have implications for the recognition and promotion of deaf agency and talent in the ‘hearing’ work place and extend understandings of structural influences on workplace discriminations to include those of interpreted communication.
- Open Access
- 2 September 2017
- Published by BMJ
- Vol. 71 (Suppl 1) , A42.2-A43
OP85 A qualitative exploration of trial-related terminology in a study involving deaf british sign language users
Background British Sign Language (BSL) is a fully grammatical, living language, independent of spoken English. Deaf BSL users are routinely excluded from clinical trials either on grounds of language and/or assumptions of confounding factors associated with disability. Few clinical trials specifically targeted at Deaf people exist internationally. Appropriate terminology in BSL for key concepts in clinical trials is needed to support informed consent.. Barriers to conceptual (mis)understanding of trial participation and sources relevant to the Deaf community are unexplored. This study set out to: (i) Explore, in BSL, the meaning and understanding of key concepts and common vocabulary used in recruitment and informed consent to a clinical trial (ii) Enable signs/signed expressions to emerge that are semantically accurate and support Deaf people’s informed consent in any future trial Methods A community participatory approach underpinned data collection. This comprised Deaf-led, qualitative, exploratory group discussions (19 self-selected participants in five groups), facilitated in BSL. Discussion was structured to explore the meaning of key terminology (such as trial, randomisation, consent) and through that exploration generate signed explanations of concepts to use in future trials. Data were video-recorded and analysed in BSL, using a phenomenological approach, built from the application of 4 themes and 8 sub-themes using NVIVO8 for visual data. Results All participants were over 30 years old, with a self-declared ‘strong Deaf identity’; BSL was their first or preferred language. Six necessary conditions for developing optimal trial information were identified. (i) developing appropriate expressions and terminology from a community basis, rather than testing out previously derived translations from a different language; (ii) paying attention to language-specific features which support best means of expression (in the case of BSL expectations of specificity, verb directionality, handshape); (iii) accounting for bilingual influences on comprehension; (iv) deliberate orientation of information to avoid misunderstanding not just to promote accessibility; (v) sensitivity to barriers to discussion about intelligibility of information that are cultural and social in origin, rather than linguistic; (vi) the importance of using contemporary language-in-use, rather than jargon-free or plain language, to support understanding. Conclusion These conditions need to be met to develop signed participant information for Deaf people that is: acceptable, accessible, transmitted accurately and understood as intended. They are required to address the cultural preferences and lower background knowledge of Deaf people (using signed languages) as well as in spoken/written languages when participants’ language use is different from the dominant language of the country.
- 2 September 2017
- Published by BMJ
- Vol. 71 (Suppl 1) , A42.2-A43
Open AccessOP85 A qualitative exploration of trial-related terminology in a study involving deaf british sign language users
Background British Sign Language (BSL) is a fully grammatical, living language, independent of spoken English. Deaf BSL users are routinely excluded from clinical trials either on grounds of language and/or assumptions of confounding factors associated with disability. Few clinical trials specifically targeted at Deaf people exist internationally. Appropriate terminology in BSL for key concepts in clinical trials is needed to support informed consent.. Barriers to conceptual (mis)understanding of trial participation and sources relevant to the Deaf community are unexplored. This study set out to: (i) Explore, in BSL, the meaning and understanding of key concepts and common vocabulary used in recruitment and informed consent to a clinical trial (ii) Enable signs/signed expressions to emerge that are semantically accurate and support Deaf people’s informed consent in any future trial Methods A community participatory approach underpinned data collection. This comprised Deaf-led, qualitative, exploratory group discussions (19 self-selected participants in five groups), facilitated in BSL. Discussion was structured to explore the meaning of key terminology (such as trial, randomisation, consent) and through that exploration generate signed explanations of concepts to use in future trials. Data were video-recorded and analysed in BSL, using a phenomenological approach, built from the application of 4 themes and 8 sub-themes using NVIVO8 for visual data. Results All participants were over 30 years old, with a self-declared ‘strong Deaf identity’; BSL was their first or preferred language. Six necessary conditions for developing optimal trial information were identified. (i) developing appropriate expressions and terminology from a community basis, rather than testing out previously derived translations from a different language; (ii) paying attention to language-specific features which support best means of expression (in the case of BSL expectations of specificity, verb directionality, handshape); (iii) accounting for bilingual influences on comprehension; (iv) deliberate orientation of information to avoid misunderstanding not just to promote accessibility; (v) sensitivity to barriers to discussion about intelligibility of information that are cultural and social in origin, rather than linguistic; (vi) the importance of using contemporary language-in-use, rather than jargon-free or plain language, to support understanding. Conclusion These conditions need to be met to develop signed participant information for Deaf people that is: acceptable, accessible, transmitted accurately and understood as intended. They are required to address the cultural preferences and lower background knowledge of Deaf people (using signed languages) as well as in spoken/written languages when participants’ language use is different from the dominant language of the country.
- 1 August 2017
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health Services and Delivery Research
- Vol. 5 (24) , 1-196
Evaluating the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of British Sign Language Improving Access to Psychological Therapies: an exploratory study
Background: Improving Access to Psychological Therapies (IAPT) is a National Institute for Health and Care Excellence-approved approach to intervention for depression and/or anxiety. This exploratory study sets the groundwork for comparing psychological therapies for Deaf sign language users experiencing anxiety and/or depression, delivered in British Sign Language (BSL) by a Deaf therapist with usual access through an interpreter within the IAPT national programme.Objectives: (1) To explore the following questions: (a) is BSL-IAPT more effective than standard IAPT for Deaf people with anxiety and/or depression? and (b) is any additional benefit from BSL-IAPT worth any additional cost to provide it? (2) To establish relevant BSL versions of assessment tools and methods to answer research questions (a) and (b). (3) To gauge the feasibility of a larger-scale definitive study and to inform its future design.Design: A mixed-methods exploratory study combing an economic model to synthesise data from multiple sources; a qualitative study of understanding and acceptability of randomisation and trial terminology; statistical determination of clinical cut-off points of standardised assessments in BSL; secondary data analysis of anonymised IAPT client records; realist inquiry incorporating interviews with service providers and survey results.Settings: IAPT service providers (NHS and private); the Deaf community.Participants: Deaf people who use BSL and who are clients of IAPT services (n = 502); healthy Deaf volunteers (n = 104); IAPT service providers (NHS and private) (n = 118).Interventions: IAPT at steps 2 and 3.Main outcome measures: Reliable recovery and reliable improvement defined by IAPT; Deaf community views on the acceptability of randomisation; BSL terminology for trial-related language; clinical cut-off measurements for the BSL versions of the Patient Health Questionnaire-9 items (PHQ-9) and the Generalised Anxiety Disorder-7 (GAD-7); a valid BSL version of the EuroQol-5 Dimensions five-level version (EQ-5D-5L); costs, quality-adjusted life-years and incremental cost-effectiveness ratios.Data sources: IAPT service provider anonymised records of the characteristics and clinical outcomes of Deaf BSL users of BSL-IAPT and of standard IAPT; published literature.Results: Randomisation may be acceptable to Deaf people who use IAPT if linguistic and cultural requirements are addressed. Specifications for effective information in BSL for recruitment have been established. A valid EQ-5D-5L in BSL has been produced. The clinical cut-off point for the GAD-7 BSL is 6 and for the PHQ-9 BSL is 8. No significant difference in rates of reliable recovery and reliable improvement between Deaf users of standard IAPT or BSL-IAPT has been found. Whether or not BSL-IAPT is more cost-effective than standard IAPT is uncertain.Limitations: The small number of participating standard IAPT services who have seen Deaf clients means that there is statistical uncertainty in the comparable clinical outcome result. Clinical cut-off scores have not been verified through gold standard clinical interview methodology. Limited data availability means that whether or not BSL-IAPT is more cost-effective than standard IAPT is uncertain.Conclusions: There is a lack of evidence to definitively compare reliable recovery and reliable improvement between Deaf users of standard IAPT and BSL-IAPT. Instrumentation and prerequisites for a larger-scale study have been established.Future work: A prospective observational study for definitive results is justified.Funding: The National Institute for Health Research Health Services and Delivery Research programme.
- 1 August 2017
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health Services and Delivery Research
- Vol. 5 (24) , 1-196
Evaluating the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of British Sign Language Improving Access to Psychological Therapies: an exploratory study
Background: Improving Access to Psychological Therapies (IAPT) is a National Institute for Health and Care Excellence-approved approach to intervention for depression and/or anxiety. This exploratory study sets the groundwork for comparing psychological therapies for Deaf sign language users experiencing anxiety and/or depression, delivered in British Sign Language (BSL) by a Deaf therapist with usual access through an interpreter within the IAPT national programme.Objectives: (1) To explore the following questions: (a) is BSL-IAPT more effective than standard IAPT for Deaf people with anxiety and/or depression? and (b) is any additional benefit from BSL-IAPT worth any additional cost to provide it? (2) To establish relevant BSL versions of assessment tools and methods to answer research questions (a) and (b). (3) To gauge the feasibility of a larger-scale definitive study and to inform its future design.Design: A mixed-methods exploratory study combing an economic model to synthesise data from multiple sources; a qualitative study of understanding and acceptability of randomisation and trial terminology; statistical determination of clinical cut-off points of standardised assessments in BSL; secondary data analysis of anonymised IAPT client records; realist inquiry incorporating interviews with service providers and survey results.Settings: IAPT service providers (NHS and private); the Deaf community.Participants: Deaf people who use BSL and who are clients of IAPT services (n = 502); healthy Deaf volunteers (n = 104); IAPT service providers (NHS and private) (n = 118).Interventions: IAPT at steps 2 and 3.Main outcome measures: Reliable recovery and reliable improvement defined by IAPT; Deaf community views on the acceptability of randomisation; BSL terminology for trial-related language; clinical cut-off measurements for the BSL versions of the Patient Health Questionnaire-9 items (PHQ-9) and the Generalised Anxiety Disorder-7 (GAD-7); a valid BSL version of the EuroQol-5 Dimensions five-level version (EQ-5D-5L); costs, quality-adjusted life-years and incremental cost-effectiveness ratios.Data sources: IAPT service provider anonymised records of the characteristics and clinical outcomes of Deaf BSL users of BSL-IAPT and of standard IAPT; published literature.Results: Randomisation may be acceptable to Deaf people who use IAPT if linguistic and cultural requirements are addressed. Specifications for effective information in BSL for recruitment have been established. A valid EQ-5D-5L in BSL has been produced. The clinical cut-off point for the GAD-7 BSL is 6 and for the PHQ-9 BSL is 8. No significant difference in rates of reliable recovery and reliable improvement between Deaf users of standard IAPT or BSL-IAPT has been found. Whether or not BSL-IAPT is more cost-effective than standard IAPT is uncertain.Limitations: The small number of participating standard IAPT services who have seen Deaf clients means that there is statistical uncertainty in the comparable clinical outcome result. Clinical cut-off scores have not been verified through gold standard clinical interview methodology. Limited data availability means that whether or not BSL-IAPT is more cost-effective than standard IAPT is uncertain.Conclusions: There is a lack of evidence to definitively compare reliable recovery and reliable improvement between Deaf users of standard IAPT and BSL-IAPT. Instrumentation and prerequisites for a larger-scale study have been established.Future work: A prospective observational study for definitive results is justified.Funding: The National Institute for Health Research Health Services and Delivery Research programme.
- 13 March 2017
- Published by University of Toronto Press Inc. (UTPress) in Journal of Applied Linguistics and Professional Practice
- Vol. 14 (1) , 75-95
Mediating identities
Deaf people's lives are frequently predicated on working with interpreters. Identity becomes known and performed through the translated self in many interactions with hearing, non-signing people. Taking an interdisciplinary approach in combining interpreting studies, deaf studies, applied linguistics and social research, the ‘Translating the Deaf Self’ project, funded by the Arts and Humanities Research Council (UK), sought to explore the experience of deaf people and other stakeholders of the lived experience of being translated. Drawing on discourses of identity, representation and trust, this paper gives an overview of the findings from two focus groups with sign language interpreters (n = 7) on their perspectives of the experiences of deaf signers being ‘known’ through interpreting. Social constructionism underpinned our approach to data analysis and the dominant theme of ‘trust’ was examined with reference to a framework for trustworthiness developed by Alan Jones and Samantha Sin. In particular, we focus on the issue of trust in relation to representation, relationships, ability and boundaries. The main findings demonstrate that sign language interpreters are acutely aware of the responsibility they have to represent deaf signers, especially at work, and thus represent their professional-and-deaf identities, and the important role of trust for deaf professionals to feel represented through interpreters. Open Access Attribution: CC BY
- 13 March 2017
- Published by University of Toronto Press Inc. (UTPress) in Journal of Applied Linguistics and Professional Practice
- Vol. 14 (1) , 75-95
Mediating identities
Deaf people's lives are frequently predicated on working with interpreters. Identity becomes known and performed through the translated self in many interactions with hearing, non-signing people. Taking an interdisciplinary approach in combining interpreting studies, deaf studies, applied linguistics and social research, the ‘Translating the Deaf Self’ project, funded by the Arts and Humanities Research Council (UK), sought to explore the experience of deaf people and other stakeholders of the lived experience of being translated. Drawing on discourses of identity, representation and trust, this paper gives an overview of the findings from two focus groups with sign language interpreters (n = 7) on their perspectives of the experiences of deaf signers being ‘known’ through interpreting. Social constructionism underpinned our approach to data analysis and the dominant theme of ‘trust’ was examined with reference to a framework for trustworthiness developed by Alan Jones and Samantha Sin. In particular, we focus on the issue of trust in relation to representation, relationships, ability and boundaries. The main findings demonstrate that sign language interpreters are acutely aware of the responsibility they have to represent deaf signers, especially at work, and thus represent their professional-and-deaf identities, and the important role of trust for deaf professionals to feel represented through interpreters. Open Access Attribution: CC BY
- Open Access
- 27 April 2016
- Published by Springer Nature in Trials
- Vol. 17 (1) , 1-12
A qualitative exploration of trial-related terminology in a study involving Deaf British Sign Language users
Internationally, few clinical trials have involved Deaf people who use a signed language and none have involved BSL (British Sign Language) users. Appropriate terminology in BSL for key concepts in clinical trials that are relevant to recruitment and participant information materials, to support informed consent, do not exist. Barriers to conceptual understanding of trial participation and sources of misunderstanding relevant to the Deaf community are undocumented. A qualitative, community participatory exploration of trial terminology including conceptual understanding of ‘randomisation’, ‘trial’, ‘informed choice’ and ‘consent’ was facilitated in BSL involving 19 participants in five focus groups. Data were video-recorded and analysed in source language (BSL) using a phenomenological approach. Six necessary conditions for developing trial information to support comprehension were identified. These included: developing appropriate expressions and terminology from a community basis, rather than testing out previously derived translations from a different language; paying attention to language-specific features which support best means of expression (in the case of BSL expectations of specificity, verb directionality, handshape); bilingual influences on comprehension; deliberate orientation of information to avoid misunderstanding not just to promote accessibility; sensitivity to barriers to discussion about intelligibility of information that are cultural and social in origin, rather than linguistic; the importance of using contemporary language-in-use, rather than jargon-free or plain language, to support meaningful understanding. The study reinforces the ethical imperative to ensure trial participants who are Deaf are provided with optimum resources to understand the implications of participation and to make an informed choice. Results are relevant to the development of trial information in other signed languages as well as in spoken/written languages when participants’ language use is different from the dominant language of the country.
- 27 April 2016
- Published by Springer Nature in Trials
- Vol. 17 (1) , 1-12
Open AccessA qualitative exploration of trial-related terminology in a study involving Deaf British Sign Language users
Internationally, few clinical trials have involved Deaf people who use a signed language and none have involved BSL (British Sign Language) users. Appropriate terminology in BSL for key concepts in clinical trials that are relevant to recruitment and participant information materials, to support informed consent, do not exist. Barriers to conceptual understanding of trial participation and sources of misunderstanding relevant to the Deaf community are undocumented. A qualitative, community participatory exploration of trial terminology including conceptual understanding of ‘randomisation’, ‘trial’, ‘informed choice’ and ‘consent’ was facilitated in BSL involving 19 participants in five focus groups. Data were video-recorded and analysed in source language (BSL) using a phenomenological approach. Six necessary conditions for developing trial information to support comprehension were identified. These included: developing appropriate expressions and terminology from a community basis, rather than testing out previously derived translations from a different language; paying attention to language-specific features which support best means of expression (in the case of BSL expectations of specificity, verb directionality, handshape); bilingual influences on comprehension; deliberate orientation of information to avoid misunderstanding not just to promote accessibility; sensitivity to barriers to discussion about intelligibility of information that are cultural and social in origin, rather than linguistic; the importance of using contemporary language-in-use, rather than jargon-free or plain language, to support meaningful understanding. The study reinforces the ethical imperative to ensure trial participants who are Deaf are provided with optimum resources to understand the implications of participation and to make an informed choice. Results are relevant to the development of trial information in other signed languages as well as in spoken/written languages when participants’ language use is different from the dominant language of the country.